← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/30/2020dismissed

Rajiv Kumar v. Sanjiv Verma And Others

2023-02-08Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi8 pages

  

        

  !"#"

$%&''   



   

    %  () ' ***



  

  

**+  ' ,-



  



 !

  

 " #$  %!

' $ (# )

*

+ $ "

  ,    "

 

%$ ! ' $ (# )

* -!

-$ -$  /  

/   & 0,& 0 , & 1& 20& 00& 0,& /& /& /& /2&  & &  ,&  /   (# )

 *

! "

    



 #  #

$%& $'( $') $(* *%&+, -&'

*''

*'( *.% *./ *.$ *.- *.)

%&* %&/ %*( %*) %*./$%0

#1 2# "3

 # 

2

 ##     0 2 2  #

 #

 31  5 3 2 

"3 

#2 #3&* &% *..% ! 

  *   * "

 #3    

  #3  2          5     6     

 "3   7 5 3 3  *..% 5 8  #9 #3 ## 

  

## 2 



  #32

  ,  

       "#  " 

 3  

 #   3  # 

 #  0 ###   

  

##   8  #9

2  8 92  7 #

5 323# :  

     2#



     8  #92   2

6 

 8 9 # 8  #9    "    #       8  #9        #;9          # 

            #      

          "  6 

         #9

5 323# 3  *..'

52

 8  #92   

  2

 

 

  "

   6 

     <0 

$&'

$%& $'( $') $(*0

#1 "

#  #

13#%* &- %&&. 

  2 

"3

   !



 8  #9  2  <02



 "



  %!

#  

          

            

      #;9#

! 

   ##2

 !

#  

 8  #9   8  #9

  #3   2

  #  #;9   8  #;9"

 "323     5 8  #9#    3"#2 2  2

  =  8  #9  #

13# 

   > /+"

0  8

 +  > $9       # ## # 3##%&&

=  8  #9  

  "# 

  1 

 3   #

 1

 2

 3  



  *

 0   

 8  #9 #

 

"# !

 3 2  

 

  

$%& $'( $') $(* *%&+, -&'

*''

*'( *.% *./ *.$ *.- *.) %&* %&/ %*( %*) %*./$%0  3   # 2    6

+*

0

#  3 

  #  # 

  2 "61=+*# 6   ," 1=+% "

 

  1=+/ !  ##

#  ##2  + Ex.C1 Photocopy of experience certificate of complainant issued by Avtar Motors, Kaithal.

Ex.C2 Photocopy of FIR No.341 dated 21.05.2009 under sections 406, 420, 467, 468, 471 of IPC, police station City Kaithal.

Ex.C3 Photocopy of application written by Jaimal Singh to The Chairman/Administrator, Improvement Trust Yamuna Nagar regarding transfer of plot no.467 situated in Sarojini Colony, Yamuna Nagar.

Ex.C4 Photocopy of affidavit of Jaimal Singh.

Ex.C5 Photocopy of application written by complainant to The Chairman/Administrator, Improvement Trust Yamuna Nagar regarding transfer of plot no.467 situated in Sarojini Colony, Yamuna Nagar in the name of Jaimal Singh. Ex.C6 Affidavit of complainant Rajiv Kumar.

 Ex.C7 Photocopy of letter dated 3.7.2009 written by Chairman, Improvement Trust Yamuna Nagar to complainant Rajiv Kumar.

Ex.C8 Photocopy of application written by Sandeep Kumar to The Chairman/Administrator, Improvement Trust Yamuna Nagar regarding transfer of plot no.466 situated in Sarojini Colony, Yamuna Nagar in the name of Arjun Singh. Ex.C9 Photocopy of affidavit of Sandeep Kumar.

Ex.C10 Photocopy of application written by Arjun Singh to The Chairman/Administrator, Improvement Trust Yamuna Nagar regarding transfer of plot no.466 situated in Sarojini Colony, Yamuna Nagar.

Ex.C11 Photocopy of affidavit of Arjun Singh.

Ex.C12 Photocopy of order dated 20.06.2009 passed by learned Sessions Judge, Kaithal.

Ex. C13 Voter list of village Lalhari Kalan of the year 1998. Ex. C14 Photocopy of visiting card in the name of Poonam Kumar, Manoj Kumar and Vijay Kumar.

Ex.C15 Photocopy of a writing issued by Sarpanch, Gram Panchayat of village lalhari Kalan regarding the relation between complainant and accused Sanjiv Kumar. Ex.C16 Photocopy of pedigree table.

