Gurdev Singh v. The Land Acquisition Collector
! "# $#%
! "# $#%
! "# $#%
! "# $#% &' ( &' ( &' ( &' ( " '
! " '
! " '
! " '
! )) * )+* , ) '
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'8 '8 '8 '8
2
!#' -.
!
!#' -.
!
!#' -.
!
!#' -.
!
- - - -
/'"
/'"
/'"
/'"
! .
" ' " . ' ! .
" ' " . ' ! .
" ' " . ' ! .
" ' " . ' #! ./.
#! ./.
#! ./.
#! ./. 6677 6677 6677 6677 "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ (/ (/ (/ (/ 6 6 6 6
'/ $ '/ $ '/ $ '/ $.
! .
! .
! .
! - - - -
/'"
/'"
/'"
/'"
2 %.
!
%.
!
%.
!
%.
!
- - - -
/'"
/'"
/'"
/'"
3 .
' .
' .
' .
' .
.
.
.
- - - -
/'"
/'"
/'"
/'"
& .
! & .
! & .
! & .
! - - - -
/'"
/'"
/'"
/'"
!#'
/4# !#'
/4# !#'
/4# !#'
/4# - - - -
/'
/'
/'
/'"
"
"
"
, !$/.
!
!$/.
!
!$/.
!
!$/.
!
- - - -
/'"
/'"
/'"
/'"
+ ' .
' .
' .
' .
,
,
,
,
.
" ' " . ' # .
" ' " . ' # .
" ' " . ' # .
" ' " . ' # #! ./ #! ./ #! ./ #! ./ 6677 6677 6677 6677 "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ (/ (/ (/ (/ 6 6 6 6
+
+
+
+
.
" ' " . ' / .
" ' " . ' / .
" ' " . ' / .
" ' " . ' / . . . .'
'
'
'. . . . 6677 6677 6677 6677 "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ (/ (/ (/ (/ 6 6 6 6 !
!
!
! "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$
9
56677 56677 56677 56677 (/ (/ (/ (/ 6 6 6 6 '. '. '. '. 92
92
92
92
56677 56677 56677 56677 "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ (/ (/ (/ (/ 6 6 6 6 + + + + +2
+2
+2
+2
#.
" ' " . ' #.
" ' " . ' #.
" ' " . ' #.
" ' " . ' #! /56677 #! /56677 #! /56677 #! /56677 "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ (/ (/ (/ (/ 6 6 6 6 + +23 +23 +23 +23
.
" ' " . ' .
" ' " . ' .
" ' " . ' .
" ' " . '
.
.
.
.
./ / / /.. . . . 56677 56677 56677 56677 "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ (/ (/ (/ (/'. '. '. '.6 6 6 6
!
!
!
! .
" ' " . '
.
" ' " . '
.
" ' " . '
.
" ' " . '
./.
./.
./.
./..5 .5 .5 .56677 6677 6677 6677
- - - -
/'"
/'"
/'"
/'"
"0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ "0# .
"// "
1$ (/ (/ (/ (/ 6 6 6 6 "8 "8 "8 "8 $8
:&/ %#.
" 4 .
:&/ %#.
" 4 .
:&/ %#.
" 4 .
:&/ %#.
" 4 .
#% #% #% #% A&7 !<6 1B 6.;1B <;-" !<= 17!1$< = > KKKK #%1% 7 #%1% 7 #%1% 7 #%1% 7 4 . 4 . 4 . 4 . ?)@ - AA1
A;<7 66
71
>; 77 66 7 B < AA C<D B7B;
C< 7 E >BF1
>; E A A
?
@ &F F 6 66 71 77; > 7 3
)99 96 >F7 7'
'%<;1/<
G "<H > ?2@ & 7F ;16 17 A <; &;
2 & <
B< B77 ; 1 7 $ 71 ' /< 1 A > C< B 3 2)993
9 2)993< <<.3 / C<1)+93 G)+93 H6B7F1 6<>7 76<61 A7F M;
;<6
B
; < < ><7;I < .)) )+93 6 >F/
C<"77 G /"H ), 3)99 1 >F A E 7< C< 7
J
1)21 2DL6 " 7
1291+99DL6
!
<AE 7
7; 77 < F > 6B <)+93 ?3@ ' 6 >F /"1 L B BE <. )+ )+931 A >6 7F 77 >F7 "< <B 3
)9 9991 7 ; ; A6 J DL 6 C F !
!
