High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/285/2016allowed

Bikramjit Singh v. State Of Punjab

2016-03-16Mr. Justice Krishna Murari16 pages

!"#$%!" !

&$'($%!" )*+, - . / , +1 . 2 3 $

&!%"4$%!" ) - . / , +1 . 2 3 4

&!%5!$%!" 6 - . / , +1 . 2 3 7

&!!74$%!" , *, - 8 . / , +1 . 2 3 (

&$%$!$%!" *), - .

/ , +1 . 2 3 "

&$7'%$%!"

*+, - . / , +1 . 2 3 5

&75(($%!" 0+ 3, - . / , +1 . 2 3 '

&7'!!$%!"

2292, - . / , +1 . 2 3 :

&(("7$%!" - . / , +1 . 2 3

, , &&

, 0* #3= 2

&$'( &$7'%$%!"

,*+, - #3= 2

&!%"4# &!%5!# &!!74# &75((# &7'!! & (("7$%!"

, #3= 2

&$%$!$%!"

>,98#339# +1 && 3 899 32 998 - 2 - -0919 & !?

&$'($%!"&)*+, - /, +1 $?

&!%"4$%!"&) - /, +1 4?

&!%5!$%!"&6 - /, +1 7?

&!!74$%!"&, *, - 8 /,

+1 (?

&$%$!$%!"& *), - /, +1 "?

&$7'%$%!"& *+, - /, +1 5?

&(("7$%!"& - /, +1 3998 -2 - 2@19 & !?

&75(($%!"&0+ 3, - /, +1 $?

&7'!!$%!"& 2292, - /, +1 , 99 2 19A 2@190 * !(!33=*1!$#$%!(#0 3, !$7&#!(4&# !(4 # !!(# !!5# !$%&# !'' 3 , !4 B!?

9809 = B = ? # !:"5# , ""& *

9-@#-3 9, 8 3#*# 223399 2 8 ** 3 8-3 =*1!$#$%!( 1 2, 9, # 8 3#*# =*1 !%# $%!( *3 C,1 > 9&$%!(; 8 - D3 1@ ,* + , - # , - 3# ) , - > - 69# )*, - 3032, - 38 8 331@ 2 9 -8 93 903 -, *, -

8 # 6 , - 89# 0+ 3 , - 3089# *) , - + 9# ,0 3 , - )89# - , - 9)# 2292 , - 3# *, - ,#,0+, - ,# *+, - ># 01 +, - ,# 3, - ,#9+ 3, - 9@ 3 - D

= 8 *3 2 3 1 0 @ 3 -@ 0 @ 3 # -, - 88393 3, )9) , 1#63 8, - 11# 3- D 11> 9 9

= 8 - ) # *3 *2 - @0 ** =,9- 8 3 23 - 09 * 18 **0 9- 8 8=3- 0 @< 333 9, 03-#* 3*3 19229 2 0291= 82 1 -

&4!'%$%!"&9+, - 3089/, +1 3

&7744($%!(& )*, - /, +1#- -09 19 =93@1 99831@ 0 2 9+, - 30898* 09@) 3 8 9- - *19 * 2 2* 2 8 *28- - 1 -8-8- = * 32* - *@ - 3 -02 )*, - 8 - D -- C,1> 9&$%!(; 1 - 3 19 0 283 = -1 103 * ,2 )*+, - #) - #6 , - # , * , - 8 # *) , - # *+ , - , - 3# @ = 1 03@ 8 3 * 3 198 3 = 3 * * 9 * 3 198 &

! "

## $ % & #' )*+, - $7!!!( 5 ) 9 9- 3 4 ) 9 2

19 2 ) - !"!!!( 9 6 - $(!!!( 9 , *, - 8 !"!!!( 9 *), - $4!!!( 9

*+, - "!$!( ( ) 9 9-

3 $ ) 9 2 - !:!!!( $$ ) 9 2 6 9 3 0 9 2

>, 98# 33 9 3= 9# +1# = 099@ - 0- 9103 2 98 1 103 2 9* 3 198 &

! "

# (

#!)*

+ )*+, - *3 - 9 *3 1@ *) , - 390* 99-39@ 393 1) 83

$% 9 1 3 - +1 ) - 99-3 1 ,- ,@ 3 * - D 6 - 99-39@3090 !$ ,1 > 9 !:'" 3 9 2=)3 '&!% ,) @0 *3 8 1 83 , *, - 8 99-3 1 ,- ,@ 39 2=)3 '&!% ,) @0 *3 8 183

