← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/440/2021dismissed

State Of Haryana And Others v. Hari Ram

2024-05-08Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji10 pages

 





       



!

"#$%&''

#$#($) "#$%*''                   %  +

' ,',',-.   ,  + ,' ,     

 ! "  # " "   

   $  "%&"     ''''' ',',/$"0/1/23/.)43$503 6(43)  /2 ( ) &     *      ,-, ./012(3042(1& 4242 6     &  6    , 7  %&   6     & 2( (2 )     , -,  &  &  +,  8.     &/ 3/$"/$ //" /$" /$#40  !' 782#9  :

 4# /$/574' #6  /$" /$#40 . 42(34 . 9::

   "  6     &  +   6 , 7& 6 & ; < " 6   6  < , 76 & ; <  ,6 =>   6% "  <6   & 5?      , 6 

2- )   ,-,    & 6   +   ,  2( (995<  %&6       2( 2( (99=    ,      49 (( 4223 6   %&<6 <& 6,6  0   &  .  % @ " . &"# ,  )       , 7 ,% 6   6   &     (995 +   <  , 7   & 2( (2  "   ,6 &    0   6   ,              !    , < ,   <  6  *< . 6 ./A 94=34223" 6 &      & &    < .  ./A 5(( (99? 

     " <   < <  , 7   & 2( (2 4225 6 8      24 (4 4223 

8  0:     < 

% , <  8       6   !+    , 

8 0="B 6 

8 01"  

8 0?   < 

8 09%  % 6     <   ,-, ) <+&  &  %+,  (( 422=

8 04"  &-,"A  6      0            <   , 7  ,   <  .% .    49 422=       < <  +&

.    %  <  & & < &   < & %   0    

3- & 49 422=",  ,   , 7 " <  "   "  , 6   42(1 & 6 + :

        <  6 ,     6       < < ,    & 49 422=< .%-, %

"A " &     &              + &  <    ,  &  25 (2 ) .% .      &   &    25 (2 4225   ,    &     )  6  . & & &     <   , 7         &      &   2( (2 4225   %,   &< ,  , 7   ,   &    <  .  &, ) 4/ 9.,4/4 #6;/ $/4/<//$"#40 !' 7/ !3 /$"#40 .422=3..(   " ,  :4 :5  +,  & 6 .

 "6 &     0 C:4 A  "6 ,  < &      & & " 6    &   "     "< <        %&    6    &   D  8" ;  6    &<  %   &         + & "  6 <       &  .  ! &  .   %  !   #% ,!  A  .,E(9=4 4.(33F &     6         &&, )  .

4-    ,             ,, %   , ,        &  && &   & < %    & ,%        &     &

  6  %   &< , ,   <    < <     ,     :5 G & <&    <&6    ,    ,  8     A    "   A +   "   !

A, +  "     ,  (:<%" ;     & %& , %<    %& 6        < 6      %        &      <   )  ;   , 7      %&  &   %<&     ,    &< .  &<%    ,  +, D & 8" H  D "   #%                 , 7       "    %&  &  ,   "6 %6         & <   &%   &    <               ,  &          %&  &   ; < " &6       6,   < , 6   &<  6 8     /&   , 7 "

  "< <+&"  <  <  +, " <      <      <  ,     ;    , 7 ,   ,  "      &  &  I = ) 6 .   %6  &6  <   ! <<  .%. " &6  0&0.

6   "   "  6  ; ;&         6 ,    ,  & %&  ) &    6 

5-   & 6,   % +&6, 6 6  .  !    /  . "   & 6 <     2( 42(3<   % # J.K  JK "6 &  %<  , 7"6<,%  & &  &

  )      2( 42(3 

8  05 6" "   && &   6    & / . 6   &  

?

 6     "  6     K&6 <<&    , 7 %6        44 (( 422=  <   & -," A  

8  04    6   &  & & &"  &  6 < ,  

   &  <  6  ,    6       ,          < &  

 % , < ,  ,        44 (( 422="   6    6" " ,  <  ,4/4 #6/ 9/$//$"#40 !'/213$"

,3$50/$" #40 . 42454  .

  .% 55=" 6         & < , "    < ,  < *<  .   ,  , 7 <&   &       D 6 &      , ,   &    , 7

)  % < %    C((?

