High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/800/2000disposed of

The State Of Haryana & ANR v. Smt. Janki Devi & ORS

2025-11-28Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

> > > > *( *( *( *(

4A"5 4A"5 4A"5 4A"5

4A"5 4A"5 4A"5 4A"5 (0 )$ (0 )$ (0 )$ (0 )$

B !

! "# "# "# "# ++(,,*) ++(,,*) ++(,,*) ++(,,*)! 45& 45& 45& 45& (!+)-() (!+)-() (!+)-() (!+)-()4!5 5 "$ "$ "$ "$ '(!()$ "'

%&"# %&"# %&"# %&"# " " " " : )*!* )..*'9*) )* (*++(,,*)! -*'!* ).'-/0*(

#*1*,-((+#*2'.-/0*( *'+'(( )3.-/0*( (0'!!8:;(0'!?,*)- )('! @@@@ .4'*,5 .4'*,5 .4'*,5 .4'*,5 #" #" #" #" "6 "6 "6 "6 768

7 '* *9(' 1*-( )(*++, !

1+,(*- )3(*++, 0*)4!5 5*! ,(3*,( '4!5 '

'(!+)-()! *)- 4-(0(*!( (-5 '

' ( '(*!)! 1() )(- ) ( *++, ). ( !*1( ! *,,

(-. !2:;(0*,,;2!

!(<0(+ )!*)-(*++, 0*)4!

!5*!1() )(- )+*'*3'*+ * 7 ( *++, 0* ) *'( '-('(- :( 1+,(* -(- *! ,(3*, ( '4!5 '(!+)- -() ! *)- 4-( (0(*!(-5 ) '-(' +2'!2( ( (+'(!() 0*!(1()-(- 1(1 +*' (! !*=() )'(0'-(3 !'9-()(( (- 2, "* )0*!( "* )0*!( "* )0*!( "* )0*!(

)3 ( +'(!() *++ +(*, 0*,,()3( *! :(() ,* - * -(0 ) -*(-

+*!!(- :9 ( ,( (*')(- -- )*, !'

0 2- -3(. *'

-*:*-80218 ( ('()0(2'

7 '

( ,9 !* )3. B #8 B" , ,*)- )(- :9 ( 0,* 1*) )!? ,*)- )('!.!

2 2*(-

)('(/()2((!*( ,,*3(*-!*+2'.(!

,* !'

0 *'

-*:

:*- 0*1( :( *0C2 '(- / -( ) )

)! -*(- 6 DD6 *

DD6 !!2 2(-2)-('(0 )!64 5*)-E (&*)-0C2 )0. D6. '!'F( 0G5.'(!+(0 /(,9. '0)!'20 H( ('*3('(*1(), ,I 2)-(' *12)** *0 )+,*)(&*)-0C2

),,(0'4 '!'F(& G5 -(* *'--*( (- B

DDB.*!!(!!(-(1* *'=(/*,2( (*0C2 '(-,*)- -J !E . ?8+(' *0'( 6 !!*

( * '(!* - *

*'-. ( '(!+)-()!? ,*)- )('!

,(-'( ('()0(+ +( )/= )3(0 (0. 00*1(:(- !+ !(- :9(,(*')( (-( ('()0(2'/ -(* *'- -*(-

-(('1 1*'=(/*,2(

(*0C2 '(-,*)-J! B ?8+ +('!C9*'-! (! .6 . ?8 +(' *0'(:(!

-(!*,, ('!*2'9:()(

!2)-('( (0 B 33 3'

(/(- ( *'-+*!!(-:9 9(,(*')(-( ('()0(2'. +'(!()*++(*,

*!+'( (''(-*( )!*)0(

'(!+)-()*(. ('(*!0' !!8 :;(0 )! ('(

,(-*( )!*)0( '(!+)-( ()!?,*)- )('! E 1+ +23) )3 ( * '(1() )(- *'-. ,(*')(- 02)!(, *++(,,*)!8*( !2:1 !*(( ('()0(2 2' () ')3*/ )3'(, (-2+ +) ( *'--*( -7 6 DDD1*-(:9(,(*'

')(-( ('()0(2' )'(!+(0 *0C2 , *)- 1*-( ) / ,,*3( *-!*+2 2' ' ( !*1( +2'+!( :2 :

9 * !2:!(C2()*0C2 )/ -()

)-*(-

DDB !!2(-2)-('(0 )6 ( D60 !*,!*'32(-*<8 <8B+'-20(-:9(*( */( ) :(() 0)!

