Kunal Chanana v. Election Commission Of India And Others

2024:PHHC:044718-DB 








 

 

       
 

  !


"" # $  

  %  

 
 
 
 
  
 
 
 
 

  & '"  '( ) * ) #

 %


 

    &  + ,% ) * ) # % - & .  / & /) *  , ) 01)   21 & - ' .

3/) *  *,) 01) & '"

'() *  *,) 01) & & 43 ) **,) 01) # % -    


.1 31 #

 % 3 %

)

 %

  (

 #  %%%  3 # 5 (

"%(  - 6- #   7 *8 

 21 % - # ( 21  #

*"2 1


1 -  ) 01 9  %



   (

"  # #  1( %  #

"%(  - 6- # ) (

 %1 #

% 3 %

  * %

 #   )

 *"2 1 !

 #

 '

 # 01 3    : & &  ;



  2"


# & ) 01 3    &"2 # ;(  *"2 1 #"  

1 9

" #

 '

 ;(  *"2

1) 3 ""  

 :)   8%  

 03)  %%

& &  ; ( #"

 &"2 % 

 *- 3 %  21

 '%+ #

;(  *"2 1 

 " 1  # 9 )

   1 

 ;(  *"2 1  " # ' < #

%  # % = * :<

#   >

 * =  

 #  #

 1) % - 

 %  6 #    #

  1 21 31 #  .1 !

 9    #   

   # ,?

  #   :) "     7<)  =

3    :<) %

(  <<) 2

 (  7 

 "%  #

 21  %  77  -  # "  < @    ( 2 ) &  + ,% ) * ) %%  %     2 # # % - ) 3  & - ' .

3/) *  *,) 01) %     2 # # % -    1  #

 #

  ) 3  +   7 ;  #

 %

  (

    # 21   

   # 7) 

" #

 ;(  *"2 1  

 8% 





 $  #

  


 #


3  2   2#

 , !

 #

;(  *"2 1 # 01  

 31)

 3   3

  3 ##  "

  (   

 #(

 % # ' < * #

*   

 #

 1  5  

  1 

#)  " # 

' < * #

 *

 "%(  - 6- #   

 2  21 % -

 "  2  3 0  #

   %

 /("  #

-(% .

 ."21 0(
   -<  :

    

 

       :

*8 7   - :A7     

 

       7 *8   $  #

  

 !


"" # $  

(

   *8  21 31 #  '; 2#

 *%8
  

)        -    *8 A

(

 .1!



 *+   *"2 1


1 # & 

 %

  % 21

 ."21 0(
   - :A7 #  %  ;  #

 %

 2"



 !


"" # $    -

*8 A  % #  "

 1 "  )

( % (   *"2 1 

1  & 

)

  # %( 3

 21   " #



"%(  - 6- # *8 

 ( 


1)  2 1  " 1 )

" )

) 2  2 5  21


  $  #

 2"

 %

 21   5 )  %2  8%    

 %2  8 5  2 2 3



( 8%) %

1 3 

" #

" #

 ""2)  1 

A   ) & .  & /)  * , ) 01)  %%

 %

)   ) 

% 

   2 (

( 21  #  1 ( 

 '

 ;(  *"2

1) #

" #

  

1 

  1 & & /)  8  1 #  '  < < * #

 *   

' < "+

"2 %

 !


""  #

 1  ( 1 

1 2( %  

 '

;(  *"2 1 3

 

")  "1 2 %# 21

 !


"" # $) 

( $  2"

  2 (   " 1   2   1 "  $  #

 2"

 #  ' < * #

 *  )

 "  1 %2 

" "

 3

 2 "  2 (   2    3

 8 "

 #"

   #  #

 1 03)  2"

  ( #

" "

  %% 2   

 " #

     1 

  1 $ 

 3) 

" # %

 ' < *) 3 

 " #

<

     1 (   

1 

  1)

 !


