← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1493/2000dismissed

State Of Pb.Etc. v. Gulzar Singh

2025-03-25Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl14 pages



   

  

 

 

 !"

#$ %& ''((

)& "

*"(+&  ,%



      !&

& "&- ."/&0 *0 !"

#$0 & ''((

& / '

 ,%   0 1 &

    !

" # $"$%"$&'( $%)( 3%(( ,

,"(&  ''(  &,"/

$%(  ''(( 4 

&,"/

$%(     (-

5 

 

     



 *  

  0  !"

#$  & 7"

&0 *"& '"& %1 ( ,"(&  ''( "

& 

 !"

#$

0 80 %(( , 

 

9 8 '

5& ''(( 1 :%% ''( ( '( 

'&(- ((:

" ( '( 

'&(- & &(

  '( 

%( (

&/

&-

"

%

& "& /&, -

  &&

 8;

%"

%

,&  &&&

& &/

8;

 8;



             * +   * <&  3"

( ''&

$%( ''((

%

"$/ 5& ''((

((,( &1

 

((-

,&"

,1

5& ''(( '(  "

& !"

#$ *1& / = ( -

3 

"( 9

%& & &&&

>% 9 "( ?

"( %1 (-

,1

'&

:% :

''  "& - :%&

'(  1

'& %

:

 :

'' 

@ 

&/- :  

9  

/0 - :



'&

@

"$/

" ( 

&,%(-  /

&(

:& ,(-

  5& ''(( 

        **

<& "

( & 0

%& % 0 %

"$/

 0 '( 



@ 

&/- :  

9 

9 ; & %

&&/ 0 % :

'' 

6%&

 8

 !"

#$

 =



; 9

  0 9 "(

''($(  !"

#$0 %"

/

''(

 @

"$/

 !"

#$0  

A/(&-

&1B

'&1

"(

9 "(

'&

  A/(&-

&1B /

&(( & //

- %& :

@ 

&/ 5&

& '&

"& '&

!&(/

- / !&  @

"$/

&

 C&-

 & 0

/ /

/

"(

1 =



8 ;9

'&

/ / 0 :%% %

&& '1  &/

  990 '%& > &(( & //

"& '&

!&(/

-?

:

&'( '%& >:%

&(( & //

"& '&

!&(/

-?

%"

:%% %1

'

:% '  C&- 0 &'& 9 "(

/ 

","

0 ;9 :%&

&

 !"

#$

 & 0 

&/1(- %( 1

'&

:% &

'&& !&(/

- :"( (

&10 '&1 %

"& -0 :%% 4& /(-  @

"$/ %"

5& ''((

&  :% (:

&1

"'%( ,"(&  ''( $ /&(

&1

 /



, * 6%

%

%& (& "

( & '&

%

'&"

''& $D

'

5& ''((

&  :% (:

&1

"'%( ,"(&  ''( $ /&(

&1

 /

& &

 %& & '(  (

" & (&

 '(  :

( ((

(" &/ '&/

&-0 '- (0 ,&"- %&

& %/ "& = ( -  

-&

9 0 9 ;

(& 1 '&-& :

( / & / &- #"



&  

"

 :&

&-0 '&/ &/ '- (0 ,&"- %& &&(

@ :

 '( 0 :%%

  '" $& %

3"&0 &

@ 

&/- :  

9 

9 ; :

1

%( & E 3

E39 9 "$& % && &/

9 ; @

(

  '" & &

"& = ( - 9 0 9 ; & &&/ &/ /(&-0 %

7"

'&/ &/

 8

 8;

( "

 & @ :

 '(  % :

(

"

& 9 "(

:% ' &/ '&/ '- (  &

'"&' 0 



''&%  

1&( 

1

(,(

 

;

80 %:1&0  

(&

8 8 C/ &0 *1& / C,% %(0 %:(0 &"

,& -

& ,(-0

" :

(

 

&(  /

" 1 & 

;  '(  (

''( 5& ''(( 1 &  9 8 :

'( ,& ((: &(    

  

             

   

 

            

           

 

 

     

   

   

 

            

    

   

    

  

     ! "#$

%!"""#$   

   

  

% 

& 

   %!"""#$ '

  

    

 !""#$

%!"""#$

      

   

  (              

 )  )

   *  '&"

( $1 :"(

%:

&&&

:& ,&  4& (- & &/

8;

 8;0

" :

(

 

 :

$ &&&

"( (- (/ & %& -&

: / %

9

'&& (

" 5& ''(( D



&

&( "( %1

,&  (- ((  &&/    8;

!&-& /  

"

 & '"&' '

:

&#

;

F%( ,&  &( "

& 9 "( 5& ''(( D



&

'

:% '  C&-  :

$ :% '  C&- 0

"$ G" / / '&1 (- '&

>:% ?

&(( & //

"& !&(/

- !&  :"( ,& 

:%&

%& :

"% / /

9 "(

''($(  !"

#$ @ :

%"

%(

 & && " %

"

 !"

#$0 %"

% :

(

9 "(

F%( ((: ''(0 1

&,"/

$%(     9 "(

&'(

8 :

&# $ &1 &

'' 

6%&

 8 '&& &'( 9 "(

8

9 "(

:%% :& ''($(  / &

"(

 D

:-

&'(

"(

 :"(   " ,

9 "(

@ :"( &(1

 (& "

( & '(  %

&&& !"

#$ &"/ 7H &1/

"( 8

%& & &&&

>8 "( ? %

'((- %,%(,% "(

8 "( :%%

&'&" %& $(:

;

+  ,"-    

  

        

 

                         .  )  , -         .           

