High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/946/2000disposed of

Sadhu Singh v. Pb.State

2026-01-28Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

&'( &'( &'( &'(

( -5 '8""#. '8""#. '8""#. '8""#.C@ @

C@ @

! "#$

! % % % %

&'(!#) *

&'(!#) 22'+ 22'+ 22'+ 22'+ ++ #& ++ #& ++ #& ++ #&45 45 45 45 '2# '2# '2# '2# #'#& #'#& #'#& #'#&45

#, 22'+ 22'+ 22'+ 22'+

(@@@4 (@@@4 (@@@4 (@@@4 -5 "+* $ "+* $ "+* $ "+* $

% % % %

&'(!#) *

&'(!#) ++ #&45 ++ #&45 ++ #&45 ++ #&45 '2# '2# '2# '2# #'#& #'#& #'#& #'#&45 -. -. -. -. ,''#&. -, (, /0- 1 /0- 1 /0- 1 /0- 1 - - - - "&" 1 ! +3=8 &' #&45 -, !#) #-' & 3+3!# #) * DDDD 34, +5 34, +5 34, +5 34, +5 1 - 1 - 1 - 1 - 7 %"

' & " 899# ,',3 *& & (,'9'#&"#' '$!+ , ",& 22'

+ ,' * *'"#$ '8"' & ' 9'

=' ,"'# !& ( 899 9#

8:!""&"#;<

,"#=+="#$"'#&"8 +( 8& :!'&"#(+ <,& ' ?'

'( *,'="&>3( 8& ,'

'*'"#$& ?'#(,9

(@@@ 67 > >(2,''#& +38 ++'#$ $' *''#+ "&

@ @A@@@2 '*>& '+'

,#'"&"# +"

"&,"8&!$'3!2# ,4 ','"#

(&', &*','(',,' B'(','#8'!,&5 6A7 ,"

"'(+>& &"#$3& '+ #<#'*> >& ' #&3"&!

&'<"& "# ,'='#!''& &' (="++ $'1!9*, 3' "+1 ,3"&,"8&2 ,4#<"&,"8&

, 4- +"5 5 8 9' & *' 8:!",' ="' &"("8 &"# A@A

@ @

!'!#', '8&"# (& '

'0 #8:!""&"#8&3 4 4(,

,&& 'E 8&F5,'2'8&"='+>(,2!*+"82!

!,2'3# 9'+> &"# +#&"&!&'

'( ,9 8'!&"8 + !8 # ''

,8 ' # 8:!""&"# ++'8&, = ="' < &' @ @ @A 3 ,' !9 ( 3 3@

;I # 88!#& 892'# &"# & < , ##I(,!"& *'

,"#$ &,'' # A3A3H;I &< , ( ,"#$&,'''G"

"&"#$=',& ' 8:!",'+ # 7 $$ $,"'=' & ','(3 & ' #&4 5I+ #<#',45 "#=?' ,'(','

#8' !#', '8&"#

C ( & ' 8&3 ''?"#$ '# #8'9'#& ( 892'# &"# ' +'

,#' '(','# #8' !,& ="' & ' "92!$#' < &' @ @A@@@ ' 892'# &"#& & '&!#'( 3AH@;I"#( =!,( #&I

A3H@;I"#( ( =!,( #&I"+* $ "#$ $ # 88!#&( '9'#&9

"#& & ' (,!"& & *'

,"#$ &,'' # ##I(,!"& *'

,"#$ &,'' "I &"("' <"& '8""#(& '+ +'

,#''(','#8'!,&3& '2, ,''#& +<','2,'(',,' "#& #8'(+ # <#', 6H7 92 2!$#"#$ & ' (,'9'#&"#'

,3 +'

,#' 8!#'+ (,

#& ,'+"' !2# '8""# &'

@ @A 2 ' *> & " !,& "# 8 ' ,"#$

A( C&"&+'E ,"=& "#$ = ' &'(!#)

& ',F&!*9"

"&& &#8'& ''= &"#(89 92'# &"#*>& ''(','#8' !,& * ' # ( (,9!+ CH 2,'2 ,' *> , "))',3 ",'8 8&, ,&"8!+&!,' '

'2 ,&9'#&3 =',#9'#& ( !# #) *3 #"$ , 3 # "#8,'

"# 8## #8'<"& & ' "?'"#2,"8'"#'G<'(& &'((,9!+ "'

CH &"++& ' &'(# #&"("8 &"#!#', '8&"# ( ( 8&"#& '2,''#&8 '< ,':!",'&*'$, #&'"#( =!,(& ' #& ;+ #<#',

7 # & '& ', #3+'

,#' &'8 !#'+!*9"&& <'++I,'

# #'

# )!&"("' < *''# 2 ' *> & ' +'

,#' '(','#8' !,& !2 2#

&"#( & '2+'

"#$ #& ''="'#8'

"+ *+'#,'8,< "8 3& !

!"& ++ (, # "#& &',(','#8' #3 & ','(,'3 ' 2, > (, "9" + ( & '

+45 2,'(',,' && '"

"#& #8'(& ' #&;+ #< <#', 67

=' '

, +'

,#' 8!#'+ (, & ' 2 ,&"' # $#' & ,!$ 2',*?("# #!*& #8'"#& '!*9""#9 '#*'

+((& ' #& 6C7 # & ' 2,''#& 8 '3 8:!""&"# 2 2,8''"#$ <',' 8 ,,"' !& = ="' #&"("8 &'

' A@A

"!'!#', '8& (& ' 8&< ','

892'# &"#:

& '(,!"&*'

,"#$&,''< !

