(O&M) Kuldip Singh v. Guru Nanak Dev University, Amritsar And Others



  !
" # "

$%  & '  
 & !

&()* +, &*-.+   /0123 45

33*11() 6*7.0.

!070 ((8 &*9 "9*7.): (2 +)5*7.

*.3+2*).



 ;%<  $"
  

!  

 



 















 




 



 





 

 


  







 








!

 
"
 





"









 
 






 
"








$




%
 




&'

&& &(()

&* +, &((-
"



', && &(('

"
  #."
"








 


  



 
"





 

%










 






$
 #."


  

% 

+/ && &(-(
0 
!










''

+( &(('

& &+ &(('

 


+(
"
1






2





*+
"








 # ."

$

 


3

2




4
+'

&& &(('








"





 #"









"

















 ', && &(('





 
"





 
 

"




! 


 5

-)


6
7!

."


3"



 






 

4

', && &(('

"

 #."





"





"
"

 



7 






 #."




  



"









 


 








 








+/ && &(('
!






$
 



$



! 



5
-)

 6
7!

."
% 
8



95
-) 

.":;





 "




 











%
"
 



 

! 


5
-)
 
."



"


 


< 

"




+-
"

 "


  

$




"




 



 


', && &(('

"


 #."






5
-)
 
."







%
%




 




"


%

$


 &'

&& &(()

= 



$






%

&'

&& &(()






"



 





&* +, &((-
"




%   

$





%

&'

&& &(()

 





2


 #."
 5
-)


."











" 
 

"


<
"





 +-
"


"


%






 "



%

 "
 


 





 


', && &(('
  "

  





 
"









>


 





?









 %
 

 





 #"
 ! 



5
-)


."





 

"

 

"



"


 





!





 

 ?






 



 
 "

 
"

%
 

 

"










5 **8&;


."
5



   





"







"


 
 
5
-)


6
7!
 ."
% 

?







 
  
$


%
@


%



  

 !!"#$ %  &'(



 &) &'

'+&+
 




"


6
7!

."
  

%
@


%

 

"

!
 5
-)



."




 

3"
 








 



"

% 
 
5
-)


."
% 





  
"







"


 







?



 #."
 
 


 "












 

"

"







+-
" 5
-)



."



 


!












 "
 


 

"


















"

 #."
3




 




"
2


5
-)
 
."


 "
 


$



 %
 

 


  

A









 




 


1
3







 ! 






%
"


 !
"

 #."

5
-)


."  

"




 
"
3"





 



"




"
 

"

 
 







"
  


3

 "





 
3"


 






 

%
@


%
 



 )* ) 

+
 

, 

 !!"#$ %  &'

(




+B +- '+&+

 




"

  















 5
-)


."

 


#

 



 
 



"


"

 

"
5
** 

."





 



!


 





C 
 


$


# 9/

 "






 




"


"
3"

 


1 






5
-)



5 **8;

A


 
"

>D 
5 
%


  


&(,,
5%
&*,)
 


7
@ E



%


5
1 
 








 

"



 



 

"










$
 

"


1 
% 
 
"

>D 
5 
%
1
 
  

#
9
&'

A




 
"


 









  
 




 

 







 

 


"



"


 
1




 


 


"
 


 



"

"

 
  






 "


! 













 




A

$



 
 




"







 


!
)

-

 
=
?
5
 #
+&#+/#'+'*
&*&&++

%0
7
&,+&+

'++-
#/#
  F
,
%
@


>D 
5 
%
 2

 "


 
 

5
-)

"




 #"









"

A
&((&
8

;
5%%
,++
 


1  % 
E

%
<
%


 >D 
5 
%






 $ 

 "











 
$

 

# 91


 






"


%

 "
 





 
(8 ;






"




 





"
"


 



"
!
"



 

"







" 

"






"


  




"
 " 

  





$




 
&)

 %
A

 

 
 "
"

