High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1448/2000disposed of

State Of Hy. v. Shyame Etc.

2026-05-15Mr. Justice Parmod Goyal8 pages

!"#$%&'

' (

!$%$)%*#$%&+'

+' (

& ,-

! " # " $ %& ''(( & )**+&%,--- .

# /"0!&1 %& ''(( & ,2*2&%,--- $. // 3 ("0!&1 %&'&0 & '' (

-.' /.( 1&0 '' ( ! '%0 $ ''(( 50%0 / //!0 $6.0/70 0)+ -* )889' 0

$( 000& (&.

:.0/" .

"3 $.%&01( & 3 '7 6.1&'%0 $'&05'( %%3 010 0

$6.0/7 0010 0-) )- )888' 0 $( 0 1:.0/"

#./. 7" 3 $ % '' ( '%0 $ ''(( 50%0 3 070 1 0'.!&(!0 & '' (01 (" $ / 0100 $ 3 $ &% 1&77& 6.0/7 & ; &% %1" % 1" ( %($" / ;%&7 & )**+&%

,---(0

, ''(( !1 ((/0%0/1&00 $( 0<&.

(&3 &0 0 0 ,) )8=8 ' 0 $ .'(.51.75/ <&((1&01( /( 0 .'(. 0&%( 0&33 73 / '&!&&%.6 1.$&% 0. 1")892> %%0& ?/+*0@A 0 1 ((/&&0 0 0,) )8=8 $3 $&%.%(0&,+ )- )8+=7 ( 0&

0 $(7 & /.0 ( 0<&. (&3 !0/!/

&!5&0 %0/ 3 &. 1&0/ !01 ! ( ( & 1&0 %1 7 0 & %%0 !B ''(1 & 7 0 $ '&05 '( %%5( 0&3 %& <&((1& & ,) )8=8 1 &&/ '7 ( 0 /.0 &1 '&05'( %%5 ( 0&3 7(% 01 & '7 ( " &''0%&7 0$/ 7 01 &17 0 $ 7 %& <&((1& %& ' /&%&00 0,) )8=8 0/ 0 %& 1&1(.& 0 3 $ ( 0<&. (&3&&. 0'! * 01&.(%&'&05'( %%& & 0 /.0 & ''&00 )9 -* )892"'&05'( %%3 &

/( 0&3!3&%0%&&%( 0.01&+&%)8921 0 ( 0.0 ".07&/ /&( 03

0 1 & ; &

1&0 & 0 & C1(.00 3 ( 07/ .'(. ( 0 .'(.51.75/ <&((1& 3 ( ' / &0 0 0 ,) )8=8 00 $1(.0/.1 ( 0 0& &%1(.&&% .1 ( 0" '&05'( %%5( 0 &3 3 01( 0 / ( 0&3 &/1(.&&% / 7 0 &%)89217 ; &0 0 0,) )8=8 0 73 / '1%1 '&!&&%)8921 '1 " & <&. (&3 !0.($&0!01 (0 $'&05'( %% '&%C )&*"!.1&0 0' /& ( 0&30 $'&05 '( %% 1 &%'&05'( %% &30( 0 !(( / 7($ / (" : 6.; 0 ' / !(( / / ("

'&05'( %% 08, / -2 3 7 !(( /: 6.; "

0,D / 0)=5)B, 3 &%( 0 0 !(( / ' / "

0-8 / &%( 0 7 .'(.51.75/ <&((1&!0 &00 0,) )8=8 0 ; ( 01&0 & 0 1&1(.00 '&05'( %%3 '&&&%28 0 0 1 ),5)B,.&%( 0 0 0 11&0/($ ((&30,9 0 0 1 '7 ( 0 001( 0)* 0 0 1),5)B,.&%( 0 .'(.( 0 = (&&0&.

" 1( ($7 0&. $'( 0/ 0 !01&% & ' (($&01( &3 7 0 $( 0 &3.01&95&%)892101(&/( 0.0 7&

.'(. 3 )8=8%& %7"3 &31 .&10 0 ,* -D )8=83 .0&'&05'( %% $ !. . & .01&95<&%)8921"'&05'( %% 0 070 !/ 1&1 (0 ( 0 %&7 / 01( 0 .'(. 1 &0 0 0 ,) )8=83 ' 0.01&95<&%)8921" <&((1& 7'&0 ' ($&%-9 0 0 1 0 0 ((&30&($,9 0 0 1 '7 ( & '&05'( %% 0 001( 0)* 0 0 1),5)B,.&%( 0 .'(. & 0" '&05'( %% 1( 7/ 07 &&%.'(. $<&((1&!0&00 0,) )8=8 / '&!

&&%)8921 0 %& 0 & 0" 1 &% ''(( 50%0 1 '&05'( %% 7(% 01 & '7 ( $%(/ %%0 !" %&" &''0%&71 ((// 0&00 0 ,) )8=8 + & ( 0<&. !/ ($1&1(.00 1&%%(/ %%0 ! $ '&05'( %% ( 0&3 1 & &' &''( / / &%'&05'( %% '7 $0.$&% . && ' &0(3 '&!&&% ..03 . & C1/ '&3 %&" E.& 3 &0' 0 $<&((1& 11&0 13 '&!&&% )8921& 3 ' !

