High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/944/1997dismissed

(O&M) Lal Singh v. Bikkar Singh And Others

2023-05-31Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!"# $ %&'( ))%%

*! +&,, &'( (!'((&$ ( )

- .

%/& &'(0"

/ 0"

))%%

2!'0"

() +&%4

0 ("

)% &+&,, &'(02 &'( -

&'(5 6 '&- !5.&. + "( &'(0 %%& &%% '7((&&.

%- 02(&%+

%'.& ( ! &'(-&) %&'(0& &%% '

(&%.

02(&%+ 0( 8!'( !& $ %&'(1 &'( &'(+ "( &'(0 8 (& &%% '7((&&.

%- 0,&' "%

.&)&

9984 ! %&'(& ( #

&:!

(&'( &08&" &'' )# &/!"

& &&' ( # & &' & )& & 4 (& &!%0 1

&'( %'.& ()% &.

/& .&)& !& 40(.0 &'(( %, %9# % % !

& )) +&,, &'(0 2 &'( -

&'( &9 (

(%9, % 1 ;&&'(0 '&'( /& &'( # &'(<!8:! %4

&'(%, %# % 8&'9=( ! &'(

(( &%, %# % 8&'9=( )% ! &'(< &'(! (%, %# % 2

&'(0-

&'( +&,, &'(>9<

&'(( ?"!

%990='

,( 19====90 ===< (!'( 99

&'(.

% .& 4% &(& #8"

!((

% 4%# (&( 0 !"(( &'( %% 4))

%&'(<

99& &'( & 8&"

"!# < %&'(

&'(&#% 8"( & &

,"&8% )& )% 84 &0 4& /& @&!

#&%4") " 4)) %%' %.

(.% (/& @&! #&%4 & .

.& (!

" &< 90 &/!"

&( 8&!

&'( &&' (&# # %%&' ,( !#8 9=== 9 ====""&' &0 (4( :!

#& (&"% &#8!

(4!0'&&'& "

! & 8&' &:! &

8&''& &"08 )) A (.&

# &%84 10(( & &! %'

% 8/"

& "( %%'&' ( %"!

& 8&' <#

8&%& 4 (

&. &)& 4!"(

"% &#(&#% 8 )!"( "&

&.& (!

&"0 !"() "

& (2 ) 4"

B! (%'

%8/"

,84 .&' .

!& .

))%4 %! ()!)7! /!&&"

& .

%!& 0 (0 8&#&.& ()"& %"

=< &6 '&- !.

" 4) ( &'( "( %%' %&

&# 84( #& 0 1 #&

&(&) () && 8!

/& %4.84 () &0

() &( 8&)

)& (&( (8 & )&

) &< &'(. ,)&')

&" % %%'%4# 84 &'( & ! (.&" &'

& &'(( 4!"( (&'0(( &'( 8"

&/!"

()

&' &'( &&'

(&##%%&',( !#89=== 9 0== ("!% %% ()) 484%?") .&' < &/!"

&( 8!%4"4 &'( & 4

& ( 8 #

& 8&&' !) ( .&'

!"( &

&'(( %#

(&( 0

(& .

%%'

&'(( %)) # !&', %# % ) 8 0

# ( "& &A .

&'(.

( &' 4( &

499

(( &'( %% ())

$ %&'(<

9984 ! $ %&'(.

% 8%% %'

% 8&&'!) () &" &'

%&'(8&' "( & 40 (.

,&'"&8%)&84 .&' A .

!& 4&/& @&! #&%4") " 4)) 4" &'

&'(.

8 "(% ()) 4%84(&#.

(& % ":!&)) 40 (0 &'(& :!&"

4 %!

&' (# &&' &0!"( ) 4&#& %

1&% )

# 0.(&"(&

%# (&#&% %&

1A .

. ()) 4%&

99 (

& %0

(& .

1( %&& $ %&'( %84 1&

!$ %&'(.

%"& 42(& %) 4 &#& % &%&' (.&

# 0!&' ("! )"&'0 1( 8 .

)" ? ) 2( )% & ( &% )%&"

& " &'

%%'

&& (.&

# .( &

&' # &

( )% &' ( ) &0 %%.&' &! . # C( ( (.&)&

D C( (

99?"!

&'( & ! $ % &'( & !%% & &"

& (&'( &D C( ( & 8 &)!"( %

8%"&

& .& (!

&"D

C( ( % (%&&/!"