%
 
6






" 

 "


5


6 % "

 
% 
5
6
% "
 ',/
 
% 

5
D 

5 



 
&'


%


 "

 $


 



  

AAA













 AE


%
A



5
 


 

"





"



 &)

%
=


/

-


 
=
?
5

#
+&#+/#'+'*
&*&&++
 %0
7
&,+&+

'++-
#,#
 
"

 


 


 


$


 "





$  
(8 ;


    

 "



"


 





"


"
 









$
1 

 


 








 







"




"






2
A

 

 


D
 
D
 


 

3 "
 

 
&)


%


 

 "

3#$



 

$

"

"##3
 





 


2  "
2 
"




 

 





  



$










 

 



 

?



% 





 

 

"


 "

%



 
 
(8 ;
 







 "
"


"  

2


  









2





$

  




 
 

 "





  
(8 ;

 2  "
2 






D
 
D
 










 

"



"


"


D
 
 
(8 ;

"





"








"


 

"













 






-
A



 
 







1
 

8 2
#&+;

 "
3









 





 

"













 C "




2



"




 








 

1
 



 "

 







 
 "


 ?

?
7 &/B+

'+&+
 
"

 # ."



$


5
8 ;

  
"


@


%



+- &'

'+&+   

$


5 
@


%
"
 
 5
-)


."





 

 
   

1

3






 %





 

 !!"#$ %  & '(




&) &'

'+&+

 



"
  

"




&-
"




!

 


"

5
-)


."





" 
 

"






+-
"


  "
 

1




."

 


 "

%





 





!

5 -)


."

 

 
3"

1



  "

5
-)


."

3"


 


"


 


$





# 90 



D

 D
 

"
    "


DD

 

"

 
"






"



 
A



"

 








!
 G

 





 "G

 
 G
 

 
 





 


D  D

D

 D
 

"

0
 

"



 

"





 
2





% 
"

 2#
 

2






 

  
3"








 

" 


 
  




"


 


"
1
 






$
 #3#

 $



"


 

H
H
H
H H
H
H
H && 0 



D

 D
 

"
    "


DD

 

"

 
"






"



 
A



"

 








!
 G

 





 "G

 
 G
 

 
 





 


D  D

D

 D
 

"

0
 

"



 

"





 
2





% 
"

 2#
 

2






 

  
3"








 

"






 
  




"


 


"
1
 






$
 #3#

 $



"


  &'

=


#






G 


''

+( '++B

'- +& '++(
I 2
#/ 
&&J

 "
3


 

 
 



3


  D "
D



 


K
-L
 










  "





1



 
  




 '/+++ @



 

 





 
5
-)


."


 
"

%

 


5
-)


."

 "

!


 3"



 





<
 
 




"
 % "






3"

  






 

"



 *+
"
1


$




%
 
"



 
"





 
 
 
', && &(('


"

 #."



 "



1


!
"

%
 



  






 



$
 


%
 









 
 


 





?



 #."
 






 


"

 #."



 



3"

 











<
 

 "

  


!

5
-)


."
 # ."


 "




"






?






 





-,
"
 


 "



  


 
  

 






"







*&
" 


C












?







 
 
%
@


%
 




5 8 ;









5

 




"






 










"



"

2









 "

  
"



@


%



 

 "
 2
"

6
7!

."





5

?



 #."


 

 




5




 
"

3"








 





5




 
"


5 
$












<

 
-,
"













 


 









  "



"
 "










 !



$






 

 ', && &(('

"

 #."




















?











 







 
"
 








 "


2



"
"












 




! 



"




 








"

 2
 "






 



 






  
 


', && &(('

"

 # ."





 #."














 


 









 

"
"


 
















"



2


"









 






 





  "
2
=







 "
2





 

2








 ?









 



 







 
"









%3 "





 
"

 
  

 "




 










"

 










 



 
"


1

 









  

371 =    

!  

 $"&!