Surinder Singh Vaid And ORS. v. U.T. Chandigarh And ORS.




   
 

!"#$#%&'&()* * +,-&($#-+&(./0!&$!($"/#-'

 #"&"&(#-'

0#-','

(&(#--&"-12/!($&.!-/!($!("/#-  #'3($#("'

)  45  +
6 5
+


-#'#(") -6!(7!89&"+&(./2+#(&-$:%!"#27&"/2 -+ !($/!7!2$:%!"#2-"/#3#"&"&(#-' -+-2 ,;8&% -'#%,"-2 --#'3($#(" (&(#--&"-12/!($&.!-/ -++6!"(-&!2$:%!"#2--#'3($#("  </#"/#-"/# #3-"#-'8%!8(#7'3!3#-=!1;#!887#$"'## "/#9,$.=#(">  ;#-##--#$""/# #3-"#--("  </#"/#-"/#9,$.=#("'/,8$;#-#3-"#$&("/#$&.#'">   5
+
2

#"&"&(#-'27/!-#&%&!8'&%#-' (7-#"&-#$ "/#

,(9!;  +"!"#  3#-!"&:#  !(?  5&=&"#$  &(   '/-"  4"/#   !(?4 2 +#%"-2/!($&.!-/2/!:#&8#$"/&'3#"&"&(-@,!'/&(.

$!"#$ 

A2-#.&'"#-#$,($#-+#%"&('!($*
  !"  8&%#  +"!"&(  #("-!82    /!($&.!-/  C  /#1/!:#!8'',./""/#@,!'/&(."/#',==(&(.-$#-$!"#$ D

 2  3!''#$  ;1  "/#  8#!-(#$  ,$&%&!8 !.&'"-!"#'"8!''2/!($&.!-/

 %=;&(#$-#!$&(."/#
&(@,#'"&(!'7#88!'"/# !338&%!"&( ((#B,-#' C!($ A-#'3#%"&:#81 '/7'"/!" != 5!82!&88&&("/#&'"-&%",-"'2/!($&.!-/27!'#("-,'"#$7&"/"/# #B#%,"&(    7!--!("'    3''#''&(  !.!&('"  "/#  ,(9!;  +"!"# 3#-!"&:#  !(?  5&=&"#$2  + '    2  +#%"-2 /!($&.!-/ ,$.=#("#;"-  
"%=#',""/!""/#'!&$!&88& !%%=3!(&#$;1 !8$#:6-&'/!( #%-##8$#- !($'=#"/#- 3#-'(':&'&"#$"/#3-#=&'#'!(?-#B#%,"&(."/#7!--!("' 3''#''&(+,-&($#-+&(./0!&$2!(!.#-"/#'!&$!(?2"8$ "/#'!&$!&88&"%("!%"/&'!(!.&(.&-#%"-  /#-#!"#-2 "/#'!&$!&88&7#("""/#&%#"/#"/#'!&$!(?27/#-# "/#"/#'!&$!(?$&$("=##"/&=2-!"/#-/&' "8$/&= "/!""/#-#!-#'"!

1-$#-'-="/#,-" /#'!&$!&88&%!=# ;!%?  "  "/#  3-#=&'#'      !(?  +/-&  !.$##3  +,-&2  +#(&- %%,("!("2!"#-:#-&&%!"&(-=/&'8!71#-2%!=#!")* !($ "8$"/#'!&$!&88&!($"/#$#%-##/8$#-"/!""/#1$("/!:#!(1 '"!1-$#-!"3-#'#("2;,""/#17,8$/!:#;"!&("/#'!=#-="/# &.

A</#("/#'!&$!&88&"-&#$"$#8&:#-"/# 3''#''&(2"/#!%%,'#$-#'&'"#$"/#'!=#!($'"!"#$"/!""/#17&88 ("!887$#8&:#-1"/#3''#''&(/##=381##'"/#!(? -!&'#$'8.!('&(8,$:&%#!.!&('""/#$#%&'&("/#,-" != 5!82!&88&!8(.7&"/"/#$#%-##/8$#-!8$#:6-&'/!(7#-#8%?#$ &('&$#"/#!(?!($"/#17#-#"8$"/!"&"/#1"-&#$".#""/#;!(? :!%!"#$2"/#("/#-#7,8$;#;8$'/#$/!.+&(./2"/#.,!-$

