High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17709/2022disposed of

Amaninder Singh @Maninder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2024-04-15Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi31 pages

!"!

#$%&'&'

(#!#) *+!#,-.#!#) *+!#,-

/#01

$ 23 & +++

! "# $$$ ++4& % &'( )) * + ,- .(( /01/(1/( 232/'4 &(1/&0-) &(5&36 + 7 ,

89/:

+ +;* ( # ,- .(3 1413(1// 20(20<21<2&(22(232&'3/'4 2& -) (<;

+ + + 1413(1// %

6 2 = %# ,-

.(( /01/(1/( 232/'4&(1/&0-)

&(&36 )%,

+ + 1< +

+ /11/(1/( #+

;# % % ,- 9/ & + ;# 1<% ;

; ;+,-

.(3 1413(1// 20(20<21<2&(22(232&'3 /'4 2& -) (< ;

" +; 1&/((1/( >

(3//(1/2 3 - ; # +

# ,- .(( /01/(1/( (&1'(1/( ? +

; 1(14(1/3 4 13 * " +; 10//(1/<89(: #" + # ; +

+ % ; < +

%# + ; 1(1'(1(( ' # * +,-

* + *

* 0 )

;+,- .(( /01/(1/(; ;; ; +

#+,- .((<

(&1'(1/( ;% %

* +#

+ # *

%;# ;

# # # * +

# 9 %,-

+ + ; # #* *

;#% +

! "#$%& ' ( )*+ " ,

! "#$ ' ( *+ , "" !

-. / &0, / *'( +12034

!3 ' (5-6'"

70( *

+& 8&4 8 "9 0

! :

% & '

( -6 '&,,$(+;. /

! "#$%& ' ( ', (+ 4 "

!3 '( '4,(*%<" /

! "#$' (', ( ) /1 )

; ;

)#%% &'()) + * ? %" +;*

# %%

;+ + # *

+ ; // - ) /( +

" +; #% -'"2:?@# ;)

! "

$" %

( )$

! * +, #

- # . / "

/ 3

/ *

( 4 1 & /5%+

$ 3 6

7 $ $

+!+,

# 8

!7+, 9 1

7+,

& &

# #

7 $

(+*

&/5+ &

;

& #$ *

#$ 1

$ <

& #

# $ #

& / &

# $ $

#$ = 0 :

> #

(

3 8 " # 8

&" &

# 7

=! .7 ! 2 7"

> 7 42, $! " ,,/ . / 22,,

?4,,/ / 04 2$"

2 7"

>44

/. $ 7, "

, 70 - $7 !9,,/ / 22,, + ! 7 " !2 7// 4 /$"

$" !2 7 !,

7 .7/ 22,, + 2 7/ / 4 $ !@- ",$ " $, ? / " + "+ #" ! 4/ 2 / 22,,

1 #$ 3

)

8 " ? +,

8 B - " ,'"2( )

A+

# $

# $ #

# 1 >

,+ " /

)

0 )

! " /

) A0

) 0 )

# $

8 $ B

'% ++ 5

$ # #

$) > $) #)

= $

$ 1 #

# #

$ ) > $) #) *

$ >

=7 7 " ! !7 "

77" 4,9 ,+ #9 ,

4$ , $7 7, 2 7,4 !! ?9 !7 ,+$"

! 77 ",$4 "

/ 4, .9470 94 ,+ 77", ,, . $ ,. ! 42/ 2 ! !7/ 2 7"

! 4" ! !4,

7"! ,, '% (

3 ?

$ $

# $

( +! 1 #

# 1 $

$ # $

!7+

/ # & $ $ &

= $

# &

# $ $

$ #

= #

# # 1 >

#$ 8

$) > $) # ) # : )

= @ : =

B >8) :.8 :<010C(1/3 + " +; );# ;

(31/(1/0 - ,"" !-. / &0, /'"2:

+ ?+)* + ; * )-

+ #%+ * = ;

+ ?@# ;)

'% 4 1

#$ $ ) 1

7 # #$* = * C

A/D #

$ $

0>$ ) *

# #

#$ #$ :

# 3

$ *

+CC!1 $#

$ #$

# *

0 >$ 1

) :

: 1

$ #>

$ ) 3

< * 37 477"+ ,,/

. 7 7 279 4 .

