← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/54/2000allowed

Parmod Kumar And ORS. v. Sdo (Civil) And ORS.

2019-03-28Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari16 pages



   

 

  

   

   

   

 !

"

 

# 

$

%

 '

  

   

   

 !

"

  

  # 

 !"# #$%&'

  %  ()

 ***+) 

( ) * +,, 

-

 

 ) . / .  ,* **,$#-,.,/", 0 1,/

 

         -  /       #!  123     453  -  $666  -   

 23  - 

    

 4753  -     8

 

8  &

 /  - 

#

!

"

 

63654555 /

*9





&

&

/ *9

   



$36:4553

 

3-





22

/ 

$5674554 

; /      6;6$455$  /

 

    

6:6$4577   

9

   &4<:= ;/  &

-

 *   -

& .

9

  0

   

-  8



8 /

$36:4553 / 4= -  4 $6 666> -.) = 

 &/

  /



/

- 9    *9



/

/

  - !

"

  /

/

 

9



/

 *



?@4 7/   

    - 

 !

"

   9     - 

  /    





/ &



 9





 /,

 9 ?

9-* =/  





:66:4577?@#4 /

*



*9



/

*9

   &<5= 42/ 

*9

?  

/

&

-

 0

 9-





/ 

  9  &

& / 

 &9 =  /



*

A 56 666>

 

*

& *9



// , 

 /   *   *  

-   /

   9 

2'2

  -< 666>

/&

B / ,   / /



B  /

/

    

* /      *

    *9    &  &

 

9 

 )+,,  

9&

/ --





  /

/

/

     

   

       *

 

* &

  



47

  & 

#  

9  &

 / ,  

  

9=

 &   /

 -

/

 -



#C 4

   

/

/

   



 

 - 



-  34#  $<*  &) 4:2 D $666 

 9-

 

$4654557

- ),3  4& ( ,!--5,/*"$6-,$#7- 1383

9$:,;*7,7 ,$#7- 13(D



/ -

*

?

&

 &   *

 : 26 666>       *9 

    - 

6:4$455:9 

, &

&

&'(*7,7  9$:,;83,$,13",33* 7-"  &

* &

 /



6:4445<7 

*

*9

*

  A<26> #

22

*



 



 /

&

*9

 /

*9



/- &/

 -) 

 !

"

 

E*  457:

4573 

*-

 E* 453;

453< - 

*

* &

 

  / 42634577

 

 &-  



-

- 

      

 - 42634577    $5674554  / 

  *9

 &

-

 @ *

 

 

 &9 

*



 

, &

 @  <*5 !",/),$#!=9"3"7"$ "! 183 >,1"6.#,,$#7- 13?  *@& 



, 

/  *

 



=

/9



  /



     *

D  *







 &*



 

 

*9

  /,  ,

D - 

 *



- * &  

  /

 /

/

   /-

 * &



 -

) 

  /

/ - /

   



/-   & -42634577  -







 

22 , &

 @   

- ( ),"$ ;A ) 3837- 13( *@  *



 * 

* =



-

 

& -



 

/







3

 ?

 

*  

- >,1"6.#,3951,  /



 /      -

/ &  /



 

 

 

3 *

 6:6$4577 0

- /-

    &<:

= ; /

  / 42634577  -/

4;.) =  0

- / / &  /

/-

-

*

-

-/

  / - 

  & 

*9

0

 !

"

   0



;/

 &9



9*

/=  A:4 62 5$6> ?

9



6;6$455$/ 

 

 

 & 

  6:6$4577  /

*9    /  



4< ;4 <:336    9*



*



-43 6$ 5<563/9* 

-

 @ 

  



/ * $5674554- 

=

6:6$4577 /

/ &9    -

  -  

=

/   *9

-

 

0



 &    







/ 

-

*

*9





 





*



/

   

(

1 ?@

 

& >

 4 ?@4 $7674554 3F #36 666>

) 

 !

"

  $ ?@$ 636:455$ < #36 666>

 /

 !

"

  : ?@:

$463455:

3 #$6 666>

.+&

 

= # !

"

  3 ?@3 626$4577 $ #4$ 666>

!

"

  2 ?@2 4$46457< $ #46 666>

!