&0 &!"'&05'( %% 0( 0 !(( / 7($ / (": 6.; 0 ' / !(( / / ("'&05 '( %% 08, / -2 3 7 !(( /: 6.; " 0,D

/ 0)=5)B, 3 &%( 0 0 !(( / ' / " 0-8

/ &%( 0 7 &0&'&! .&%( 0&0 &!"

'&05'( %% 0 0.($ C 70 7 ; " 3 (E.

/ ( 5)"3 & 00.($'&!0 0 C )&*' /&( 01&7'0!. &% !(( / 7($" / (": 6.; 0 ' / )- & 0"3 1( 7&% ''(( 50%0 ( 03 01( 0.'(.& '&7 0 $ 3 " &3! 0'&3 & 00.10!01 %& ( 0<&. (&3 %&" &($ 7 ( ! ( ( & 1&0 0 ' / & ( 0 &30 $ '&05'( %% & )9 -* )892" ''&00 3 / &!( 0 01$ ((F0 " %&"& 3 &)9 -* )892"'&05'( %%3

/( 0&3& ( 0 &(0/33 '7 ((7 )) % 0 ( 0 1&10" $0&&% ((3 '.!3&%( 30%0.01& ,>+A&%)8921 . (&%1&,>+A&%)8921 &3 ( 0

/0 7 7 / .6 1$ 1 )8+D > %%0& ?

1*0@A 1&*>)A&%)++D1 0%0 ( 0 ( 03 &&11.'0 &% $ .(0/ &3&

(

!(( / 0&11.'0& (%%& /1.(. ('.'&&%& '.'&.

!& /1.(.&%&' . 01(.0 &%

.(0/ 0& .1.&.1 ( 0 '&!&&%1&,>+A&% )8921 03 1&*>)A&%)++D13 0.($1&00 $ &@ (.'7<&. )% 23 456 ' 3%4%*347$553 3$%!.

4!84%4")8D8:)+, 095!3%:26 '040$;4!84%4")88->)A <<,,D 'C<&. 0 (0 0 ( 01 & ;& 11&.3 (1 (1.( /.'(. .0 1 1 .& / &11.'0 &(%& /1.(. ( '.'&&%& '.'&.

!& /1.(. $3'1%1 (($%&.0& & 1&!0 $'&!&&%1&,>+A&%)8921" %&"1&.(0& !

1(.0007 &&%.'(. ), %&"'1 " 0

( 01&.(0& ! 1(.00%&07/.'(.( 0 $ <&((1&3 (' /&00 0,) )8=8 & 7'3 7 0& C1(.0.1 ( 0 $<&((1&3 (' /&00 0,) )8=8 )2 7 (& /73 '( 0 $( 01&.(%& '&05'( %% '1 %&7'&&&%' ($&%-9 1 .0 '&!& &% 1& 95< &% )8921" & &1 %& 7'&&&%.1 ' ($3 /!&( 0&3 0 %& 73 !&( &&%'1'(&% . (6.1 &1.0.01&95< &%)89213 &($%&07 &&%.'(. 0&%&' ($ %&"'1 ' ($&%-9 1&%( 0&%'7 (

7'&0 $<&((1&!0 &00 0,) )8=81 & . 0 7!&( &&%'1'(&% . (6.1 0 4%043%:26 '040$; )%94<4%# ! '")8=8:9*D"3 (0 &1/ 0/'&10/%&.'(. & &1%&7'&/ ' ($ 3 %. (0 %&0.1&'7 ( &1 / 0/' ($7 0 &$E.7 )* %&"!3&%&5C1(.&&%( 03 3 #

& 3(( 7'&&&%' ($3 &.&1 7 ;&00 0,) )8=8"01( /( 0.'(."( (& 0

/ 1 &%'1'(&% . (6.13 ( ' / &0 0 0 ,) )8=8 0 7 !&( & &% '1%1 '&!&&%)89213 C1(.0# 0 ( 0%&7&' & &7!01(0 $'&05'( %% C ) &C *"1( ($7 0&. ( /1 .;&%( 03 #

& 03 & C1(.00%&07 &&% .'(. 0 &% '&05'( %% !(( / / ("

'&05'( %% 08, / -2 3 &%( 0&.&%3 ,- / )) 3 3 0-9 3 &%( 03 7( ($!(( /: 6.; "'&05'( %% 0,D / 0)=G

3 &%( 0&.&%3 -8 / 0))G 3 &%( 03

"3 !(( / ' / -+ / &%( 03 &3!" ( 03 3&/($1(.00%&07 &&%.'(. !3&% &!&0% 10.($'&!0 $3 $&%!01"1( ($ 7 0&. & <&. !/ ($1&7&1&1(.& &0

0 0,) )8=83 ( (& 0 / 0 / '1'(&% . (6.1 3(( '&!&&%)8921 &3!" (%/ 0 $<&. (&30& 7&0%0 $/ 0&0 0 0,) )8=8" 07 &&%.'(. 1 &1&7& 0 71 & 070 $<!(<&. 0 7 0& 5 ''1 0 $ . & 0.'(. 0& 070 ' (7&%( 0&3 0 11&0/($3 (.'

&(0// 0&% 7'./0&00 0,) )8=8" (0 . &$ (( %& 07.'(. 0&%( 0&3 11&0 13 ( 3 %/!/&1& ((1&10 ''&!&&%)8921B $ <(/& 0&(0/1")8D, )9 '' ( 0'&0&% &!7 )= 0/ ''(1 &>A"% $" 00'&0&% &&1&'$&% 6.0/7 '( 10& %(&%1&101

- +'

+' (