High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/27284/2015dismissed

Karamjit Singh Bhullar v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2016-10-27Mr. Justice Krishna Murari10 pages

!!"#$#%& " '!()

* +(,-# .#%/00122( 3 ! # #%!( 4$ . ! 1%-'%5 0!($ 3 !$6%5!% $ & 78 ..

(!$!% & $ +0#%5)59" ! ( 0!6! # #%!( ($0%6(!! .#%/0)) 1%-'

! # #%!( :0#2! 6$ !5 $ $$#$ % .16!(#% !%5!% #2) 2%50()#$22!/!5 09!!; ( !5,%!<(, 0!#%, !$ 0!-#2% 5#!(!% 6(! !; %5 1%5!( 0(! 0!(! (! 22!/ #%$ 0 0! 1$!5 $1662< #% ;#"% $ #%$#5! 0! -#2 0! #%, !$ ! 0$ 66("0!5 0#$ 1( #%9=#%/ 0!-1(#$5#" #%1%5!(.!" #%( (>1$0#%/

5 !512<?

)

1%5!(.!" #%$?@

* ).!" #%$ ) ABC 0! ." %5.!" #%$%5 ?BC 0! (!9!% #% ((16 #%" (!/#$ !(!5 2#"!. #%+ :2#)#$ (#" +61( 02%5

22 0!$1'$!>1!% 6("!!5#%/$(#$#%/1 0!$#5 !2$$!!=$ 6( !" #%2#!%52#'!( < 0!0%5$(!$6%5!% $ %5*:0(! B (#$%$C %5 #"# #%/ B (#$%$C) (!$6!" #9!2< ! # #%!( "2#,$ 0 %""1% 0#$66(!"#'2!:(=$% !22#/!%"! #"!(0!05 '!!% /#9!% ,,!%5 #% !( ##" ! % 1/1$

)

? %5 :$ !2#"# !5%%5!6!%5!%"!<!"2#,$ 0 0!0$'!!%#%$ (1,!% 2#% (!"9!(#%/ #% ;#" #%/ $1'$ %"!$ (, 0! #%, !$ 0! -#2 (!/(5#%/ :0#"0 "(#,#%2 "$! $ %5$ (!/#$ !(!5 ! 05 0#/02#/0 !5 %1,'!( #((!/12(# #!$ #% 61("0$! % !!% # !,$ ( 0! 6(#$%!($ ! :$ (%$!((!5 5#!(!% 62"!$ !($0( #% !(92$ #,!(, (#5= .%/(1() !(D!61() 2%50( %5 -61( :# 0 ,2#5! #% !% #%$

! # #%!("2#,$ 0 01/00!05,!(# (#1$(!"(5'1 :# 0 ,2#5! #% !% #%0!:$$1$6!%5!5%12< *)

% 0!/(1%5 0 0!05/#9!% $ !,!% #% 0! (!$$#%9#2 #%%51" 12!$ ! # #%!(05#2!5 E

"022!%/#%/ 0!$1$6!%$#%(5!(#%:0#"0% #"! 05'!!%#$$1!5 0!. !(12<)

! # #%!(:$#,62#" !5#% "$! 5 !512<?

)

% 0!22!/ #% 0 0!:$(1%%#%/ %#22#"# 5(1/("=! #%$#5!-#20!6! # #%!(",! =%:'1 0!$#5

(, 0!%!:$# !,#%0!(#'1%!5 !51/1$ )

!"2#,$ 0 0!:$% 6(9#5!5"6< 0! %( 0!$,!:$$!% 0!1( :# 0,2#5!#% !% #%!"2#,$ 0 0! #$,5!61%#$0,!% ( 09#%/,5!% !,6 !;6$!$!%#(#"!($ 0! (#$%!6( ,!% 0!6! # #%!("2#,$ 0 0! #$"1% !('2$ 0!" 0!6! # #%!(