"" # $) 3  

2 2 21

" "

# 8 "

 #  (

 21  $ %%

 # 2") & & /)

 #

 /("

 ,  0(
   
 !"
#  !!
#$$%&&
' (
)!
"
 *&%#
#$$%!!%#
#+


%
'(


 #&" 
,-./'0(
1
20. & & /)  #

 2"

 

 /("   % 21

 %

  

3
!"4 &#
'!13()

 2 

     #   2

 %  2  31 # 

  1 

3  % %

 #   "  #

  & & /)  #

  

  #

!


"" # $)  (

 "%(  #   7 *8 

  21

  #  ) 3 %#

1 / #) 2    3

 "  # * 7 



 # $  3

' < #

 * ) 3

5

   %  %%   
# & )     ""2 #

 ;(  *"2 1)



  %  2 (  




 (

" #    ""2 #

 '

 ;(  *"2 1 3

 8 "

+( 




# & ) 3

   ) 3   

 # 2") & & /)  %1 # "

 3 %

 : @ 2 # # % - !


"" # $) &  + ,% ) * )  2"

'

< * #

 * ) % # " "

# #

( 

 (  1 

1 

 %

' < * #

 * )   2

 !


"" #"

( 1 21 ) 3 

 " #

"

 1 

  1 & ,% )  +   ( 

 21   2 )  3 

" " #  1 

  1     () %

+ 

 % ) 3   %

 2"


# & ) 3

 2(  ""2 #

;(  *"2 1  ;( 
  9 #)  "

 % # * 7 




) 

%  "


# & ) #  % # 8 "

)

3)  

  (

" #     ""2 #

'

 ;(  *"2

1) 3

 8 "

 #"

   #

+( 

 & ,% ) #

 2"

* 7 




) 

% 

 % # '

< * #

 *

 !


"")   "

 #   % 1)   # #

 # 



5"   21  3

 8 "

 #

"%  #

 ## #

 & 6
# &  

 "1 2 ) 2/

  2

1 #

 16

 '

 & ,% )  #

 #  % - 7 #

 % 1 #   2 # # % - ) 3    B7 $ " #

 )  21   2  3 

 1 3 #

  1 )    )  #

 8 "

 '

%%  1 # ((

    2   #



 1 21  "  #


   '

,"  *

   # ) 3  %

%  3 (


# &    

21  ) 3  "( " #  3

  1   #

3 -" #

4 9"

"( 4 4

"( 1  0 % #"

*"

 ( # # 1  #    1 79 "

< :A7 7 :A

 &

C 

:A7 

:A7 *%%8  *

%%8"

"

01 7 :A 

:A7 A  :::

 ::<

"

C  < :::

 7 :::

*%%8 :

;8"%

%%8"

"

'9 *
#  7 :::

@

 < 

 : "

C :7  :  *%%8  -



"

*("

 A 

'9 *
# -(  

 

 :

 "

C

7 << *%%8 *

< "

01 

 7

 $    2"

 21 & ,%

' < *

 *   %  2

 !


"" # $)   1 

  

 2 # 1 8%  1 2  

(

   

# 2")  "  %1 # "

3 %



E% (

  2" #

% )

 #

3( 5   # /  

% %





 

(

# %

 ' < *

%  #

 % = * :<

 21   1   '

 ;(  *"2

1) 

2  3 

 " % #  # 

1) 3  2

  1F  

 

 ( #  #

 )

 " # * 7 




 # $)       8"

(

1 #

 "%(  # F
 



(

 #   *8 A ) 21  *"2


1 #  )  %   #  7 *8 

)  " 1F

   

  #

 %     ( 

(

#  

 



 0 3  2 %%  #

 % # '  <  < * #

 * ) 3    <
  

 '

 ;(  *"2 G  

  #  ""2 

 ;(  *"2 #  '

 2"         

 ;(  *"2 1    )

 !

"" 

) 2/

 % # 2  21   #  

 @## ,?

