M.C. Ludhiana v. Ralson India Ltd.
!" "# $ % &" ' $ $ %
!" "# $ % &" ' $ $ %
!!"" #"$%% &
#% '
! ((((( (" ) " ' $# $ % !* +
, !" "# $ % "
%" -!# $ %- !.."# /, " ". 0 "", # %"
# . )#
) "* # ".
%",, * * , "
"% %" ,% 1 +
2
%# "*, ," .") 0 ", 3 , ,% "
/ 1" ,% ") ". ). )1 . 44 7 45 5 "
*" #
1 . . ) 1,, . ""
) "/%3 )" . ", % .# . " % 1 / , ".
8" %"
" % , "
9 "
" # %# .
)1 . * , ". ). . " "
. ", , ".
% "3 ." # % " 9 " " . / , "
"
"% "3 ." . ", % 1 / %"
." . ", ) "/%3 )" %",, * 1
"% " 3%%
"% , ). . " % 1 / ".
8" 3%% / 2
1, ,% "
/ * , 44 5;# %""# )1 % . 7 . 44 5; " )
* %", " . 3 / , ") ".# , ," "0 . ", , 3%% 3 . 3 1 . " , ) % ." ' 3 " ", 9%, < " 3"/" 3 "
01 ", # 3% " "* 44 5; 7 * 1 3 / ." %"
") ".# 1" ,% =
,, # " 3" .# ", " .") 10 " * " " ") 1""
"
5
> 01 !" "
."#
1 . . ) % 0* >%3 . ?
) " , ?
." " ", # .
* ." . " , * ,.
" % " ."
.
",% %", " . " ' 3)# *
+ 1 1, 3", ) " " %", 7 * ".
* ,.# 3%%
"# .
",% %", * ,. , ",% %", . 5452@5@
; . 5452@55; . ,. %# *") ",% "*"
7 * , 3%% .
",% %",?
) 9. ," " * "
. "?
"
1 , ) . " ." "
, " ,. 3%% .
",% %", ", # ",% 9 .
",% %", ,. "
3% :%""# ". 0 "
.") 0 .1 ' # % ") .
> " 3" . ), , %"# 3%"# "", *".
, "# 3, 3"
, ". A%%"
1 . . ) 8""
,% . 1% B
>>
A%%"
". .") 0 ") ," , B
>> @ A%%"
" * " 1"" ")
; 5
> 01 !" " B
>
5
' .) . %" 1" ,% %"
1", +
, % *") * ""
5
@# !* +
3% ! +
= 3 * * 1% . 1% " %) 10 3 3" * "" ! +
' .) . %" ! +
3" . . ! +
9 . " 1 %*, +
. "
". 1%
>" 3" " = " * " %"
" * .
- "
%", ", .# " ! " ,# ' ! # $ %# + @ 1% * "
. ) " , # 1% 3" " )# # %"
# . )# "* 3" "" ".
%",, 1* * * ,
"% %" ,% 1 +
2
3" " 3 , ,% "
/ 1" ,% ") ". ). )1 . 44 5; 7 44 5; :% # * ,. "
4
!" "# $ % ,,"* ,. " """ 1" " ,# $ %# 3%% 3" , " ,# $ %# 3% * ,. " 4
2# . 1% , # !" "# $ % % // "
% ! "# 3) , , "
# 3%% 3" ,* " ; # 3% %
" %" ,% "
. " " !%/% &% & &
0 /"# "'% % ! /'!% % "%& % "&"!%% "% !"% % % !/"% "%% ! ' % / %" /' "'
% ! 1%& %" !"% % "% ! '% $ % %/ "
!"% % %! & " , ,2+3 % /%""
4 2)
- ) 2
) /%""4 2)
2 2
) %& ' & #5! '6& %! ##%"% /" #% % % & ' "' /
% &!! & ""'5!
!"% % ! '#5! &
" #% #%" / ! % & #5! '
'# !% & # #%"%! /' !"% % ! ' # 5! ' '
!"% % #7% !' % '
" & #% / ! /' !"% % ! ' %& ' !"% % ! '
/% ' 5!% 8 .
