Dr.Virinder Kumar v. Sukhdev Singh &ORS
!"!
#$%&%'
($ )*( % + ( *
! "#!$ %
&
!'
"#!$
# ( ) "#!$ &!
+ "#!$ &!*!"!, "-
/" "#!$ &!*!"!0
( *,%- *.
2*&"2'
)
""
"-456-55,* "2' !! "
.
&&"! 8/!01#29:
$
)"& )!& ! / !, 7 / ) "
) ) )$: " / !- 7;/ /.!&$!.* !: #" 2' " # " .*/)"
" - " " "
" -456-55, * " 2' "
% ""$!.* !!&, <- 555=3!/!&!
$!.* !!&0 66 555=3".
"2' # %!&$! 2/!'
) )$ 2/ 2 !
)) #" 2' & ) !& " ! / !& $! 2/!'
) )$ % /&& $!.* ! 0 " & $! " ) $! !
" 2'
*!" "2' **$
)# "$ "2' >36 ! '% ! "
"$!$ /"") )$! ?!&@5A! * !&
6 " $!/ &!
)/"
* $ *!" !,3" # !& !&&"
) #
$ ! % ) )
"! $! 2/" $ / )
" &/ $
."
$!.* !! ""!
! ' /&& "
! ( !
$! " $!.!&
"&
"!$ $/ ! !& )$ '! $$!/!&@5A"
'"/! /&&"2'
" @ " $!/ &! *!"
# /**!" $!$ / !" %2' "
# "
%
>36
""/ ' ".
"
"% "3 !$!
!
!
" * $!& "% 05&% "
)@ &( $
2.! " " % !#
$ 2% $
"!&&"
)2/ %
$ '*!#
% ;/ '
*! 2 &!$ / " % "2' " C & )!&$! 2/!') )$ '"*" /*! $!&!.
!! $!&$!..
! %
"$! 2/" $ / !& "*$ ! '% ! "% !
**" !% 2!?% B/"3
>36 " # !&!&&"
)2/
"! " >
"! " .
!&
" ! !
! # "$
2 ?$* &! $!3 ?
!!&
%
>36 !$!$ /" $! 2/!' ) )$ ! * !&
"
2 ".
"2'*!"!, "- !%# "
2' **$
) $!3?
! !& >6
" $!$ /""
$! 2/!') )$ < $! " ! .!& # %
& )!$!""
2' " $ !2/
" " . / !&.
3 !&$!3?
!!& >6 "
! '$! ""* !&$!3?
!2/
! ( $!3?
!
$! " ! %
!/) !
#2 (D! */*!!& "'
&$ $!3?
!!& >6 *!"/$" /"3
!!!"
# $ %
&! !!!" '
&( !!!"
#
) *
#
+ ,
#
-
&&#
& -
&
. /
# .#
0#123*
& &4
& &4
#
# )
#
'
! # " .5
67 8 #
5
9 4 & $!3?
!!& >6 !)% !.
" ?
!3 3$
& ) " ! .
!& " ( !
$! " ! $ '.
"!/
>6
"*$ & ' "
2/ ! +3,,3E@<-!&&"
)#
$ % "/ '! $" >6$!.
)&!.
!**! " "2/% *!$!&!# ( ) $!! ' >6
" " ?
!3 3$
&
% "
/ $ *"!&@5
! $!$ &
" "!& !
" >6
" !
"
2/% 2 )" # ") ).
)
*" "%
( )!# $!! '
"
)
$ >6
3
** "2 (
$
" .!$!.!
% %
2'2/ / ) # "
) ! $ " !
. " *!
$$!.* '
. >36"/ ' "
2/% " #2'*!" !,3/( "# "D!,C5"
",05E,EE4% !")" 2!# !"& $ " ?
!3 3$
&"!2(* .
"%
**$
) . .
" $!3?
! ' 2$ /
"*!" 2/&!. "
$!& 2!/5-&/ !)
""
$2% $!3! ' "$ % ,3,=-&/ !) .!& " % !#
$ 2%2/ "$ %!/ "! "!
$!$ / !
"$! 2/" $ / )
"
' . ' 2$ /!
"% 05&% "%!/ " !! "! $!$ / !
"$! 2/" $ / )
" 2!#& $"!2$! ""% !!&
%
"*$ & ' "
% "
$ .!" *"! &
" "!&!
"%
$!$ "!& !
"
" !$
."
""/ ' ** " 2 (
$ %
2' 2/ *!$!&!# ( ) $!3! ' "% %
" .!!**" & $ "2' >36
! 2$! $"! !%!2%!)2'*!"!,2' *! ## "$*!"!,3" #!&!&&"
)#
$
! "!$!. !% 2!? ".
( .) "
).
!&
"!!
"& $$!3?
!& # "$!& >36
!
' $ '.
"!/
"!$! 2/"
2'% '!& ' $!&!.
!!$!..
$ / ) ""
"
,-5E,EE4 & ) !& " ) " ! $! 2/!'
' ) )$ &! $ !2/
" $$!"
) ' " E " $!/ &!