) 

%

 *"2 

1     % #

 %% # #

(

 1   2#     "1 2 %# 

  # ) 

 % #

 *

     "

 

%%

1)  #  "1 2)  

   #  ""2  #



1

 $#

 1   2  1      1  

1 #

 '  
   # 1 '   92)

  #    2

%#1

 %  #



2 (

'  
     '   92) 

  "1 2

:

< * 9" "

# #

(  #    

) :) <  < G-

( 1

(     )  :)  <   < )  21  # #

( 1 1 #   1 #

    

2  3

  % # 8 "

 #"

  #

  #

 1 



(   

   

%% 1 #G

 " #

" #  ""2     1 

  1H 

 !


""  

 3


 

,"  #

 ##



 21

  %I * 2 % # ' < #

 * ) 3  

   1  

 '

;(  *"2 1)

 !


"" 

21   #  

 @## ,?

) 

%

 *"2


1     % #

 %% # #

(

 1   2#     "1 2 %# 

  #  03)   2

# % # ' <  %2 1 " "

#  1  2 #

 % 21

 !


"" -3) ' < * %2  " "

 3  21    2   #

% 1 1 #   '    :

<

 *

 

  (

 # %)

 2 +%  "

(

 (

   %  #"

 "1) 1

  1   1 (

(  ((

  (

  2  

 

< * %  ( #

 # % # '

< * #

 * 3   3

 " "" 3



2        1  % 



( 1

(    '  ) :) <  < )  21  # #

( 1 1 #   1 #

  '  

2  3

  % # 8 "

 #"

  #

  #

 1 9 ( # 

  %# " # 8 "

  2/

3 8% ) "

1) 3 

 " #

" #  ""2  2       1 

  1  3 

 !


""  

 3


  ,"  #

 ##



21  3

  %)



 %% %

%    ' < * 3   %% 1

7  % # ' < *   1 2 %  21  4 .

 ,  0(
   
 !"
#  !!
#$$%&&
' (5!
*!
'!13(
3  3    B * 2 ( #

 2 5  '  "+



   2 

 !


"" # $  #

%

  1  #

 " #

" #  ""2     1 

  1 

 ' <

  "  8%    1 "

21  # #

( %  1 " 2  3

  % # 8 "

 #"

   #  #

 1  %   1

 21  

2

  #

%  1 #

 " #

" #  ""2     1 3

  1I $ "1 2  

'; - A 6  # (

  4 . /("

 ,  0(

 ) 3 "  3

3     <  :

% 21

 0=2  *%8


 J

")   %  21

 %

 

/("     !
  "% ) %

1  3 # 3

 2   % - < #

  /(" ) 3 3     B< $

%

)

2  2 ) 3

 ( 

 "%(    

 

1  #  3   2 %2  #

 %

  "   #

 2   " 

1 ##

 

 #  %     

  "

( 3

  2 %  1 3    3

  2 #   2 1  2  )  %     3    2      #  %     3   2 " 

1 ##  9

( # 

 ( # 2   2  #    #

 1 21 %% 1(  ## 1 +  21 " ( 2 3 3 "

   

) %  % ) ## #"

  3 

 

(  

 ( # 2   2   3     %     9   2(

 #"

(   2( %

 (

       %  #  2  % # ")

(

  2    #   2  % 2  31 # 

  1  

3  % %

#   "  

  (

  (

 !
$  #

  1  #  % #   

  1) 

  "  "%

 

1 

 

   #     



')

 "1 #   %

  ' 





 * :< ) 3   2  2  

3  # #

 "( 5" # " %     *  :

 /  #


  *  7 #




 # $I

A #)

    #

 %

 3

 1( %

 /("   % 5!
*!
%

 21    2   (

 

1 #  '

*"2 1 3 

 " " #

 1 

  1)  

2  $ 5  2   



 #(     % 5!
*!
% )   

(

 #(    

3
!"4 &#
# 5!
*!
'!13() 3  "(

 2  "  % < # 

3
!"4 &#
# 5!  % ) 3  2(

   #

 . ) 

" # (

  /("  ! 


