(O&M) V.K.Chandela v. Nawab










 





 



























 







 






 


!"## $ "%&'()*+"(, #" &#--#..  "/+( "(, #""#-#    

 







        !"#$#"%%





   !


" 



 








 





 


!"## $ "/+( "(, #" &#--#..  "0&1&' &(, #" "%231&' &(, #"," 42#, "5"#-#  6  

 #











   !


" 



 





 $ 
% &


 





 


!"## $ "/+( "(, #" &#--#..  "0&1&' &(, #" " %23 1&' & (, # " "#-#       



 '











   !


" 



 










 




 


!"## $ "/+( "(, #" &#--#..  "%&'()*+"(, #""#-#    

 (











   !


" 



 





 

 






 


!"## $ "/+( "(, #" &#--#..  "%&'()*+"(, #""#-#     

 )







 



 







 






 


!"## $ "%&'()*+"(, #" &#--#..  "/+( "(, #""#-#    

 "&

 '( )* &+!,+-%"*&*.' %--)   

 &*.' %--)/!01 

7&'"#"8'..'-#


 

,"42#, '

 &##&(##+#"9#* +#8" # 



-#43 &# ",,'#  .'+ 7"'4*.
"'48&#"#43,+-# '&4####,,* # &1'23!.#&0%'9&%&"+'2*"'#* '#43 "*  &'-. %'9& 8&#"# 1) &#. '.# &# ,.'+ " +9# "* ' ":;

<
 

 &(# 4## '.# 43 7&# "'# . *",# = 8'

&8&+ &##'9(#&',.# "*,0;!

8'*"# "42#, '

'
  

&(#4##-"##""#43%+  #"8 ' &#"'"#-#, # & 1'23!.


&4##'.#43'2*"#5,.'+ "*  

  

 43 1) &#. 
" &# 0#  ,(#'#,# &#-"

'#&..4#"##""# >'*",#,+-3? >,.'+ ?










 !
" #$%#



*#. " &# '*",# ,+-3 8*. "9*# ,(#"  # ' "#-#,   "*,0 ' @*# ' 8 ##, '(# "+

   

  7&# '*"# '*# ,&#@*#  #   " -3+#   -"#+'*+  / 5   7&# +# 8 -"## # " #,&+#   



  9  '&"# 7&# '*",# ,+-3 ,,#..# &# -.',3  #  ' '+ &# '*"# 8'

& "#9" '&*" &#,&#@*#8#..,,#.. ' &#-.',3('#.#

#"  # <



 '"9*#  &#'*",#,+-3&,,#..#

&# -.',3 +*,& -"'" &# ,,*""#,# ' @*# 0 -.,# 



 

 &#'*",#,+-3, 4#.#8'

&.'4'.'

3 -3 ,+-# '   &# .

#" '(# '

' -"3#  #(# ' &# '*",# ,+-3 ' &#. .'4.#  -3 ,+-# &# ,.'+  "#,(#"3 "'9&  +3 4# 9'(# 9' &# '*"#  &#"# 8  , ",   '*",# &# #,,'# '#  

 7'.@* *+,+-# '..8#'(*"%& 1) &#."+9# &#"#'+"* ',"'

'"9*# +"* ',"'

+#. &#,,*""#,#'@*# '&&--## 4* <3#" &#"# #" '*"

&#""9*# &#(#&',.#8'-#, # 43 &# *"(#3"  '*",# ,+-3  &# -"#-"# "#-"   #





AB/C5##. *#/

 ' *"

&#" "9*# &# ,.'+  '.#  *,# ,9#   ,(','9 #('#,# *--"

''9 &#7"'4*...8'9,+-#

*#/

<< -@*+9# &#+"* ',"

*#."#-"## '9 &#,.'+  #"8 ' &#" "*1) &#.&(#*--"

#''9 &#7"'4*.&.'9

&# '*",# ,+-3 .'4.#  -3 ,+-# ' #(# ' &# ,&#@*# '*# 43 &# '*"# " -3+#   -"#+'*+ 9  '&*"# " -.',3 ' @*# ' 8 ,,#..# *#" ' '+ &# '*"#   *--"

 &#'", # ' &#3&(#"#.'#*-2*9+# :?4.# %*-"#+# *"

 &'
 !(
)* +&

,!
-
).
 !
/&*

0 1

0(2(.1
% 7"#* #, # ' &#'*",#,+-3",&..#9'9 @* *+,+-# '8'

&"#9" +9# +"* ',""#' ,*#. " &# ,.'+  8*. "9*# &# 7"'4*.   # '.# ,'#" '".,*+# "3#('#,#"#,"&""'(# 

''9 &# ,.'+  -#  /6 8" '#"#  '

#+  ,,"'9.3 &# ,.'+  8 "'9& .3 "#'+4*"# *#  /

<< -

*#. "#-"## '9 &# ," 42#, " '
    

&-"3#"#&,#+# ,+-# ' &#-"#+'# 7"'4*.& ..8#4##'

',"##'',+#"* *"#-"-#,  #*, # 5""-#".#B-##9' 5 & 4#..8#' ,'",*+ ,# &#--.', '&4##'.#438'8 &"##+'" ,&'."#-"#  &##,###@* #,+-# ''.'4.#

4#-'*#",(# '.&#:#&., ## ',+#

&# #,## ' .'4.#  4# ##  &# 4'    #+#   " /2##"%''#+-.3#"1'23!.

