← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/35/1997allowed

(O&M) Ved Parkash Arya v. Madan Mohan Singh

2018-12-06Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal11 pages

    !"#$  % 

 %&' %'()*)+  ,  

  -'.*/*  



       



  -'.*/*  

  

+0 1#2 "

23 !2 !.'*'&+          !   " #$!%&&'



()    

)  !   " *+%,!*,,* 

-     

.   !    " #$!%&&'

 - / .  !    " *+%,!*,,* 23 !2 4"        !  " #$!%&&'  " *+%,!*,,* 1        (  

  

 2( ! (  

 !!  (    1(       

   

( 3  (     !     0 4 (51  

%&6&  7   (

5( (  ( (   (!  (   1 ! 8        !     (  1!        5(  1  ( 9(     1  (!    !    

       1  (8  !  9(1         " *+%,!*,,* 

" #$!%&'  / " %:+ ;#$<-  

(

 1 

   (  !   (       ((  / !

 (  -(  %*%#!   3  (=;



  

     

        

      

    

  



        

   

               

       



     !



"

  

        

  

   

 

   

  



 # 2    1                   (  !

(            9(    ! %:6 #6>;

2   ! !!  !  %:

%* %&'+   (   %6&%,%% %6!  ;<3  (=;

$

  

        %  &'  !

  ( )     *            

   $+, * -.



  

       

      /

       



   

  

    

     -

 

   

  

     01 $

   "2.3 / *   "/.3 4

   )     

 



 -$&     

  

 



)   %    

  

    

      

      6

     

 %)   



       

  

 

   



 







  

 

  

  $7

   $+,* 1-.

      

         



     

    



    



   

    

 

  

     $$

      

       

   

   

 

      

              



 

   $4 



  

 







 



     

 



          

      8           9   

 :9

            

  

   

)     

        

 #  



        0   !!          !  ( (          ! /     ! -

   !! 2 !(  !! !    1        6 %, %&'&     !     !;  

   ( !!;  ? :>;



  !   *$,>;   !    #$,>; 

! ( (  ! -

 4 @!! ! A    ( :

'

%&:, ( !! ;

( 

/ 1

 (    1( !(   

  2   !(      !     !!       !!     *, :

%&:,  (1 1 !

   1      1( !   (    ! !!

0 /   ( & & %&:,  0 !;

 ! 0  !

  ( ! 

2     ( (1    

  !;

 1 1 4 @!! & * %&:6 !;

 !

   !!;  !   ! 1!  <  )(- 

0 !1 !;   1 <  )( 2 !    !!;   !;     @    !  ( ! /     1 - !   A -   *6 & %&:$ !;!-7

    1 - !               0 !; ! 

  1 4 @!!      <  )(

   ((1    

2   !  1  -(

     - !        - !     !1 !;

  /

  ! ( !

/

2  1      !!;  (1 1! -( !;   (   !        2  !( 1   - !     /  ( 1 !;   (   1  0 !1

!;    ( (1   

          !( ((       !       !     - !

    /

@  !!! !;  !  / 9( 1   (    !     1 (  (   ( (1    

 ! (!  5(    !;    ! / 

  !;          1    (       1     !;         (   ! !!

2   !    / 9(  

 !1        (  

  ( !  9(   (!      ! !!     !       0 !;         1             - 9(   (!  5(        !  (  

    5( !

 (   (!1 !!

!  (   (   1 <  )(

     !  ( (1    

0 !   (    !!  1 1

<  )( !;     !  (!(       !;

 !  ! !! 

!  !1 !!;  0 !  (!(    1! - !    !;          

     !  (    1

<  )(   !   ! ( (1    

    1 - !    1

 2! 1   

1!  -(    1 !  (!(   1     (  (    (*#! 5(  1 <  )(

    !   ( (1    

!(  5(  1 ! 

( 1 ( 5 (  (   0 ! 

(      ! 

(!;( !

( 1 1 !; 2!  5(  1 !  (      (

     !;  1! 

      1!     

, !  1  !;    2     !     

    ;    (1 9(  

    (!  ( !   (   !  (

 (  (=;

"

  

   

     

     

      

    ;

  

        "

   

 



   

1

 

    

  2.3            -



/.3      1 

 *                    

1

 

        

 

      

      )    

 

          1 

     



  

 *     

    $4       

           

            

1  

  



   < 

 

                       '     

            

1

 

   =       

        



1  

  



 

  :$77'1       "

      ( 

 1>

         )       

     )  



             

 

    





        





1  

' 

   

    

 



  "

=     ?@(/   

 

    

    

                       

      

1

 

                

   

 

 :+'1         

1  

    

    @

 2.3    )    

 1 

    :+'1           

   

  



   

    

1  

       )          *  

  

 1



    

1  

  

   

  

 =   

?@(/                 

    



     

  

 

                

  *        



       

       

    

        

  

   ((     

    

 

     



       

  /7+$6/+7



  

 =   



            

  

  4$7$626  

   

   (! 1 !!     1 ( 1  !!;

    ( 1  1 !( !

  !; 

        '$B  !           1(      1 ( ! !

     

 !   (    

    :>; ( !!;  !(    ( 

   / 9( ( ! (1(    1 !;

       (   ; 

 !  ( %6!  ;  1 (! 1  2   ( %6 ! !;

 (!     ( 

      !         %,,>;     

   

  1  ( 1    !(1  ( 2  ! ! 9(  ! ! 1   ! (!   " #$!%&&'   5(   1 !  (  

  !  (     !

      !  !

 0   !!;    (      !    5(   5(   !! (  / 9( !

   -(    ( !;        ( 2  (     (  !   (     -  !  (51  <    C ( 



!   1 !( 

    / 9(  1(     !  ( (

 !

      !     (           

5( !  (

(!   (  1(@*(*! -!-  (    (   1 2    ! 5(    " #$!%&&'      1 (1 (   (!1

!!    1  1 !  ( 2  ! 1  " *+%,!*,,*      !      !  !

  ,  23 !2 67* "%

89'&9'.*:'7);<.'*'+ $'*< 89'&9'.':.&=>'+  $'*<