) 3    3 3  2  1  

3
!"4 &#
# 5!
 %

 #

:

)

 /("  

  # 

3
!"4 &#
#
'!13() % 3    %  21

 %

)   1  %   % <

#

  2    #   2  % 2( 31 # 

  1  

3  % %

 #  "  

  (

  ( 21

!


"" # $  #

  1  #    % $

%

'; -

6 : # (

 # /("  "  3

3       : % 21

 0=2  *%8




 *  1   2)

 2/  2  ' < * #

 * )  

 1 1 #

6 1 

1 %   3  3 1 8 "

= %  2  % 9 (  %

 2 %



(   

 '  

%% 1 #

 " #

" #  ""2     1 

  1) 1 +%(  3

     "2( 2/

 % ( % # '

< *)

      1 2 "  2  # 1      21

(      21 31 #  2     2      ' < * #

 *

  2/        # 1 

1

 '

    2 # %  03)

((   %

 ' < * #

 * )  ( %% 2

1 #

 % # ' < * #  %   

1) 3  #  

 1 2/    1 %%    2 %% #"  %  (

#)  

 %

   " 1  %    1 8%  )  8%

 "  2  $  

3

2      2   + 31

 ## # 1 % #

 *

  %%  $ #$% %#
#+


%
)!
"%6%

 %

.708

072)

 2  21

 0=2  '%"
   B9  2        1   31 2  8  3

 %  %   

 ## # 

(



3

   " #   "  $#

 3 #

  "

     %2  #  1   %    %   (""     #

 3

#   2       3

      

 % # %  $  )

  2       2   #1(

 3  %   " 2    2 %  

  "

 ;(  21 31 # 2

    21 31 # "

(

 "2  % #

%  %

  " I  .

%

1 %% )  2 "" %

 2       %% 2




 %H   # 1      

"

 %  #

 ( H

   21 31 #  2     # "

(

 %  #

 (  

 

3

 %  2/  #

 (  ! #

(

 #

 2      %   ( ##    ## ) " 2 % #     ( #

     $

 ( #  #

 %  %

' < * #

 * )   8%       

)    3  2 %

#  5 9     "(

 2 ## 

 

 1 1 & 1 2

 " #

" 

  1)   (  2

 !

"" # $) #"

(

 21  9 ) K  -  3 

 2 " < * ( K  -) #  * 7

 




 # $   ) 3

  

<

9&%*
.28
&" 
3#:%!%# !
!
&#
% %!& !

# &  

2 %%  21

 ,

 

 &  

2 %%  21

, 

  #


# & ) 

&  

 ## (

 %  #

, 

 '

 #

( L + ) & 1   @ )

 

2  &    ( # 2 3 # 3  "1    2   ( #

 3 # #

 ' 
   2+3    1 

 3+

*  .

88 88




 # &  

2 

 1 %2

 ;(  *"2 1 #

 '





88 88



* &  3  # 1 % # 8   "

   ""2 #

 ;(  #

 '

 

 8%  #

%   2  & I 7  "2  % # * 7  " % #   2# 


 . # 0M2  '%"
  
"
) $
:
"%
%6"1:
%
% "
"% +
% %!& 



 #&" 
.7/.'.(

2.2 9       3

 %% " # '

 9- '(  3   ""2 # 

  # ;(  #

 '

# E

  ) 
# &  # E

   9


 . #

 %   % (  !(  $ 3 2

2 1 

&  " 2 ""2 #

  " 2 #  " 8%  )  & )    ""2 #

  "     2  &  #  2# % ( 3

 " (        &  9 
 % (

/("

 0(
 ) /

 

(

%% " # '

 9- '( 
# &   3 #

* 7 




 9 
 %

, 

   %% )  
# & )  %) 3     ""2 #

(  

" # %% " 2


# &   5) 3

 3    ##  
# & ) (

" # 

(  3

  % # 8   "

 #"

  #  %% "  $  
"1 "1%
:
&&
#+
;6
,--.'8(

'%:% (
2--
0M2  '%"


