Shamsher Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
"
"#"""
$%
""""& '
( &
) *+,- &"
./012(- 0)3*2 4/& 20)&
) *+,- &"
./012(- & )21 4
&
0)3*2 4/& 20)&!
."
!" "!"# $ %& '
$ ( )("*"!!"!" $
&& ++
$+ , %&
+ ( & &+ -$ %+ ) 0 567 /8'9 "
. 9'
,:
;
9'
,:.&8 -:9 8 0 , . /
$
+ $+ 01# '
+ + '
& +
+ ' '
$ $ ' & +
' + '
'
$ + 2+ ' '
&
3 '
$+ /
++
$ &
& '&
$ , $+
'
+ +
'
' $++ / $+
& ++ $ + & + '
+$ + +'&
$ ' /$+
+$ 4 &+ ) 0 )<
&8. .
5= 0 679
. 679
0 > ( '"
&8 0= !
-?"
8.
, % ' + 5& &6 $ , ''
++ +
+ ' ' & 3 + $
$
7 + $& , ' &
$&$ ,:6 *
@ ( "
'
!
, '
'
$$&'
/
+ + '
$ $ %&
$ '
' '& + 8
A6 8
!"#" $%&'()*#&+ ,- #&(%!# .'"# ,!"#! , / 0+#&, " +#" -,! &,+ !#$,!+ '& +)# %&1 2 3 !4 & '5) ,%!+ ,& "%# " +# '& ,
&" 6(, &,+ !#$,!+ '& +)# ,--'7# ,- !4 & 8 ) &"'5 !) !"#" $%&'()*#&+ ,- !&'&5 .'"# ,!"#! , / 0+#&, " +#" 9 '& 70 7 (# , " +#" 8:0(6#7+!'7'+47+8 ; %! !"#" $%&'()*#&+ ,- #&(%!# .'"# ,!"#! , /
0+#&," +#",& 77,%&+,- 66#5#"*'(7,&"%7+ '&7 (# ," +#"8:0(6#7+!'7'+47+8
" !; !& 6 !"#" $%&'()*#&+ ,- 7#&(%!# .'"# ,!"#! " +#" -,! &,+ -,66,'&5 %$ 7 (# , 0 " !; !& 6 )# 77%(#"$#!(,& 7<%'++#"24+)#7,%!+,- '!!#5%6 !'+'#(#!#-,%&",&+)#'!$ !+ !"#" !&'&5.'"#,!"#! , /
" +#" ,& 77,%&+,- 66#5#"*'(7,&"%7++) +7 (# , 09
'.'6='&#(; !& 6)# (+)#'&.#(+'5 +',&,--'7#!,-+)# 7 (# +, '(7'$6'&# &+#5!'+4
#&#! 6#* !>( &"'(7'$6'&#
,," +'(- 7+,!4 & .#! 5#+4$# +, ,&#(+4 ,+,&#(+
#6 +',&()'$'+)$%26'7 &" 2#) .',%! '+) +)#* #6 +',&()'$ '+) +)# (%2,!"'& +#( &" 2#) .',! '+) +)# 1%&',!(
#&#! 6+,6#! &7#$,#! &",!5 &'? +',& 6
#!(,& 6'+4 &" '&'+' +'.#
,#!,-,** &" ,"#!& 4 ,- '&.#(+'5 +',& &" '&+#!#(+'&*,"#!&$,6'7# 4(
!#7 %+',& !4 &" (# !7) !#6 +',& <% 6'-'7 +',& @$#!'#&7# ,- *,"#!& 6 &"$!,7#"%!# &+#5!'+4 '(<% 6'-'7 +',& '- &4 &" +)# ( *# ) ( 2##& 2!,%5)+ +, +)# &,+'7# ,- +)#7,&7#!&#",--'7#!
#&#! 6#* !>( ,+ ,," ,+ ,," ,+ ,," ,+ ,," ,+ ,," ,+ + >'&5 '&+#!#(+ &" *'(%('&5)'($,#! ,+ ,," ,+ ,," ,+#@$#!'#&7#" ,%2+-%6 %!'&5$,(+'&5'&/ ; !& 68 7 (# ) ( 2##& !#5'(+#!#" '& #6)'8 '& )'7) )# ( 2(#&+#" &",& 77,%&+ ,- )'7) "#$ !+*#&+ 6 #&<%'!4 ( '&'+' +#" )'7) '( $#&"'&5 &" 7,%!+ 7 (# '( 6(, $#&"'&5 8'5#&+ &" &,&/ !#($,&('26# #*$6,4##8 ), '( %&+!%(+,!+)4 #7#(('+4+,'*$!,.#+)# 2#) .',%! "%!'&5 ,!>'&5 &" +, '*$!,.# +)#( *#'& ,.+,!>
6 (('-'7 +',& ,- !#$,!+8 .#!4 5,,"8 5,,"8 .#! 5# ,! 2#6, .#! 5# A#6,.#! 5# +,9 ,%2+-%6 .#! 5# .#! 5# ,+6,4 6 .#! 5# .#! 5# .#! 5# #( '(*'((#" -!,* (#!.'7# ,&9 A#6, .#! 5#B ,&#(+4 ,! 6 ,%! 5# !# "'&#(( +, #@$,(# * 6$! 7+'7#( ,- (%2,!"'& +#( =,4 6+4 +, +)# ,.+ '& $,#! !#5 !" +, $,6'+'7 6 &" $ !+4 -##6'&5(
#!(,& 6'+4 &" '&'+' +'.#
,#!,-,** &"
!#.#&+'.# &""#+#7+'.# 2'6'+'#( #6' 2'6'+4 #-#7+ '- &4 &" )#+)#! +)# ( *# ) .# 2##& 2!,%5)+ +, +)# &,+'7# ,- 7,&7#!&#" ,--'7#! '+) &4 7,**%&'7 +',&
#&#! 6!#* !>( +#5,!4,-!#$,!+
$ 9 +'
+
+ + )4
$ / + $
'
$$ + +
'
$ )& + &' + + &+
$
++ +$ + & +
$3 +'
+-
'
: ';$ $+ / ' + '8'
& /&' &
$'
&
$ ' + + &
& !"
## $
"
$ %&'( ) ((; 4 C)#+)#!($# >'&50!# (,&#" D #( 0 , C)#+)#!#$,!+ 26# D #( 0 ,