Shinder Kaur And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR




    
 
                        

 !"#$%$ &'()*) +
 ,

  + )))))))))

$ $ &-%  

STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS )))) %. &"& % '  /0 ) +
1
 +) 2

    



 !!

   "! # !$%&!'&%( )#*   ))



  #% $ 



 +  , ----- 1
 +) 2)) -   *  . !  &!

!

  * !&

 /!$ 0

!$



 !$ !1!"! '!

! '!

!1



22 + ! &!

!

   "! # !$ %&!'& %( )#*    

  *&

 + 
0 1 !  *# !

 &!

!

!&& '  &!    ))  

     *&

  +    ,   &  1  !  *#  !

 &!

!

!&& '  &! 

00 3! 



   !  !  &!

!

 ! && ' !/ *  4!&   
 4 "

  ! !!

  #) !!

 ! )  6

5 

5 !"!&

)  ! 

 

 75  5*! /

/!$8)!$

9:  + 2266
22
)  ;;;6
6
6<

:! &5 
=2 !   

 7:

5>  ;=

:

5&  $! 

&!

!

 "%! !

 !&&

8)!&

!$ !!$ 

"  *!

"!  2=2;2
 1) 0   *'  !  .  !' !

    *

&  !& ?:&&8$! !

 
2
22

!5  $ !

" 

 $ !$

"!

!*'   ! 

!! $ ' &&

 ;

) !

  

*  !

" @)!

!&$! 9!

5&.&'! * !"

+ 2; 262;22. &1 



! 

) ) 0









 




 
 
 


 




 







 
!




 "#$

#
 


% %
  


 
&'%





 







 


"#$

#
 
 



 



  



 
!



(
) 




*+ 

0;0  

!








 


 

 




 
&'%
,%








 




 
 
 


 





   (# 










  (# 






 

%

-%








 




 
 
 


 

 
 
&'



 



 



 
.(
/0
1%2%1%(1





 



1 

%
3%


  









 
 






    

$



 

  

 

 



$


  %
6 A  

)&     ! )  )"

"!"

$  !  4 !

) *#  &)!

! )"

$  ! ,   ))  

     *&

 +  , ! &"!



 9: &&

8)!&

!$*!$8) = .9)&&

!5 !"






     

       

      

 

!

""

 #

$%

 * )  4*56
7










  





 
$


 






1 




$ 



 
,65


1%2%1%
7
 





 $

 
$







 



% % 8
  



 


1 8

8
     

#  8%

060 *59

& '

(

 '

& '

 

  ) '*
4



"%





  

  




$
$ :

7
 
 

# 
 
  
$ 






 

 

$ 





$

 %;

*<
7
$ 


 


# 


 
 


 
# 
#   


%



 



  




 



 


 

  
   

$

1 
 







 




 

$ 
  
 



$



 

 

 
  

#  % */
=







 
5<*9

 1%2%1%


 
 
 



$

$

$ 



 
,65


1%2%1% *5
7
  






 



> 


 



 %





# 



$ 



 
,65


1%2%1%




 

  
$

 

 


 



 

 

 
8 
 

#  8%
+  
$

 
  


  



 ? 
  




 
 
 



 
$


1 



$ 



 
,65


1%2%1%

  


  









$ 

 


 
 %
7

  


 




 





 
$  




 






 




    
$
  

#  
$



 



%

0,0 *
7
 
 

 


 

 





 




 1%2%1%
$

 

 
$ 


1 



 
,65%
& 





 



 
 
 


1 


$

$ 

> 




 

?   

  
$ 
 



 
5<

 1%2%1%





  



$


     

#  % *,
7
$ 



 
,65


1%2%1%





@ ?+


" 

  



 

1 %
7

  



  





?

 





1 






 
$ %

$

 $

 

 

  


 %
7
$ 



 
,65


1%2%1%


 %
$ 


1 
$



 

$
 

  %
7



$ 



$
  

 %
7
1 






? 
 






 


%
7
1 
 



  
 

 
 

 
  ?


