Balbir Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
'
'4'4155040, !" .&!
(/+01+02
7 !
3 &#& !"# $ %!
& 7 &8!
% &
'(
)* '+
:
!
"#$%
# ! 7< / ;;;
+, - &
'() "
&*+,- 4
56
""
" ./0 ! &1, &* 2( )2)&
)) ! 3
% &*(1- 4! 56 </
!%3 / 3 3 3
)
3 &* 2( )2)& ()2 "
"
" % ! <71 <#< (7&& 8 3 "% > 3%
8 , ,72 % 9 " - < =33
6'12 % "&212%
?
"-% ?"6 &22 % " - " 3
6 " "
%3
/< @
./0-6
, 9
? "
B B C
% % ,23 :
" 3
% +,+
,2" " ()2 " % % < % " " 3
3 (,, ('2
% % A3('' %3 3%3
/ %3 "
.
9
" %" -= = <&,6 :
2( 2, )2))-= <&'6 % ! 0 < <'& &*7,<)2)& 3
&+ +,-(6
" / <""% /
2& )2))
2* 2& )2) ),-=<&76 B
" : %
%3 %
/ "
D
" 8
"3 .3 " A % % 4(7&& 5
3A "
1( 1* ! 9 $ " %3 B5% "
#$ %&'( (( )
*
%
'
9 &* 2+ )2 2), %"
"3 . " E $ : B 3 ?% . % 3 " "% " 3 % B % %3 < <
% % 0 < < < '&*7,<)2)& 2( 2, )2))
!"!
!" %"+,!
$
!" "# $ $ 4# $&$ $""% $&# !
*
*
'' # ($)*#' * + -+
#% $2
+ #, # - ( )
'+. + * # $/ 0!1( + ' + + ( ('+ + **
(
**#( * ( +* + $2 *# $/ 0!1( + % & 3
. <
%
&2 2'
)2),
2
$ 6 $ 5!" ( ( .
.
!" " 4#$&$ $""% $& ( #
4! 4" " ' (74745 * # # -+ + ' %# , $2 4 &8 *((29 #'
4 + ' '. * ' * + ( '
$)# ( #
! " ""0&8 451 (
:4 +* + ( , *
( #$2 +*
( (''+ $/ 0!1(
(( :
$
* . ! ** ;2
,+ $ * ** (29 # *+ ' + '+ + # + !6 # + # + ' * *+
;.; . +
' . + *+ .# ; :
/:5 * + ,46 4=4!6 . # + *+ + , + * ($); * ' + ++ # ,+ $ . !:" :
/:5 * * * + ;.; . # * ,46 4=4!
* + !6 !:" * + . 5 , % ' * & " :55:"" 4'* ' ' * * + ; # + + $ * < 2 + 4$. ' * * 4 * * +
% '
+
$ *+' **' + 3 ( *
# (74745 6 4" "# ( , ':4
' + * #
( '
+ . $ / 0!1 (
+ +( 3 ( ( ( '
+ * +*'
* * 1 # $2
' * '
( ,(
$ / 0!1 4 + + * 7 () '# &
&=# - -+ + * . ) /" "
+ **# ( 8 - 3 + : % "
" %
%3.
9
2+ + 2) )2)) -= <&,6 /
33 B /
"
"3
& +,-(6
$%
% " % 3 % " " 3 3
% /
%3
$
" "
3 3 %" 3 3
"3%3
" $ " % "
0
-
-
(
*
. 0
(
0
$
.
&
/
*
*
#
' && &
( B
3 3 "
$% 3
" %
% 3
" / "= "
"<> +
# + * + + +
"%" % *
$%
$ #
/
#
" "
3 &2
%
&& / 8
3
3 "
%3
" %
3 BC
%
" %3# "C
! - 6
#
&)
3 0 3
" %
3 %
$% " &,
"
-6
3
, -
)( 2& )2)1 * DC! - 6 > C Yes/No (ii) Whether reportable :