, *), - 8 99-39@ 393 3# 3103 9- 2 3 9 2=)3 '&!% ,) @0 *3 8 183

*+, - *3 - 9 99-3 1 - - *# - -2 39 22- 3*9 - 99-31* 3 2 9@ 022 - - , - 8# , - 0 3 63 8 , - 11 -- 8 99-39@ = 3 =*1 !%# $%!(1 8*231@ @990 @2 83 3 3 ** - 1 2 10 8 -3 =*1 !$# $%!( 9 2 1= -- C,1> 9&$%!(; 1 3930 9809 0 3 , $

9809=B = ?#!:"5# C ; C0 9809 ; 313 , $ B2? 0 9809=@ 1 313 , $B? #8 3998 & E$B?E*"(- *(% !&!

'F# 9 3=309 #* @ ) 1@0 3=309 B8 1@** - 1@83# 2) 8 # 1@ - 1@ =19 2 8?#

B? 8 33#022 @9*#1 - 10# @-0 38 =# 2 @ 3 2 @ 3 *

# 8 @ 3=309 -02 3=309 1 - 10 0 G B? 8 39*#H0 #302 33 302 =- @ 3 9 -@ 3G B?

8 0 33 0 3 - 3F * C0 9809 =@; 3 8 * C0 9809 1 0 9809 1 3 9-D2H0* , 4 8 01+ 22=9 1@ 10 9 03 1@ 9 = * 0 3 , ( 899 9@ 1 3119 0 8 =@ 99-3 - 2 **1 9809 E0 9809=@F20 190 3, !% !4 9 - 30 - 0 =- * 6# *9@#C,;#C ,; 3C,;B * 99@ 93 H0 , 0 9?

8 33 =*1 $:# $%!( !4 90 @ !

. 3 !:'7 3-, - 9 33 1*3 0--9 309 1 3 39- 83- 3 = * 8 3 9 - 3 3 3

29 339- C> 9 I 313; 3 9-> 9 8 0 093 3 * 9@ - - , - 9 8 ** 31@ 3 6 * 3 8 8- 33 *1(#$%!( 2 0229* @* 0229* @* 6 9 -8 8 * * 8 33 -- # 2 32=)3'A!%,) @0 *38 1 83- > 9 39* 2 **0 @*

+1 0229* @ * 33 10 ! * 3 8093131190 9 0291= ) - 1 =9=3 8 !'%33*1"# $%!( 0 3 9 - 8@ # -3 9 , ) 0# D20 = 1 !(# $%!( 3 1 $(# $%!( !:'=*1!"#$%!(0 3, $:(#7$5#(%"# (!!#!(4&#!$%#!7'#!7: #38 , $(A(7A(: * -3 9 , >89 * 2 - * 3 1!%#$%!( ,*99@ 2 , * , - 8 9 1 =9=3 8 !:'=*1!"#$%!(0 3,

$:(#7$5#(%"#(!!#!(4&#!$%#!7'#!7: #38 , $(A(7A(: *-3 9, >89*2 - * 3 33 1!%#$%!( !((33=*1 $:# $%!( 0 3 , $'4# 47!# 74!# 7$5# !''# !7'# !7: # 9- 8@# 9, )# 3 33 1 !(#$%!( ,*99@2 *), - + 9 1 * 3 03 * !:%33=*1!"#$%!7# 3, 4%5#4$7#7$5#$:( 3, $(A$5 * -3 9, 119# 3 =*1!"#$%!7# !("3309@$:#$%!7#0 3, 4%'# 47$#44"#(%"#!7' 3, $( *#-3 9 , 119# 3 09@!%#$%!(

!:$33 1!7#$%!(#0 3, 4%5#4(4#44$#444# 4'$#$'"#!$%& #-3 9, @>)2013 2 ,*99@ 2 *+ , - 1 =9=3 8 !:'=*1!"#$%!(0 3, $:(#7$5# (%"#(!!#!(4&#!$%#!7'#!7: #38 , $(A(7A(: * -3 9 , >89 * !$% 33 *1 !:# $%!(# 0 3 , 7$% # -3 9 , +

,2 0+ 3, - 3# 1

* 303 =*8 998 & ?

