Manish Luthra & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ANR




    


   

 !"# $#%&'&()    * !(&'+,-"+.!!($"+#.'

#"&"&(#.'

/#.'-'

0"!"# -(1!2!($!("+#.

#'3($#("'

 ) 4 , 0
5,0 .#'#(") '-.'+!.!(5!((6 $7%!"#6 ."+#3#"&"&(#.' .&8+&95
+3.!6#3-": -(1!2 .0+#.-;!(6 $7%!"#6 ."+#%;39!&(!("

 <+#"+#."+##3."#.' 9%!9(#='3!3#.;!:2#!99=#$"'## "+#1-$>;#("? #'  2#.# #..#$""+##3."#..(" #'  <+#"+#."+#1-$>;#("'+-9$2#.#3."#$&("+#$&>#'"? #'   5,06  +#  3.#'#("  3#"&"&(#.'  +!7#  &9#$  "+&'  3#"&"&(  -($#.

0#%"&(  @ 
.
  .  A-!'+&(>        *  $!"#$    6 .#>&'"#.#$-($#.0#%"&('@B6@

6  
!"9&%#0"!"&( <;#(6 ;.&"'!.
&":6&'".&%" ;.&"'!. "  &'  %9!&;#$  "+!"  3#"&"&(#.     !(&'+  ,-"+.!6  &'

2."+#.&(9!= #"+63#"&"&(#. ##(!C&(!8'+&=& #

  !(&'+,-"+.!6&''&'"#.&(9!= #"+!(&63#"&"&(#.&"&8!C &"-6&'=&$='&'"#.&(9!=!(!$63#"&"&(#.@ !(!8!16&'

!"+#.&(9!=!($3#"&"&(#.*0(#+,!"!C !29&&';"+#.&( 9!= "+#%;39!&(!("

""+#7#.:-"'#"6&"+!'%;#-""+!"!

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

.#'3($#("  +#&(A-#'"&(&';&'-'# 3.%#''
-."+#3#"&"&(#.+!'("+&(>"$=&"+"+#;!".&;(&!9$&'3-"# .#'3($#(" =&"++#.+-'2!($

 "&%#=!'&''-#$""+#.#'3($#("' +#  0"!"#6  &(  "+#  .#39:6  +!'  "!8#(  "+#  '"!($  "+!" 3#"&"&(#.' !($+!7#("2##((;&(!"#$!'!%%-'#$!($ "+!"(=6"+#%+!99!(+!'2##(3.#'#("#$!>!&('"3#"&"&(#.' @!($* "&''"!"#$"+!"3#"&"&(#.' !($ +!7#>";!$# '#3!.!"#.!"&(%!.$62-""+#:9&7#=&"+3#"&"&(#.'@!($*&("+# '!;#+-'#&#-'#

B6!9& 6'+=!.!>!.6!.( !.!(  !$6  &'".&%"  ;.&"'!.   "  =!'  -."+#.  '"!"#$  "+!"  $-.&(> &(7#'"&>!"&(6&(A-&.:=!'%($-%"#$!($!

"#."+#&(A-&.:6'-

&%&#("

#7&$#(%#=!' -($!($%+!99!(+!$2##(3.#'#("#$"=!' -."+#.

'"!"#$"+!" ;&",-"+.!6+-'2!($ %;39!&(!(".#'3($#(" 6 +!$2##($#%9!.#$!3.%9!&;#$

#($#.62-"(=+#+!'2##( >.!("#$!("&%&3!".:2!&92:"+&'
-."=&"+!$&.#%"&("'-..#($#. 2# .#"+#".&!9
-." +!7#+#!.$9#!.(#$%-('#9 ."+#3!."&#'!($+!7# !9'%!.# -99:>(#"+.->+"+# &9# ,#!.(#$%-('#9 ."+#3#"&"&(#.+!'"!8#("+&'
-."" "+#%("#("' "+#&(A-#'"&("'"!"#"+!""+#.#!.#7!>-# !99#>!"&('!>!&('"3#"&"&(#. !($"+!"("+#2!'&' 7!>-# !99#>!"&('63#"&"&(#. +!'2##(%+!99!(#$"+->++#&'9&7&(> '#3!.!"#9: .;"+#%;39!&(!("+#%;39!&(!("+!$!$&'3-"#