09#%/ 0#/02#/0 !5 0! #((!/12(# #!$ #% 61("0$! % !!% # !,$ (, 1%66(9!5 $ (! ! ( ( (!$( #%/ ! !%5!(#%/ #% 9#2 #% 1%-' % !!% 12!$:0#"005(!$12 !5#%:(%/12/#% (!$6%5!% $ %5 * !$6%5!% *:0#$",62#%% #% 0! #$0#,$!2"#%/#%>1#(< #% :0#"0 6! # #%!( #$ 0! ,#% :# %!$$ ! # #%!( "2#,$ 0 0! 09#%/ "022!%/!5 0! (5!( 0#$ $1$6!%$#% 0#/02#/0 #%/ #((!/12(# #!$ #% 0! E ) 0! 0$ '!!% 2$!2< #%929!5 #% 0! "$! :# 0 ,2#5! #% !% #%$

!$6%5!% * 0$ / '#$!5 #%>1#(< "%51" !5 /#%$ 0! 6! # #%!( 0! #%, !$ =!$0 %5# ) 8=0# 0122() +125!!6 %=) (9#%5!( ,,1) (:%) :0 :!(! 22!/!52< $!22#%/ 5(1/$ 0! #%$ %"! 0! 6! # #%!($ %5$ (%$!((!5 5#!(!% -#2$ 1%-'( 0!2$ %!%5 02<!(.($($0$#%)6!($%:0:$22!/!52< 0(! !%!5'< 0! 6! # #%!( :$ "1/0 %5 (!"9!(< 0(!! :(=#%/ ,'#2!60%!$ :$!!" !5(,0#,0!6! # #%!(05!(2#!(2$'!!%#%929!52$!2< #%"$!

5 !5.!6 !,'!()

A1%5!(.!" #%$) )

2#"!. #%# < !(D!61( 0!'!0!$ (!$6%5!% * ! 0$ 2$ "022!%/!5 0 0! 6($!"1 #% 0$ '!!% 21%"0!5 :# 01 /! #%/$%" #%(, 0!9!(%,!% #$"2#,!5'< 0!6! # #%!( 0 0! 0$'!!%2$!2<#,62#" !5% 0!'$#$9/1!%51%"!( #%22!/ #%$ #"! :$ #$$1!5 0! (!$6%5!% $ !62< :$ #2!5 #% 0! $06!#59# 55# #%2 B (#$%C 0$'!!%"2#,!5 0 % 0!'$#$$!"(! #%(, #%09#%/'!!%(!"!#9!5(,$,!-#2#"#2$ 6$ !5 #% !% (2 #2) 2%50( (!/(5#%/ 1%2:12 " #9# < #% "221$#%

:# 0 1%5!( (#2@ "%9#" $ :0#"0 2$ #%"215!5 $,1//2#%/ %(" #" $1'$ %"!$ #% 0! -#2 %5 (#"=#%/ 0!(! ,%/$ 0! 6(#$%!($) (!$6%5!% )B (#$%C#2)(!>1#(!5 0!..

)+61( 02 9!(#< 0!" #9# #!$ 0!#"#2$#%-#2% 0!(!62<)(!!(!%"!0$'!!%,5! %1,'!(,!,(%51,$#$$1!5 0!6! # #%!(0!, !(:$#%>1#(!5 #% %5# (%$6#(!5 0 !:#"#2$ 0!-#21$!5 $1662<0!(#%(, 1 $#5! 0!-#2"6< 0!(!6( (!$6%5!% *)% 0!'$#$ 0! $ !,!% $ 0!1%5!( (#2$):$$!% .. )+61( 02((!/#$ ( #% %5#%9!$ #/ #% 0!"$!1,'!(5"1,!% $09!'!!%62"!5% (!"(5 $1'$ % # ! 0!22!/ #% 0 0!6! # #%!(05'!!%,#$1$#%/0#$ 1 0(# < '< 61("0$#%/ 0! ( #"2!$ ( 0! -#2 $1662#!5 '< ! ( $ (!$ 0!22!/ #%$,2#5!09!'!!%5!%#!5 0!5! #2!5(!!(!%"! 0!22!/ #%$#% 0!(!62<5!$% 66!( '!%!"!$$(<( 0!5!"#$#% 0!"$!$ 0!22!/ #%/#%$ 0!6! # #%!()$(!2!" !5#% 0!(!6( 1%5!(.!" #% ?BC( 09! '!$!!%#%"% !; 0!6(,! !($2#55:%#% 0!-15/,!% #%

! "

# $# "% &') AA . * % 0! $#5 -15/,!% ) 0!6!;1( 0$0!25 0 0! #%6( #"12("$!"%'! >1$0!5#%"$! 0!, !(22$#%%< 0!22:#%/6(,! !($& C E0!(! 0! 22!/ #%$ ,5! #% 0!

