Manvir Singh v. Ut Chandigarh And Others
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND
HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
! "#
$ % &
' () # " # #
* +
,-./01 !
2&!'31 +-3!,+ /+'+
+-3!,+ /+'+)
!
" "# $$% & '
( # !% !) $)$* +, !- "# ! ."# '
# )/ )0 !11! +, $- "# 2 3 " " 4
'
# . '
' "# ' ' #
#
$
"' " #
'' "
5 *0%+$-+ - *%% *%6 70* 6)% & 3 '
$0 )!
$))1 8 ' $/ )!
$))1 9&: 6$! $/ )1 $))/ 5 *%* *%% *0%+$-+ - *$* 70* & 5 5 !0 " ''
'' "
5 *0%+$-+ - & . .
'
. ' #
. " ' "# ; 3 ' $$ )0 $)!*
*
< ' # )0 !$ $)$$
!) # !! ' )/ # ' , !6 # )0 ' !* # 4 .
# # "# 2 3 " )/ )0 !11!
"
# +, $- " , " '
# . '
" '' "# $ * 4. ! '
' "
5 = .
" 3 # '
"# & . ' ! .
.
# "# "#
5 =
8' #
4
& "# = >
5 = . (
. "# 4?"
5'
! " #
' "# ' 3 # "
"' "# = . # ' '
&
"' ' .
= '' '
"# $ * "3 '
" "# '
( ' "
#
.
#
'
3 ' 4?"
5' $ % $& % $' ( %"))' * )*'
"+%' ,-
")*."//')*'"))' ))0 '*
" %!, ,
"
"' " '' ' '
# " ' &
"'
' ( '
'
.
' # 5 2'
. " 10 2,
" . .
)$ )% $)$* "#
( . ' '
'' 4. '
# ( '
.
'
'
%
& "
'
'
# " ' 5 7*$+$-
'. ' '
# ( = " "# . " . "
. 3 & :
3? + - 4?"
5' " .
3
, .
, .
. .
# , . ' ''
, . . # # " , # "
# " & .
" " . '
, 3
.
' '
4?"
5'
'
3 ' 5 4 # = +$)!)- 7 5 $!% . '.( , . ' .
" , .
# ,
3 ' 34 *? + - '
# " @$0 . '
# . ' . , '
'
( . 0$ !%! &
" # .
5 ,
'
' "
'
# 8
' "# '
. .
" A "# , " . . '# " , . ' ' .
. # .
# . & . . ,
. 3
'
' 5 . " 3
'
.
3 ' " "
"
A # 5
4. , . !%! 5 7** ' #
# # " " ' '' . '# !%! '' /
& $? + - 4?"
5'
' " . ' "# 34 *? + - ."#
*/ .
" @*/ ' '
'
# 8 '
# ( . .
' . #
C . .
# '' 'C .
# '' 'C .
.
# # 'C ' D ' '
'
:
" '
"# 4?"
5' $? + - ? + -
. " ( "# = +- . #
C +- "
" # ' " C +-
'' ' C +- # " "# ( C +- ' D '
!)
. '
# " ' 2 3 " ' 4' = ' # +, $- )/ )0 !11!
' '' ( . 5 7*$ 7** 7**+-
.
!%!
&
# "
# # ''' '' " # '
"
'
;
9 . " ''
'' . " '
. ' '' # % 6 . " ' .
# " '
# % F
'
.
# # 7
8 '
'' # % 6
'' &'' . '
&' ' &''
. '
&' ' &' ' . '
&' ' &' ' . '
&' ' &'' . ' 9 +%7 !7 $) !$ !/ !) !7 !) !7 / !7 9 967 !) !7 / !$ / !$ / !$ % !/ !!
& ' ' # # )/ )0 !11! .
# '
" '
. ' 4 ' #
E # )/ )0 !11! . '
" !) #
'' !7 # '' . ' 5 # !6 )7 $)$7 "# .
!) # !! ' )/ #
'' !% # )$ # ' , "#
E # ' 8 8 '
!$
" # .
. # '
"# 5 ' '
' # ' "
"
:
" # '
"# ' " "# '
' # : " " '
"# , * 5%3 .*)"))' ))0 '*
2!
%!
. '
" . '
.
' ' # '
" "3 '
. . '
!7 $!
# '
( ' '
.
# 2' ' "# " 8
# .
" ,
" '
"
# " '
5'
. .
. "# 4?"
5' $65 "))' ))0 '*
' &"22 !*
& ! 3 '
.
, 6 . # )$ )% $)$* 10
2,
. .
"
( ( '
"# : ! 3 # '
' "# ' !% !) $)$* F
'
. ' ! (
"# = >
5 = .
''
& "# '
# '
.
, ' " # '# 5 7*$+$-
& $7 + - 4?"
5' .
. '
" = " # ' ' . '
' ( .
+ ' - 3
. 3 ( ' "3 ' " ' = ? ' '' . . '? ' "
!7
& $? + - .
" . = . "
. , ' '
"
4.
# ? '
.(
#
. '
=
4?"
5'
" " ' .
= . " ' = . " '
= .
( ;# " 3
' , '
(
' ' C '
'
'' ' ' '
' '' 5 # .
"
,
, "# ' '
. " " # , G # 34 *? + - .
" 5 , . ' ( .
# " " "
. '
# &
"
# '
" " & $? + - 4?"
5' . " :' ; '
' # '
' '
!7
F #
.
. "# 4?"
5' " 3 ' ' " . ' ! '
# ( = '#
=
.
(
. . 8 " (
= >5 = $!
)* $)$* " %$$>5
&& !0
!
$
G
' .
#
*
# #
# "#
. ' ' . ''
+- "# ' # >'
G # '' ' "#
%
G
# '' '
G # #'
/
5' D '
3# "
>'
!) # '
>'
!!
G ' 'D ' # #
'
!$
#
#
!* F . F
!6
. '
" . ( '
.
'
''' 8 # )/ )0 !11! ' $% !) $)$* # '
. " '
# )/ )0 !11! . .
' ' & ( # . '
. '
"# .
" '
' '
"# "3 ' 8 '
!%
.
16.04.2024 (MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes Whether reportable Yes