High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/26968/2017disposed of

Jaskaran Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2022-12-19Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl13 pages

!" !

$%&'()&*+,+'-.

" #$

& ' ( ) )&*+*,)&-./ #

',& (( 0 )

&+-1&-&1

& '

" 3 "

&+-1&-&1

0 ### !" !

',& (( 0 )

&+-1&-&1

" 3 "

&+-1&-&1

!" !

" "

( )

)&*+*,)&-./ 0

',& (( 4

53 .&& &1.&&-.- 1&* 1&'

1&1

1'.

11* .', .'+ 3( 6 1-/ 3(

7 &8

&/98'98+

# ! !

./-+&-.'

1&* 1&'

1&1 " .'+ 1'. 3( 4 1-/ 3( !

())1+/+):)&-.'

./-+&-.'

)

# " $! % &'"

()"

! &*"+*

" # $

# $

%"$&

( "((" ) ; " 53 .&& &1.&&-.-

1&* 1&'

1&1 1'.

11* .', .'+ 3( 6 1-/3(

7 &8 &/98'98+

# ! !

;

" 4 "

" 4

1-/ 3( ())1+/+):)&-.' " 0

./-+&-.'

0 "0 # 0 "

9 ',& (( 4

53 4

./-+&-.' 3

&,-/&-./ ())1+/+):)&-.'

" !

.8-.&-., 0

( "

" 3 " !

") *+

, -

. # ( # $

. (. $

." (( -("

& .(," /&0

(. $

$-$$ &

$ (. $

- 0 .( $ - & 1 ,0

(. $ ,

. - " $ #

, "( 1 $

. # ( ($ $ "$ $

/ .

(. , ($ , ." , 23-

" $ ) -'-1&-&-

( "

'- ---9)

*- ---9)

,- ---9) "

< = 5

,- ---9) " " 3 :

&* (

" 0

< < < :<

0 ( "

0 "

0 0 !

> < ( 3 *!!' (('

,-./

01,0 23 (' 4 * # + ""

%+) 5*%#+6

&+-+&-&.

0 " 2 4 (

> < ( 3 3 (' % * 67 " >

',& (( " 0 !

") * 1 .("

& 0 "

, + $ $ $ !&- 0 ( '- 0 /0 /

((" , ( $ ."

'.. -"$ $ "

$ $

4. 5 '.. ! $

& "(

0 # "

, , ,

$ '.. ! "(

- #

-$ ,

. '.. #

, (

$ , "$ (

$ #

, $ $0 6 4 , 0 785 $ ( ,

& , '

( 4( $" $ $ ( $" $ 1 -5 '( 6 9. :

& $(0

;$ "$ ( / 4+50 '- (& ( $

'.. "$ (

$ #

< " ( ,

"$ (

$ #

<<< <<< <<<

1 2

,0 & $

" ,

,,( $

. & (-

$ ."

& ( # ( $

" , ( , ( .($ 0 ( =" "( .($ <( ,

.# "$ ( 0 & ,

,,( (."$- 1 2

" ( $"- - & "

(=" ,,( ,

,,( -$

-$ , $ & $" $

, $.

. ( ..( "

, 0 & , "." $0 $

. :

& ->( ,

$ , ( >" (

.. "

( .($ & &

" ,,( #

,,( .$ , . & "0 ( - " $ .( & ,

$ - (( "$$ .. $ $ $

(& ( 2$ "

, , $ & >" ( (

$ , .. # & # "->(

#," <(.

( # (. "( . (& ( 0

" "

<( "( $ ( #

(

"$0 . & #

( (" ( ""$

( $

(. - &$ 0 $ #

$" $

" $ " ,

,,(0 - $

($"( ,

(("$0 -, $ ,

( $( 1 "( , <(

< $ .# "$ ( #" $ - ("

$ , >" ( 1 ( - $ $ , ( (

.# ,

$ "- >" ( ' ( & ( "( , .# "$ (

$ $ .( " >" (0 #

& ,( $ ( (" ( , (0

$ & >" ( ?

$0 ( # " ,,( & - .&$ .. 0 "( -, "

- < $$0 ("

" -&$ -

" ! $

@?& ,">-@?$;< !4".5 <<< <<< <<<

" "". $ $

..$ (

" =" " $$ -

(. - #

. .( , ,,( 7(."$- 8 #

,#0

< $ .# > $ ".

" "$ ( & $

"$ ' (

0 ( - &$ -$

$ -"$ , (

0 #

"( .# , # $ .

"$ "

- <( $ (,"

( < , =" ( .($ 0 - $B 4 5 ! " $ ,,( ,

,,(

(( " ,

( C 4 5 " ,

>"0 , C 4 5 D " " , (. - #

(("$ $

& ( C @ 4 &5 $"(

(("$ .0 . $ ,

(("( ,

.". $,,($

& ( $ )

" ; 0 " >

',& (( 0 1&- (( 3 0

) >

;

( 77,8080701,9 %"% 0.1,01,: ? 5*;#+ % "+*# # ""

5&<= %

"+*#6 " ',& (( !

" ?

, $ "$ ( , =" ,

+ !

0 $ $

6 4'<" "$ (

0 0

6 $

4"-=" $$$ ( 6 $

50 $ ( $ !# 0 E ( !# 0

- , (. $ $ 4'<" 5 $

"-=" .($

, ( "$

>"$

, (& ( $ $ , (0 -

$ $

.$ -

$ '$$ "$ 0 $ F

! 0 # -

(("$.