 "/#!(?'"$&(-(""/#=!&(.!"#!8(.7&"//&'.,(!($'!&$ "/!"/#&';,($;1"/#-$#-'/&'&%#-'!($/#7,8$&-#"/# .,(&"/#(##$!-&'#'/#'!&$!&88&!($"/#$#%-##/8$#-7#-# ("!887#$"%=#,"-="/#!(?;1"/#&%#-'&%&!8'!($ "/#17#-#?#3"%(&(#$&('&$#"/#!(?/#(2!"!;,"*)

2 "/#!&88&!($"/#$#%-##/8$#-7#-#!887#$"%=#,""/# !(?  (81  !"#-  "/#1  =!$#  -#3#!"#$  -#@,#'"'  -  "/#  '!=# /#-#!"#-2"/#.!"#"/#!(?7!'8%?#$ 8!-.#(,=;#- #=381##'"/#-;-!(%/#'"/#!(?!8'-#!%/#$"/#!(? !($-!&'#$'8.!('!""/#'3"/#'!&$!&88&!%%-$&(.81=:#$ !(!338&%!"&(;#-#"/#+#(&-+,;,$.#2/!($&.!-/2=!?&(.! %=38!&(""/#=!""#-27/&%/7!'-7!-$#$""/#38&%#2(7/&%/ "/#3-#'#("%!'#7!'-#.&'"#-#$
/!:#/#!-$"/#8#!-(#$%,('#8-"/#3!-"&#'!($/!:# !8'%!-#,881.(#"/-,./"/#&8# 5#!-(#$  '#(&-  %,('#8  -  "/#  3#"&"&(#-'  /!' :#/#=#("81  !-.,#$  "/!"  &(  "/&'  %!'#2  "/#  3#"&"&(#-'  !-#  "/# #=381##'"/#'!&$!(?/#1/!$(3#-'(!8&("#-#'"
(!%"2 "/##9#%"=#(""/#!(?7!'-$#-#$;1"/#87#-,-"!'7#88!' ;1"/#!33#88!"#,-"!($"/!""/#'!&$!(?/!$=:#$""/#&./ ,-"&( #.,8!-+#%($33#!8&# + 

A
"&'

'"!"#$"/!""/#'"!1-$#-7!'.-!("#$(

A   /#3-#'#("%%,--#(%#&''"!"#$";#

A
"&'%(%#$#$ "/!"("/#$!1%%,--#(%#2"/#-#7!'('"!1-$#-
"7!'

 !-.,#$"/!""/#3#"&"&(#-/!$#!-8&#-&8#$  *  

A2&(7/&%/"/&',-"2:&$#-$#-$!"#$

   2/!$$&'=&''#$"/#3#"&"&(!'("3-#''#$7&"/!$&-#%"&(""/# +#(&-  +,3#-&("#($#("  

8&%#  "  %('&$#-  "/# -#3-#'#("!"&(!338&%!"&(  $!"#$  *

A2  &8#$  ;1  "/#  !(!.#-2

,(9!;  +"!"#  3#-!"&:#  !(?2  +#%"-2  /!($&.!-/  !($ $#%&$#  "/#  '!=#  !"#-  /8$&(.  ',%/  &(@,&-1  !'  /#  =!1  $##= (#%#''!-1,($#-"/#%&-%,='"!(%#'"/#%!'#
"&''"!"#$"/!"&( 3,-',!(%#"/#'!&$-$#-2!(&(@,&-17!'/#8$!($ #3-"$!"#$ 

  7!'3-#3!-#$2&(7/&%/"/#%!(%#88!"&( -#3-"  7!'  -#%==#($#$  
"  &'  ,-"/#-  '"!"#$  "/!"  7/#(  "/# %!(%#88!"&(-#3-"7!'',;=&""#$2"/#'!=#7!'33'#$;1"/# %=38!&(!("!&88&'!1&(."/!"/#&'("'!"&'&#$7&"/"/#-#3-"!($ 3-!1#$-,-"/#-&(:#'"&.!"&(/#-#!"#-2"/#8#!-(#$!.&'"-!"# 3!''#$"/#',==(&(.-$#-$!"#$D

/#-#8#:!("#B"-!%"

-="/#'!=#&'-#3-$,%#$;#87) E
/!:#3#-,'#$"/#&8#  -="/#!88#.!"&('

