Vrinda Krishna Realtech Pvt Ltd v. State Of Punjab And ORS




   
  




 


 

 
 



!"  

# $

%
& '





(      


 

   

   

 

) 
$
) *
+

%



)
(
 
, *
+  
+

- *
& '
.....

   



(
%



1
%
"

 " ""

2


( 
3





'

%


 
$  

%


4

2 0
+  0
+ *


5%


6

+
+ 78*
1 
 2
(
( 
%
 9
%

 0
" 






(" 
1

 (2

   0


) "*
/



: 


;
( 


2
'


2 



< 
5+ =
8

+
" "( 
1

%


4

2 0
+  0*
& '
5%



6 +78

  
%


"( 0

+

"



1
(  *

 0
 



 
5+ =
>8
1




"( 0
%
 0
%

(( 



"(


(





 >
5+ =
 8















 


(
'0


"( 0






 >
1




 

(

2




1



0
(
%
"




+


(




 
5+ =
8
1

'" 


0
  *
1

*
1 *
""

0
 & 


5+ =
8



" 
(( 
%
  
%



(& 

1

 
(





(  0
2




'0



/


(( 
1

 



>  
5+ =
8

/


% 
 < 

 *


22

0
 



 *
1

*
1 *
1  1


5+ =
<8

 

( %






 
$  
58
%

+
+ 

?1 *
(
'

2
 *




 

(  
%
 9
%

 0
"(


1

@ 

'

"

"

%
%2
%

*
1
1


%


*

*



%




1
(  

1 %%# 

"
%
( 
%
( % 2




) 
$
) *

 


 2

 0
2




"( 0



  

1

(&  *





0

(  0
2



@

%


%




'


 *

"(  
%
(  0
%

*
'

2
 0
 '  0

2
'


"(





(

2 *

2 0

"2

2

"( 0
*

*


"

*

1
'





%
&

 
 @2
( 
%
 9

"

% 2



%

!

 



"

%%























 
% 
"


1





(*



"(
(1


%%

 

"
%
(  
A
((
%




*

 




(

  

         

 

 !"##"$#%&' (
) *+,** "- #.&%#%&')*
            !"# $%&'(&$'('(  *+,** "- #/%0#%#%)
)    

 *)       

   

  (..''(#%#&  *+,** "- &/%&#%##*
+,  

  -.       / 0      

 ! ( ) "#..(#%#%  *+,** "- &0%'#%#&


     1  (&1&//(#%#% *+,**"-&.%##%#&)



 

'"


"

'0

 


%


'
%





 % 

<
  2


"



*

1
'

  
 

  0
%
$  
58
%

+
+ *


(

'0

$(

%
A


%
+,  .  

 *)      

 2#%## &)  ,2,!)/31 >




2
1
@


3
 
61


 
%

 
( 

$  
58
%

+
%
2

'

 
2


17*

+( =



6&/1
-"45+"-6,*5*2,7 89":!,; 8,"-+ 684 "- 89 5"<"85"$ 5* "6,8 4-*5+8,"- =/ 3)"$ 89 +8 :,-; +! 66,-,86!$  -*89 5"<"85679" 5,-5+, 8 "$ <"-> 79,+9 ,6 :,-; +! ,<* :> 89 9"< :4>56? !!"886$"55$4-* -**85<,-*,-89$,568 ! + :> 89 +"< 8-8 489"5,8>  ,$ !;,6! 845 ,- ,86 7,6*"< ,-8-** 8" -645 89 8 <"-> "-+ *85<,-* :> 89 489"5,8> : 6 2* ,$

 ! ,6 8" : 5$55* 8 89
















,-68 -+"$89 5"<"85 $85*4+"< !, -+"$ 5* "6,8 6 -2,6 ;* 4-*5+8,"- =/ 3)"$ 89 +8  ,- -" +,5+4<68 -++ -:6 ,*8":"-5"46 6 5 >*$"5"5,- 2,"! 8,"- "$58,+!6 &="5 &0 &) ;) "$ 89 "-68,848,"- "$
-*, @  
A





 (





$( 
%
A


%




%
+,  -

     ! .

 -

 "3     4   1


#%&0 =='0

( 
%
( 

"

%
%2
%






% 0
  
(

 0

1
%%

 

"
%
(  *

?2
 *
=  2
(1
 
+ 

%

   
%
A 
%

= ( 

%
2 



(


A

%
"846  !8+9 288*
5 ( 8*
1



(
'0

*



B
 *
1  2

&2"


%

$(

%
A




%
?6 +9-,<"-8 28 8* 5 ( 8*
= "

"(2 
 







"


1



1


= ( 

2
2 



(*

'0
( " 2



;

&  
%

?2

 
+ 

%

   
%
A
'0

2

( 

@ 
(  *
 &

  
%







(

0
%


'0
"

;2



0
(  

/
&2"


1*

*
'

%






+
" 
 1
1


'0



B



< 5 689  5"<"856 -* 2!"