@ =&"++#.+-'2!($!($3#"&"&(#. +!'("+&(>"$=&"+"+# '!;#  "+!'2##(!.>-#$"+!"'&(%#"+#%+!99!(=!'3.#'#("#$ $-.&(>"+#3#($#(%: "+#3.#'#("3#"&"&(!($"+!""+#%+!.>#'

=#.#  !9'  .!;#$  $-.&(>  "+#  3#($#(%:    "+#  3.#'#("  3#"&"&(6 "+#.# .#6"+#'!;#'+-9$!9'2#A-!'+#$ +&'  %("#("&(  +!'  2##(  '#.&-'9:  33'#$  2:  "+# 9#!.(#$%-('#9 ."+#%;39!&(!("!'=#99!'"+#9#!.(#$0"!"# %-('#9 ,#!.(#$  %-('#9  .  "+#  3#"&"&(#.  +!'  .#9&#$  -3( !-"+.&": "+&'
-."&(
  

     

    

.&;&(!9*B*!($"=!-"+.&"&#'

 "+#  (429#  0-3.#;# 
-."  &(            

    

     B0-3.#;#
-."
!'#'6 E*E!($!"  

        

     0-3.#;#
-."
!'#'6E@  ,#!.(#$%-('#9 ."+#%;39!&(!("+!'3.$-%#$';# "+#.!-"+.&"&#'  "+#(429#0-3.#;#
-." +.## -$>#'

#(%+ "+#(429#0-3.#;#
-."&("      

  E

.&;&(!9EE 6=+&9#$&'%-''&(>"+# '%3# 0#%"&(@ 
.
6+!'2'#.7#$!'-($#.) 0#%"&(@ 
.&;&(!9.%#$-.#
$#$#'("

%( #.!(:(#=3=#.("+#&>+
-.""(9:

'!7#'  "+#  &(+#.#("  3=#.  =+&%+  "+# 
-."

* 3''#''#$2# .#"+##(!%";#(" "+#
$#"

#(7&'!>#'  "+.##  %&.%-;'"!(%#'  -($#.  =+&%+  "+# &(+#.#("1-.&'$&%"&(;!:2##D#.%&'#$6(!;#9:6& ">&7##

#%""!(.$#.-($#."+#
$#6&&" 3.#7#("!2-'# "+#3.%#'' %-."6!($&&&" "+#.=&'#'#%-.#"+##($' 1-'"&%#"&'(#&"+#.

3''&29#(.$#'&.!29#"9!:$=(!(:&( 9#D&29# .-9#=+&%+=-9$>7#.("+##D#.%&'# &(+#.#("

1-.&'$&%"&(9#>&'9!"&7##(!%";#("$#!9&(>=&"+ 3.%#$-.#  %!(  3.7&$#  .  !99  %!'#'  "+!"  ;!:

3''&29:  !.&'# 
-."'6  "+#.# .#6  +!7#  &(+#.#("

3=#.'!3!." .;#D3.#''3.7&'&(' 9!==+&%+ !.# (#%#''!.: . 3.3#. $&'%+!.>#   -(%"&('

!($$-"&#'&;3'#$-3("+#;2:9!=+!"&'"+# $%".&(#  =+&%+  &($'  #D3.#''&(  &(  "+#  '#%"&( =+&%+;#.#9:.#%>(&G#'!($3.#'#.7#'&(+#.#(" 3=#.' "+#&>+
-."' 99%-."'6=+#"+#.%&7&9 .%.&;&(!93''#''6&("+#!2'#(%# !(:#D3.#''

3.7&'&(6!'&(+#.#("&("+#&.%('"&"-"&(6!99'-%+ 3=#.'!'!.#(#%#''!.:"$"+#.&>+"!($" -($!=.(>&(%-.'# !$;&(&'".!"&( 1-'"&%# ("+#3.&(%&39#HA-!($9#D!9&A-&$!9&%-&%(%#$&"6 %(%#$#.#7&$#"-.#"&$'&(#A-.#'&3'!##''# ((3"#'"H=+#("+#9!=>&7#'!3#.'(!(:"+&(> &"  >&7#'  +&;  "+!"  =&"+-"  =+&%+  &"  %!(("  #D&'" <+&9#  #D#.%&'&(>  3=#.'  -($#.  "+#  '#%"&(6  "+# %-."$#'(" -(%"&(!'!%-." !33#!9.

