High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/26862/2015allowed

Surjit Singh v. CBI Chandigarh

2015-08-31Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal7 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*

+,-.&"+&(/0 #"&"&(#- 1#-','

#("-!2,-#!, (3#'"&/!"&(4 0!($&/!-0 #'5($#("

) 67 + 8 7+ -#'#(") -/&($#-!2!"-!4$3%!"#4 -4 -!/.&"+&(/0+!-!4$3%!"#4 -"0#5#"&"&(#- -+,90$##5++!($0,4+#(&-+"!($&(/ ,('#24

--#'5($#(" :0#"0#-"0##5-"#-' 2%!2(#;'5!5#-<!=>#!22;#$"'## "0#.,$/<#("?

>#-# #--#$""0##5-"#--(" * :0#"0#-"0#.,$/<#("'0,2$>#-#5-"#$&("0#$&/#'"? 7+ 4

7 0&'&''#%($!552&%!"&( &2#$>="0#5#"&"&(#- -/-!("

-#/,2!->!&2&(

*$!"#$*4 -#/&'"#-#$ ,($#- +#%"&(' @@ @A@@A@AAB !"2&%#+"!"&( 0!($&/!-0&'#!-2&#-!552&%!"&(

-/-!(" -#/,2!->!&2;!'$&'<&''#$>="0&' ,-"43&$#-$#- $!"#$*@45!''#$&( *B@ @

-&# 2='"!"#$4!%-&<&(!2%!'#;!'-#/&'"#-#$!/!&('""0# 5#"&"&(#- - -/#-= !($ <&'!55-5-&!"&( >!(9 <(#=4 !<,("&(/"'4 4B4BB ("0&'-#/!-$4$!"#$

B;!'-#/&'"#-#$,($#-+#%"&('@@ @A@@A@AA B !"2&%#+"!"&( &"=8"9!5,-!4&'"-&%"!-&$9"4 !""0#&('"!(%# +0-&+8%00#-4-!(%0!(!/#-4,(.!>!($ +&($!(948"9!5,-!-!(%04&'"-&%"!-&$9" &('0-"6"0#!(96 0#-#!

"#-(B4"0#5#"&"&(#-',--#($#-#$># -#"0#"-&!2

,-"&(%!'#5#-"!&(&(/"$!"#$ B!($0#;!'

-#<!($#$ "52&%# %,'"$= - &3#$!='!($"0#-#!

"#-'#("" .,$&%&!2%,'"$=7!"#-( BB4"0#5#"&"&(#-;!'#(2!-/#$( -#/,2!->!&2,($#-+#%"&(A - !

"#--#<!&(&(/&(%,'"$=

-*<("0'!($*$!='-#5-",($#-+#%"&(A* - ;!'

5-#'#("#$ &( ,-" 0# %0!-/#' ;#-# -!<#$ !/!&('" "0# !%%,'#$5#"&"&(#- -< " @B ,-&(/ "0# 5#($#(%= "0# "-&!24 "; $&

#-#(" ' * !($ ** $!"#$ ;#-#/"-#/&'"#-#$!/!&('""0#!%%,'#$5#"&"&(#->="0# '!&$!(9("0#!22#/!"&('"0!"!/$#3+&(/0'( ($#-+&(/0 ;!'!22;#$"!3!&2%!'0%-#$&"2&<&" '2!%'(A

!/!&('" "0# <-"/!/# 2!($ <#!',-&(/ A 9!(!2' @ <!-2!'4 '&",!"#$!"3&22!/##0>!280,-$7!"#-(4!/$#3+&(/0$&'%2'#$ ""0#'!&$!(9"0!"0#;#'("0&(/""0#'!&$!(9!($"0!""0# 2!($0!'>##(-#$##<#$>="0#'!&$!";!-&0#!("&%&5!"-=>!&2&(

* "0# '!&$ %!'# ;!' $#%2&(#$ >= "0# ,-" 0# 5#"&"&(#- 0!'

%0!22#(/#$"0#2#/!2&"= "0#',>'#C,#("'&#'*!($ ** $!"#$ -#/&'"#-#$ ,($#- +#%"&('

@@ @A@@A@AA@B !" 2&%# +"!"&( &"= 8"9!5,-!4&'"-&%"!-&$9"4&("0&' ,-">= &2&(/ AB 4>,""0#'!<#;!'$&'<&''#$43&$#-$#-$!"#$*

((#D,-# ( "0# <#!("&<#4 "0# 5#"&"&(#- ;!' $#%2!-#$ ! 5-%2!&<#$

#($#-!'0#>#%!<#!>'#("># -#"0#"-&!2 ,-"&( %!'#5#-"!&(&(/"$!"#$ B ((#D,-# "&' ,-"0#-'"!"#$"0!"4"0#'!&$!(9 &2#$ *@BB B4 '##9&(/ $&-#%"&( " "-!('