!#"2!&'+> ''*>& '0

8:!""&"#+ ++'8&,="'"& &'@ @ @A #& '* "(& '(,9 9!+

CH 2,'2 ,' *> , "))'

',3 & ' & '# ",'8&, ,&"8!+& &!,' '2 ,&9'#&3 =',#9'#& ( !#) *3 #"

"$ , # !8 8",8!9& #8'3

"#8,'

'"#2,2 ,&"# &'&& ' "?'"#2,"8'"# 'G(,9 CH&

< ,':!"

",' &*' ,'"# #( =!,(& ' #&;+ #< <#', ' (,'9'#&"#'(,9 9!+ ("#8,'

'* '

'#& ' &"#(2,"8'"# 'G3$"='#"#( =!,(+ #<# #', '='# 22, ='*>& "!,&="''8""# &'@@C@ 2 '"# A C(

A C(

"#8 '(B1 ,& B1 ,& B1 ,& B1 ,& 1 ,# "+ "#$ #( ,"1'

1 ,# "+ "#$ #( ,"1'

1' ' 1' '

"#$ # (

," 1' "#$ !88', "#

," 1' "#$ !88', "# # "#&','& ( + &' ," 1' ,3 * # "#&','& ( + &' ," 1' ,3 * # "#&','& ( + &' ," 1' ,3 * # "#&','& ( + &' ," 1' ,3 * *& *& *& *& ,'"'#& ( %"

,'"'#& ( %"

%"++ %"++ %"++ %"++ $' , #3 ' "+ ' , #3 ' "+ ' , #3 ' "+ ' , #3 ' "+ #?& % !#) &' & ,!

#?& % !#) &' & ,!

!$ !$ !$ !$ ++'8&,!,

++'8&,!,

2!, #& ',J

2!, #& ',J'+'= #&2

& ','(",'2,!8' ','!#', ,.I B +"(,'# #8'9'#&( ( 892'# &"#(,= +!'(& '&, ,'' < "

"8 <','+&&& '<#',*>& '

8:!""&"#(+ # '$,"'=

#8' 'G2 2,''"& && ''(','#8'!

!,& 88'2&'& '= &"#( ( & '

&,''

'9 2',& '(,9!+ 8 ++'

/,")) ,/(,9!+ /(, ' "#$ ' &,'' (, & ' >'

CH ' +'

,#' 8!#'+ (, & '

#& <!

!+ ,$!'& &"#!#) ++ + #!&,"' #G2,&,2, 0"9 9"&' %',! K "+ "#$ "# @ ( @@3 '8"' # C@ @ @ @3 & " !,& ( 8&, ,' & ' "#8,'

' (, '9'#& & ( +!'(&,''(,& '!*':!'#&> >'

,*>& ?"#$#&'(& '"#8,'

' "#2 2,"8'"#'G#& "8 '3& '+'

,#'8!#'+ ,$!'& "

"#& ' = &"#9 2',,")) )) ,/(,9!+ (& '>'

CH3 2,"8 8' "#'G $#' (,9 2 2"#& & H@ 2"#& "# C "3

8,"#$ & "93 <!+ 9'

# "#8,'

' ( AL =', & ' 2, 2,"8'

''*>& ' &"#(, ")) ,/(,9!+ 2&& '= #<!+ +2,="'(,AL"#8,'

'# &"#9 2',& ' &" #(,")) ,/(,9!+ MMJ J 6 7 "

"!,&3'='#"#8 '(#"# #"# #"# #"# (#"

#& ',=',!,"& (#"

#& ',=',!,"& "& 9 "& 9 "& 9 "& 9

"#$ 3@@ 5

"#$ 3@@ 5 4"="+5H 4"="+5H 4"="+5H 4"="+5H3!#',"9"+ ,(

8& #8",8!9& #8'3!2 '+ "#8,'

' * ' # "((','#8' ( & ' < +' +'

' 2,"8' "#'G # & ' 2,''#& (

8&3 !#"2!&'+>3*'

'&<''# CHI

3& ',' *'

'# 22,2,"

&'"#8,'

'"#& '2, ,"8' "#'G < "8

$#' (,9 2"#& & @C 2"#&3 & ','*> 9 ?"#$

"#8,'

'( ,!

!#C@L=',& '2,"8' ''

*>,"))',"#"&(,9!+

CH 6 @7 2 # &"#(& '2+'

"#$ #'="'#8' "+ *+'#,'8 ,3 #&;+

#<#', ,' '+ '#&"&+' (, , ( 892'# &"# :!

( ,"#$ &,'' <'++ ##I(,!"& *'

,"#$ &,''

' < "+' & ?"#$ "#& 88!#& & '", #!9*',(,9& & ','8,2,'2 ,'*>& ','2 2#'#& #& ' '9'#&& *' +!'"#&',9 (,")) ,/(,9!+ 88, ,"#$+>3& '"92!$#'

@ @A@@@32 '*>& ''(','#8'!,&" 9"("' #*& & ' +

++<'&& ''

G&'#&& &* '#& ' &"#(2,"8'"#'G*'&<''# CH H&

3& ' + #&I+ #<#', ++*''#&"&+'

'(,"#8,'

'(OC@L=',

*='& ' 9!

!#& ''*>& '0 #8:!""

"&"#++'8&,="'"&

@ @A &<

,892'# &"#(,& '(,!"& &*'

,"#$&,'' <'++ ##I( ,"#$ &,'' * *'"' ++ & ', & &!&,> *'

'#'("& # "#&','& 2,="'

9""*+'!#'

',& ' 8&

7 '# #"#$ &"#453"( #> ++

+& #"2'( 1 -5 1 -5 1 -5 1 -5 #!

,> #!

,>C C C C3@ 3@ 3@ 3@ &"? 4 4 4 4

N N '& ',2'

?"#$;,'

' '& ',,'2,& *+'

' ; ;