<AE7 ;
; ;<7< 77 1 6 >F/" A1 > ; 77 < F > D < )+ +93 ;;B 1 6 66 7 6 ? @
A6 6<;;
1 7 <7
<>A 7 "< B;
6<>F A7F
A6 A 776 7 7 / <7 7 <6 A >F H>76N" < A 7-. A 7-. A 7-. A 7-.
F
F
F
F 1 6 G
33 " "B
33 " "B7
33 " "B
33 " "B7 7 , +H 7 , +H 7 , +H 7 , +H 7 6 ;A 776 7 7 ><;7F
<7> E < 6<6 A A EB
7<
667F; 666 < A 77 ? )@ /
<7 <6< 7 )3 )9 993 N$L) 6 ; ) & 7 7 J
DL 6 & 1 C<>
E >; ;; 76 /
<7 7<>A >F 667F;< >7<
A 77 B7B 7 )3 )993 N$L)1 EB 7< >L
B< 7 ? @ /
<7 D7 76< E; <AA 6 7 C< 1 7 7 < A EB 7< > > < < < ;
?
@ 1 7 . <7 <>A 7 "< ;7F7<6 7 2 2)993 N'
'L2 B & & 7 7 <A A
DJ)
DL 6 & 6 <7
7F 7 6 7 >7 ;; 7
2 2)993 N 'L2A6 4
) 1 ),1 )+ )9< 4 ) B A6 C< 7 <1<>A 6 >F7 "< > 66 66 A 7 >7 A1< 77 ?,@
B 7 <7 6 ; <; 6>E 77
<> <>A > ?+@
6 1 A7F F1 C< 7 A 6 A<6 77A <6 7"AA1'
77 6< >F>6 6 A 776 7 7 A <;> )&
) & 7F 6D. B > >7 6< ;7 76 ;7 B 7F7 ;<E 7 A F>
7B E 6< <>F6B6
7 ><7 AN <8L .
76< .
76< .
76< .
76< <>F <>F <>F <>F .
7 " D$& '<A $ .
7 )3 )993 $B
N> .77 &<F &L& B< N$L) =.; = < D 4<7 .; N$L $< " D.
A & 7> " D A N$L2 $A .; O .; D .
A6< .; N$L3
A4 < & 7= < D . A .; N$L
= D .
/ .< $ 7
L L ) 3
DL .
7 )3) )99)
L2 LL )1
DL 3
DL .
7 9) )99
L) LL )+1
DL +1
DL .
7 9) )992
L) LL 2
DL +1
DL .
7 + )99)
L2 LL +
DL
DL
=
.
7 ) 9)99) N$L .A> A D/ A
= D .A>
A N$L, & 7B .; .; D
EA .; N$L+ .< $
L L ) LL
DL 3
DL .
7 ) )99
L LL
DL 2
DL .
7 ) +)99 .A & 7= < L2 LL 9
DL
DL .
76< .
76< .
76< .
76< <>F <>F <>F <>F6 6 6 6 .
7 " D$&
L )+1
DL 21
DL
L LL 2
DL
L LL
DL )
DL
L LL 2
DL 1
DL '<A $ .
7 9) )99 $B
N> .77 &<F &L& B< Ex.D-1 !<A 7.; 4<7 < .
7 )
)993 N'L & ; .;
B < N'L2 !<A.; % 7A .; .
7 2 2)993 .
7 3 9)992 N'L3 B .; A $
)L LL
DL
DL
L LL ) 1
DL ,1
DL .
7 )+ +)993 N'L '
76.; % .; .
7 3)99 N'L -$ E - N'L, -$ E .
< .
7 )
)99
L3P LL
DL 31333DL ?9@ A >B >71 > 7 N'L 1 N'L N'L,6<>F6 66 66 6 < <<.3 )+93 <1>7 7 <6 <1 7 N'L)1 N 'L2 N'L3 6< >F 61 6 <<.3 )+ +93 1 > > E 6 N'L)1 N'
'L2
N'L31 A NA<A66> A A <)
DL6>
7 A A 7 N 2 2) 993 N'L2 ?) @ 1 6 7 6<>F
1 7 )3 3 )993 N$L) 7 ; ) & 7 ;
DL6>
A
7 6< >F
16 A 776 7 7 > ;< 1 6 77FB
6D. A7 7B B>
>76< F 6 ;7 ;6 7 7
1
77 6 <>F>6 7 A 77 6 7
7 7 7F >7 C< 7 B F A6 A<6 77A < <6 7"AA1' 7 6 B ;>< AA 76<6
?) )@ B1 H>76N"< A 7-.
