← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1582/2026dismissed

Hari Kishan Since Deceased Through Lrs And ORS. v. Jaswant And ORS.

2026-05-15Mr. Justice Yashvir Singh Rathor13 pages



 



  !   "#$%&'$()*)%+,- - 

-

.

/

  ----00$11"+#* 2$3*4* 5  ---$*0%+'$+#* -

  .

/

  ----00$11"+#* 2$3*4* 5  ---$*0%+'$+#*   ,  6 /- !2  

   

   

 

!"*78)3)+97"#7%3:-

3"1   ! 

 "  #

      

;     <  

$   

  % && '  ()) 

 !  !    

 *  $  +  ,

-    

  

#  !    

 *  $  + ,  "



     



   

&

 



'* ./&&0&1" !    !   (0 0 &0&1 "$ 

 2    3!   #   

   "$   

4      "         

 "$  

 4     "        !  "$   )  ( 0/ &0/"    #   

    $  "$ 

 "  #

     "$   "   5 $  

"$ 



     !" 

$

" 

&

'* .61&0&1" !    !   (0 0 &0&1 "$ 

 2    3!   # 

 "$ 

4  "   !  "$   )  ( 0/ &0/"    #   

    $  "$ 

 "    

"$ 



      !

" 

$

" 

(

  

    $7  8  * 9./+ & ,   : $ #

 ! # 8 "$  '

2      !    '5 " # $

!

$       $ !    

      

  !   "   01 0& &09 ) ) 

3! +3 2  ,        $#"$  

(

  " !   $#  

   8

       $ ;   "         #              $             !(65<  ((05<

= 

(& 1> ? 

11 (>* 

1/ 1> 

9@ (> A$#$   

! 

      !

@

2    #         

 

  



$ !   "

$)    "%;;' &)) %  "      

 8  * 9./ :$   %  '   ! " 

   ! 

    ' 8   

   * 9./ #    #     8 "$7  

# #   #     8

"$  '  !

$7 5   '             '>

   

!! 

 !    '   ;  #$  '    :  != 

(& 1>? 

11 (> *  

  1/ 1>    

  9@ (>           "$#

   8 #  8    #      "$'    

  !#     *  A #

!  (0 0.

66/#    8# !

   *          

@

# (0 0.

66/ ;   "   :$  #   !#  #       #

       !   !   0& &09 "$ ) ) 

3!+3 2  ,    

 $ 8

 #!!   #    "

 !   !   

"

 "  

.

- 

 !  

# ! # 0( 0/ &09    

         

   

      

   

       

    

              



  

      

       

    

!      

    

"          

  

  #



$ %

& ''

(

             

 

) ) #

   

        

   *  

  

      

 &

  

   B ?   ) 8      '  '  

    * 3#   !     

   # "B?& 2A  #

.

B ?( $    =B  =B 6 =B ?(4 =B ?(4;

%   B 7 !2 $ 2 2? 2 *  8    

  # "B 2?& B  $#2?('2?@

$   =B 2 =B 2(

/

  !  ! ! !   



  )     :$ #   #    "

  $

4  8

         !          "$   

    #

    

"$  #  

-

!!! 

 

 #

  

  "      %  @  '   &&  ))      - 

 )   !  ! ! !      

     !  "$   )  

##  #

"  

 "$ #   #        " ! $   -

!!!    

 "



0

C        

   !      ! !  "    

 !

  

 "

         #     !   C  !   

 $ !      "

  ## "%;;' &))#

"$   

   

1

C B     0  "C ' //9



 $ ! 

"  

  ) 

) C $   

  "  ! "  



    !          

   ;        

   

  



"

 "       

&

      !  "$ -  

  ) #"$  !  "$   ) "      + ,    )  *      ) 

      *  

  -  ,+".) 

           

    -  ,+".)   

    /

 0         )  *  

     

  )   

 *   

  * *   (



 ,   *       )    

   

1      - 



   -  ,+".     2

   ( 

   3

    -  

 

    -  ,+".     2

     ) )   

  (

              4  %

)   3

)  0     55"66. 789: (       

       

    -  ,+".) *         * 

    ;     #   -  ,+".

