High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2013/1999disposed of

Baljeet Singh v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2025-11-13Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

& ($"&% ($"&% ($"&% ($"&% :

: &% &% &% &% ; B < ; B < ; B < ; B < "2,,&# "2,,&# "2,,&# "2,,&#

: : : :C ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$

")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$;<

& :

:CC&% &% &% &% ; B < ; B < ; B < ; B <

))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$

")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$;<

& = = = =&% &% &% &%:::

:::

:::; B < ; B < ; B < ; B <

))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$

")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$ ")&#1"#$;<

!""#$

%&!

"")(7,#9'(,#,-18&2($"

$'"())"**(#$;<@*(#1&6#"!;< +',#('(,#--(!.(# #( AAAA - - - -; !(*< ; !(*< ; !(*< ; !(*< /0 ,1 1" $', 2&33&# &!1"!- (** $'" (%&!"3"#$,&#"1 ())"(* (!" +"

",#9 1"2,1"1 ( $'" (3" '(8" (!,"# &5$ &% 2&3 33&# (245,,$,&#@6(!1 ,#8&*8 8,#9 ,1"#$,2(*%(2$( (#145"$,&#&%*(6 &!$'"(7 7"&%+!"8,$.-%(2$(!"+",#9$(7 7"# : &% %!&3

/0 . 6(. &% )!""#$ ())"(*;<- 2'(* **"#9" '( +""# *(,1 $& $'" 6 6(!1 1($"1 ::= )("1 +. $'" *"(!#"1 11* ,$!,2$ 519"- 5!57'"

"$!( ;'"!",#(%$"!$&+ +"!"%"!!"1($'"> "%"!"#2" &5!$?<-6'"!"+. "%"!"#2" "$,$

%,*"15#1"!"2$, ,&#D&%$'"(#1245,,$,&# 2$-D=;%&!'&!$>$'"D= 2$?< ($ $'" ,#$(#2"

" &% $'" *(#1&6#"!;< 6( )( (!$*. (**&6"1 6',*" 9!(#$,#9 '

',3 "#'(#2"1 2&3) "#($,&# -::-:::@F)"! ( (2!" 45( $'" (245,!"1*(#1+", ,1" $'"D=2$ (6(!1,#9&$'"! $($5$&!.+"#"%,$@,#$"!"$5#1"!$ / 0 !

,"%*. $($,#9- ,# $'" )!""#$ 2( (";<- 2"!$(,# *(#1 &6#"1 +. ())"**(#$;<,$5 5($"16,$',#$'"!"8"#5""$($"& &%8,**(9" &I((!( (*(#-"'

',* '(#"(!-,$!, ,2$ 5!57'"$!(-2(3"$&+"(24 45,!"18,1"&$,%,2($,&#)5+*,'

'"1 &# DE (#1 DD ,5"1 5#1"! "2$,&# = B G &% $'" D= 2$ !")"2$,8"*.%&! $'")5+*,2)5!)&"#(3"*.%&! 2&#$!52$,&#&%!&(1%!&3(*(!

!)5! !&(1$&8,**(9" ,!3($2'#6(!16()("1 1+.$'"(#1245,,$,&#&**"2 2$&! ;%&!'&!$>$'" ?<&#E:GD$'"!"+.1"

"$"!3,#,#9$'"3(!7"$8(*5"&% (245,!"1*(#1 -D-:::@F)"!(2!" /=0 99 9!,"8"1 $'"!"&%- $'" ())"**(#$; <F*(#1&6#"!;< ,#8&7"1 "%"!"# #2" 5#1"! "2$,&# D &% $'" D= 2$- '&6"8"! $'

'" (3" 6( )(!$*. (**&6"1 6'

',*" 9!(#$,#9"#'(#2 2"12&3)"#($,&# -::-::

::@F)"!(2!"45($'"(245,!"1*( (#1 +",1" (6(!1,# #9 &$'"! $($5$&!. +"#"%,$@,#$"

"!"$ 5#1"! $'" D= 2$ "

",#9 1,F($,%,"1(9( (,#$$'"(%&!"(,16(!1-$'")!