-('(- ( 2! !2:1 ! * ( * *'- +*!!(- :9 ( ,(*') )(- ( ('()0(2'

' *!, *:,(:(!(*!

-(:9 '(!'

)3(* *'-+*!!(-:9 &

) ( (' *)-. ,(*')(- () ' 02)!(, *++(*'

)3 ) :(*,

'(!+)-()!?,*) )- )('!?0'!!8:;(0'!!2:1 !*(,(*')(-( ('()0( 2'

() ')3

,( - !0*'- )3 ( !*,( )!*) )0(! <!7 *)- 6. (*0 -* *(-

B DD / -( ( 0*'(*1(*!2'

B!C9* *'-!*)- 7B!C9*'-!.'(!+(0 /( (,9.

*,, )('(/ /()2((!*( ,,*3(*, *,

('(!,-*('*( !7E ?8 +(' !C9*'-!(!2 2:1 !*('(/()2((!*(

,,*3(*, *, *:2!*)-*-; )!

,,*3( *-!* +2'. 2! ( !*,( )!*)0(! < <!7 *)- 6 ('( '(C2 '(- :( *=() ) *00 2) :9 *++,9 )3 *++'+'

*( -(-20 ) ('(2+) *'-! !1*,,)(!! ,*) )-+*'0(, )/,/(-('( )&(*') )(-() '2)!(,*,!(1+*!

K(! *'(,9 )32+ )!*,( )!*)0(!<!7*)-6 6.('(!+)-()!?,*)- )('!

('( *,!() ,(- '

'*++'(0 '( 1(3*+ :( (()(-*( !*,( )!*) )0(! *)-(-*( ) )

(0 )(0*!( )*)-*)- 2! (1*'=(/*,2( ( *!'(C2 '(-:(()*)0(-*0 00'- )3,9 */( (*'- ,(*')(- 02)!(, ( +*' (! *)- 3)( '23 +*+('8:=*!

(,,*!'(0'-! (0*!( D + +('2!*, ( '(0'- ! ! * * <8 8B +'-20(- :9 *( *'( *,, + ! )

) *)-. 2! 0*)) :( *=() ) 0)!

-('* ) ( ,(*')(- ( ('() )0( 2' ,( 1*= )3 ( '(8 8-(('1 )* 1*'=( /*,2( J ! B ?8 +(' !C C 9*'-!. '(, (- 2+) ( +'(/ 2! ( ('()0( 2' *'- -* *(- 7 6 DDD'(,* (-/ ,,*3(*-!*+2'(, (*')(-( ('()0(2'02,- */( !* (,9+,*0(-'( (, *)0(2+)(!*,((<(1+,*'!

!<7A<6-*(-

B DD (*0.23+( '* )3('(/()2((!*(

,,*3(*, *, (!+(0 *,,9 (

! ) - !+2(- :9 ( ,(*')(- *( 02)!(, * ( '(/()2( (!*( ,, *3( *-!*+2'*)- - ,,*3(*, *, *'(*:2 )3* *)-*-; )3:( )3!

2*(- !*1( / 9 * *)- ( !* - *0 *! (/() :(( () (!*:, !(- ) '(0'- '1

-(+!

*, + #21*'. *,C* * *'

,,*3(! L*K '+2' *)- *, *, ( -(* ,! (

* '(1() )(-!*,(-((-!*'( ((<'*0(-('(2)-('$8 <! <! <! <! *( *( *( *( *,*'(* *,*'(* *,*'(* *,*'(* *, *, *, *, 0)!