.#7&'&(  (+#.#("  1-.&'$&%"&(  -($#.  "+#  '#%"&( "+->+  =&$#  +!'  "  2#  #D#.%&'#$  '3!.&(>9:6

B %!.# -99:  !($  =&"+  %!-"&(  !($  (9:  =+#(  '-%+ #D#.%&'#&'1-'"& &#$2:"+#"#'"' '3#%& &%!99:9!&$ $=(&("+#'#%"&(&"'#9 "&'"2##D#.%&'#$#D $#2&"1-'"&"&!#"$.#!9!($'-2'"!("&!91-'"&%# .

"+#  !$;&(&'".!"&(    =+&%+  !9(#  %-."'  #D&'"

-"+.&": "+#%-."#D&'"' .!$7!(%#;#(" 1-'"&%#!($& !(:!""#;3"&';!$#"!2-'#"+!"

!-"+.&":'!'"3.$-%#&(1-'"&%#6"+#%-."+!' 3=#."3.#7#("!2-'#"=-9$2#!(!2-'# 3.%#''    "+#  %-."  "  !99=  !(: !%"&(  =+&%+ =-9$.#'-9"&(&(1-'"&%#!($3.#7#("3.;"&( 1-'"&%#(#D#.%&'# "+#3=#.'%-."=-9$2# 1-'"& &#$"A-!'+!(:3.%##$&(>& &" &($'"+!"

&(&"&!"&(%("&(-!(%# &"!;-("'"!2-'# "+# 3.%#'' %-.".A-!'+&(> "+#'#3.%##$&(>'

=-9$"+#.=&'#'#.7#"+##($' 1-'"&%#I (  "+#  '!&$  %!'#6  "+#  %+!.>#'+##"  =!'  &9#$  !($  "+# %+!.>#'=#.#!9' .!;#$+#.# .#6"+#A-!'+&(> "+#=!'

.# -'#$2:2'#.7&(>!'-($#.) * 339&%!"&( &9#$2# .#"+#&>+
-.".#9!"#$ "  !99#>#$  %;;&''&(    

#(%#'  3-(&'+!29# -($#.  0#%"&(  @

 !($  @B    ($&!(  #(!9
$#  ($&'3-"#$9:  "+#  %+!.>#'+##"  +!'  2##(

&9#$!($"+#'!;#=!'("&(A-#'"&(
+!.>#' +!7#!9'2##( .!;#$!($6"+#.# .#6"+#A-#'"&( A-!'+&(>"+#$#'("!.&'#I ( # "

  

    

E 

      
  
.&;&(!9  *@ 6  "+#  %+!.>#'+##"  =!'

A-!'+#$2:"+#(429#0-3.#;#
-."&(#D#.%&'# 3=#.'-($#.

."&%9# @  "+#
('"&"-"&( ($&!=&"+-">&(>&(""+#9#>!9&":

"+#!99#>!"&('=#7#.6.#>!.$&(>"+##D#.%&'# 3=#.'-($#.

0#%"&(@ 
.
6"+# 3#D
-."+!'.# #..#$""+#3.$-%#$ %!'#9!=("+#3&("!($2'#.7#$!'-($#.) F * DDDDD DDDDDD DDDDDD +#'%3# #D#.%&'# "+#3=#.-($#.

0#%"&( @    "+#
$# !($ %!"#>.&#'    "+# %!'#'=+#.#&>+
-.";!:#D#.%&'#&"'3=#. -($#.&".#9!"&(>"%>(&G!29#

#(%#'"3.#7#("

"+#!2-'# "+#3.%#'' %-."."+#.=&'#" '#%-.#"+##($' 1-'"&%#=#.#'#"&($#"!&92:"+#

3#D
-."&("+#%!'# $%  &     ' J

* 0-339  0

 *K  "+#: +!7# 2##(#(-;#.!"#$!'-($#.)    <+#.#  "+#  !99#>!"&('  ;!$#  &(  "+#  &.'"