  

              





 

    

 



        

    



        







 '&"

( $1 "( :"(

%:

"

& "( 0  %



%

8 "(

%(( 

&"

'&1 - '&

:%/ "(

''(- - &,% :%% &" %/ "

& "( =

& &&

& //(- $& // / "(

%"

&,% :%% &" "

& 9 "(

'(  %

1

' %



%(( ,  !"

#$

''( '&/&-

" &



>

:%%& & :%

@ 

&/- :  

9 

9 ; &

'&& !&(/

- $"

"& -0 :

&G"& ,&  %

"

& !"

#$ *1& / = ( -

3 

"(

9 &

I?

"(

!"

#$ *1& / = ( -

3 

"(

9 &

"

&  (  /0     

   



8

  

   

 



 

  



   ! "

 

      

 



     #  $



 #

 !  %& '

    

&() *+(& 

       

        

    

       

  



        '

      *  '&"

(

&"( :"(

'((-

%:

'%& :%%

$ "

'&1

> &(( & //

"& '&

!&(/

-?

/

:%&



A/(&-

&1B :"( /

& '&

>:% ?

&(( & //

"& '&

!&(/

- 6%"

$& & $1 "( :"( (&(-

%:

1

'&

:% %

&

'&&

"% (&

$" %

"& !&(/

-0 :"( ( "

>/(&-

&1?

:"( ( (/

"

& 9 "( :%% :"( (" &/

&- 

'&1 "

& "(

9 "(

"(

&'&" %& $(:

,- 



  

./#    

    



  

  ./ ,- /&           

    

  

           

 

      

   



 

 1               

 % %"!%""

 2 3.  ) 4   &   

         

 ,-.  

/&   

        ,-  ' 

   

    

       

             

     ,-2  /&   

        ,- 

       

 

 

                  +    

 



  / ,"-&       

            

       5  6 , -    

  

            

   

.

 +   ,%-&        

 

      

 

  

          +       

          

 7        7     

 7      

 



 

   7    

   

 +   *

1

J % %

 0 1

3  41

0

!   &'&

*++%*1'5-(&0

:& G"   :%%& '&

:%

&(( & //

- %& F

@ 

&/ 5&

'&& !&(/

- # 1(



 

!"

#$ & %

 %&,4&&/ &/ &/ 5& :

(

'-

&-  "

& 9 "(

1"& /'(- @

 0 1

J % D



&

9 "( /&

0  

A/(&-

&1B

,1

"(

9 "(

& 

&

/0 / 1  ("

'&

:% # 1(

 !"

#$0 :

(

& %/ "& '&

!&(/

-0 1

 % &

'&&

"% (&

F%( 

 0 1

J % %

( D



&



:% '  C&- $

 C&- 0



"

8 ;9 :%%  

:

/  :% && '1  &/

  99

"(  :

'((- /  A/(&-

&1B :"( /

& '&

>-'#'$.

/))0  &(( & //

"& '&

!&(/

-?

%"

/  ("

%& :

  

( ,", "(

''($(  !"

#$  C&-  1

J % ''(

(( "&



( &,"/ &

$%(  &1

&#

$

(1 '&

0 1

6 

"'&

&'&" %& $(:

  

 

  

7

   ! "

 



    $

 ) &(*+(&    8

             1    # 8      

9  

 ! "



  



         

          # 8 :

  $

' 

;

*+(%< 5  =

  

      !  &&( '

  



    

  877777 9      



 )  

 ":9)    /    (    0        

      7    ;

     <        

         

     

     0    ,         

 -                      

  

 2   

=     2      %9 

 3      :

>

 ":  

       

        

    

       

  



        '

       : !          

  >

6 

    

#     $

        #

  

) &(*+(& 

 

      ! "

= 

      

   $

       8

  !     

#  $

   

   

     0     *+(?         

 

 ) &(*+(&0 ?*+(?

            >  

  !



 

   

  

  

  ; - 

 

 

$ > 

          

    ) ?   

              

           

  

 =   

 )   

                    

    # @  

 



 

     1 A 



       !   B+      '

    

   

     !  +*+C(       >  

  6 

         **+((       .

   (  0       

      7  ;

    @            

 

    

  

    

     2      %9 

 

 >

  :": 

  

  0  ,   1 >

 -    

 

   

        

         

    

         

   



    

     '

      A   

     

  1 A          

    

    

 

   

  

               

  $

      

  

   

 



                

   

   

 =   5     





;

  

  1 # 8  1  A     7   1 # 8



  

   



 



                     $

 



     



 

 

      





 1 A 

 

                

    



      $



  ;

 



 1 # 8      1 A  

    



 1 # 8

                 

.

         

 .



    

  

   .



2  "!   ' 

      5         

     "" 5    

  



  

   $

 !   



! 8

     1 # 8   

   

    

  



 ; -

777777 ": !

 

  =

  

 

      8

         1   # 8

       

      

  

 

    

    

    )   &(  *+(&   0 ?*+(?

  

  

 

    

"$ &      

&   

   &       

  



   <   

    

      

>

  :": 

B # ":#3  5    



* 5& ''(( %"

&,%(- 

& ((

"

G" 

&,%(- '&(- ((:

" ( '(  !&-& & ,& '

'( 

&,%(- &# 5& ''((

&

,1

'

&/ 5&

 ( - ''( ,

   .'

1:

$1 

&"/   5& ''((

&  :% (:

&1

"'%( ,"(&  ''( $ /&(

&1

 /

& ,(-0  /

 (( '  / (( "

''(

 -0

%((

 

1:

$1 && 123112

 2  

4')5')"(&)$670%+")$(#0).* )(+# 4')5')"")&#"5$/8)* )(+#