    9  2 #

 8% N#" "( ""2 #

;( N  * 7

   #

 %

 

%   (   2 %%   
# &    &  2

%% " 3  2 ( 21 * 7  ) 3 %         ""2     &  


# & ) 

  "1 2)    (

" # 

 ;(  3

 % # 8   "

) #"

   #  %% "  *

7  )

#)    # %3   2 ( % # %% " #   (    &   #   

  $   

1 

   #  5 #      #  ""2) 3  2 %%   
# &    & ) 

  "1 2)     ##

 (

( " #   3

  % # 8   "

OOO PPP PPP PPP  9  5   " # * 7) 3 3  #

     % #  )   1 ((



1) 1 "  " 2  ""2 #

 ;(  

" # %% "

(  8%  )  ""2 "1 2 (  "  2

 %"

     & )  (  2  ""2) #    % # 8   "

 2 "

 (

 ;(  

 "3

 *  &"2 #


 # & ) 1 &   

 %2

 ;(  *"2 1 *
 # &  %%  (

" #  ;(  *"2 1 3     ##  ( 

1    /1

 # #

;(  *"2 1 * % %%    & ) 

 


# & ) 3     ""2 #

 ;( ) 3

3      &  "

#) (  (   % # 8   "

 #   %% " ) (

" #

;(  *"2 1  #  #   )  "



  2  &  %% " #   %) 3  # (    ""2 3

 % # ( # 8   "

) 3   1 %

 5   " # *

7 2 3    #  2

 2 %%  # %  %2 ," J"



 21 %2(

" "

# N8   "

N ( 3   (  &  " (

;(    1  

  (   2 %"

 "  &  # 1 % 21 8   "

)

 (

(   

 "3

 (  21

  2#

 8%1 #

 % # 8   "

)  #

3 21  

( ) 3  

%"

"

 2 %%   &   ( 3

 (

(

(  (

" #

 ;(  *"2 1  N% (N #  (   &  # N8 "

N 3



2(    ""2   1   "  #

 

 (

" #

  ;(  *"2 1 $

8   # #

   2  (

" #   3

 % # ( # N8   "

N 9  % (  % #

    $ )  3  "   2  & ) #    (  (

 % # 8 "

  M% (M  


# &   3  

  %%  9 #)   %"2  # ##

# & )  %%

 "    & ) 3



" (

(  ) (

" #

 " "2 1 9  "   2  & ) # (  % # 8   "

)   ( 3

  %% "   

 "2 1 9   ( # 
# & ) (

" #

 " "2 1 3 )

#) 2 #  5  # 

    9 %"

 

 2 %%  (

" #

 " (  "2

1) 3



(

(   (

 % # 8   "

) 3  2 2 # % " 1 "1 ' * 7  %     #   (  &      ## 21  % # 8   "

) 3

 2(  )  "  

   %%    &   * 7

 2(  ""2 #

 ;(  "

  2  &      3

 8   "



 %% (

 



 (

(  ) 3 )

#) 2  2 #


 %  2 # 

 (  !1 &  " 3  

 1) 

1  

1) #"

 %

 ( 

 !

  !  "

2 %  # * 7  3   3

  %  %%    & ) 3  

"   ""2 #

( )  2"  &     



"

 

    &  #  "

 8   "

)    2  (  

"3

 9  

 %  %"

( % %% "  #

   & ) 3

 (

( 

 "3

) 3   1 "+ * 7  ( 1 2

3    2  

 2 %"  1( *

7 $ 3 

    #

 J( J



 %      2  &  3

 2(  1  ) 21 %  %% " ) 

" #  % # 8   "

 $#

 3 %"

)   (    21 % %% "  "  &   #

   " #

*"2 1   %  3

1 % 2   1 % " 1 1 " # ,"  '   3  2  1

 2 %%  # "1)   #  # 


 9   #

 #" #




   

%% "  #    % # 8   "

)  2 %"

2 # 

(

"% N%% " NOOOI A $ )

) "#

 & 6
# & )

  ##) % 8%  #

 % # 8 "

) #    2"  ""2 #

 '

 ;(  *"2

1) 3

  % # 8 "

 9 #)    5 " ( #"

 # %    * 7

 




 # $ 

  %  %%    & 6
# &    '

   %      ""2

 '

 ;(  *"2 1)

      

 % )     +    *"2 

  % # 8 "

 #"

     + 

: !