!""#$())"(*6"!")!"%"!!"1($ &6#"!;< ,#$(#2"&%*(#1& /C0 3) )59#,#9$'"(%&!"(,16(!1-*"

"(!#"12&5#"*%&!$'"())"**(# #$;< 5+3,$ $'($ $'

&59' $'" 3(!7"$ 8(*5" ,# $'" )!""#$ 2(";< 6( ,#2!"("1 1 $&

-::-:::@F)"

"!(2!"+.$'"*"(!#"1 "%"!"#2 2"&5!$-'&6"8"!,$%(,*"1$&$ (7" ,#$& (22&5#$ $'

'" 6(!1 1($"1 ;

H FG< )("1 +. ,$ ,# 2(" &% (245,,$,&#&%*( (#1)"!$(,#,#9$&$'"*(#1&%( (3"!"8"#5""$($"&%8,**(9" (!( (*(#-"',*'

'(#"(!-,$!,2$ 5!57'"$!(#& &$,%,"1&#C:DE5#1"!"2$

=&%$'"D= 2$(#1$'"3(!7"$8(*5"6(( (""1 -E:-DG@F)"!(2 2!" "(!#"12&5#"* *$'55+3,$$'($,3,*(!3(!7"

"$8(*5"6(!"45,!"1$&+"(6(!1 1"1 ,#%(8&5!&%$'"

"())"**(#$;<@*(#1&6#"!;<($'

'"(245,,$,&#,#$'")!""#$2("

";< 6(!"*($"1$&$'

'($8"!.!"8"#5""$($"&%8,**(9 9"(!( (*(#(#1$'"&$,%,2($ 5#1"!"2$,&#= &%$'"D=2$6(I5$$6&3 3&#$'(%$"!$'"#&$,%,2($,&#,#2 2(" &%6(!11($"1

;H FG< /G0 # $'" &$'"! '(#1- *"(!#"1 $( ($" 2&5#"* 5+3,$ $'($ $'" #& ,#$"!%"!"#2"6( 2(**"1%&!,#$'"6(!1)("1 +.$'"*"(!#"1 "%"!"#2"&5!$ ( 5%%,2,"#$!"(&# #6"!"!"2&!1"1,#$'",3)59# #"1&!1"!&($&I5$,%.$'"# #&#F !"*,(#2"5)&# 6(!11($"1 ;H FG G<%&!$'")5!)&"&%1"$"!3,#($ &%3(!7"$8(*5" ,#$'"2(";<,#'(#1"(!#"1 $($"2&5#"*$'5-5+3,$$'($ ())"(*;<)!"%"!!

!"1+.$'"())"**(#$;<@*(#1&6#"

"!6(*,(+*"$&+""$(,1" /E0 '

'(8" '"(!1 *"(!#"1 2&5#"* %&! $'" )(!$," (#1 9&#" $'!&59' )()"! +&&7 %,#1 5+$(#2" ,# $'" 5+3 3,,&# 3(1" &# +"'(*% &% ())"**(#$;<@*(#1 1&6#"!;< /D0 13 3,$$"1*.-$'"(245,,$,&#,#$'" )!""#$2(";<!"*($"$&$'"*( (#1 %&!3,#9 )(!$ &% % !"8"#5" "$($" &% 8,**(9" (!( ( (*(#- "',* '(#"(!- ,$ $!,2$ 5!57'"$!(%&!

!$'")5+*,2)5!)&"#(3"*.%&! 2&#$!52$,&#&%!&(1%!&3(*(!