56 28 8*  26 -,"- "$
-*,  )    

 *)    



 


5 ( 8
A



,5< !,-;95 ( 8*



B



;
"
















 1


1

1
'
;

(2

 1

% "

*
( " 
%2
%



 
%
9
%

 0
"



%
 9
 

<**

#
%

 0

"
%

 
 




 
!


1
= "


1



"



%
1 2
%# 2

"
%
( 
%
 9
%
(  0
"
%


C


((

*
1


"

2 0






 >*


 0
%

1

"(





+
( 


 
1

1

"( 
1

'"

+*
& '

22



(
2 
%
 *
"( 
  %



'






%
 
%
$  

%

+
+ 


+20*

1


 


<
1



*

1

 (0
1

'" 
+20*



 



  <
1

*
1

0
 




 <*
'


 (0
1

'" 

/


1

*

"" 



  <


(




( 

2 0
D 




> <



/

 

 




  <
'



1


 (0

'

%
%



C 0*

 
1





'0
1 0
%
(' 


 
6/

/' 7

> <*
'



(





%


1

(




> <

  0

 



 >*
 0
%

1

"(


A
1


'0

+
6=
9 2+"-6,*5*89< 885+ 5$4!!> -* < "$ 89 2,7 89 8 89 2,"! 8,"- "$ +8,"- / "$ 89 +8 ,6 68 :!,69*"-895+"5*
8,6 !6"68 :!,69*"-895+"5* 89 8*6 ,8 *A4 8"

"584-,8,6;,2-8"8956 "-*-8
















99 6$ ,!*8" 5"2,* ->B ! - 8,"-$"5-"8

!>,-;$"5 5;,685 8,"- "$ 89 5"C+8 7,89,- 89 68, 4! 8* 8,< 6 64+9 ,< "6,8,"- "$ - !8> 4-*5 +8,"- 30 "$ 89 +8 ,6 +"< !8!> 7 55 -8*
- 89
-68 -8 + 6 89 +"68 "$ 89 *2!"

<-8 7"5D6 6 7!! 6 89 +9 5;6 $"5 6+45,-; 2 5,"46

5"2 !6 +"<6 8" 6#/% +5"56 6 -"8* ,- 89

52,"46 5 9 5"C+8,66 5 *"25
- - 5 "$1&1 +566 55 "585+,2*$5"<89"$$,+"$89 48> "<<,66,"-5 89 -D"8 89"!!+8"55 8$"556,*-8, !

"66 ,- 2,!! ;  <""- $"5 89 > 5 #%&/(&= 7 6

6.% %%%?( 5< 5!

< D,-;89+"68"$! -*8": 6=.% +5"56  -*898"8 ! 5"C+8+"688" 6.0%+5"569"4;9 89< B,<4< - !8>4-*589! 7+ -:&%E"$89+"68 "$89 5"C+8 >88 D,-; 6>< 898,+2,7"$89< 885 

- !8>"$ 63%%%! D96,6,< "6*4 "-8956 "-*-8 9,6 - !8> 69"4!* : * "6,8* ,- 89 "25-<-8 5 645>4-*5 *(%#&.("46,-;('%(-5 !('%%"895 5+, 867,89,-#<"-896$5"<89* 8"$,664"$89,6"5*5 -*  +"

> "$ 89 5+, 8 64:<,88* 8" 89,6 489"5,8> $"5 5+"5*@ 

 


0

1


1


'







/


%

' 

/



%  *
;

0



 % *


%

(


"

 0
 
1


1



%
 < *
1
(
%

2
'

B



+% 22
%

"

"

*

 


 2


% 0
1  1







 0
%



 
$  
58
%

+
+ 
/





F 2,-; 5;4* 89 < 885 8 6"< !-;89  ! 5-* +"4-6!$"589 8,8,"-5664:<,8689 89: 5<,88*8" 7,89*5 789 8,8,"-6" 68"- :!89 8,8,"-568" 2 ,! 895<*>"$

 !4-*5+8,"-=/ 3)"$89  !68 8

;4! 8,"- -*2!"

<-8)+8 #%&.

,$6" *2,6*
















,6<,66* 67,89*5 7-@ 
:

(

1
(  

2
'


1  1
'0

*




(  


'


( % 



?1 *

 0
 
%
"




%

*


 





'

+


0

<*

2


"(  
%
(  0
%

% 
'

;


 >*
( 

1

0
(

2
 


1



2"


%

(& 



%%




"

*

0

(  0
2



*
 
 0

'

+



  2

1


'& 

%


  
'0

 *
1
%






=

 
%
( 
"

2

%%


A
 1
%

' *
1


%
0
"




1
 

20
 "



 
) 


  )
 








 
 


 
2 2

;2#

 
,

#3


 ( 
,

#3