&( .;!"&(.#3."."+#%;39!&("6#7#(& "+#:!.# "!8#(  !"  "+#&.  !%#  7!9-#  !($  !%%#3"#$  &(  "+#&.

#("&.#":$("3.&;! !%&#%('"&"-"#!(:

#(%#.

;!8#-"!%!'#!>!&('""+#!%%-'#$  <+#.#"+#!99#>!"&('&("+# &.'"&( .;!"&( .#3."!($"+#.;!"#.&!9'6& !(:6!%%;3!(:&(> "+#    $  ("  $&'%9'#  !  %>(&G!29#  

#(%#6 1-'"& :&(>!(&(7#'"&>!"&(2:39&%#

&%#.'-($#.

0#%"&( *B  "+#
$##D%#3"-($#.!(.$#.

!!>&'".!"#=&"+&("+#3-.7&#= 0#%"&( **

  "+#
$# <+#.#"+#-(%(".7#."#$!99#>!"&(';!$#&( "+#.%;39!&("!($"+##7&$#(%#%99#%"#$&( '-33."    "+#  '!;#  $  ("  $&'%9'#  "+# %;;&''&( !(:

#(%#!($;!8#-"!%!'# !>!&('""+#!%%-'#$ @  <+#.#6  "+#  !99#>!"&('  &(  "+#    $  (" %('"&"-"#!%>(&G!29#

#(%#2-"%('"&"-"#(9:

!  ((%>(&G!29#  

#(%#6  (  &(7#'"&>!"&(  &'

3#.;&""#$2:!39&%#

&%#.=&"+-"!(.$#. !

!>&'".!"#!'%("#;39!"#$-($#.0#%"&( **  "+#
$# *  <+#.#  "+#  !99#>!"&('  ;!$#  &(  "+#    . %;39!&("!.#'!2'-.$!($&(+#.#("9:&;3.2!29# ("+#2!'&' =+&%+(3.-$#("3#.'(%!(#7#.

.#!%+  !  1-'"  %(%9-'&(  "+!"  "+#.#  &'  '-

&%&#("

>.-($ .3.%##$&(>!>!&('""+#!%%-'#$ B<+#.#"+#.#&'!(#D3.#''9#>!92!.#(>.! "#$ &(  !(:    "+#  3.7&'&('    "+# 
$#  .  "+# %(%#.(#$ %"-($#.=+&%+!%.&;&(!93.%##$&(> &'&('"&"-"#$""+#&('"&"-"&(!($%("&(-!(%# "+#3.%##$&(>'!($.=+#.#"+#.#&'!'3#%& &% 3.7&'&(  &(  "+# 
$#  .  "+#  %(%#.(#$  %"6 3.7&$&(>#

&%!%&-'.#$.#'' ."+#>.&#7!(%# "+#!>>.&#7#$3!.": E  <+#.#  !  %.&;&(!9  3.%##$&(>  &'  ;!(& #'"9:

!""#($#$  =&"+  ;!9!  &$#  !($.  =+#.#  "+# 3.%##$&(>&';!9&%&-'9:&('"&"-"#$=&"+!(-9"#.&. ;"&7# .  =.#!8&(> 7#(>#!(%#  (  "+# !%%-'#$

!($=&"+!7&#="'3&"#+&;$-#"3.&7!"#!($ 3#.'(!9>.-$># #.#  !99#>!"&('  ;!$#  &(  "+#  .#3."  !($  "+# #7&$#(%#'%99#%"#$&("+#%-.'# &(7#'"&>!"&( %('".-#!%>(&G!29#

#(%#6&"=-9$(" !99&( !(:%!"#>.: "+#%!'##(-;#.!"#$!27#6%!99

.  "+#  #D#.%&'#    #D".!  .$&(!.:  3=#.'  .