  , %6  ,4/4 #6;/ $/4/</ =' '';

/ 3  #40 .  > , ?" 6             , -, 6  6 +  & ,&     , 7  & 6   <    & 6 &  6    &   6   <       6    ;

6-   6   , , 7   & &  6   %,            6    ,  %& && 

,    %

          %  )  8 .   &  &  &  H%  6      6  <  &  ,        (2

 6      ) <     

    8 & , 7 6 =  & H%  8 &6<    %6 6        ,   , 7  0        6 &  6 ,    ,  6 &    8    ,  6 <              ;    ;&       ,  6<   < &6   ,  &    &% &  <     & < ;&   D     & 6    , 6  &  .0D      ! L L*<    "   " , 6 & 6

% < %    :

D%   <%   8&  ,    &, J , 7 M  & H%" 6 ,&    )  & &   %6   (2       & 6  <   &      

&    <  D   6 " #%           %         &      %& %   &        )   &    < ,"%  , /      

    &  ,   &                   & <   ;& "    6 < &    < ,  !        & < ;&    6 6  , ,   & 

7- "< < &6   ,  &    &% & " &    &  < , H%&  & & #%      "      , 7    %&   ,    6  %      6  <   & 

   &   < " 0  H%" & &  0 <  6 8   &     (2 422=  =  J 0 M <       &% 6      & H%" &     &             0 8 &     &" 06,  &  %< 6  ,     6   %  &   <  <+&   &% & 6     6  ,,  %&    ;;&    " , 7   %&         8         &   H%" &  %   06,L &L&  6   ,< .  . ; " %         

 & &    0 , 7   &  G   

"  #%             08 &8& , %   &      ,     & 6    ,   &         % , D & & & &"  6 6  <&     :5 & H%" 6     , <&    , 7 "    <&    0 8 & 6 & 6 &   ,   &"  <& 8            :5  H%  8   )   0 8 &   &     6,L &L    6     (2   

8-   %&    (2 422= 6  % ,   &   

        &     <   D

         0 8 &       :5H%"< &   &  6  6    <  :5 H%"      & &    &      &"&    08 &    8 & 6 < & &    6      6       < &         :5H%" &   ?

 )  <+& <      &      :5  H%60 @    6 %      &  %&6   &   

        &     < " <  & H%6   "     , 7 %6   , %& &           L           &&   ,      06,L0 &L&    ,       &  , 7  ,  %  %         "   <   ,      %   , &     &  &      6 % 6             (2 422=     &    H% 6    & 

   

&   < " %&  "  ,   ; ;& "   <&    , 7

&         & 8 & , 7 6 8  & H%  & 8 & 6           ,     6" 6    &   "   ,   <     , 7         <%  &  H% 0   )   % <    ,        

      &    H%  )    N  & " #,   &     & 

9-     , 7  6  8     & H%    I (2 /  & ,  &  " 6      &       ,   <     +,       & -," A           <  .% -, % "6  < &  , 7 6 +&"

<<&&" & & & & &      &-,&

<<   %6  6  6    /213$"

 ,3$50 (8 / 6 &  <       < 8.  ,4/4 #6/ 9/$/!';0/@@/$,3$50.* A 99=:42(= O%   6"   &&    2( 42(3" % 6 &        &   %  #  J.K   JK  " 6  &  % < , 7" 6 < ,%   & &  &  < <&     ,     7/ !3A)/ (8 /< 6   . "   6     &

 <  +&  , 7     %&   )     &     

& (?

2= 42(36 &    CA&  ) (? - "42(3 A =L1L42(30D#  *PD 8 & 6 &  <  % &529 .  D  6  %  & =      #% " #        #   %&" #%     <   6 ,     #% " #        #   %&0("A& A #   (5L. L  529L4221"(5   4221" 

P  OA OA)  #% #       #    %&0(" A&  A  # (5L. L

 529L4221"

10- (5  "4221 6 , % <  "

 Q %    %  #  C.I   QQ   6  ,    &L&  &L  6,L6 0&  , <" 6  &

 < ,       , 7  &   %

&    A (3<%  %  <6   6,<" < , 76 &   6 ,<  , 7

Q (( /      &         , -,  6 +   ,  ,   <   , 7     ,            6 % <  ,    <  , 7 %

8 0:09 / 

 ,<           ,-,6

  <%6 D6< % +& 6          <   , 7 " 6         %    <  ,    <        &&   ,  8.  & &   , 7  6      &    6  ,  &< ,  (4  "   %6    <% & "        <    ,  %6   &   & & &  <%   ,&    ',',-   ,    *''     /     ,L   B /    < B