"

  ; ?@;

4$46457< $ #46 666>

!

"

  <  $<624553 < #35 666>

!

"

  7 ?@7 654$455:

6;3  #5 666>

.+& # !

"

 



 /

?@< 0





  





  /



/-

  /



  9 / -

 D 





-



 

 @  



 

  9 -

9 - 

9

0

 @ 

- 





 *    --

 26

/ 

  

-

2@2

 



 / * 9--

/ *



 



 

* 

 

, &

   #!1;7;-4554()B 3-.,1977 83- *7,7 ,1A,$,,$#,$7- 1( 4;67$646 /

*



/-



 







/



 @ 0



/  9



 

   /

 @     & 

   

 9        -  

 

9  -     /

      &   

  

 0





, &

 (

GB/   - 

* -   *

     /

  9  -      *



-/

  -  --



-

  /

9   , 

-

 91 9

*   -   

      -   *9

  /

- &  

-

   *    - 



  *     *9 

  /

>

 9-

D  9  

 

-, 

 =





 9 





  /

@

  - 

         

 

     , 

-

 90 

9 9

- 0

*

& /

  * * &

 *

  



-

 



3-



9 - 

 /  

   

     / & 

* 9   

  



 

9  & & /9  

    /

   

2&2  

&  -





-



   

 

- 

- 

3-



-

  -

 --

 D / * 

-



 &



*9

/





 





 



*9

-

 9D

*

-/

-- 

  0





/

  *

   *

  

 

 * - 

 

-

42 $69  



  /



*& 9*

&   

= & -- -

  

-

  H

      

   /9  

 

  



 

, &

 @  ,3,$7 >9C,1  83  $"$    $#",  

 *     ,,1 83

1,#,;,# D /5C $797-1"7A*@ @*4  0

*  / 

/

9 - 

&  







*



=-    &4<:= ;

 @  * 9 & &*

/

:69 ;6 9

 /



&

9*

  *9

0

& 



/- &/

) 





/  =

/ * -

 =

 &  /

*

, &

 

22 

 &

/



/- &/

)   



47

/

90



 -

 

 /-

 

 -

    /  /

 )       )  





/  * & /

*

)    

 



-

)  



  * - /

)   

 &  

 -  C 4   =      /  /  &

9 ,



/

 



/

 









-

  #

 

 - /*9/9- 



/ *

 



  









- 

*9 - &  -  

0

 @  *,7"3- >9C,1957,7- 1383*7,7 ,1A,$,7- 13 @

* @ 



 - 34#  $<

*   - 

# 



, &



( G$6D  

0   -  





  * 



 &



/ * 

@  - &

  *



9 

, &

   



-



2 



=



0

/ & - 



H #

 

/-

/ -

  -?

&

 & 

6:4$455:

 

- 9





 --

-  -$9 *

/

/  ?

/



&  / +"  +

//







!"

  9B*

1467 0

    





 9-

 / /



 

/  -



 9 

/ ,!-5,/*"$6-3951,  9 

, &



-,$,13",33 * 7-"3951,  / *

 /

& 

6:4445<7/

/469    D 





-/ 3 29 

 ?

/



 





* &



 

*-

- #<26> &

 /  - 9



 *  -

   

 

 -  

*

- *  &)

4:2 D $666 #! $666  *

  

/

 

 





 - /

)  0

9



 9 

 

 /># 

--

  /

/

/

 -) 

 0





/* 

0      -    



 

      * 

 

@  - &

 

9 - 

      

 , &

   0

     

 &9  B/   

-



-

--

   &

  ?@# 4 /

/



- -

?  

:66:4577 

<5= 42- /A#56 666>

- -

   

  *

&

 =

 &  /

, &

I "/,$#,791,/,3 151,7"$)"C"7 #83 ,C 3-;-,""D,$;-," ,7 /,$#,$7- 1?

&  *@0 



- 



#

   

 @  

 * -

=

/ 

   $5674554

  #  / @

#C $ / 

// -

9

#

 

 

//

)   -!"

  /

-

   *

* 

 

 - /-

 

B/   -/ 



-#C $  / 

2 * 

9

/*9  -9 *  /

/

  -!

