High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/633/1997dismissed

Punjab State Electricity Board Etc. v. Sant Ram

2017-12-06Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh10 pages

!"#$%& '

()* +,,*'!--%..&/ 012

"#!# $% " ''

) "(( ('

()* +,,*'3#!%..&/ 012

"#!# $% " ''

) "(( +"#(& ,

()* +,,*'#..%..&/ 012

"#!# $% " "( ''

) "(( "# "+* ('

1 451 '

6 "

- "(& , & "* .!

(

"+ *# #/&0&

" (' (# (+ (&#1 + "

"2 "

.0&'"

" (' #

6 "'

%$ &#(/*

4(& #('(

# &"

"( !

(!**5 6 "#(

* 7& "# (

#(8"

(,6 "9#.#(#0 "1(,90

(#(## $ " "# &"

* &(:6 #"( (6# & $

! # 4 *'

#8"

(,90.#

"* * ;

< =9 & # &#( ( ; 6&# "# " +* #8"

(' # 6

(,90.#

"* *;>;

;=9 & # (!& <; % & * 6 "

"#?

6# & "* ;+"#(& , #8"

(' #

.# *< @8

< =@ # &#( (,90 &#(( (6 "#?

6# & "* ;<7& $6 /#.

( $"*

$6 "#?

#( * #*#/( $

6#//"-8

#"( (6 ! #(A

" # ( 6'

"(( $* 4 "# + "

1& , 6&# (,90 #1 #( 6

"#?

6# & "* ;

/#.

( $ "*

#"##/# ( ( &

$ (8

(:6 $#('

$"*

##/ ( $ /"

#(8"

(' (6

## $

(#( ( (!

!(# "'"* # 7& (8

#( 5 # #*#

### #/

(# B"*

#/( 6#/#(( (# 6 "

-8 C&

##(

& $#= 6 ;#(

##(

#'"

$ "D B"*

#/( 6#/#(( (#

6 "

-8 C&

##(

& $6#

"* D

(# #(

"*D 9 C&

(# #( 6# &# #*#

#D9

B"*

#/( 6#/#(( (# 6 "

-8 C&

##(

(

/ D

##(

#D C&

"(# #(

#& (!

( #D9 > C&

"(# #( 6# &# #*#

#D9 C&

"(# #(

"8# " (( "$'

(D 9 C&

##( ''

$&#(6 !!

"*# #/ '"

(# D9 ; 4 (6 /#.

''"

.# ''"

!&(# #

#(6 ( !"

$6 /#.

( $"*

##/ 7& "

( # $ '"

( 6

#(*#(( $

" #"(

&#("

"( !

4& &

" !( & /

&"/& !" ,

" !(

(& (( *#

!(# "( #(''"

&#(!

#( "

#0 0!# "

"!&#:* '

&$.%#'#0& "

, 1& "(A < E <A

".(&6 #+* "(A << E > A " 2'

. 7& 0 *##(

7"#

0& #/ "&% !& 0& #/ "& "(A <<; E>

#/&.

0(* "9#('

( "

(( 0**#((#

> "( <> E < " &

" !( " "

(' ( *#

#(8"

(' ( 6

(

'( #" ( 6 # !!" 6# & '"!

" (A #"( ! #(A

6 "(#*# " $ '

"(( $* 4 "# + " 1& , &

( $ "*

#" ##/ (

#(8"

(' ((

1#/( $

(#( 7&#(0"

& (/#.

# &/& !(#

# "#.

#( !

$/ &"/& !" 7& 6#/ ##('

-8

#(8"

(' ( #

( 6

(#( :6 #" ( (

! #( # *# '

# "# "+* "# 6 "#?

"* ;6&

(( (+"#(& , # #

6 "#?

6# & "*

;<A !

6 *' $

(# !#.# (# (# 1& ,

# 0#.# # < 6&#!& 6 ( !"

<< 6&

(4 "# + "# !#.# (# > 6&#!&6 ( !"

<< % & 1& ,

4 "# + "6 ##

(,90 &!

(#( #" ( ( 6 "

"#?

6# & "* ;:6 $6 /"

( $"*

#"##/ $* "/#/ #"'

"# ( #( (8

##/

#( '"!

"# #( #"!

#(6

/ #( (

'( (4 (#*# "(#

# :F

0( #% !&'"

)+ 6) .

+7 <<<40 ;<;& (#(!(( (#*# "'"'(# 6# /"

'&(> ( "-8 G>

"*# /$( ##/ F(!

$F &!F F"

# (F F( '8/ #(5#

*# # "#

E"#('" "

"#/" :#/&0"

9 &# &6 !

(

( #

"*# /$(&

/#.

#/ (6 (/#.

49&#/"

F(!

= *##/6&

*' $

0( #!

( ".

# * !(# "#(

( ##(!"#*#

( 6"(H'".#(#

H#!#

#/H H '"

#HC &#1

#//#.

"*# /$#9&#/"

F( 6# & $ '' #!

# #& 6&

#( "$#/ 6"1 5#

$# 6&#!&6# #(

# &#( #" $ /'

"#( '"'( ( $ &/& '(( (( 5#(#

5 ##!

# &/&&#(

& (

" !(

# @"

''".

:#/&0"

7& &"

"*(F &!F F( '8/ 'F F"

# (F # "

5 ( # ( "#('" 4

"*(# " (#5 #6 &

1 #!