0,, 77/+ 4

!, 9+ , /,;"/!",,9 #" ! ,/ 2"2 ",$. !" 2 7/ 7/ 2

9 *

3 & >

!7+

$ #

$ $ CC! 2 /

!7+

$ 5

& #$ 3 $

$ - #$

$ * - 12034'"2( ?@# D

?+)

A9 1

"$-27 3! ,7 174$+ * 2 * 3,A)* ' )(A6?** '@( )6; '@( #

# # 8

= ;

( "

F 1

!7+

$ EF $

/ E#F # $ EF

$ # &

# $

# $ &

$ >

F =

$ &

!7+

/ $ #

F 1

$ # >

& $

!7+ / EF " %

# % "

$ #

# % 1

E F D #

# 3

!7+

/ E

# #

F & $

!7+

F 1 > 8

!, !

< * # # 8

# %

$ 8

!7+/>

F 5

& $ >

$ #

# %

# > #

$# >

!7+

/ &F 1 % 8

# # % #$

!7+

/ E&F * >

" E& F #

!7+

$ &

& $ >

# #

# 9+ " *

+,= "/

%,+ "/

,C "/ 1

0 >$ #> $ >

$ ) 3

$ 2

# #

# $

0>$ 0>$ ) *

$ 3

#$ ="*

3 1

$ $ CC!

3 #$

!7+/"

: >

# #$

9 " A".

!3+ * '--(36+)

'% ( " $

% %

$ #

$4,,,@%<&

# "D

$ #

# #

( 9! " / EF

(9 "

# 8

$ #$

!7+/ "

;

!7+/

$# # $

8 #

& >

# $ " #

# 1

8 #

8 ( 94 " $#/EF

(C " $

$ #

, "/ % #

++/ $$ #

,@!

# 8

$#$ &

!7+ /( 99 " 9 A89 ",,A .

!32 ' ()3 *

#$ % #

% # 8 *#

H( 9 " &#9A"4

!3 3,3 * >

(! "

% #

/54

% # #$

$ &

& %

# )

)

# #

# #$

# % 8

# $>

4 5

1 8

% # # 5

!7+/

- ?7!!

+,,( 17" 3 7 27 " ! . " 7 !

"24 " !! / " + 22

".,", 7.97 !

7B"

, !7 77"+ 7/ $7 /7 77" $ B" = 7 7," "$B" ,7$27 7 9 77 !7 .7 !"77 77"+.,"$, 4 "7 ! ,7 " ", $ ! ,/ "7 , ?7, $ B", . 2 2

"!", 2"2 ",$. $97 42,,/ 77" !7 ,"$B" ,9+ 477" $ ,+$7B"

7/ " 2"7 9 .,$, 9 !.7 77 !$

.7$/"7 "$B"

, .7/ ,, 77"2 2$, .$, "

! ./ "7 7 7," B"/ 2 7/+ / "

7!",,9>4 " !.7,9"7

7 7," , " ! 4 , .,$, / $7 /77" 92 !.77 49 7$"7/ 77" !7

, -! ! ! , 7 $27 7 9+ 2 7/ ", $B"

7 "

# % 1

$# #

#& $

# 8

#& $

C 1 3

!7+

/ C

$# $ $ # $

# & = # & $

# & & #

# # &

! 9 .

#6,+2 "22'( * &- ) G

!A 0.

1.22 ' ( G&

< ,7 6/ 49 ', (*F * #

#$ #

# #

& & $

%!7+/ =, 7 / 29 ! 77" ! B"/ !2 7/>7 !2 "

+ 77 !7 .7 ! 77" $,0+,922 7/ " 49 $/ "! #7 / 22,7 ! / " !

,, / 2 7/ 7 ",,$>7 !"