#($ %(, #% !6( ( 0! ",62#% ) !9!% # 0!< (! =!% 0!#("!921!%5""!6 !5#% 0!#(!% #(! <5

% 6(#,"#!"%$ # 1 !%<!%"!(,=!1 "$! /#%$ 0!""1$!5 C E0!(! 0! 22!/ #%$ #% 0! #($ %(, #%

!6( %5 0!( , !(#2$) # %<) "",6%<#%/ 0!

5% 5#$"2$!"/%#D'2!!%"!)-1$ #<#%/% #%9!$ #/ #% '< 62#"! #"!($ 1%5!( .

*B C 0! 5! !;"!6 1%5!( % (5!( /#$ ( ! :# 0#% 0! 61(9#!:.

BC 0!5! ?C E0!(! 0!1%"% (9!( !522!/ #%$,5!#% 0!

(",62#% %5 0!!9#5!%"!"22!" !5#%$166( 0!$,!5% 5#$"2$! 0!",,#$$#%%<!%"! %5,=!1 "$!/#%$ 0!""1$!5 C E0!(!) 0! 22!/ #%$ #% 0! 5 % "%$ # 1 !"/%#D'2!!%"!'1 "%$ # 1 !%2<%% "/%#D'2! !%"!) % #%9!$ #/ #% #$ 6!(,# !5 '< 62#"! #"!( :# 01 % (5!( /#$ ( ! $ "% !,62 !51%5!(.

BC 0!5!

C E0!(! 0! 22!/ #%$ ,5! #% 0! ( ",62#% (!$'$1(5%5#%0!(!% 2<#,6(''2!% 0! '$#$:0#"0%6(15!% 6!($%"%!9!((!"0-1$ "%"21$#% 0 0!(!#$$1#"#!% /(1%5(6("!!5#%/ /#%$ 0!""1$!5

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

BC( %5 $ #$< 0#$1( 0 0! 6(,! ($ 2#5 5:% #% "% &')# "$! B$16(C (! $ #$#!5 :((% #%/>1$0#%/ 0! 0!(!6( 0$'!!%62"!5%(!"(5 1%$!2( 0!6! # #%!(0$5(:% 0! !% #% 0#$1( 0!$ !,!% 8=0'#(.#%/0H81"=<0122((!"(5!

%5 0!($ !,!% $(!"(5!5%1/1$ )

1%5!(.!" #% *( ) :02%/:# 02:#%5!(.#%/0 %/!!2).0'+01$()/ ( (:%) ,,1 %5 0!($ 05 22!/!52< #%512/!5 #% 0! '1$#%!$$ 0!(#% #% 5!(%#2)+61( 02 #$"2#,!5 0 0!<22(!6("1(!5:# %!$$!$

09! /%! 0(1/0 0! $ !,!% 0%5!( 0!!() -1 .#%/0).1=50!9.#%/0H01 ).1=0:#%5!(.#%/0) 9#.0%=().#,(-# .#%/0)$=(%.#%/0+2$#)($01$#%,('#(.#%/0-:%5+1221 0!$#5:# %!$$!$09!22!/!56<,!% ,%!< 0!6! # #%!(( 0! 6!(#551(#%/0#$6$ #%/#%5!(%#2)+61( 02 8!(%!5 "1%$!2 ( 0! 6! # #%!( 0$ $1',# !5 0 0! 6! # #%!(-#%!5#%5!(%#2)+61( 02%<? )

?%5:$/#% (%$!((!5(, 0#$#2% " '!()

? (5!( (%$!(:$$ <!5 %9!,'!()