!)5! !&(1 $& 8,**(9" ,!3($2' $ 6( !"2&!1"1 +. $'" *"(!#"1 $'" *"(!#"1 "%"!"# #2" &5!$ $'($ $'" 1"$"!3,#($,&# 3(1" ,# $'" 6(!1 1($"1 ;H

FG< )"!$(,#,#9 $& $'

'" 3(!7"$ 8(*5" (""1 ( &# # C:DE $'&59' !"*($"1 $& (3" !"8"#5" "

"$($" &% 8,**(9" (!( (*(#."$ $ 2&5*1 #&$ +" !"*,"1 5)&# %&! )!""#$(245,,$, ,&#)!&2""1,#9&#$'"9!&5#1$ $'($$'"(245,,$,&#,#$'"(,12 2(" ;H FG<6(%& &!6,1"#,#9&%)($'(#1%&!3(7 7,#9$'"7(2'(+"!3&#+&$', ,1"

$'"!"&%(#1$'($ $$'"*(#1,#$'"(,1(245,,$,& &#6(&%1,%%"!"#$)&$"#$,(*+"

",#9 (*!"(1.(1I&,#,# #9$&$'""H,$,#9)($''"(,1 1!"(&#,#9!"2&!1"1+.$'"*"(!# #"1

"%"!"#2" &5!

!$ 6( 6'&**. 5#I5$,%,"1 ,# $'

'" %(2$ (#1 2,!253$(#2" &% )!""#$2(";<( (,#$'"2(";<,#'(#1(*&$'

'"*(#1,$5($"16,$',#$'"!"8"# #5" "$($" &% 8,**(9"

" (!( (*(# '( +""# (245,!"

"1 %&! $'" )5!)&" &% 6,1"#,#9 9 &% (*!"(1. "H,$,#9 9 2&#&*,1($,&# )($' (#1 $', %( (2$ '( +""# 15*. (13,$$"1 +. !")&#1"#$ ,# $'",! 6!,$$"# $($"3"#$ %,*"1 +"

"%&!" $'" *"(!#"1 "%"!"#2" & 5!$ '"!"*"8(#$"H$ $!(2$$'"!"&%,!")!&152"1'"!"5# #1"!

F J '($ $'" $($" &% (!.(#( '( '(1 2&#$!52$"1 $'" *,#7 !&(1 &# "H, ,$,#9 2&#&*,1($,&# )($' ;'&!&59 9' (!"< %&! $'" 2&#8"#,"#2" &% % $'" !", ,1"#$ (#1 *(#1 &6#"! &# $'", ",! !"45"$ (22&!1,#9 $& $'" 1" ,9# )!" "2!,+"1+.$'"&8$'"(11,$,&# #(**(#1'(1+""#(245,!"1(*&#96 6,$' )($'

$'($'"6,1$'&%)($'6(#&$5 5%%,2,"#$$&3(,#$(,#$'"!&(15"

5"$& 2&# #$!52$,&#&%)522(!&(1$',(!"('

'(1"8"*&)"1-(,$6(#&$)& ,+*" %&! &3"&#"$&3&8"%!&3&#")*(2 2"$&&$'"!15!,#9$'"!(,#."(&# #&! &$'"

'"!6,"+"2(5"$'"*(#1(#18,**(9 9"6(,#(22",+*"15"$&7(2'() )($' &# #$!52$,&#&%!&(1'(9!"($*.+"#"

#"%,$$"1$'"*(#1&6#"!(#1!",1"

"#$ HHH HHHHHHHK /0 22 2&!1,#9*.-&#2",$6("$(+*,'"

"1&#!"2&!1$'($$'"(245,,$,&# #&% *(#16(%&!$'"

")5!)&"&%2&#$!52$,&#&%*,#7 7!&(1+.6,1"#,#9&%$'""19" &% (*!"(1."H,$,#9 2&#&*,1($,&#)($'(#16($'5 5&%,3,*(!#($5!"(#1)&$"#$,( *( $'($ &% %&!3,#9 9 )(!$ &% (245,,$,&# 2(!!,"1 &5 5$ 8,1" )!"8,&5 #&$,%,2($,&# 1( ($"1 C:DE,5 5"15#1"!"2$,&#=&%$'"D= =2$-,$6((%"$&!"*.5)&# 6(!11($"1 :

;H FG<)"!$(,#,#9$& $'"(%&!"3"#$,&#"1#&$,%,2($,&# ," C:DE 6'"

"!",# $'"*(#1 %&!3,#9 )(!$ &% $ $'" (3" !"8"#5" "$($" &%8,** (9" (!( (*(#6( (245,!"1'"!"%&!"-(3"3(!