1) '

 &  ;

 %
# &  #

 '

 # 01)    ( ( 3

  # & 

 ,) 

   

  (  3 %  21

, 3

## #"

  # '25

1) '



:

&  ; ) 3  3     &"2 # ;(  *"2

1) #"  ) ( #"

  

 

 *- ) 3 3 %  21

 0=2  '%+) 01   '2 )   *-

 #)

21 "+(

     9  3
2  '

 -2 '( ')
# & ) + 

   '

 '    ""2 #

 ;(  *"2 1)

#)  " # * 7 




 # $)

  2 (  (

" #     ""2 #

 '

;(  *"2 1 3

 8 "

 # +( 



# &   3

 8 "

 #"

 $

%%

 

1 

  1 1  2 # ( # 21   (

 #

" " #

 3 "2
# &  2(

  1 

 1 2(  2 )  #

 2 # 3

 "%(  # *8 

 (

  

1) 

  

 %  !


"" # $)  1 #



 "  # * 7 




 # $  $#

    

 2   

1 #  )  (

 2   21

  #

 %

)

 

3  2

  

1 

" %  

  "

" #

 '

 ;(  *"2 1   -"2) ) %

  2

1 #

 1 9 2(

% )

 !


"" # $)  2 

 ""

 1    (

 21





1 #  ) (

 "  # *

7 




 # $ *(

1) 

 ( #  #

 % ) 

 % # *

7        #

 !


"" # $) #  ( ( #   #

   #  

1 

 '

 ;(  *"2 1 K  -  3 ( 1       # 1 2  

 2"

  #

 %



 

!


"" # $)  %(   21  #  *"2 1


1)  " 1 

(

  #     *8 A  $

"1 2  

  #     *8 A

 2  21

 !


"" # $ #

(

   # *+   *"2 1


1 # & 

) +%(  3

 /(" %   % 5!
*!
'!13( $   3) "  # *8 A # 3

(    2    2  " 1 

 %

 !


"" # $) " ) 3 

 "   %   /

 % 21

 -(% .

 ."21 0(


     1 

 !


"" # $) 

 3 

 K  -  3  (   *

  ()

  #

 %



    ("

 %% 3  2  21 (    #      3

  1 

 " 3      8%  



'

 8 5) "% 1" #   "%3 # "% (

   %() " ) 3 

 ,

!



 '

 ;(  *"2 1 

 '

 # 01)   

 "

# -"2)     

 # 2" #

  #

 %

) 3) 3   # 1 # 

 ") %

1 

(

 /("

 21

 0=2  '%"


  # $#
<$
1  "
:!
 *&%#
#$$%!!%#
+


%
,-.=

'(
,>02
3   "

 2/  3

 3 21 2(  
BOO

    #

  "  

 +%  

1 "( %  9   8% 3

(  

 8 5  2

    ( $   2

 %  "1



 

 #

% OOI  ;  #

 %

    %    

 /("

  + 0(
  %
 
  &"
)!
&"
"% +
 *&%#
#$$%!!%#%   7  A   :  A) 2

 "  #  %

" 

  /("   ( 2   #   #

")

   /("

 4 .

,

0(



  

 !"
#  !!
#$$%&& 5!  % ) 3 

  2(

      21

  + 0(


  # %
 
  &"5!

% 



< $ 3 #

 2) #(  "

 %

%

)

 "  21 " 7 *

%( %%   # 1 ) 

  % # ' 
(









' 
  (
   */1  6   
 
  Q6-   

    Q6-