% 1%"
"% &#% % % /' % '
# &/" " & !" '
% # $ /' %" 0 / % & % !% " ! %% % % 9.. % %!"
0!% # % '"
/ & : ; !% & !"5 % '% !% /'!'<# % % % !"% % !% ' ' & %! /' "
!' % ' ' ' "
"% % " & %: ; /%""
% !"% % ##%""% &!' %: ; /%"" %# # $% %
% % % & !"% % % % &%! %".
#'
%" !"% % !
'% $ % # & $% % % % %" "#% %"0% % % %4*
! % ' %" !! % & "% % %" $% % % % '
'! %= ' " !% $ & %"0%!4 > 2!
!
!
!
"
#
$
%$&"# %'
()* % !+ ! *
$
$
, $
*
!
# !-
, . $
$!
$ $ !
# /*0
#$
, $
$ 1
345*
6*
2
!7
!
5 5*
6* $ $
!
# $
# $
$ #
! !
$
$
2
!
$
!
8 A% ."
. 1" " ,# $ %# % %. ,". 3% " ! " < 1"* 1% 3" ,". 7 %",1 !
".
,. , . " ".
%"
" ) 13 %.
3%%"
" , .
"
# .
)1 1 "%"# 9. :% . A
.
>"/%# . ) !
:%""# !
.
",% %", " , 4@ !% "& !# @
"* .
",% %", " " ,
. # 7 " " 1 A% "," 1"
" * ! "
"
5
> 01 !" " # " " ,# """ *" ,. " "* 1% !
, % % ,.# 1"*, % 3" 1 " $" C ."
", . * " " ; 3% !
1) " ) , % , , !* ! " " * ! " 1"" 3 " $" !
% " % *") 3%%
"3" 1" ! " 1 3 %* 3% *") " "
" " ."
%.
$" """ 3 , *" ,.
!"# $%&%'!(%))
"*!
' " +,-.
/01 $
% ! # $%&%'!( %))
!")!+,-.
221)!) 3 "!(!# 4
!!
5!%6 "7 "
+,.. 89+:2-"%; !$ ')!# )!) 3!"6!$!7$"01+<8/9 8%=%(92+- !"!
5!)%# !& !$$!8* !*9) "
+,,/829 0/4
!$ !>%$"
"%
)*# $%&%'!("'"!)%$3 (( $* "%)67 "
+,:, +/04 !$*%>!8 9)*#
$%&%'!("'"!)%$3 * %!$! $;!? @!(
'") !$*)!) )
:02
%"
%# " " % ,. ! " 1 3# 1., 3% . " %"
% ,. "%"."# " * "
) 1""
"
5
> 01 !" " 1. " " % < """ *" ,. %(%'
!%$7$"# )!) 3 !;!
) !$011: 8 !;901.!? "
$*%! )* # )!) 3 $;!? 7 "
01+1809 <+, $%&%'!(%))
!*5!# !"6!)!(+,-.
2<- "%; !$# $%&%'!("'"!)%$3"%) !"+,-.
0.0 $%&%'!(%))
!) %$*!# "%
!$!(+,-.
/14 *% %$
!& %$
)*# )!) 3 $;!?
7 "
+,,+ 809
0<2 !)%$!(
")%(%A "
)* # $%&%'!(%))
!) %$*!+,,:8+9 8%=%(9<0%"(!
$)B"> # )!) 3 $;!?+,,2809
+1,$*%!$ %( "'"!)%$# $%&%'!("'"!)%$ (( $* !"+,,28+9
+:/
"
%", "* "# '
,. ! " 1 3 " = # 3 " :%) "
".
) , ) "
".) '
) " "
3% "" , "" ! " 1 3 !
., 1 . "
, .
% "
3 :%""# %" "
/ , ." / ") ".
* , ." % " 7 * 1 3% .
%", 1 . 9. "
"" !" E* :%""# * " "", ."
,", ". .") 0 + 1 = 3 " " 3% ." " . ", )
))2
1!% &3 ? 4 1!/" ? 4