! $
)"
;/ /. !& $!.* ! "
) " &! !% $!.* !# " .*/)" "3 :
! )!& ) @5 555=3
:
"/&& @5 555=3
:
'
, 55 555=3
#:
?*! *! @5 555=3
"
"*$
"
#:
!!& . @5 555=3
"B!'.!& & :
!!& " # 0C 555=3
:
"
# 4 555=3 !
0 66 555=3 ,5 $ !& B/'% B/"
"/&&"*.
' $!.* * '
2 ! B/"$
/" "!& 8 .2/.!?*!& *! !$
) "
$
) *$
"
9 8*
"/&& )9 8 !!& $!."/ ) .9 8 ! !& ) $ ' ! $$!/ !& *.
9 8 ! !& &//
. !& &9 8 !!&&//*!*$9 "8&//."
?*9 ,,
& ."
?* $!$"
"$
."&/ .2/.&!.
.* !'2 !#. !$!
2) ",@ 555&!?*!% " *! ! "
"*$
"
*# "$ "2'
".
" !*
F"&!,C"
' .
"/" .!&"!$!&! .! !$
."
% $!& "!2"&! .! /" "# $!&
4 "!$! * ) # % ! * !" !& !*
! " .
.!/ !& 65 555=3 %!/ " 2 **!*
/" " !& *! ! "
$
) "*$
"
./
# /&&" ! !& &// .
" /&&" *.
'! $$!/!& ! )!& ) " $".!#.!&
"
$$!"
) '
2 "!$!.* !!& , 55 555=3&! !!& .
!#.!$!
" ./
# /&&" ! !& &// *!*$ ! ! $$!/ !& *.
$$!"
) ' .!/!&, 55 555=3 ""
!% " ! !& &// *!*$ ! # "$
2 " ! !% ;/ .!& '&//."
?* &!!$!.* '
2 /"
" " "
) "$!.* !!& @5 555=3!% "*
"/&& ) %
"!2
$" . $$!"
) '
$"!, 55 555=3
!
2 ) " 0C 555=3 !% " ! !& " # " 4 555=3 !% " !!&."
# & ."
# $!$"
."
#
2 !!#..* !' .
!& )
" ' !$
2 $$!"
) ' !$!.* !&! !!&!& ."
# B/ & " & !!& " # $!$"
. $
2 .!& .!&!#..* !' & /2
# ( ' .!/ ! "
$ ! ! !#..* !' $$!"
) ' !!& " #"/ )* !"!& . !2$! "" !/&&""/ ) .2'
" " #&! .! )-5 555=3 * .! &! %!/ "2 " !
5 C5 555=3 ! $$!/ ! !& " #= ! !& $!. "/ . ,- .
$! !/ / ) "! !!& '!%
"! # %!&@5A*.
'/&&"! $$!/!& $".!#.!& . ! )!& )2'5-$. ,0
".
" ' *$ * ! !#. .* !'%!( "!$! !#. !* "$!/ &! / $!.* '
&"!B/"). " 6# !""1/#
78#9* %:"%+!";;# /+;/7# #/% -5--7-: G7:
,<@! )/
% B/" !#..* !'% !
"/&&"
*.
%!/ "!2 "! !!& )$ ' $! /!2 # $ *$
$! /"
# $ " "!
.!&/* / " &! ! " ! ' ! !& ) $ '
" ! /&&" !!& )! $$!/!&*.
B/' ,6 # %!&B/").$ "2' "$!/ &!/ $ !.* ' & ". $ *!B$"2' "$!/ &!/ $ !.* '*$
$! /"!2 !#. .* !' " % ) .
' # & /&& ) *.
*.
! "!/2 ./
# $/
"
B!'.!& . !& & &// &//*!*$ " &!
!/
"'
$"$!.* !/" "# 8*
"/&& )9 8 !!&&// . 9 "8 !!&&//*!*$9 # %!&& $ "$ $/. $!& *$ %
$! /!.
# $
# "!
.!& /* / ! !$!.* !&! !!& )$ '! $$!/!& *.
B/'
2* '
2 ,@
$$!"
) ' 3%!(" $!.* ! * '
2 !
/"3
"
?* *! !
"
$
) 65 555=3 !!& . , 55 555=3 !!&&// *!*$ , 55 555=3
"/&& ) , 55 555=3 !!& "
#= !!& $!. "/ )* !"!& . 66 555=3 70C 555H4 555:
C5 555=3 !.* !
""2'
, <- 555=3 !.* !
""
6 55 555=3
$.!& $!.* ! 6 55 555=3 "" :3 , <- 555=3 ""2' :
- -4 555=3 ,C
3$
! 2 " ! !#
$" .!/= .!/""/$"! $$!/!&$! 2/!') )$!
?!&<@A&!. "
!&&
)!&$
.* !
!
'!&*!"!* '$!.* !
2 * " ,<
"
*!"!& 2!#. ,4
"
** !7: & ' ""
*!"!& - ( *.
%&%'
:
2 ) # " ;
<"'
)
;
<"'