!:' 33 =*1 !"# $%!( 0 3 , $:(# 7$5# (%"# (!!# !(4&# !$%# !7'# !7: # 3 8 , $(A(7A(: * -3

9, >89* ?

!$' 33 *1 '# $%!(# 0 3 , 45:#7$5 38 , 4$A44 # -3 9, 119# ?

$$"# 33 *1 "# $%!(# 0 3 , $'4# 47!# 74!# !''# !7'# !7: # -3 9 , ,3 =?

!((#33=*1$:#$%!(#0 3, $'4#47!#74!#7$5#!''#!7'#!7: #38 , ' 9- 8@#-3 9, )# =?

4$5# 33 *1 $# $%!(# 0 3 , $'4# 47!# 74!# 7$5# 45:# !7'# !7: -3

9, @ ,*99@2 - 91 =9=3 8 !:'33=*1!"#$%!(0 3, $:(# 7$5#(%"#(!!#!(4&#!$%#!7'#!7: #38 , $(A(7A(: *-3 9, >89* !'%

33*1"#$%!(#0 3 9- 8@-3 9 , ) 0 D20 8 @13 = 33 0 99- - 2 J 989338 / +# !"01$

!## !:"$,:((#8 2, !$7 J 2= 9!:B!?B?

19 18 3=309 0 3* 9 - 3 20193F 2J0 # '!"0(1$2"! " "+!#B$%!(? ( , ! 8 9 3 - J2 C3* 2 J2 ;# 1=3998 & E!4 93030 8 J2 E3* 2 3 J2 F 2 8 0 3* 9 3 3 - * 1 0* - 30 # 3 3=@# 3 3 * 30 = 3=@2090 8=0 2209 9 !:B!?B? 9@ 8 0 30 3=@ 9=9 * 9!:B$?

!"01$

3*"4)# !::(,!5'( 35*#4 !"+ #3(!"0 1$

3*"4)#$%%:B4? B9?$$7#8 8 93 ** D - -= * 8093 99 8 *1 C3*2 3J2 ;108 838 2) = 2 0 3 @ 8 - 2019 33301 98 33#2H031) 2019 3 )*+ , - # ) , - # 6 - #, *, - # *), - # *+, - 3 , - =1 03@8=*1 3*1$%!(899 9@1311908 9103 2 8093 99 0 3 0 3* 9 - C3* 2 J2 ; 30 39!:B!?B? 0 3 80931 0 3, !$7& 3!(4 0 29 1= 6#+!7 # )! 3

( # !$

# # )! #$!)! 3

( 1$

5*4# "+

#$# $%!" B!?

B9?(7$# 1 93 0 - 0 3, !(4 3 !(4 # 2* 9 - *@# 3 99&899 18 3 9-099 -0-- 9-02 3 **0 # @ 9 8 0 -02 **0 093 1 =9=3 9@ - 9 - **0 @ -02 8 0 @ @ **0 @ -02#8093 , !(4 3!(4

2 # * @ 2 1 3399319 - - @ **0 @ 9 - *@# 399&899891@ @ -02**0 @209 299 3 -- C,1> 9;8 = 3 2 ,00 , 1899 9@131190 30 - 0 9 8 -3 3 3 9* 2* - *@18 3 -02*30 6 0 J2 @ 2 *# 2 1 -

&$'(# &!%"4# &!%5!# &!!74# &$7'%$%!" & (("7 $%!" 9983 )*+ , - B

&$'( $%!"?# ) , - B

&!%"4 $%!"?# 6 , - B

& !%5! $%!"?# , * , - B

&!!74 $%!"?# *+ , - B

&$7'% $%!"? 3 , - B

&(("7 $%!"? 33193 19 0 -191 3A0@1 3 #* ,2 0+ 3, - 2292, - 3# 2 1 -

&75(($%!" 3

&7'!! $%!"99983 333 2 0+ 3, - 2292, - @899193 19 -01+ 3 @899 + =- 38 H031@ 29 3 @899 *28 =3 *2 =- @*

*) , - 3 1 - 3 *19 9 -0 3 1 -

&$%$!$%!" 99983 *), - 33193 19 0 - 19 1 3A 0@ 1 3 # * 0 1=3 2 =1 - 319 01+ 3 @8093 309- @=@30 - 2 3 @ 98 8093 03 2* - *@ 18 3 -02 -3 3* 13 J2 2 *

!"#$%!" B ,? +@