A 7-.
A 7-.
A 7-.
F
F
F
F <6 7 A7
F < 6 7 7
A;6 7NA67 A6 C<7 >7 1 > C< 67 ;7 <6< 7NA67 6 6 6 ; A 77 6 7 7
67F; < >7 <
A 77 < < 7 7B 6 ; 6 ,
+ N
<8L M , ,
1 A< A<767 7 A 77671
6 > 7 >7 B B A ; A6 . 7;
7 A6A ; < 7 1 7; ; 7 6; A6
A 6 <7 > FA< >7 7 A;A EB 7<
<> >C<7F1 667F C< < < A 7< 7<NA F<> < 74 =
74 = 74 =
74 =
<
<
<
< B .
B .
B .
B .
. $<= >1
) ."" . $<= >1
) ."" . $<= >1
) ."" . $<= >1
) .""
"< 7
77 78 Q 7
B 7 NA67 A7 7 1; 7<7 7 ; NA67 1
> 1 >
6R7 >; A6<77F E F A 6 1 7 ; B 7< 7< A7 7 7 7F F B >
> 77; 6< 77 ; 77 >< A
C<Q
+
B > . AA .;B. . AA .;B. . AA .;B. . AA .;B. $1 $1 $1 $1
)2) .""29
)2) .""29
)2) .""29
)2) .""29 L=< <;> "<7
<6
A <A A<7 67 7 7 >7 1"< 777F; 7< 7<NA67 <76
77 ;1 7 7<7 ; B ; B 7< A F>A;<<I
A1 > 7> > < ) &
7 B )3 )993 N$L) A6 4 ) )3 A7F E <A> A C< 7 7F 6 ), 3)99 6 >F/" ?))@ < 1A
B B
)3 )99 93 N$L) 66 6B 7 > ; < A1 6 77F A7 F > < 6 7 7 A; 6 7 )3 )9 993 N$L) C< 7 <7F
>7 B1 6 B1 F <>7 ;< 7 B 7 < 7 )3 )99 93 N$L) 1 7 "< B N$L)>F; ;<
<> <7 76NAF A A 6 <. 3 )+93
> FB>7 >F6
FE <> > >< 7 A A 7 N$L L)1 < ; <; B>>F F7 "< C<;
;< 76 ?) @ ;7F1 B < < A >B1 7 )3 )993 N$L) ) & 7 7 J
DL6 6> 1>7<6 77; 8L
7 N$L) 6 4 )3 B A6 C<7 S
7 )3 )993 N$L) 7 7 6 NAF <.3 )+93 1 < 3 2)993S
)3
)993 N$L)7
A B B< B77 ; S B
>B N$ $L) ; 76 ?)2@ < B
<1 7
)3 )993 N N$L) >; 7 NA A67 ; ; 7 B ) & 7 7J
DL6& 1 >7 <6 6<6 A A EB 7<
C<7 ?)3@ B1 ;
C< 7 A < ;
&; 2 & 1 7 6 7 A; 6 7 ) )3 )993 N$L)A7F)
& 1 < >7< > 667
< A 77 B B7B
E; <
C<7 A6 A A<6 77A ' 1' /< 6 7 6
B ; >;<
AA 76< 6 <
T7> 666 A 77
;
;7F1 77>7 A EB
7< J
DL6 6>
N
D)
?) @ B1;B
C<
> < 6<>76<61 A7F1 ;<6 B
; < <1 <1 6 <
F 7
6A<A <7O
C< < N6<
6B;
7 << A 1 <1 <
B76A >A6 ?) @ ;7F1 E; <
C<7 A A< 6 77A ' 1' /< 6< A 7 6 6 B ; >;< AA 76<61
77>7 < AA EB 7<J
DL 6 > < . 3 )+93
17 77 7>7
77 <F>
6 6B<6B
)+93 A<6
7 77 7>7 7 < AJ2 T> <6 ?),@ " C<7F1 B <A >B1 77
66 7 6 D7 >F 6 7F
77
A ?)+@ R B 7 D B < < 7F N6
66 7DL >=
7;
7;
7 B> A67 1 F F 77 > 7>F E N < 6 >F AB; 666 667 > 7
N<;"< ?)9@ 77 6; 667 1 F1 77 7 6 4 . #% 4 . #% 4 . #% 4 . #% %#'!
%#'!
%#'!
%#'!
1111
E R R 6 E;D ( 6 >7 ( D D