Suman Kumar v. Ut Chandigarh
!"#$#$ % +,-.,- %%%%%%%
/ + +
!01 !0! %%%%%%% + + #% &'&' 2*( '#$#$ +, %%%%%%%
/ + +
!01 !0! %%%%%%% + + 3% &'&' 22 '#$#$ . +1! %%%%%%%
/ + + + !01 ! %%%%%%% + & 45& % ++.
&
! !"##$%!&'&' ! !"(%#)!&'&'
! !"(()"!&'&'
* &
! !"##$%!&'&' ! !"(%#)!&'&'
& +67.,- "% + ", ""
&'"(
- .
. ,)$'''/!
01 234 5 6 2
1 .6 7!
. 2
,)$'''/! .
8 .6 45 * '''# "9 '"
&'&'1 6 "(
#"(#&' #9$#%" "&'!:5
1 1.81
;
1 '% '& &'&' 8
< 1
. )'$'''/! 1 234 5 6 5
8
.
= <
> .
.6 . >234 5 6 1 < =
8=
8
1
,'
'"
&'&'
- - - ?
1
.
8
.
1 + - "''.
8
@:8 .
5
1
,
1
. '9 '& &'&' 1
5 "' 1 6 45
;
&( '& &'&'10 .6 . .
.6
6. 1 + @
! !"'"#$!&'&' 1 . #$&
:6 '9 ', &'&' /5 @ 1 1 1 1
1 .6
.
-
,)$'''/! 8 1 6
1 .
6 @ '( '% &'&'
! !"##$%!&'&'
1 .
&# '9 &'&' ! !",("'!&'&'
.
6
6 +.&'"( 1 .
# 21 .
< =
1 .6
&# '9 &'&' ! !",9%&!&'&' ! !",('"!
&'&' 8
1 6.
.1 1 1 . . .6 6
@ .6 ..
.6
6-
;
.
#,(
8 .
:
.
. 1
.68 =
< =
1 2
1 6 6
.68=
< =
2
1 1 . 6 1 6 @
6
616'% '& &'&'
36 6. 5 5
6
.
8 1
) 1
.
>
.8
@:8 . 4
- .* :
81
1
8
1
")"'''/!
1 45 * '( '"
'& &'&'
5
#"(#&'#9$#%" "&'!:5 A 45 * ,) &"
'& &'&'
#&' "&'!:5 99 5
6&'''
.
.
45 * '( '"
'& &'&'
21 1 .
1 1
. 45 * ,) &"
'& &'&' 1 45 * '( '"
'& &'&'.1 .
.
36
1 &$ ', &'&'
6
1.
-
!8 9 :%+
0! ;#$#$+ 5+* <1 1
.6 . .
6.
- 1 .6 B "( ') &'&'
! !)##(9!&'"( :0 =!>,:%+ 7 .6 .
.6 +67!0 :% ;?#$ #@ +($<
.
. .
.-
8
.
6.
6.6 8 6.
. 6
> ! 1 .6 1 6
. +
8
.
8=
< =
1
@ +
.- 6 211
1 6
6 . 36
6
1. 5 .- 45
6 . 5
% 111 1 7
6
.
6. 5
6.
1. . 8,""
0
. - 5 6 . 6
> ! 8 .
.
61
. .
< =
21
. &$ ', &'&' 36
6
6 . 5 5 +
.61 6 6
6.6
@
.
1 1.
1
6. .
6 #9$ #%"5 .,&'
$
.6
6 6
1
>
#&' 5 1 .1
6 . . 1
21
. 0 45
.
.6 36 . 5
6 .
6
@ 1 . 0 6
6 1 . .6 1 1.6 !.,- :%+! ;?#$ (@)+#*3< 1 .
5
1
1. 1 21 6
1
..-
6 1 .
45 * '''# "9 '"
&'&' "(
. &'''''/! 1 1
(
8 5 @ /36
- 1 1 4
6 6 1 +.") &'&' C - 6
D B ;
8 / ?/* ;
. ?/*