  

 %
'

 


  
$


  

$


$
$
 
 









 
 


1 
$




 




 







 
  

  

$
 


 

$

 
 % B . &$& ! ! &  &!  '

 8)!$

#)$" '  &  

 *4  C D*& " 5  !  "

 'Gian Singh Versus State of Punjab and another,(2012)10 SCC303'. Still further, the broad principles for exercising the powers under Section 482 were summarized by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in

0=0 the matter of 'Parbatbhai Aahir @ Parbatbhai Bhimsinhbhai Karmur and others versus State of Gujarat and another" (2017) 9 SCC 641'. 8.

:!!!!'

"!

*&  &)!

!) "

$   !   ) )& )

 '

)& *   *4

!)!

!$. 

!$! &!/&4 *'

#)!

!&!"    *  

!

 < . C D*& " 5   & !  "

D"# + , , -

  &    *

$



)

 .!/0" '!

* $

!E   &! )

 !  "  ! '!

  )

 !#) !     1!*! "& !4

""!!





)  !

))  8)!$

 '!

 '

)& 

! )*&!

 !   5   8)9: !!'

&"

!"

$  ! . * !

C D*& "5 !1 ) 0

19. We thus sum-up and hold that as opposed to Section 320 Cr.P.C. where the Court is squarely guided by the compromise between the parties in respect of offences 'compoundable' within the statutory framework, the extraordinary power enjoined upon a High Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. or vested in this Court under Article 142 of the Constitution, can be invoked beyond the metes and bounds of Section 320 Cr.P.C. Nonetheless, we reiterate that such powers of wide amplitude ought to be exercised carefully in the context of quashing criminal proceedings, bearing in mind: (i) Nature and effect of the offence on the conscious of the society; (ii) Seriousness of the injury, if any; (iii) Voluntary nature of compromise between the accused and the victim; & (iv) Conduct of the accused persons, prior to

0B0 and after the occurrence of the purported offence and/or other relevant considerations.

2 .

&& '!$ &

" $

"  )&

'&&)*8)& ") &"!$ 

!

!

' )  65  50 !    )&

 '

)&  '  ! !  

 !



 !

 !!  :#) !  * )! !  

& "

$  !'

' !!$!"&

&!4 !!!  : ! ! )    )$  ! ! ! 8)!

!4 2
 !!&&!!!& $

!!$!

 !& 

 *

!&   !  . !!

 + ;6, !$$

) 


< 
4 

!)

!"!&!

 !

!&!/&4  )& ))  

  

 !!

   

!!

 + 
= $;,4  !!

 +  !  624  &5 !)!

!$!&!/&4

) !

)

!&  

)!

  !!

  !  . !!

  !

"!$*

   ! &!

!  *'   ! ! &!/&4   !& 4   )&"

 

&

&!4 !! .

 !8)!

 *! *! )

 

 '

)&*

/!$

 !



!4

 )*&!

& $: &  * "  

/!$

 !

5 F

00 viii)  !)!

!$

!$  ! ) $ !$ 

!"!&

!$! &!/&4 )*0  4& $ )*&!

! F ix)  .

!$   &!/&4    ! )!&!4

 '

! )

 

 )!

F 1  + & $  )*&!

 )

'

)&* *4

!)!

!$F xi) 

!     )

  4

!"!&       !)&$!4)

!"!& ) !$  4

 

  $! !

9:  xii) .

" &! !   &!/&4   )

  

 )!

5 !)!

!$!&!/&4 *  '

 #)!

!&!" . *# 

&' ! '&&  '  !  & !

 !

   

    )&&4

01!&!! 4 11.

In view of the report of the@)!

!&$! 9!

5& .&'! * a ! ! &&! '*4 15 !1



-'

        $

$

 !!'&& "# + , , -

  &   

$

 )

 .!/& *49)&&

!5 !




    -'

      *

 !

""

 #

$% ! !!

!&& '.

! FIR No. 0044 dated 21.02.2018 under Sections 323, 324, 148 and 149 of the IPC (Section 326 of the IPC added later on) registered at Police Station Raman, District Bathinda and all other consequential proceedings arising

0<0 therefrom - 4-56 78 %4"9 8)  !!

  ! !'

"! dated 06.03.2018 (Annexure P-2) However, the same would be subject to payment of cost of Rs.3,000/- each to be deposited by the petitioners with the ""Punjab and Haryana High Court Bar Clerk's Association" within one month from receipt of certified copy of this order.

!!

!&& '       1
 +) 2  (9        A
 
3  /!$?

  ' G?+ 3  

*&  G?+