*#." &#'*",#,+-3&*--"

##+# +#43 &#7"'4*. '*"

&#""9*# ,"42#, '&(#4## -"##""# #"-#"' 3#"',#'.'9--#. &#"#'#.3 +"# &6

3'"# '.'9 &#,"42#, '8'

&* 3 9'4.# #B-. ' 7&#7"'4*.'-" &#8"8&'.##.'98'

& @*# '>8&'"#-'4.#"-3+# ,+-# '?&&#. -3+#   -"#+'*+ '  ,,#"  &'" -"

3  *4#@*# ,,#.. ' &#-.',3*# '&",&#@*#8*. #, "'9&  &'"-"

38&',&&,,"*# &# #,,'# /##"#,#& 4##+# 2*9+# ' ).
 !
/&*
+&*-" &*"

&#" 4##&#. -"-."'*"'9 &##'9 "*,08*4+'

#

    &# ,,'#  & 0# -.,#   

  &#@*# 4#"'9  

 AB/5  8 '*#     &#"#"#

*4#@*#  ,,#.. '  -.',3 *#  '&"  ,&#@*# 8*.  #, "'9&  &#,.'+  !#"*.  &# "#' 4#"( ' .#(#  +#"  *4 &#7"'4*.& "#2#, #-.# &#'*",#,+-3 *#  '&"  ,&#@*# " -3+#   -"#+'*+ &# -.',3 8 ,,#..#*#' '+ '8# &#'*"#C&# &#,  ,'",*+ ,# &#-"## ,#"##B+'#' &#.'9& 2*9+#  :?4.# &# %*-"#+# *"

 ' ).
 !
/&*
+& *-"  ' '

'',*.

'#"8'

&''9 &#7"'4*. &#'*",#,+-3 , #,-#'

.'4'.'

3 -3,+-# &#,.'+ :8#(#"  &#,,'# 0-.,# #",,#.. ' &#'*",#-.',3*#" *# ' '+ &# '*"# &# '*",# ,+-3 &.. 4# # '

.# "'9& "#,(#"39' &#'*"# #"',&"9'9'

.'4'.'

3 8"

&#,.'+    &'('#8  &# +

#" ''9 &# 7"'4*. 8'

& "#9" "#-'4'.'

3 -3,+-# '"#+''#,,"'9.3 7&#7"'4*.&8"#*+/

<< '"#-#,  +9# "* ' "+#.

',,*""#,# 0-.,#'-"'.

7&#,.'+ #B+'#94'"%'9&!C < -"(#4'..AB!C<5  &#(.*#/6 8"'#"# '

#++# '# &#"#'7&# 7"'4*.'-"  &#8"& ',# 94'"%'9&-"*,# ,* #"'.4'.."+%"

 #





%"

7&# 4'.. 4#"'9 6  #   

 ' &# 4'.. ' @*# '  7&# 4'..  6 '  # 6   8&#"# 4'..   '  # 6 <  %'+'.".3 4'.. 6  '  # <   8&#"# 4'.. 6 '  #   

70'9('#8"+ &# #4'..6 4# <   &#4'..'@*# '6 4# #  

'

,"# #*4

< 8'

&"#9" 9#*'## &#4'..-"*,#4394'"%'9& .3

&'' &#4'..AB!C<5 &#"#'+# '-*",&#43&#.." "#"8'8"#"'00'#.#, "',8"08&',&+'

#.38 #435( "7&#,.'+ & -"*,#34'..8'

& "#9" -*",&#'

#+*,&43&#.." "#"8'8"#" '00'  #.#, "',. 8"0  7&#"# '  #B-. ##"# 43 ,.'+    &8  4'.. & 4## '*# 43 5 (  " 8'

& "#9" &#"#'-*",&##.#, "',8"0' &#4'..'@*# '   ,*+*. '(# ,'#" 

"#'

8 #"'* , "', '5',"#-,'# ' &# ,#  ,.'+  ' "#-#,   4'.. AB!C<5 '

 ' '',*.