&0 ) 4D C( ( &( ' %"!

&="

! & &% D

> C( ( ( 8))%4 %! ()!) 7! D

C( ( & #

8%D

9 C( ( 1& % )"& %" =D

C( (6 '&- !& " 4) 4D

%& > !8:! %4 . & %&!. #&

0.(&"( !

# 2() &. )) !& & % &"& !)) (&)"

&"% &# 9 ( &' (% "!% () &0 & 7! !86!'A 7% 0+ &/!'# "

&!.&&&' !% ("

&"%

.&)&

99?"!

84 ! %&'(& &'( 8&&'!) (#+4.

4) &' " )# &/!"

&0 . &#& &'& )& & 4 B%&' ''& 84 ( & /!'# "0 1( &% )) %& (7! & % & &"

6!'0+ 0.(&/!'# "

&#&

)) %!)(%&' (/!'# ") 84 & %7! +&'&

&&.& (/!'# ") 84

(7! 8%.0 1$ %&'(&% () '!% " )) % 8 (& 7! 0 &" .(&"( .

'& ) 0.()!

& )) " (!'("!% A( ( % "!% () &8&'&'

(!'( (" A (&

0)% %'.& (

&'(8&'"( & (/& 4

&'(8&' 8 "(%( ?"!

% % .& ('

(&( & 42( %0.(&"(& &#)!'& &

9984 ! %&'(2("

99.( &'(( ?"!

%& ! %&'(0 (.

% .& 4( & 48"

!(( % 4 % (% "#&' (&( && %@.0 &&' % %'

% %&"!# " &'

%&'(( &% "&&%!&

&'( & ()"&'&

90(( 8 &#%%&',( !#89=== 9 0== 2( % & ( 8?"!

84 !)% &&

99 1. (&' 8&.& ('

(%'

%& 4 %0.(&"(( 8?"!

84 &'( (!'((&

4 & !)% &99""&'

% &8 ""! ( &'8?"!

&&%

& &/!"

&&!84 (7! C& ('

99?"!

84 !$ %&'(

( 8 "% 8&%%'

%0!%% &84 & %7! 2( & %7! ( ""%!

&" &'(( % 4?"!

% E? E? & ! (!'((&

40 (0 (.

% .& 4( & (% %?"!

84(&# & !$ %&'(.

!%% &2(8/"

& &84$ &'(

%( 8?"!

84 !

9 (!'((&

.(&/!"

& )

&0 (0 %E? E? %'

% %& "!# .

"& /"

A ( 88

("&&% !& &.(&"(

9 .

) ( 8 !% &#

%4&#&0 ( (&/!"

&#'& (& %0.(&"(( 8?"!

84 &'(

(!'((&

4& !)% &"

&%48 !% (% 8&%%'

%0!%% &2( %( & (8 "( %%'84 &'("% 8&%%'

%0!%% &84

(7! "#) /!&&"

&2( & %7! &' /!'#

) &%%A& ) 90$ ( '( 8

"#)% %&" & &/!"

&! !% 7 7& !%%& 8&'.& (!

/!&&"

&2( & ( &'( %4 8 (% 8 8 & )!"( "&

&84 (7! 8%.

9984 !$ %&'(.

! 8&%%'

%A .

("( ( 8&/& )& .( &'(.

.& 4( & (/& 40("!%

)&8%4)!

%&'(&)& 4)&"% 2(!&

&'( %4"84 & %7! $ & % & &"

6!'0+ !(&#%&

'# .& & %7! &# (&&' & %7!

&!!)(%&' (/!'# ") 84 & %7! &

()"&#&&' )) % '

(/!'#

! "# $

&'( )

*)+

, -

. / 0

* 1 2

* 3" 1( 3/45(%

. 84% "!%

))%% 0 ( ))%&"

8% () "

! &

"&"!#

" (" ?

&.(&"(!"(8

&( 8 # > C& (""! &&'( &'8"84 7! 8%. ))%% = 0.(&"( 8 ))

)) & %&" ""

& )

&% . (8&' &%%'

%& 4&&#& 4.& (&#)!'/!'# ") 84

(7! 8%.0 (&'! & .& (!"(&#)!' /!'# "&'!% " )) % 1!8

%:! &% . && (& )) % 9 B&&'#& & )) %0 #

&#& &" ( # & )) % & &#&0 ( #&"%% !

))%&"

& 0& 4

&) ""&'%4 +&/

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#