Ex.C17 Certified copy of statement of PW-2 Teul Ram recorded in civil suit titled Telu Ram Vs. Transport Commissioner and others.

Ex.C18 Photocopy of judgment dated 01.08.2011 passed in civil suit titled Teul Ram Vs. The Transport Commissioner and other.

Ex.C19 Photocopy of report of DSP (Headquarter) Kaithal and photocopy of statement of Surender Pal, Clerk sought under the RTI Act. Ex.C20 Photocopy of letter dated 9.10.1995 issued by Employment Directorate, Haryana. Ex.C21 Photocopy of letter dated 06.04.1995 issued by Employment Directorate, Haryana. Ex.C22 Photocopy of letter issued by District Employment Officer, Kaithal.

Ex.C23 Photocopy of letter dated 26.05.1987 issued by Employment Directorate, Haryana. Ex.C24 Photocopy of Procedural Circular No.10/95/7.9 issued by District Employment Officer, Kaithal.

2 Ex.C25 Photocopy of information sought by Sanjiv Verma from Employment Office under RTI Act.

Ex.C26 Photocopy of information supplied by District Employment Officer to Sanjiv Verma.

Ex.C27 Photocopy of information supplied to Sanjiv Verma by District Employment Officer. Ex.C28 Photocopy of register of employment office, Kaithal bearing the particulars of complainant. Ex.C29 Photocopy of dispatch register of Employment Office, Kaithal.

Ex.C30 Photocopy of experience certificate of complainant issued by Laxmi Agricultural Implements Works, Kaithal. Ex.C31 Photocopy of a register of employment office, Kaithal. Ex.C32 Photocopy of a register of employment office, Kaithal. Ex. C33 Photocopy of notification of vacancy issued by General Manager, Haryana Roadways, Kaithal.

Ex.C34 Photocopy of vacancy order register.

Ex.C35 Photocopy of dispatch register of employment office, Kaithal.

Ex.C37 Photocopy of letter dated 13.02.2016 written by General Manager, Haryana Roadways, Kaithal to Transport Commissioner, Haryana regarding interview schedule for the post of Storeman.

Ex.C37 Photocopy of list of candidates forwarded by employment office for the post of Storeman.

Ex.C38 Photocopy of selection list for the post of Storeman. Ex.C39 Photocopy of letter dated 22.2.2010.

Ex.C40 Photocopy of information supplied by District Employment Officer to State Information Commissioner.

Ex.41 Photocopy of register of employment office, Kaithal. Ex.C42 Photocopy of register of employment office, Kaithal.

1

+ 

$ &

$  -

  -$ +   ,   (# )

*

#!!

   & +





#$  %!

' $& 

- - 

(# )

*

0

    

 $$!



$   $

  



4 

)- "

-$

+ - 

) " - 

"$

   

  !

+

--

" +

#$  %!

 "

)-!

$  4  

$$ !   --

   5  

   -   - 

) " 

+ 



  +

&  

-!   

 - "5

  

$

,

+



$   $

  

$$ !

  

7+ -    &



+  

)   

-$ - #+ !

  9 #+  7

- (-$*

:+ - 7"

 &



+ ! ! $ ;3

-$

$$ !

   " $ 

$

-$ 4$ $ 

9-$ $$ 

  9 

#+ !

$  !

-$

+

! & 

$   

! - $ -

 4 

-$ $$4 

45

)    !



 - 9 #+ 

<

"



)   

"$ " 7"

  -

  

,

 9 

7+ -   &

"$ $ 

+  !!

 

  

 5

  - 9 #+ 

 +

-$

-$



  7"

54

- (-$*

3

-$

  

 

 $"$  ) 

   97+

-

;

& $

- 

 "+   



-$

  

$$ !

  

!!

  

-$

-$ -"

    &

 !$ - 4 

  

!     

4  

-$

-$ -"



4 -

$$ ! $  "

  

$$ !

$ -    &

&

 !

7"

$

-$

$ -    4 ") 

-$ 

!

!!

  

=+ 

4

    $$ !

-

$ "$

+ 

--

       & - $& 3 "

!

3 ' - !

   &

$$ !  

-$

$      $ !!

 "$

-&    

- $5 $$ !$  - 



    

- 5

! "$5  

$ =)   4$ $ 

-$ !

   "$   !

$  4





   "

+ !!



 !

"

$$ ! $$ !$ 

-$ - 



0 / 



!

5 + "$5  

 (   * $  "$

+

--  $

3 +

  &   

- &

-

**  

.,/,0&+ 

=   

 ?

> = 

"# ?

> = 

"# ?

>