, 9", / ! 4 "7 ! "

4 4+ 2 / "

0 77 " + $ !7 "7 ! 77" . 0>7 ! > 92 "

= "7 77" $7 #"42$,+ ! / C! 42", ! , 9 ! CD "7

!77"7$#" !$, ! 7 "

!" >7 2 " ! !

4, 7" - & '"2: ?+ ) 6

# >

A =

$+%)

",7,+,9 #

?+ +,9

9!"//

2 # 0

/ $

/ 0 >?

0# $

* # $*) E

/ $:

/ 0 >?

0 : ?

1 ? +,

/5% )

,9,+,7 !

& /5%)

# #

/5%+)

+4,,,,,@%

/5% #

#$#

$ 1 /5%

9!%*"/ $

"""*

+7,C+,7 4 #

+7,C+,7

D # "

+!++,7#

> #$

+7,C+,7 9 "

& 1 ?+, $

" #

> 1 /.

2 ) 6" '&,,(

% #

% 7 *-*

$ #$

% C " # #$

, "

% # 1

?!4I9

> 0

EF 8

'% (!2

# )

& #$

# #

)

# 8

41 >

* ?+9+C9

)

# "

)

# (

( 3 #

1 #$

: 8

) $

# )

: < "

)

# #

9 "

$ #

$ # #

# 1 "

4 /.

! "#$ '

(&-*) *

( &!

/ / "/ #"/4 , $9 ,7 ",! 22,7 + .94"77,

" , 7 / 4 9 ! +!

77" 7B"

+ 74, 2 7/ 7 $ " / 7 77" 4 ! 2 7 + 2 $ ! 4 9 ! 4 2 7"

+ 4 77"7B"

$9 7 " $, +=. 2 27 ! 7/7 .7 +.,"$, 4 !

7 " ", $ ! ,/ , ,9 ! 2"2 ! 7 42, / 2 7" 2 "7 7 7," !"

?! + 74, 2 7/ 7 $24

7 "/ 22,7

?! +""7!7 77"4 7 !

7,,,, $9 &2> " +74, 2 7// 22,7

E ! + / "

!4E ! )+" ) &F - + ,7

64$"+ 1 7 ", 2" 7 $" $9B"

!7+/

! D

J -;. /'"2: )

A9 1

$8 "

% 8

* $

7 D %

0 " <"2 /,A.

! "#$ 2 *' ( '4,(

! 1

F* C74

,+@! "/ " 8 %

#$ "

$ &

& 8 1

$ > 36#

* &

. ;#

7 .

4$# # &/

2 '(7 *)*#$# ! '% E 1

# 8

1 #

$ # #$

$ E

= 0

:4,1..

'E? !1,(+'1,(2 '( '4,( )

$ > 36#

* & 3 8

,!=@!"/

!"//4 > '% E41

+!,C+,,

$ #$

",A"4.

('4,()

'(16?

% #

# 8

# *

!7 ,+ !C "/ >

,!@!"/

% #

$ #

'% (1 8

> 8

" A"4.

9+&- "24 "

# #

# E , " &4#

2 )'( )* % #

$ %

?"+7+ .7 "/ $"7

4+,, / , 7 ",,"79

4 ! " 27,,9 ", , ,0,9 $

4 7 ! 7 77" - ",$!"

, >7 7 " 2 7/ / 2

7 77" 7B"

$ !4 !,,/

- . ! $ .+ 7" !7 + 2 2 ,, @-E ) "7 * + +*)+ + % - /

+ 1 7

E/+ , 3 2 $9 , " ,, 7 B" , 2 7/ / ! 4 $9 B" - 4 "'"2:?@# D

?+)

A* ? B", . 2 2 , $ .7 7 !?

'"2( .+

7 " ! . !7 !2 7",7+ ,9G/ " !,,/ 4$9 2 7"

/ 77"2 4 ,7 ,,7 "/ . / +! ! " 7 ! ,/ 7 77"2 + ,7 " + 7 /"74 , .7+! " 2 7"

2 . 7/ 77"2 !7/ , ! " 7$ 4 ,7+! , 7 "7 / $7 /77"+,,2 /", +,, / , 7 "/ $7 / 77",,$ /$"

,>7 / " ! " +7 ,,. $,97B"

, ! 77"+ $7 /

) -"7 " + ,,$,922 2 !