-('* 0)!

-('* -! !7E ?8 !B6 ?8 '-! !7E ?8 !6E ?8 '

0( +(' !C '

0( +(' !C 9*'- 9*'- 9*'- 9*'- !*,( !*,( !*,( !*,( ) ) ) 7

B DD B!C9*'- 6

B DD 7B!C9*'

!2++'.'(, *)0(0*):(+,*0(- 2+)*-(0 )-*(- B

+*!!(- ) ++(*, 6EE DD. , ,(- *! H"?! (, ,) K('! H"?! (, ,) K('! H"?! (, ,) K('! H"?! (, ,) K('! ! ! ! ! ) )- *I ) )- *I ) )- *I ) )- *I I. ('( )()G:,(+(< 2' ()),-*(!

!*,( -((-! ' * *'- -! '(,* )3 *-; )3 / ,,*3(!

! 02,- :( '(, (- 2+) *! '(,(/ /*) + (0( (/ -()0 0( '(+2'+!( -(('1 )*

1*'=(/*,2( )0*!((!

!*,( (<(1+,*'! ( (0)0(')(-/ ,,*3(! ('()*/ /* ,*:,(

'('1'(.0)!

-('

)3( *0 *(!*,( )!*)0(!<!7* 6*'(-*(-

B DD M ('(*!)

2)-('(0 (0 0*!( )*)- * *! !!2(-) 6 DD6M( 1(3*+:( (()(!*,((<(1+ +,*' *)-()

0* (0 !69(*'!.*)*++'(0 )J N +('*))21.2!

!)((-!:(3'*)(- */2' ,*)- )('!)(!*,(+'

0( ( <!7A6 (/('.*= )*002)( (!1*,,)(!! (*'(* )/,/(- - ( !*,( (<(1+ +,*' <!7 A 6. 0 !

B !C 9*'-! *)- 7B !C 9*'

'-!. '(!+(0 /(,9*)- -(,*)-2)-('*0C2 ):( )3*'2)- =*)*,!.*)*++'+'

*( 02 B N)((- -!:(*++, (- *'-!(!1*, ,,)(!! *'(* (!*,((<(1+,* *'!

(/('. )(0*!( )*)-.!

)0 0((*0C2 ! '(+2'+ +!( 0)!'20 ( ('*3('(*1(),*)2 2)-(' *12)*0 ),*)*)-

*(2!.- -) )!2

('*)9,!! *'-!+ 1212 K* *'(**0C2 '(- -' - -)!2

('*) )9(<+()!(! '+'/ - )3*-- )*, '*!'202'*,*1() (!, =( '*-!. +*'=!. 3'

'(() :(,! ' 0112) 9 :2 ,-

)3! (0 ) 02 ! '(C2 '(- :(

1+!(- *'- -!-(/(,+1()0!

)/ ( ('(*!) )3'(0'-(- -('( )*:/(.(1*'=(/*,2( ( (*0C2 '(-,*) )-*!)(-*( )

) )2)-('(0 (0 0*!( )*)-:9 9*= )*002)(!*,((< <(1+,*'!<!7*)-6*)-2+ +) *++'(0 N+('*))21 '( 1(3*+:

:( (()(-*( !*,( )!*)0( ( (-*( !!2* *)0( )

(0*)-* ('*++,9 02 B N.(1 1*'=(/*,2(01(!! E +('!C2*'(9*'-

7 ) )!(C2(),9. ( *++(*,

,(- :

:9 ( *++(,,*)!8*( ! ('( (:9 - !1 !!(-M ('

'(*!(0'!!8:;(0 )!+'( (''

'(-*( )!*)0( '(!+)-() )!? ,*)- )('!*'( ('(:9+*',9*,, (-

6 () )- )31 !0*++, )4!5. *)9 9.!*,,*,!!*)-- !+!(- #"5 #"5 #"5 #"5 /(1:('

/(1:('

....

= 4 4 4 4

B L L (('!+(*= )3?'(*!)(-

((''(+'*:,(

!? !?