&(+#.#("  3=#.  A-!'+&(>  "+#  %+!.>#  '+##" '-2;&""#$&("+#!27#("#$%!'#'I -."+#.>-&$#9&(#' 9!&$&( 
 

       

B0


6=#.#!9'$&'%-''#$!'-($#.) (


 

B0
 

6  "+&' 
-."  '-;;!.&'#'  ';# %!"#>.&#'   %!'#'&(=+&%+&(+#.#("3=#.%!(!($'+-9$2# #D#.%&'#$"A-!'+"+#3.%##$&(>') &<+#.#&";!(& #'"9:!33#!.'"+!""+#.#&'!9#>!9 2!.!>!&('""+#&('"&"-"&(.%("&(-!(%##>=!(" '!(%"&(L &&<+#.#"+#!99#>!"&('&("+# &.'"&( .;!"&( .#3.".%;39!&(""!8#(!""+#&. !%#7!9-#!($ !%%#3"#$  &(  "+#&.  #("&.#":  $  ("  %('"&"-"#  "+#

#(%#!99#>#$ &&&<+#.#"+#!99#>!"&('%('"&"-"#!(

#(%#6 2-"  "+#.#  &'  (  9#>!9  #7&$#(%#  !$$-%#$  .  "+# #7&$#(%#  !$$-%#$  %9#!.9:  .  ;!(& #'"9:  !&9'  " 3.7#"+#%+!.>#I <+&9#  .# #..&(>  "  "+#  %!'#     "      !

     

      0

 E*6  "+#  3#D 
-."

 2'#.7#$!'-($#.) F  +&'
-."&("+#9!"#'"$#%&'&(+!'+#9$"+!" =+#.#&(7#'"&>!"&(=!'%;39#"#$6%+!.>#'+##" +!$2##( &9#$!($%+!.>#'!.# .!;#$6"+#&>+
-."'+-9$(".$&(!.&9:#;2!.8-3(!(#(A-&.: !'  "  "+#  .#9&!2&9&":    

#(%#'  "  '-'"!&(  "+# !99#>!"&('  ;!$#  &(  "+#  %;39!&("  =+&%+  &'  "+#

-(%"&(    "+#  ".&!9  %-."  J'##   "    !

 

   0

E*KI +#  3'&"&( &(  "+# 3.#'#("  %!'#  &'  "+!"  3#($&(> "+# 3.#'#("3#"&"&(6"+#&(7#'"&>!"&(=!'%!..&#$-"!($"= "+# 3#"&"&(#.'=#.# -($&((%#("+#39&%#%99#%"#$"+##7&$#(%# !($ &9#$"+#%+!.>#'+##"+#9#!.(#$ -$&%&!9!>&'".!"# '"
9!''6 !

"#.  >&(>  "+.->+  "+#  .#3."    "+#  39&%#  -($#.  0#%"&(  E
.
6"+#'"!"#;#("' "+#=&"(#''#'.#%.$#$-($#.0#%"&(

.
  !($  "+#  $%-;#("'  39!%#$  (  &9#6  .!;#$  "+#  %+!.>#'

!>!&('"3#"&"&(#.' 6@6!($*-($#.0#%"&('@B!($@


67&$#%+!.>#'+##"$!"#$ B   @ ((#D-.#   ("+&'

%!'#6"+.##=&"(#''#'+!7#!9'2##(#D!;&(#$+#.# .#6.#9:&(> -3("+#%!'#9!= "+#(429#0-3.#;#
-."&("   ( %!'#'-3.!6$&'%-''#$!27#6!; "+#7&#="+!".$&(!.&9:=+#( "+#39&%#+!'3.#'#("#$"+#%+!99!(-($#.0#%"&( E
.
!($ "+#".&!9
-."+!'!9' .!;#$"+#%+!.>#'!

"#.!339:&(>&"';&($( "+##7&$#(%#%99#%"#$$-.&(>"+#39&%#&(7#'"&>!"&(6"+#&(

A-#'"&(  !9(>=&"+  %('#A-#("&!9  3.%##$&(>'  !.&'&(>  "+#.# .;

'+-9$("2#A-!'+#$

%%.$&(>9:6"+#3.#'#("3#"&"&(&'$&';&''#$ 5,0



   * '18'