!7"$8(*5" -E:-DG@F)"!( (2!" ,(6(!1"1$&$'

'"())"**(#$;<@*(#1&6#"!,#$'

")!""#$(245,,$,&#2(!!,"1&5 $,#

$"!3&%#&$,%,2( ($,&#1($"1DE)5+*,'"

"15#1"!"2$,&#=&%$'"D= 2$ )"!$(,#,#9 $& $'

'" (3" !"8"#5" "$($" &% 8,**(9 9" (!( (*(# &!"&- 6'"# 1"$"!3,#($,&# 3(1" 8,1" 6(!1 1($"1 :

;H FG< (*!"(1. $( #1 (%%,!3"1 +. $', &5!$ 8,1" I5193"#$ 1($"1 :

::C )("1 +. $', &5!$ $ ,#

&:C &

&:C & &% C &% C &% C &% C $,$*"1 >&)(* &)(* &)(* &)(* !,'(# ( !,'(# ( !,'(# ( !,'(# ( (#1 (#&$'"! (#1 245,,$ (#1 (#&$'"! (#1 245,,$ (#1 (#&$'"! (#1 245,,$ (#1 (#&$'"! (#1 245,,$ ,$,&# ,$,&# ,$,&# ,$,&# &**"2$&!(#1(# &**"2$&!(#1(# &**"2$&!(#1(# &**"2$&!(#1(# #&$'"!

#&$'"!

#&$'"!???? /:0 22 2&!1,#9*.,#8,"6&%(%&!"(,11 1,25,&#-(**$'"())"(*)!"%"!

!!"1 ($ $'" ,#$(#2" &% ())"**(#$;<F*(#1&6#"!;< ( (!" '"!"+. )(!$*. (**&6"1 ,# (%&!"(,1$"!3 &#"45"#$*.-$'"3(!7"$8(*5 5"%&!$'"*(#15#1"!(245,,$,&# #, (""1 -E:-DG@F )"! (2!" # (11,$,& &#- $'" *(#1&6#"!;< '(** (*& +" "#$,$*"1 %&! (6( (!1 &% (** $($5$&!. +"#"%,$ (# #1 ,#$"!"$ ( )!&8,1"1 5#1"! )!&8,,&#&%$'"

"D=2$;(3"#1"15)$&$&1( ($"<'"*(#1&6#"!;<'(**(*& &+" "#$,$*"1%&!&*($ $,53 :L+",1"(6(!1&%,# #$"!"$$'"!"5)&#(6"** /0

!$'"!-6'"!"8"!$'"*(#1&6#"!;< <'(@'(8"5#%&!$5#($"*."H),!"1 1,# $'" ())"(*;<@2!

!&F&+I"2$,&#;< (%$"! %,*,#9 $'"

"!"&% (#1 $'" *"9(* '",! '(8" #&$ +""#,3)*"(1"1- -$'".'(**+"($*,+"!$.$&""7"

"H"25$,&#&%$'")!""#$1"2,,&# #+. 3&8,#9())!&)!

!,($"())*,2($,&#;<+"%&!"$'"*"( (!#"1H"25$,#9&5!$ /0 ** )"#1,#9())*,2($,&#;<-,%(#.- '(**(*&$(#11,)&"1&% <

< &8"3+"!

&8"3+"!

---- $,7 ; ; ; ; :C :C :C :C M'

'"$'"!)"(7,#9@!"(&#"1 " '"$'"!!")&!$(+*" " @& @&