#- "0# &(3#'"&/!"&( 5#-"!&(&(/"$!"#$ B4-#/&'"#-#$,($#-+#%"&('

@@ @A@@AB !" 2&%# +"!"&( &"= 8"9!5,-!4&'"-&%"!-&$9"4""0# 0&' ,-"43&$#-$#-$!"#$ B ((#D,-#A 4"-!('

#--#$"0#&(3#'"&/!"&(""0# 4 !($"0# ;!'$&-#%"#$"%<52#"#"0#&(3#'"&/!"&(;&"0&('&D <("0' -<"0#$!"# "!9&(/3#-"0#&(3#'"&/!"&("&''"!"#$"0!" (;"0#5#"&"&(#-;!'!--#'"#$(@!($0#&'#("&"2#$" -#/,2!->!&2 0!3#0#!-$2#!-(#$%,('#2 -"0#5#"&"&(#-42#!-(#$ '#(&- '"!($&(/ %,('#2 - !($ 0!3# !2' %!-# ,22= /(# "0-,/0"0# &2#

("0#2!'"$!"#4"0# ;!'$&-#%"#$"3#-& ="0#

@ %#-"& &%!"# ((#D,-# 4 &2#$>=+<"8,2>&-!28!,-4;& # "0# 5#"&"&(#-4-#/!-$&(/0#-$<&%&2#4;0&%0;!'&'',#$>="0##0'&2$!- "#-"0# 3#-& &%!"&(4 "0# 0!'',><&""#$&"' -#5-" !2(/;&"0 "0#- $%,<#("'4 ;0&%0 '0;' "0!" "0# $<&%&2# %#-"& &%!"# ;!'

&'',#$("0#!

&$!3&"' &2#$>="0#+!-5!(%04,(&%&5!2 ,(%&22- !($"0#'#2 !""#'"#$!

&$!3&"' "0#;& # "0#5#"&"&(#-!($0&'

5#"&"&(#-6' $!,/0"#- 0#!""#'"#$50"%5&#' !!$0!-%!-$4 $-&3&(/2&%#(%#450"3"#-&$#("&"=%!-$!($-!"&(%!-$>#!-&(/"0# 5-#3&,'!$$-#''&#+"-##"4 -##(3#(,#4!-&$9"4;#-# !2'!""!%0#$;&"0"0#3#-& &%!"&(-#5-"0#%#-"& &%!"# $<&%&2# 0!' >##( &'',#$ (2= - "0# 5,-5'# !$<&''&( &( "0# #$,%!"&(!2&('"&","&( "#%0(&%!2<#$&%!2&('"&","&('(2= ("0# !

&$!3&"4&"&''"!"#$>=8,2>&-!28!,-4;& # "0#5#"&"&(#-"0!"

#!-2&#-'0#;!'-#'&$#(" -##(3#(,#4+"-##"4!-&$9"4 !%9'&$# #("!2 22#/#4 !($ (; -#'&$&(/ !" 8!99!- 2(=4 !%9'&$#!"0!-,:-9'054#-E#5,-!$4#0'&2!($&'"-&%" !-&$9" "0!'>##('"!"#$"0!";0&2#$&'5'&(/ "0#5-#3&,'

!552&%!"&( "0#5#"&"&(#-<3#$,($#-+#%"&(A -&<&(!2 -%#$,-# $#(*@4"0&' ,-"0!$>'#-3#$"0!""0# '!&$0,'#&( -##(3#(,#4!-&$9"4;!'!$<&""#$2='2$!($"0!" "0# 5#"&"&(#- 0!$ "-&#$ " <&''"!"# %#-"!&( !%"' -#/!-$&(/ 0&'

-#'&$#(%#># -#"0&' ,-"4;0&%0;#-#"!9#(&("%('&$#-!"&(" $&'<&''"0#!552&%!"&(";!' ,-"0#-("&%#$"0!""0#5#"&"&(#-0!$

>#%<#!5-%2!&<#$

#($#- "0!'>##( ,-"0#-%("#($#$( >#0!2 "0!"#3#((;"0#$<&%&2#%#-"& &%!"#;!'>"!&(#$( "0# >!'&' ;-(/ !%"' >= +<" 8,2>&- !2 8!,-4 ;& # "0# 5#"&"&(#- 0#5#-,'!2 "0# !%"'!($%&-%,<'"!(%#''0;"0!""0# 5#"&"&(#-;!'&(&"&!22=!--#'"#$(("0#<#!(;0&2#4"0# 5#"&"&(#-;!'$#%2!-#$!5-%2!&<#$

#($#-!($"0#-#!