=!$#&("/#%=38!&("2&"!33#!-'"/!""/#!%%,'#$/!:# %==&""#$#(%#,'DC2*222*A
7/&8# %=38!&(!(" !=5!87!'$&'%/!-.&(./&'&%&!8$,"1 5#"!88"/#!%%,'#$;#',==(#$- 

F
"&''"!"#$"/!""/#'!&$-$#-&'!(('3#!?&(.-$#- !($"/!""/#-#7!'(3-"#'"3#"&"&(&8#$;1"/#'!&$!&88&
"/!' ;##(3-!1#$"/!""/#'!&$-$#-=!1;#@,!'/#$-!"8#!'"2"/# %!'#'/,8$;#-#=!($#$;!%?

*   3#-,'!8    "/#  &(@,&-1  -#3-"  $!"#$  



 '/7'"/!" !=5!82!&88&2'"$;1/&''"!"#=#("

;#-# "/# #3,"1 +,3#-&("#($#("    8&%#2  7/ %($,%"#$ "/# &(@,&-1:#($,-&(."/#&(@,&-12&"/!$%=#,""/!""/#'!&$!&88& 7!'$#"!&(#$2;,"&"7!'/#8$"/!"$,#"'#%,-&"1-#!'('2"/#.-&88 .!"#"/#!(?7!'%8'#$!""/#"&=#%8'&(."/#%!'/2;,""/# '!&$!&88&2$,#"'=#=&',($#-'"!($&(.(/&'3!-"2"?&"!'/&' $#"#("&(
"7!''"!"#$"/!""/##1#7&"(#''#'/!:#("',33-"#$ "/#:#-'&("/#'!&$!&88&/#-#-#2"/#%!(%#88!"&(-#3-"7!' -#%==#($#$
"!8'%=#',""/!"&("/#%&:&88&"&.!"&(3#($&(. ;#-#"/&',-";#&(. + 

A2"/#'!&$!(?!($ "/#$#%-##/8$#-#("#-#$&("!%=3-=&'#2,($#-7/&%/"/#'!&$ !(?!.-##$":!%!"#"/#3-#=&'#'7&"/&((#1#!-2!'%=&(.," -="/#-$#-3!''#$;1"/&',-"( 

D   /#-#-#2 &"%=#'," "/!"(7"/#$#%-##/8$#-&''!"&'&#$ /,'2/#7&88;#"/#8!'"3#-'("',33-""/#%=38!&(""/#'!&$ !&88& 72  "/#  @,#'"&(  7,8$  !-&'#  7/#"/#-  !(1  7-&""#( 3-"#'"3#"&"&(&'!%($&"&(3-#%#$#("-3!''&(.!(1-$#-("/# %!(%#88!"&(-#3-">
&($"/#-#381&((#.!"&:#:#(&"/#3-"#'"3#"&"&(&' ("&8#$2"/#,-"&';,($"%('&$#-"/#-#3-""/#38&%# ,($#-+#%"&(A- 2"/#'"!"#=#("'7&"(#''#'-#%-$#$ ,($#-+#%"&(C- !($"/#$%,=#("'38!%#$(&8#
("/#

C 3-#'#("%!'#2"/#'!&$!&88&7!'!%"&(.&($&'%/!-.#/&'&%&!8 $,"&#'!($/#/!$(&887&88!($#(=&"1!.!&('";!(?&%&!8'# /!$'3#%&&%!881%=38!&(#$"/!"/#!8(.7&"/"/#$#%-##/8$#-7!' $#"!&(#$G  "/#  .!"#'  7#-#  %8'#$  !($  "/#  .,!-$    "/#  ;!(? "/-#!"#(#$"&-#2&"/#(#%#''&"1!-&'#' :#("/#'8.!('7#-# !8'-!&'#$!.!&('""/#-$#-'"/#,-"/#'!&$!&88&7!'8#" !"*)

(81!"#-/&'-#3#!"#$-#@,#'"'/#'"-1%8'&(. "/#.!"#-'#%,-&"1-#!'($,#"%8'&(.%!'/&'"/#$##(%# '"-1    "/#  ;!(?  &%&!8'   /#-#-#2  "/#  &(@,&-1  -#3-"  $!"#$ 