 

           <

 789": ;) 

     *    

9

 

   ;               

    6 =    

   -  ,+".) * )       

  )        

 =    ;       

        6 =   

) 

  

*   > 8 

 $1) 

 $$

1) ,

 $.$1)  <

 +! 1 <)

   

  )                   9   . ;    )   ) 

       

   -

           

 ?*)   

  )

       

*   

      (    ) 

 

       

    

) *                -

      ;   

 *              ) *    



 9

      

   %

 

       ?1  ?

 @ 

      !  "    #$   % &#'(  #)  

*

#( +) *   ?1  ?

 @

  

*       



>   (



   *      

  

 4 A 4    )  



    % 4   *  

              < )



     

* *  

   )  

       * 

*   @    



 

   % 4 ;)  

    4 A)          

)     

/

! ( 

    )   

 *     

   

 <

)     

        

)

 

     

       ) *     

*      

          )  )    A

-         

# #    

)       

      

  

   

     ) *     

       

  )    



   

 

  9         7  

:     ) *          

   " BBB $ (



          

)  *       



  

  

  C  )   

   

    

-

   

*   

  



     *  

   

 + ;  @)    ,, --    $

.&/010(2 03

       

 

*  

    

    

       



   )           ) 

 *



    )    

 * 

      

      ( *        



 # )           

) *



     = 

  ( *         

    

    ) *     

     %

6

    

 

  4 $ $ #5#- 6" +728 6 <) *   

)       

*        

   



5 D                              

E  )  9   *      # #

    ) 

 3

 %

)  



 

 

    3

 %

       

  ?*)                 )       *    

  

 4  

 

   *    )  

  

     -

     66+ ?*)       0 (       9

       

   3)         

  

  (      

     )     

      

*

   "6 =     9

    

  ) 

 =    4  )     

    

  



 D         9       

  

  

      (( %   @@    

    )      

   

 

   *  *

 ?  

    

  ) 

 



 

  

 789 :) *  *   =  *  * 

-     789 5:)   @ 

 *  *

  

   789 6: ( 

    

 )   

 

          #$   9   #$ ::2;(<- $  = 9$;$ 

" "

."

$ "

   :2( 5( +<

0

9  $ #*

&, #::: 5 ( ?*)   @     *   

  ;

   

  

 *

     ) *         

 - 

     0          

     )

 )                 

       (( %   @@ 3   

 * * 

 

  

   

        



 =          ;   

           

         ) ) 

     

 D                 

   #    

)   2

      



     ( 

     ) 

   

   >" , ;,  , ::';:3 .#  

#$  

  3(+: ;  @

 

    

  (    )  * 

  !5.5+)      

   #     

 *  

 (     ) *         

         

   F

   

  *

      *   ( %   @@ 8 * )  2

  )  )     

 

  

 

  

      

 

  2

   ;)             #  

 

 @= )     

  

 ;   

                     



 D           

*  <  5     % 4) ..+)   -

 *     

 )  



             <     4 ;  

      ;   

  

 -

)      -

  

 -



*   *   @

@

  *   % @ ?)    

  



! ,      

    @

" ( *   

   )   @      *   

   

   

     -

 ;

 

 

             9  

    -  ,+".) *       

         9     

   @= )  ,  !

       



 

   & (

"$  

 ) #

 !   !#

 !  "$  ) #

   ) #!

$     $ !  "

!       !   ) #   $      #     $  !       "    



  $    !      ((& 5<  $  $   (65<



 $   .65$ "$  

2        

      $        "

    

   

    !

  B            #    4 !       $!   !

 "    !B    !    

&

  C-  

 )   ! $        #  B !.65$ 

@



 

"$ 

#

 

      !   !  "   !  01 0& &09 ) 

3!+3 2  ,   "      " !   $#  

  $ 

       #     " "%;;' &))   

   "   "    

 #  

     #

    "  

      !

C 8#  :$ #  

          "   

    4   :$ #   

   C-  

  )  ! $"   :$         $   $  $ #"   "   $    

.

    "$     0 "

C' //9"

#       

:$ 

 " $"   

      $   $: 

8  #    $"  # 

$ #    $" "

(

 $"$ ) 

)  "$ ')       " ! $

"$ -  

 )

1

*    "!"  )

9

    ;  

      

   ! !   $ 

!

$ ! $   

/   !  

  $

   

6

   $  "

 

   

  !2    - - 

 $88 ?  8 !4 <4* ? '  "

 <4*