Munish Parbhakar v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- - .,*+/ #01/#2#0 ------ %$*$*&,%0 3%0+.+ 4$#$% &$/%0+ ------
%+6&,(%,$+
7 8 -
4 4
0%+%,$ 09#0#,5&$ 4*,:/
/*22#;
(<&)#$%
6%$*$*&,%0-
+- #060*=# 9/#,%2#;
(<&)#$%
0- #<,%%$ 4*,:/;
4%,*&0 ! &- -
- - 4 ;
-
8 - 0#=%0 *,+$#,$ )*<*> ?0*$ 6%$*$*&, '*>%( .,(%0 0$*)>%+ @ &,+$*$.$*&, ,(*# *++.#,)% ?0*$ ,#$.0% A#,(#A.+ (*0%)$*,:
&- 0%A&<% +&>*( ?#+$% )&>>%)$%( '0&A ?#+$% :%,%0#$&0+;
1%*,:
(.A6%( #$ >&)#$*&,
>( &+$
''*)%
&#(;
#0( &- ;
/#:?#0#- -
'.0$/%0 60#=%0 /#+ 1%%, A#(% (*0%)$*,:
&- (.A6 )&>>%)$%( '0&A <#0*&.+ ?#+$% :%,%0#$&0+ #$ 60&6%0 :0&.,(+;
+*$.#$%( 2*>&A%$%0+ #?#= '0&A )*$= (*0%)$%( $/*+ &.0$;
<*(% &0(%0+ - - - - 6#++%( -
-
+- #060*=# 9/#,%2#;
(<&)#$% #>&,:?*$/ 0- #<,%%$ 4*,:/;
4%,*&0 ! #66%#0 1%/#>'
0%+6&,(%,$ &-
/#,(%( &<%0 )&6= &''*)% - - ;
*++.%( &>>.$*&, &,$0&> �( #((0%++%( &AA*++*&,%0;
!*+$0*)$ 9#6.0$/#>#;
&.0$ $&(#= *$+%>';
0%)&0( +.15%)$ #>> 5.+$ %B)%6$*&,+ )&6= $/%0%&'
/#+ 1%%, /#,(%( &<%0 6%$*$*&,%0-
0%>%<#,$ %B$0#)$+ 0%#( .,(%0
!
"
# $ %
&'
( )
*
# $ %
&+
( '
,
-
", !
( .
/
!
! (
# $
! !"
/ !
(
"
,
-
12%32 123#2 12452 (
" ! "
# $
1)& +
"
(
+
/%
5 6 ( / 7% !
1(+&
0 "(
" ,
# $ 1)& +
&
(
! :")&)0(7
!
!
2
;
<9+( <
2
2
1
= ) :
"
!"
,
&'
(> - /*>% 0%'%00*,:
>%$$%0;
+ #66%#0*,:
1%/#>'
0%+6&,(%,$ &- +.1A*$ ,%)%++#0= 0%:#0(+ 0%A&<#> '0&A >&)#$*&, C.%+$*&, *-%- #$
>( &+$
''*)%
&#(;
#0( &- ;
!*+$0*)$ 9#6.0$/#># &$/%0 >&)#$*&,+ ?*$/*, <*)*,*$= #>0%#(= +$#,(+ *++.%(-
- 0-
-9- .0&0#;
(<&)#$%;
#66%#0+ '*>%+ 3#2#>#$,#A# 1%/#>'
0%+6&,(%,$ &-
!*+$0*)$ 9#6.0$/#># &.0$ $&(#= *$+%>';
0%)&0( +.15%)$ #>> 5.+$ %B)%6$*&,+- 8%#0,%( +.1A*$+ ?*$/*, <*)*,*$= $/%0% '*<% )&>>%)$*&, )%,$0%+ &,% +*$%;
+$#$%(
1% >&)#$%( 2*>&A%$%0+ #?#= '0&A )*$=-
$ +$#$%( ,&?;
+/&?, ,,%B.0% /&$&+;
+$#,(+
)>%#0%(-
$ '.0$/%0 +.1A*$$%( +/#>> #1*(% *++.%( &>>.$*&, &,$0&> �(- - &,+*(%0*,:
+$#,( &>>.$*&, &,$0&> �(
4$#$% #>+& +$#$%A%,$ A#(% 0%60%+%,$*,:
/#:?#0#D #A )&,+*(%0%( <*%?
:0*%<#,)% + 0#*+%( 6%$*$*&,%0 #((0%++%( +&A% %B$%,$- ))&0(*,:>= *,+$#,$ ?0*$ 6%$*$*&, (*+6&+%( ?*$/ '&>>&?*,:
(*0%)$*&,+
* +/#>> %,+.0% )&A6>*#,)% )&,$#*,%( - - *++.%( &>>.$*&, &,$0&> �( *$+ $0.% +6*0*$D
** +/&.>( *,*$*#$% )&A60%/%,+*<% 6.1>*) %(.)#$*&, )#A6#*:,+ 0#*+% #?#0%,%++ #1&.$ %,<*0&,A%,$#> /%#>$/ *A6#)$+ *>>%:#> (.A6*,:- )#A6#*:, A#= *,)>.(% #,,&.,)%A%,$+ $/0&.:/ >&)#> 0#(*&
%>%<*+*&,D &.$0%#)/ <*# +&)*#> A%(*# 6>#$'&0A+ *,'&0A )*$*E%,+ #1&.$ 60&6%0 ?#+$% (*+6&+#> A%$/&(+;
/#0A+ *>>%:#> #<#*>#1>% '#)*>*$*%+ )&>>%)$*&, 0%)=)>*,:- (.)#$*&,#> ?&02+/&6+ +)/&&>+ 0%+*(%,$*#> )&>&,*%+ 1% %,)&.0#:%(D
*** +/&.>( (%6>&= +.0<%*>>#,)% A%#+.0%+D #+;
)>%#0 +*:,#:% 60&/*1*$*,:
3 )#A%0#+ A#= 1% *,+$#>>%( 2,&?, F(.A6*,:
/&$+6&$+G (%$%0 >&*$%0*,:
*>>%:#> #)$*<*$*%+D
*< A#= )&,+*(%0 %+$#1>*+/*,:
0%:.>#0 6#$0&>>*,:
0%6&0$*,:
A%)/#,*+A+
A&,*$&0 )&A6>*#,)% *++.*,:
?#0,*,:+ '*0+$ &''%,(%0+D
< A#= )&,+*(%0 %+$#1>*+/*,:
%,'&0)*,:
+$0.)$.0%( 6%,#>$= +=+$%A 0%6%#$%( <*&>#$*&,+;
A#= *,)>.(% '*,%+;
)&AA.,*$= +%0<*)% &0 #660&60*#$% >%:#> #)$*&, *>>%:#> )#, +%0<% (%$%00%,$D
<* %'&0% *A6>%A%,$*,:
+$0.)$.0%( 6%,#>$= +=+$%A;
+/#>> %,+.0% +=+$%A ?%>> 6.1>*)*E%(- - +/#>> %,+.0% )&A6>*#,)% *$+ $0.% +6*0*$-
@- %,(*,:
#66>*)#$*&,+ +;
*'
#,=;
+/#>> #>+& +$#,( )>&+%(-
4
!
- -
+52+ /%$/%0 +6%#2*,:
0%#+&,%(
"%+
& /%$/%0 0%6&0$#1>% "%+
&