High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3731/1997dismissed

Beant Singh v. Sucha Singh Etc.

2025-11-10Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal13 pages

! "#$%&&'$'( )* "+ "#",#- .

#*$&&'$'(

/ 01 & 2 31 !" #$ % & '( ## )&' *

# # +&'( #

+"),# +&' * -./ 2 31 4 .

0

**&

'!" + , /123.445 * 6 &

& (

" ' (

+ , 242..447* !6 889 &

& *

"

':

+

9 ;.* %+!9&.4.3&

*!*< =

:

"!" 9

** ! + **

..

8 *

"!, , + ,

!

" '& , *, * ( , * "* (

*'

& , * + 8 ,&

" "*

9>

' , + ,

(* &(

* 9 / ? " &

*!*

***& (

!* 9 ,

*

'

,, @*

( <

**: //.442 * ?

9,,

& %+!& # -/.42 *'**-.

/&

&' & *

(

$

&

**> * 17 : 3, * &(,

' (

**

.7/.43;8 *

**> & A

(

5.2.432!B

"

, * *

(

.7./.431 ,

'

*

**> , &

, + "

,! *

(* = &*-./

*

+ ( , , !

&,

* ! "

" * $

> .7/.43;&

**>

9 '

-.3.*.43D&! ,(

"&(( (/4;.433(

!"*

& !

E/1 .

;9%9 "

**>

& ** , *

(

.7./.431& * * A //.442 ;

** *

& A "

** ,

,

*

&(

*

"

' * * '!" C , A,

&,"

'

& ,& 9

" *, *

( *, *

*, ' + ' ,*&

. $

A(

5.2.432& *'*

**GE%% / //.442*?

9,,

%+! , -/.42&

*

(

GE%% 1

** ( * " GE%% ;

** , + " *GE%% 7 , !

*,GE% D !/1& .

;9%9GE% 5 "'

* ** + GE%%

3 $

A(

.7./.431& *'*

***-./GE% 4

* ( ** B

'

* ' ,C * * & !6 889 &

*'*

0

**& !'

<

!"# $

%&%$ & ' (

% %

) %

*

*

= 7.

'!"

&

0 *

!* 6 &

0 , 9>* ) # '* -D&(

(A, "

'!"

9 # ( !' <

( + %

!,

% (

*

"

-

= *, + ,* ?

9&

0

**

C

, & ( "' H ('& "

-./

, * ! ( * ,, * , ' "+ 8 ' *

" A, !, + (

&'

& * !" ! ( !, "'

( , I

"

* *

#* >

*

( I.

"

# -*+ , !*

9 <35 *5 *5

,67 -* .)** "+ *5

#* 8"-

!9#:

; <9*5 *5)* "+ *5 89"

,9*&= *

**!,

&

**

* ?

9,,

&

&' 8& ,

& A ' ,9B "& *, !+, * .2 9' "& * * * ?

9 "& !+,*!

**

& &

" F

25.2.432 (

F

.7./.4318(* !, &,* (&, *

"& ?

9> , ** , &

>

! ,

..

? B ' '

& '

*E/1 .*9%9 '&(

/

*

* *

# # 0 ! %

%

1 2

333 )

* # #

%

%

% #4

#

#*

% )

#*

#*

#

#

#*

#

#"

*

5

# *

#"

4

# *

#4

#

#4 6 #

# * #

*

#"

4

7 ( #

%

#

#4

#4 6 *

8 ./ 8 , *

**

'

* ./27.43D& "*(

JAF;0& ( , ( (/42;.433& '

JAK0/8 * , , 9 (

! *

* ,!+,8

A& ! ;* .&E/1&!

***,

"!B * !+, * , ,<!+,= * 9%9!( !" >!

A9 2)>>)65 )

& & )!)#>)>

&4 $ ?&( 7& 9 *

( /7 9 2

6%!

# #* # *

#"

4

5

% #

#

*

%

%

.

%

#"

4

% )

:

#"

4 :

%!

* )

*

)

;

# #"

4

% (

#

<' =

5

#

% #

< ' = %

% "

5

*

*

*

#

% #

%

% *

<' =

$

*

%

'

*

*

##

* #"

4

#

%

95 $ % '

(* =9 1 $ #*77 )

:

#"

4 :2

69 % !

) %

:

#"

4 :

# % # %

#* , #

% , >&9

%&##

=96' ?@

#

% #

#

#"

8 .1 ,(

!" >!

$+

9 @,79 9#)65)9 @"* -5) & .6)>)> @)#7965)9 )* >4 ' ,7 A ( 29.)>) & ))B)#) <).B4 A #* '& >!

):

9 / # #

2

69 # * %

% )

=

*

% *

# #

%

" %

% %

% *#

#

*

= *

* # .

# .;

8 >!

):

9 <

# #

%

4" %

% %

% *#

=

.7 "* >!

A9 2)>>)65 )

& &

)!)#>)> )#! "*5

,8) (

!" '

*

9 #!

8)> 9#:5 & #!

@),4 %% 1 .D ?, * & '

, <!+,= E/1& .9%9, *

'&

'

,*

*8&<!+,= , **(

**,!

! !

*

.5 A *, ( I!+ ,>*! *

!"

**& "*

*(

,:JAF;08 '

&

**

!+, A *

?

9,, > & *

"

" '

" >!

A 9 )*9#!

9#:5 & 5 *)* "+ )!5B) )!

5 )#! "*5

4 '$' 8 D ",* ,!:.

#*

/7

* %

#

#

7?

)

#*& $A% & $

@?

#

(*#

? #

& $ #

# #

*

) A%

#

$ *

*

*

%

* % *

*

* * #

# * B # % B *

* #

#

%

* *#

+ 9 @ % * *

$ &%<& < $*=

@ @&6@

#

%

* %

)

* *

% % &

% *

% & % #

)

+

&"$%

@ +& ?+ #

%

#* * %

4 A

%

" # %

*:

: *

%

#

#

%

*

*#

#*

% & % #

)

& C %; 1 &7?D.

% "

? ?&D9"

&%& >EF ? & 6+?D ' # % &

' 7 +&+?D9%%$(

@ @&61D$ #'

F # 5% E A) 6&D! ! %& F

&7D "F%< & 6& @8 .5.

, * , ' *" & A "

&"" , ''

"' (

8 &

**(

* "!

F

25.2.432&(

'

"*

F

A *'* * .3 8 '

** "

!

A

F

25.2.432& A (**,"

,&

F

!" * !"**! !"

,E "

* , !" ?

9,,

!

&

&' .4

( " !+,*

*

!"

**&(

( F

25.2.432&(

** , (

&

& & "&

'

"* F

*'* *8 & !+,*!

**> ,

F

*25.2.432 >F

'

*! .4.

**'

"( ( '

/42;.433&'

!"JAK0/& '

*E/1 .

; !9%9 *

** ,!+ , ?

9

"

! ,!+, ( ( 9B "& * , "

"

> *

:, &

"& , &(

+ ,* ?

9!

*

/2 9B * + , &

,

& *"&*

(

* & * '

(* -* ," *

& "

" *

* ,

2 31 $&&'$'( ),) ""* Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No