0 # (& ( $ $ ($ <<<G<<<<<< H" ,

, $ + $

$ ,

$ >"$ $ $ , ( $ $

.$ -

$ '$$ "$ 0 $ F

! 0 "

- , (. $ $ 4'<" 50 $ - #

. $"

.$(,

.. -,

" <<<<<<<<< "

( , &= !3+ % "+* *#&# ""

*) % "+* 01,>- *!!' ,10 ( $$

(."$ , ,,(

.. $

-&$

& # ..

(& ( .$ -,

" $ . $ (. 0

" & $ ". .# "$

( =" ( .($ ("

$,>" ($ -&$"$B * 1 ," & .# "$ (

#&0 $ $-

" ,

.# "$ ( ($" $ $ . ... $ ("

$,>" (

' $

$"- <.$ -

$ "$ #

.# "$ ( ($" $

( .($

- , (. $ - #

. ( - &$ & ,

(("$ - $ $ (& ( $ -

" 0 # , $

?* * !% *#&' "

%+) 5*%#+ 4 * 011.0 *!!' /,1 011.9 8/-0

", " $ ."

$ ,

.. "-$5 $ - (& ( $ "$ ( 6' $ $ $ ($

3 . $ .. # .$ -,

, .. (" 1 '.< " =" $

( .($ . & #

.(" ,( $ ( (" ( ,

( $

, >" ( -&

I( " , ( .($ #" $ - -" ,

.( , #I $ - &

.# "$ ' (

(

" $ . .#

"$ ' (

( $ $( ( - ( "$ & & $

"( ". .#

J 1 "$ , >" $ ( <( - -

" "$ ( ($" $ #

& # .&

-" , # ("

$ , >" (0 #&0 # $ "

( "$ .# ="

.($

(."$- ,,(

- "$ (

($" $ -"

"( .#0 " ( $$ & #0 <( - &

<. - $ & , "( .# ," >" , $,( $( (" (,

(

6<<<<<<

<<<<<<

.(" ,( $ ( (" (

. -"

( & 4 ( "$ $"

$ # , .$ !

& ".. $

0 # ,

( $$ & #

(. #" $ $ :

. $ (" . ,

, - # &

> , !((.

( ,

(. #" $ $ $ , (. >" ( #

& ( , " >" ( $ & (

- & , .# "$ ( ($" $ , (& ( , (("$ -

" $ $" .$( , .. "(

(& ( 0 .. - , ( &

>" $ ( $ $#

.($ "->(

( , "$

=" $ ,

, $0 # #

$ $

>"$ $ $ $ $ .$ !

, '$$ , "$ ( / 0 2 0

- , (. $ $ 66

&$ - #

.$ ! 4 E& 5 # > ="

' ( ( 0

( (. , $ - .$ ! $ $ ="

- , -& $ (. "

.. .,$ -

-& $ $ $ $ #" $ - $$ ,"( "" $ -$( $-

, '.. " 2 ) 0

( , 3+' !3+ *#&# ""

5&<= 01,-> *!!' 98. # -

(("$ # (& ( $ "$ (

$ # ($ "$ " . , # 0

. $ (. $"

.$( ,

.. 1 " ".

>"$ , ' +% *#&# ""

*) 011/ 9 *!!' .>. % ++ " !3+ *#&# ""

5&<= ,//80 *!!' >/0 #$

(."$ , ,,( .( , ,,( "$ (

.. #

# - .

.( - #

. 0 "( ,,( ( - (."$$ <<<G<<<<<< '(($ 0+!

0$ $

6 4'<" "$ (

0 0

6 $

4"-=" $$$ ( 6 $

50 $ ( $ !# 0 E ( !# $ "-="

.($

,0 ="

(("$ .

0 =" $0

- , (. $ $ 4'<" 50 "->(

. , ( , 00 - $. $

">- ; & ('"

0 $ =" 0

>"$ , (& ( $ $ , (0 -

$ $

.$ -

$ '$$ "$ 0 $ F

! 0 $ "->( . ,( ) (

(

-+-1&-./ ( 1+- &-./ 2&'%( !3+ # !<)&*% "+*6 ) ? ( ( - . ($ &#+') ? ! ##% #

(;!#+ * + * 01,, 0 *!!' 0/. $ ? %* 5*=+& # )% ='' 01,1 ,1/8 1 & >" $ ( ,

" , ( #" $ "

- -"

$ , >" ( - #

& , , $

(. " 0 -, $ $,,"$" , "( (. =" #" $ & &

,&" ,

. , # $"

( ( - & -

" 1 & <( #" $ - ((

. ,(

J,! - " '( . ( . $ $# ? %* 5*=+& # )% =''01,1,1/80#" $-=" , , $ ,

(. =" #$ - ,,( $ - #

. #

" & # , , $0 ."

$ >"$ $ $ J .$ - '$$ "$ 0 /" - & $ (& ( $ ( ,

# ".

$ $ =" $

& .

#$ "->(

$. , K ,

( =" " . $ $# ? %* 5*=+& # #&(* ; & ( '"

0 ,

$ - , (="( !( (="( , #)

> < ( ? %* 5*=+& # )%

='' 01,1 ,1/8 "

( "

% " "

> < ( 3 3 ('

4 * # 67

" 0

0 ( 5 0

1-/ 3( 0

" 0

0 0 3 ( !

0 0 &-.-

" 0 "

" !

9 "

0 " 5 0 0

4 ) "

" "

53 .&& &1.&&-.- 1&* 1&'

1&1 1'.

11*

.', .'+ 3( 6 1-/ 3(

7 &8 &/98'98+

# ! ! 4

./-+&-.' 0

!! 0 " 01! 2

&*&34&5 6 E& $L" = 9

@9A = @9A