# "$*

#/ 6"(

#/ !** $ ((#/ *#(

"(7&

#/ /#.

='"

((# H"

# (H # "F( E#!#

9#!

# "$ #( H !!# " "

# ( !

(

$H 7&#( (& .#( $!

# #(* !!#

( '

#! " "/ (#

# (!&

.#( $6 ! # #" $ / "#% " " "

!"#

" !(

#6# & :#/& 0"

'(( (( '"

(!"#

5 ##!

# "(!& '".# # ! # ((!& " #" $ / '

"# ( !

& H"

# (H 4 % !1F( , 6 #!

# "$ ='"

((# H"

# (H*

(H!!""#/ $!& H "

# (

&#/& $"

&( ##!

# !!"( $ $ !& " !!#

6&#!& ! &

(

7& ='"

((#H &!H#% !1F(, 9#!

# "$

(H(*

&#/6&#!&#("* " #! '"'( H7& ='"

((#H( '8/ 'H ('

"="9#!

# "$

( H

*'"

"$ 6 $

#/ 6# & '"

* "

#($#/

H 4 =" 9#!

# "$ 6" F &!F *

( " #! "'"'( A('

!# $4 9#!

# "$ 6" F"

# (F*

(& #/ !!# "!&

(#/ ;4

#$ "F(, 6, =#! # #

6"F &!F#( (!"#

(H"'

#! "'"'(

#(& #/ " !!

" 6# & '

#! " "

'"'( F7&

#/6"F"

# ( F#(/#.

6&#!&& ( ( 6&#!&6 (#( A

6&#!&#("

( $('

"#""!

6&#!&# #( #*'((#

(#( A

"*($$*(6# &F!

2F 7& *

((#/

"*( 6&#

"'"

#/'".#(#( 6#

;

'".#(#(

= '"'( "

6&#!& ='"

((#( ( 7&

#/ $

"*( # !

= !*'

( $ #!

"( & #/ !

'( 6# ( !#"!*(

(#6&#!&

'"'( # 6#

(( "$ 1# '"'( "

6&#!& '( (!"

" ( (

# " " 4

" "# ##!

'( #(!"

#! "

*'"

"$ ! #/ !$ " '

"# ('

!## # " (!& '(

$ (!"#

(F &!F"F( '8/ 'F4 '( #(!"

#6&#!&& (( $ "#( !! #/ (*

*'"

(!& '(

(!"#

(F"

# (F #

4 #(* *

! #/ !$

"#(#/ !!

$#!*'

#/ '"!

(("

!"# '( $"

( # #( '((#

'( .

# *

&#(! #/ !$

#(* # ''"'"#

F( '8/ 'F ""

/ '( (F &!F

4 #( '((#

$6 $( #/& 8 !1

"* " /#.

=& ( #.

#( !#"!*(

( (#

#(#6&#!&(!& &!

# ("

'8/ '!

((!& &#(#(!((##( #

!#"!*(

( " (#

#( # 6&#!&

(#!

"(!

# !* 6# &# (!'

"*(4 #( $ ##!

''" !& 6&#

#/6# & 5

( $#!

"(# "

<4 E"#('"

"(6&'(( ((

5#(#

5 ##!

#! "'(

& #(

6# & ''".

''"'"#

&"# ! # (# '( #" $

"# (!&

H( '8 / '""

# ("'"

&!H4 &#(.# 6

(#/

(#( 6&#!&

'"*

(# 9 &#:#/& "E#!# # 6 (& :#/&0"

# (@ &!@( '8 / 'F 6& $ "" ( "

=! (# &(

( & #" ! #( / & ( "

$#( "" (

4.# 6"!! (#( "

# 5 (&

$ #( &'".#(# #

( #

$#"

!"# " $'"* ##

9 &#:#/& "E#!#

'"#" *

!"# ( # $

" ; #"

( $*(

"*#

(#(! #(

/ &( 0 "

(##!

##/ F(!

$(# &#(/* #!

"( /"

('( * $

"(*

"/ ('

# :#/& 0"

6 6 ## #(#/ $6# &# "# (#=6

1("*

&#(/* I 7& /* ( "

" !( "

#( #/#(&

# !# #! ( '' $ ( '"

6!*#/ '# #*#

" !(

( & ( ( *#

(# #( #

$ '

"# #*#

# 4 & !(# &#( ( *#((# # ""# ( 6 #/& #*# "'"'(# 6&

#(!(( &#(0"

# ) 8 * 9 + . 5*: +/

'-#3%..& !# %3'#'#$%#2'4

## ( <

6 ("

"#?

<;:6 (# (# $&#* ; 7&#(0"

6& "(#( //"# "* !""#/ ( # (#

$ #*#

# &/&

"#!

"#!# $% "# '

!# ,

6&#!&6 (#(*#(( > < #*# "'"'(# 6#( #. .

# (7& "

# (&

!""#/!

(

# (# (# #(8"

(' 6# &#

"# #*#

# # ''"

#( .#

&#(0"

!(# '##

##/( !"

'"'

''"

.# $#

#"* ( (

.#* "#

$#(*#(( 6# &!( (7& /* !"

(

#"* / 6 2 !"#$%& :6) C&

"('

1#/@"

( J (@ C&

J (@