 '"+ ''9  &# 7"'4*. ,.'+ '# '

.# 9# ,+-# ' &#4'4'..AB!C<5 7&# '*",# ,+-3 --' #  *"(#3"  '-#, (#&',.#  &# *4+'

# &' "#-"

 (.*'9 +9# *#  /

  70'9 '  ,'#" &# "#-"

 *4+'

# 43 *"(#3"  &# '*",# ,+-3 ,*-.# 8'

& "#-"

  &# *"(#3" --' #43 &#,.'+ .98'

&#('#,#"#,"' #"# 2* ',# 8*. 4# #"(# ' &# ,.'+  ' 8"#  *+  /

 " +9# &#,"'@*# ',,"'9.3,+-# '##43 7"'4*.'"#*,# &##B # /

<< 7&#'*",#,+-3 &..4## '

.# "#,(#" &##B,#+* '."#3-'43'.'9 --"-"' # --.', ' 4#"# &# 7"'4*.  :8#(#" &# +*   /

&..,""3' #"#  &#" #"+ &#-#"'' #"+

&#8"-#43 &#7"'4*. 7&'4"'9 *"

&#,"42#, '-"##""#43%+  #"8 ' &#"'"#-#, # &1'23!.

7&# 7"'4*. & 8"#  *+  /

 # '.# &#"#*#"$  &.3',+# &##,## /

D#*, '"-#".#B-##

5" *.

'-.'#"

=#-##,3 / 6

*#".#B-##  /

= #  # /

=,"

'*+ &#8'8 /

%+  #"8 '!C 6#-# &#"&*48"'(#" ,"8'

&%&/2##"%'' ."3/

-#"+ &/2##" %''!C

8*.  # 1'23!.8-'."3/

-#" + &4#'#/

'.3..8,#%  #+#  #"8 '''.# 4* 3'.3..8,#4#'9-' &##,##
"+  #+#  /2##"%'''

,4#'#""# &##,##8-''..+"#

&/6

-#"+ & '-* 4.3 &#"#'#('#,# *--"

-.# &#,.'+ 8'

&"#9" ."3 &##,##"/2##" %''&-"*,#3,*+# "3#('#,#8'

&"#9" -3+#  '.3..8,# &##,##7&#+''+*+89#0'..#8"0#"  &#"#.#( '+# 8"4#.8/

-#" + &##43 7"'4*.   &# 9'(# ,#"' #+#   ',+#   /

 -#" + &''"+#

.'+  &.. 4# # '

.#  '

' ' ',+# " * *"# -"-#,  &#" # E &##,##8<3#".+''4.# +*.

'-.'#"' <7&#--.', '",+-# '&4##'.#43

8'8 &"##+'",&'."#-"#  &##,##A(#',.'+ +#43 &#" &##,##'"#2#, ##*, '"-#".#B-## 8*. 4# 5 &   &' +#" .  #-##,3 ' ,.,*. #  /6

 F/ 6

 /

 B  B < G / <    E

8" * *"# -"-#,    /

  5 & 8" -#". #B-##H ;#" ,(# '. &# ,.'+  &.. 4# # '

.# /

# '.#&#"#*#"$ =,"

'*+ &#8'8 /

= #  # /

*#".#B-##  /

('#8 &#4(#  .,+-# ''/

 '

'.+* '/ <  /

I/

-34.# 8'

&' #"#  &#" #< E-#"*+"+ &# #-# '

'.. "#.'J '#B,#- " &#-#"'#.36 3'"# '.'9 &#," 42#, ' 7&#--#. &#,"42#, '"#-"

.3..8#' "#' #"+


 


7&# 7"'4*. & 8"# ,+-# '  / 665 "*#   /

 ' "#-#,   '2*"'# * '# 43 +'" "*# '.#&#"#*#"$ #',.#B-##  /

66

(#3,#,&"9# /

AB-##-#,'.'#   /

 --#" &*9& &#"# '  -#,'', +# ' ' 8" 4*   *+  /

 & 4## 8"# " -'  *#"'9 *#"9#43 &#(', '+

*#." &#--#.. 8*."9*# &#'2*"#5(', '+ * '#+*.

'-.#'2*"'#&#"&#,#&"'9& &*.#""'9& .#94,0'##"# ,%&#"#+'#+'

#' &#&-'

."

3 '"9*# ,+-# '..8#43 &#7"'4*.''#@* # ###&,#+# 

*#."#-"## '9 &#'*",#,+-38*.  #

&#"#'2* '', '"..8'9'

'.+*  "*+'"* '#'2*"'#'#"# -"

&#"43 "#+'#+'

#'A,"

#',. # "#
"'4"-#"' 

 3  :#" -"#  +*  &(# "#+'# 4*3 ' 

#'9 (', '+,*'9. &#'"',+#7&#7"'4*.& 8"#3 ,+-# '"#"(',#

#   &#9'(#,#"',.'+ &..4## '

.# '

'.+* /

8'

&"#9" #"(',#  

#   .  ',+# &# -"#   7&# '

'. +* &..4#-34.#8'

&' #"#  &#" #< E-#"*+"+ &# # -# '

'.."#.'J ' 7&#--#.'-"

.3..8#' &#"#' #"+
  
$















3
4,1
>DK*. '?


















C&# &#"-#0'95"## $ 3#5 C&# &#""#-"

4.# $ 3#5