" +! !#" 7,, 2. $" !

2 7 ! , B" 2 7/ / "7 $7 /77" 9$9>7/

2 "7

- , 4 2 !

/ " 7 / " 7 4,

7" 7,9$" 2. $" ! 2 7 !97 " 7" !

#" 722 2 7+"72 B" $ >7 #" 7.$9 ,

- $ .24 +>4/ !7 ! 2 7+ " ! . ! 2 B" !7 ,+"7 , ",! ,9$!"

, >7,,4 " $" ! 2 7 !,

? " !" ! 22 2 7

74,2 7// 2 B" $ B" &77 /,9+ 74, 2 7/+ $/ <

E ! +7 2 / E0

) ! + 2/ $! , ;

@ + ".2" B"

?677 /,9,, J -<" /'"2(

A E "$ 2 ,74)2 @-+$"

2 22 2

77" 7" 9 7,2 7,4 !!+ "

! 4 E,9>2 77".,9$7B"

$9 ,?, "

7 $ $.

7 / .7 7 , $9 2 7"

2 . 2 4$, . 227 9 " !!7 -2,9+

$4 ,,

2 7"

/ 2 2 4 .77 $ $ "/ 7 ,74,,9 " 7 77" ,9 $ 7B"

/ $9+ .77$/,"2 $9

4 7,9$ $9 ,?, "

)

4 7 77" ! 2 7B"

7 1 #

$ #

CCI!,+" / "

3$ 6 EF

8 "

" $

!7+

/ C 8 "

CC " /

" /

% % ) $ #

# $ #$

% #

$ C " -

6 EF

# 8

$ &

& 8 ") A0

) 6

# $

$ #

-. ! ! 7" +-4 ! .

2 7,,+ ",$>7 !"

, 92 7// 2 2 4 !.7 /$ 2,9 4 , .7 $ 7 ,,7 / 2

! 2"2 ! ,"7 2

@-E

* +/ " +

+ ! - , *+* +* ! &4 &7 + * ,7

9 #2"+ 1 7 , '&>" (,, "$B" 2 7//

! 4! " $$" !2 7 !, $9B" J /2 " +; #%

+ +* + +

* #* ?#

% ; # %; + # * % % * #

#9 % + ; #"# + ,- # #* ? ;

;+ + # # * % % + #

# * %

%* +,- /& );+# *+ 6 + - )

" +; 10//(1/<

A! "

/5 3# "

% &

#$ 20

$ $ >

1 $

#$/5C #

/ >

$ 4 * $ # # # ")<" #

: #

$ #

$ #$

: #$

#$#

79"/

/ >

0 $ :

. >

* :

$ $

# 3

/5+. >

/5C/ >

# #

$ #

)

479"/ 9 /

$ 1 $ #

#$ >

#$ /5C / >

> #

1 # 1

# $

)

# > 1

# $

!+,"/

# $ $ # 1

$ $

!+, "/ #$

$ $ $

$ #

$ &

7 = #

$ $ $

$ $ $ #

# $ #

$ #

> #$ $

!+,"/1

# $ #

# $

C " 8

$# "

# $

# $ #

# "

479!+,!C"/!+@!4: * #$

# 1

# #

$# $

!%*/" #

& # #

# $#

, > "

/3 " +;*

;

+ 6 + +* %

6 # #

## -

# ; %;; #%6 ;#

% ,

; #

+ F . )) + #+

+ + #;

+ *

; %

+ + % ?

% # * + ;

# + ;) 9 % /4 - # - # ;

; #% + %

,- .(( /01/(1/(

232/'4&(1/&0-) &(5&36 + 7 ,

89 /:

* + +;* * 5++6 7*!8%4'

% = 20/F H = 2 $, H