"

  &  





/

&



B - 

  

@

/48* /

  -



 /$ :8*

  -

B  



  *





*/,

 + +& C/ 

-F=

#  / 

-F=



 9-

/   





 @

) 

C $ / /





) 

B 

 - /

)   

 -C 1; /



*  *



 

B/   



/



 

       *   +   * /  +   +& /

  9 # 



 0



 / &  /

 

/

* =-

  #  

9  - 9* 

 





  -

*9/9-

-C 7     / /



/

-







 /

*

 / 

-





 ?@ < 0

/ *9C 5 

-    C B*  

@ -



 /

'2

/

9 -



9



  B   

 //

)  

9 4577 /

- 





-



B/   C 4$   

/ /

)  

/

 * F= -

  9   

 

  /      9

- 9*



& 



*

-   

A46J  

&

-

--

-:9 *

/



?@# 4



0  

=

/= A4 45 <56>

 --   4 45 766>    

9*

- - &   /   

9 9



 -.) =

/ 

4 25 <$6>

 

9  

  

-    &*

42634577 





3

$5674554 

   &

-

 



 * 



 



 -

 -

:69  #

  ,#"3- 77",/, ,C9/ ;A) 383- ),$# !=9"3"7"$ "! 1@ *4 &

9* 

 & /

 *

 45<5

-

 



 &  - /

9  4554C  

, &

),"$  /



2

-, 

 * 

*9&

& 

A42J



/

-

/ -

 &  -45<5 4554 

  *

)9 45<5    /  /   

2 442 

966,55, 7-) 7- 1383),$#!=9"3"7"$ "! 12!9C2

,$#,/ D $9  "! 1,$7- 1  

  4:4$$646  / 



, &

,#"3- 77",/, ,C9/ D



      *

 

9  45<<  /

 

  9 /

9 4556D



, &

),"$  *5 !",/),$#!=9"3"7"$ "! 183 >,1"6.#,7- 13  *@&/ =   &

&;J

=

 D /- 



  9/& -7J 46J   & 

-



-

# 



, &



( G7C 

 /

 & &

-

 

/  &* = 45<< 

 ::9 &  /  ,    





 

  & - 

 -

  -/ &-  

 & /-;J



  

& - 

 -

-  4<4445<< 

-  9 :<4556  /

*

/ *9

B& /  

-, 

 5 



  - 

  

  *

 

)

  +  #     

      / & 



-42J 



=

2





  /& 

  C  -

 /  -  &     42J  

 

-

 

-

- 9

  ! 

 

=

 4<4445<</

  /

/ 



 

=



:<45560

-& / ;J 

=



 :<4556 



-  &   /

 

 

 =

     

4<4445<</* 

 D



 /  - 

  / 

 &   -     /

 &   

 & /

@ 

- 

&

 



/

=

 



   

 ;J     

  C

 -   

   9

 /

 /9 -

-

= & 

  9/&   7J

46J-

=



  & 

-

 

 46C

 &9/

   /

   /   *

 /   *9 

 B&   

&  ;J 

-4<4445<< :<4556 

=



 :<45560



 &   9

;J 

-



-/$4:4554 

-9

0



/ &   9 9 

   H

-

   ,- 1,  >-,7$    7- 13  83  D $9 "D"3"$,/ "! 1E),$#!=9"3"7"$ "! 17- 13  '

* '  //-/ *9



 &





- 

&  /

 //   -/    ,/.,$  *"$6-    7- 13  83  ),$#  !=9"3"7"$

// !71,$7- 1 4 '

*  #  

9 =

 &  /

* , &

 

 

-



/*

-

9

-

A;J 

-42634577 

-

3

  $5674554  --

- &  *9





-



*9



?

 



 /  

-/

   9*

 #  

9 

 - *9

  9 /  *9 

=

A#4 45 766>   /



9*

-  -

 /  

-

 .  ) =  

     

 &9 

#4 25 <$6>   &/



9*

-  -

/*

-

- -9

-

A ;J  

-42634577  $5674554 -



-

 

=

 &  -

 -  

 

-

3 B/ 

/ 

-

- -  

  /

/ -&  **+)

 &0

  

 = &> 

( K

#  * ( K