  %!((";#"!?#(!'.'3#8"-,"/:#( &("/#'!&$&(@,&-12"/#!88#.!"&('$#"#("&("/#'!&$!&88& 7#-#3-:#$"/,./2"/##B38!(!"&(7!'',./"";#.&:#(
("/#'#%&-%,='"!(%#'2
!="/#:&#7"/!"#:#(&"/# '!&$!&88&$&$("&8#!7-&""#(3-"#'"3#"&"&(!($(81=!$#! '"!"#=#(""/!"/#&'("'!"&'&#$7&"/"/#-#3-"2"/#,-"2!"#- #B!=&(&(."/#-#3-",($#-+#%"&(A- 2"/#'"!"#=#("' "/#  7&"(#''#'  -#%-$#$  ,($#-  +#%"&(  C  -   !($  "/# $%,=#("'38!%#$(&8#2%,8$3!''"/#',==(&(.-$#-:#( "/,./"/#-$#-&'("$#"!&8#$(#2;,"&"'/7'"/!""/#8#!-(#$ !.&'"-!"#/!$!338&#$/&'=&($""/#!%"'"/#%!'#,-&(."/# "-&!82&"&'(""/#@,!("&"1;,""/#@,!8&"1#:&$#(%#27/&%/=!""#-'
"&'(""/#8!7"/!""/#'"!"#=#("'&(.8#7&"(#''&'("";# -#8&#$,3(/#$##(%#"/#!%%,'#$%!((";#%('&$#-#$!" "/#'"!.#',==(&(./#-#-#2"/#-#&'(&88#.!8&"1-&(&-=&"1

A &("/#&=3,.(#$-$#-$!"#$D

 2:&$#7/&%/ "/#%!(%#88!"&(-#3-"7!'-#9#%"#$!($"/#8#!-(#$!.&'"-!"#"? "/#%.(&H!(%#"/#%!'#!($',==(#$"/#!%%,'#$ 5#!-(#$  '#(&-  %,('#8  -  "/#  3#"&"&(#-'  /!'  -#8&#$ ,3("/#!,"/-&"&#'"/#(4;8#+,3-#=#,-"&( 
  

             -&=&(!8 D!($     

  



  

  -&=&(!8 AC!'7#88!'!,"/-&"1"/&',-"&(

   

 

  ! 

   -&=&(!8 D   /#  8#!-(#$  '#(&-  %,('#8  /!'  ,-"/#-  -#8&#$  ,3(  "/# !,"/-&"188!/!;!$&./,-"&( "  

 "    

 

 #     

D-&5CAA  3#-,'!8    "/#'#  !,"/-&"&#'  '/7'  "/!"  "/#'#  !-# -#.!-$&(.$&#-#("!%"' 
"$#3#($',3("/#!%"'#!%/%!'# 7/#"/#-&"&'!&"%!'#-@,!'/&(.-("/#!%"'"/#3-#'#(" %!'#!-#$&'"&(.,&'/!;8##-#"/#&%#-"/#,-"/!$.(#" "/#!(?"#B#%,"#"/#7!--!("'3''#''&(!($/#!8(.7&"/ "/#$#%-##/8$#-7!'8%?#$&('&$#;1"/#;!(?&%&!8' /# $##(%#8%?&(."/#.!"#-'#%,-&"1-#!'($,#"%8'&(. %!'/&'";##B!=&(#$(=#-&"$,-&(."-&!8/#-#-#2#:#(&( "/#-7&"(#''',33-"'"/#3-'#%,"&(%!'#2"/#,-"&'"#B!=&(# "/#'"!"#=#(""/#'!&$!&88&!%%=3!(&#$;1"/#$%,=#("'" '##7/#"/#-"/#!88#.#$%%,--#(%#&'3-:#$-(" 
("/#'# %&-%,='"!(%#'2
$("&($!(1=#-&"&("/#3-#'#("3#"&"&(!($"/#

D '!=#&'$&'=&''#$ #-#  3!-"&(.  7&"/  "/#  -$#-2  &"  %=#'  ,"  "/!"  "/# 3-#'#("3#"&"&(7!'&8#$&("/#1#!-

2&(7/&%/3-%##$&(.'

;#-#"/#"-&!8,-"7#-#'"!1#$/#-#-#2&"&'#B3#%"#$"/!"(7 "/#"-&!8,-"7&88$&'3'#"/#%!'##B3#$&"&,'81

5
+
   * * '9?'