"#-;!'-# !--#'"#$>="0#,(.!>2&%#(B@0# !--#'"#$"0# 5#"&"&(#-(@ "&'!2'("!$#(=&(/ !%""0!"' !- %0!22!( 0!' (">##(5-#'#("#$&("0# ,-" "&'!2' ,-"0#- >-,/0" " "0# ("&%# "0&' ,-" "0!" "0#

#(%# ,($#- "0# -#3#("&( --,5"&(%"4B40!'!2'>##(!$$#$"&''"!"#$ "0!" "0#-# ;#-# &('"!(%#' -!,$4 '5-#!$ 3#- =#!-' %%-$&(/""0#&(3#'"&/!"&(/

&%#-4"0##<>#EE2#<#(";!'$(# >=5#-'('4;0&%0&'""0#",(# '@" %--#'0#-# -#4 "0# "9"&<#"&(3#'"&/!"#"0#%!'# "&' ,-"0#-'"!"#$"0!"

05# ,22=;&"0&( ,-<("0'4"0#%0!22!(;&22>#5-#'#("#$"%<#' ,""0!"(;"0#5#"&"&(#-&'&(.!&2 -"0#2!'"<-#"0!(F=#!-'

;&"0,""0#%0!22!(>#&(/5-#'#("#$>= !/!&('"0&< ;4"0#C,#'"&(;,2$!-&'#;0#"0#-(!%%,("

<&''"!"#<#(" %#-"!&( !%"' -#/!-$&(/ "0# !$$-#''4 %!( "0# 5#"&"&(#->#9#5">#0&($>!-' -&($# &(&"#5#-&$? &($"0!"'<#>!2!(%#0!'">#'"-,%9>#";##(

5#-'(!22&>#-"= "0#5#"&"&(#-!($"0#%2!&< "0# 0# 5#"&"&(#-%!((">#9#5">#0&($>!-' -&($# &(&"#5#-&$;&"0,"

"-&!2 3#(,($#-"0#-#3#("&( --,5"&(%"4B40#%!(># '#("#(%#$"&<5-&'(<#("3!-=&(/>#";##("0-##" &3#=#!-'!'

"0#<!D&<,<'#("#(%# "0#

#(%#&''#3#(=#!-'">#&(/'4 !< "0#3&#;"0!"(!%%,(" ((5-#'#("!"&( %0!22!( - <-#"0!(F=#!-'!($9##5&(/&(3&#;"0#%,'"$=5#-&$!2-#!$= ,($#-/(#4#3#(># -#"0#5-#'#("!"&( %0!22!(4"0#5#"&"&(#-&'

#("&"2#$"-#/,2!->!&2 ;4 "0# ,-"0#- C,#'"&( ;,2$ !-&'# !>,"

!55-#0#('&( "0!""0#5#"&"&(#-<!=!/!&(!>'%($ 0# !55-#0#('&(%!(>#<#">=&<5'&(/'"-&%"%($&"&(' ( 3&#; "0# <!""#-4 "0#5#"&"&(#- &' -$#-#$ " ># -#2#!'#$( ,-(&'0&(/5#-'(!2>($'&("0#',< ' 44 ;&"0(#',-#"=&("0#2&9#!<,("""0#'!"&' !%"&( "0#2#!-(#$

0&# ,$&%&!2 !/&'"-!"#4 !-&$9"4 ;0&%0 ;&22 ># &<<3!>2# 5-5#-"=4',>.#%"""0# 22;&(/%($&"&(')

& "0!"5#"&"&(#-;&22-#'&$#!"8!99!- 2(=0,'#&# 0,'# 0&'$!,/0"#-!"!-&$9"$,-&(/"-&!2G

&& "0!"5#"&"&(#-;&22-#5-"(#3#-=($!="+ 4&( ;0'#.,-&'$&%"&(8!99!- 2(=4!-&$9"4 !22'!($"0#+ '0!22

,-"0#-'#($"0#-#5-"""0# G

&&& "0!"5#"&"&(#-;&22("2#!3#"0#%,("-=;&"0,""0#5-&-

A 5#-<&''&( "0#"-&!2 ,-"G

&3 "0!"5#"&"&(#-;&22("/&3#!(=&($,%#<#("4"0-#!"!($ 5-<&'#"!(=;&"(#''!($;&22("$&-#%"2=-&($&-#%"2=%("!%"!(= ;&"(#''!%C,!&("#$;&"0"0# !%"' "0#%!'#G

"0!"5#"&"&(#-;&22!2'',--#($#-0&'5!''5-"4& !(=4 ># -#"0# !

"#-0&'-#2#!'# 0#$#'("0!3#"0#5!''5-"4 0#;&22(">##("&"2#$"!(=5!''5-""&22"0#%(%2,'&( "0#"-&!2G

3& "0!""0# ;&22!2'&( -<!22"0#5-"'!($!&-5-"'4 $&-#%"&(/"0#<(""!22;"0#5#"&"&(#-"2#!3#"0#%,("-=

'.9'