State Of Haryana Etc. v. Roshan Lal
! "# $%& ' () )() )
"%&%*&+ $%& ' ), () )()
-.%/$ $%&01 2 3!40 ' ), () )() , 51 01 "%&.6%- "/04# -/"0%701 8*$9: &04! -"%&%*&+ $%"7*..8*$9: &04!-"%&%*&+ $ '
*..
1 $ ./6;47/&6;%701 -"%&%*&+ : &0%77*.. 8*$9: &0;/&$" /!%&!01 " %7 ' %0/--.4+/3.
' <=
>
!"!
#
$
$ % !
&&&& >
; ' ( )
* + ,
-.-/'001!
2 * !3
+ ,
4.-4'004!
( * !
)
4
( * 5 ( 3
* 45-4'0..6
) 3 3 !, !3 73 ,!
,
, 8
% 9, 8 3
:
-1'-'0/13 3 3
3 (
3 ,
! '4'4'0/1
-;-4'0// < ( 3
, 3 3
3 3 ; (
3 , : , + * * + = ,
=
, ,
3
3
/-* *> , !3 3 * 45-4'0..
3 , , 8 ,
3
(
3( ?
8
> , ?
8 > 3 , 8
( 3
, 6'+9, ! 64 :9,
6.
%9, , 8 ! 3 3
3
8
'; @ ,3 > 8! 3 -. @ , ,
3
, 3 3
, , 3 , 3
! 3 3 ,
( *
!
"
#
# $ %&&
"# "
' "
$ %&( !
' "
!
$ %&(
$ %&(
"
"
)&) #$ %&( * +,- 1 $
3
( * ! + ,
4.-4'004
,
, 3 3 3
3 , , 8 . + ,
4.-4'004!
A !B !
) 2 2
, *
, 3 !
, -1'-'0/13
'14' + ! ,
) , ,
( 2 * '4'4'0/1
%#" ! ! !3,
,
3
-;-4'0//
%" !3 3 -1'-'0/1* 8 !
3
3 / $ + ,
-.-/'001!
2 * !
, + , 0 -0-0'00.!3 , !
, + ,
3
!
)
'-
)
! , + ,
2 * 3 !
, ,
!3 3 ! ,
! ! , , 3 +
3
2 *
,
, 3
!3
, ,
'' &
"
!
) !
+ ,
2 * !
, '14' !
,
8 ,
! ,!3
'4 #
, 3C, 3 '5 # '14' !3
.
/0 (
1
#
"
""
" #
"
"
""
# "
"
"
#" 2
3 " 1
#"
"
444-
'< 3 , , ,
, ,
, D
, ! ,
,!3
! , ,
!3
,# !
8
, , ! 8 : 8 3 , '; (
! 3
7 ( ,
-<-''0/1 <5- ! ! 3 * $ 3
* $ ,!3 9,!3 !
, 8 ( !
3 % 9, !3 3: ,3 :, 8 ! 3 ! 3
3 , !3 * $ , ( ,'--)7 ,% 9,
8 ( ! 3 >, : !$ !3 3 , : ( 7
, , 8 3
( ! 3 * : , : % 9, ! 3 , ;1-)7
,
, #3
% 9,
, ! ,
'1 ( * , C, ,
-1'-'0/1!
=
'4'4'0/1!
-;-4'0//!
!3
3 7 ( ! 3 ,
-1'-'0/1!3
4'! ,
7
,
8
, 2
"
" ""
5 ""
" 4"
"
&6 )
* 1
&"
7
3 8,2 4
"
) * 7 9
""
"
3 "
!:!,! &; < = 1
" ""
"
3 "
: &;
%
& 3 8
8
)13 * 1 8
1
"
#
" ""
"
&, 8 *
"
4 9
"
&"
#
&, 2 > # 4 1
#
"
"
" * 7
&6 )
* 1
&7 1
&; # ((* ! 1" ?4&(:
1 ?4 &(: ""
"
3
3 " = "
"
) * 7
"
&7 ?4 &(: 8
# "
#
) * 7
&"
7
8,2
@
" " "
"
!
"
) * 7
# 2 "" "A
" 9
" #
, 5
A
1
) 81 7 !
) * 7
"
" B !BB
"
# 9 " 81 7 !
?
#"
1 ) * 7
#"
5 "
# "
9
) 81 7 !
1 ) * 7
B 8 " " "
"
3
# 1
< # 1
#
"
""
1 ( <
&, "
# 1
#"
' " 2 ""
) 81 7 !
) * 7 1
"
, "
"
3 "" 6:, ( +, /5 0 6
&"
- '. (
!
'4'4'0/1
B 9 # "
&, ( <
" 1
# "
&, %
& 3
"
"
#
1
,
( <
&,
3 A
"
A
3
A
"
"
3 1
( <
" *:, "
"
1
"
"
!
"
#$% "
?4,) * 7 81 7 !: 7
"
"
6:, ( +,
( 2 "
C
&"
=
* = - '/ (
-;-4'0//
!
#
# " "
?4) * 7 : 7
A
1 ""
""
&"
*
"
' "
9
" 9
" " "
#
" 9
1
"
4
1 9
A
1"
9 ?A
%
"
"
9 " 1
4
"
" #
"
"
( 9
1
" 1
A
(
"
' 9 ?A
%
"
1
1
# 4"
"
9 6
&"
A
"
# "
( <
1
3
" " #
"
#
1" " # ""
3
9 " "
( <
#
3
3
9 "
"
A
9
""
31
1
"
"
"
"3 1
#
#
9 '" "
9
6
&" :(
2 "
C
&"
"
9
""
# 1
" 9
"
" " "
1
"
9 "3
"
' "
"
/?4) * 7 : 70
" 6:, ( +
( "
C
&"
( ) 2 "
C
&"
=
-
'0 ( ( * 8
4- #
,* # $ "
#& !# '
() #**+
9
-
#
"
""
-
# 9 "
""
"
"
""
"
"
""
- 4' # # ,$- &. # /
')#** ! @ ,* ,
, ,
,
3
* 44 % $ *
# 1
2# '0)#340 ! , ,
3
* 45 # 74.54'00. # $ " * & # ! +! * ,
,, !3 , ! 3
4< ( C,
, , 6
!
-0
-.
, 3: ( !
C,
!
, ,
( C,
( * 3
,
! 3 ,, !
,
( , 8 3
3 '05< !
3 # , ! 3+ , , , !
3 8 , 3 3 ( ! 3 , !
2 * 8
( *
, 4; 2 ! 3
+ ,
-.-/'001!
2 *
( *
, 3
41
!
!
), () )() >
: )
E)B
E)B