? ! # #%!(:$/#9!% 0!51 <$!"1(# <1 !( :!($%5,=!!% (<#%5#2<#"!(!6( '=%5 0 0!5#5% !% !( 0!-#2 !(9!,'!( A)

?!"2#,$ 0 %1/1$ )

?)0#$ 51 <:$#;!5 (%# !$ (' #% #"!( #$"2#,!5 0 0! 22!/ #%$ /#%$ 0! 6! # #%!( (! /!%!(2 %5 0! ,$ :125 "%$ # 1 !!; ( #%'1 %!%"!1%5!(.!" #%( ? 0! (!9!% #% ((16 #% " #$ ,5! 1 0$ '!!% 22!/!5 0 0! 22!/ #%$ (! 9/1!%51%"!( #%1%$!2( 0!6! # #%!(0$(!!((!5 %1,'!( "% (5#" #%$#% 0!$ !,!% $ 0!:# %!$$!$,60$#$:$,5!% 0! 6(9#$#%$.!" #% A 0! ." :0#"06(9#5!$61%#$0,!% % ""1% #21(!#"!(%51 <%0#$"%%#9%"! 0!"% (9!% #% 0!6(9#$#%$ 0!" :$(/1!5 0 $%51 <1%5!( ." 0$'!!%#,6$!516% 0!6! # #%!(%5 0!(!#$%(5!(#% 0#$(!/(5)$ $1"0 0!22!/ #% 0 0!:$/#9!% 0!"1$ 5<%<55#" (%< 0!( 6!($%"0(/!5:# 0%!%"!1%5!( 0#$" #$% "((!" #$"2#,!5

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

%#% "%$#5!( #% 0!$ !,!% $9(#1$:# %!$$!$(!"(5!551(#%/ 0!"1($!#%9!$ #/ #% #$6!( #%!% ,!% #%0!(! 0 0!$!(9#"! (!"(5 0! 6! # #%!( '!#%/ /5 ,< "%$ # 1 ! /5 5!!%"! 0! 5! #2!5 62!$ ,2#5! % 0! 6( 6($!"1 #% /!%"< 0$ '!!% 0#/02#/0 !5'< 0!6! # #%!(:0#"0"%2$% '!66(!"# !5 0!#%# #2 $ /!'1 0!$#5, !(#2"%'!1$!5 0! #,!"($$!;,#% #% 0!, !(#2:# %!$$!$ 09!#% !% #%22<9#5!5 0!5! #2!55#$"1$$#%% 0!62!$ 5!!%"!(#$!5'<"1%$!2( 0!6! # #%!(2!$ # $01256(!-15#"!0#, (09#%/5#$"2$!5 0!5!!%"! #%# #2$ /!E0! 0!( 0!"% !% #%$ "1%$!2 ( 0! 6! # #%!( 22 1%5!( %< 0! 6(,! ($ 2#5 5:% ( >1$0#%/ #% "% &')# "$!

B$16(C '1 66(!"# #% !9#5!%"!

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

!$6!"#22< :0!% 0! "0(/!$0!! 0$'!!% #2!5 %5# #$6!% 0! 6! # #%!( $ #$< 0! (#21( % 0!'$#$ 0!, !(#2(,#%/6( 0!(!6( 1%5!(.!" #% ?BC( $!!=5#$"0(/!#%6( #"12( !%"! 1%$!2( 0!6! # #%!($0$"# !522:#%/-15/,!% $& #C (,!2 ,4$. !(<%)

?B?C B(2C

I ##C ++ $0(- 4$ . ! +!(2)

B*C B(2C

*AAI ###C .1,!$04$. !+!(2)

BC+!(8*?

I%5

#9C

#%!$0=1,(H!!%4$. !)

BC I 09!/%! 0(1/0 0!$#5-15/,!% $%5, 0!6#%#% 0 #%6!"12#("#("1,$ %"!$ 0!6(!$!% "$!) 0!'9!$#5-15/,!% $ (!% 662#"'2! 0#$$ /!(>1$0#%/ 0! /(1%5#$,5!1 (>1$0#%/ 0! #$,#$$!5 " '!()

* B.C $%-< E0! 0!($6!=#%/@(!$%!5& !$@ E0! 0!( !6( '2!& !$@