← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2040/2023dismissed

Haryana State Industrial And Infrastructure Development Corportaion Ltd v. M/S Ars Enterprises Pvt Ltd And ORS

2023-12-22Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja8 pages

     

 

 ! "# # ! $!% ! # #  

          

    

 ! 

 "     & '(& #) *)&

#

 $"%  "   

&%  '"

&%  

  "

%   ()

"  '%*%%   (+ , -----  *)&# ) .'    %" $ " /     ,0))+0++%

/" 

 &

$ % '% "  1 '"  /"   2 " / "   

'   ' )003+0),+004+0)5 "    

6$

7 %"   

  /$"    ,8

7 %)948"       :)948; +

"   %" 

 "   

 <$  %= "

" " %  '% / 7   ),03+0)0 )+03+0))%

  8 >%   %" )948'  ))



" )948'   )003+0),=" 7 '        1    )3%)> )5%" "   $  1

 "  /  , $$  " 7  $ %" $ ' 

 ? ()4,+0+0))%'"  '" $ 

"  '  /  /"   )5)0+0))  ="    '     '

       

+4))+0),$$  % '  /"  /  "

@/  1 %'"  $   $ $

'   0)05+0)8% "'  % "      

/   "

@/  1 '"" '"

' +808+0)9 8

"  '" %"      " '

)003+0),7 "  ' 2 ()' '"

"      +004+0)5 ()  /  "      %$  "   '

)003+0),   +004+0),     "                /"   /  "      A

$""

' 6 2 /"      ' ="      $ "     ' %    ,0))+0++ 3

 $$  "       %          "

  

/ "

 "$

" ' )003+0),%"

'6    / 

/"  )5)0+0))A  

/" @/     %" 

 '   6  /"   "  2 ' 



"  $ %   "      " '

 )003+0),%  '"  %    '   

 "  "  

    "

7    1   "  $   '""          $ $

  '  

 /  "     '  6          $   " 

       (844

)003+0),      " '$    #2   B"(+43 )+0++0)4% 

"  $ "$ C $ &!



% '"  /%" 

" 

6  /

  B"(5,0 0+09+0),%  " "  

    "   $    1

$  "    "

 ' 6  .

"     %    "    

"" 

" 

    6     /  "  

  /   )+0++0)4    "

%  "         /    '" "          +004+0)5% ' '     "   > D" " " %      $  ()  " ' )003+0), "  "

 %" 

7 ' 6  /"    (844 )003+0),%'""

"    7   "  / $$ () '     "

'   +90++0)5%

/ /" (/= "

%" "    '     "   /2 $ %  " " %     '  /   "

 $" ( ' " (+> )445%   

  

    %'"  '  $

"" 

"   / 6   /

%

 ' (+="   ()8"    

 !" !"#$  %&'# (&)&(* %% +  $  ,-&  #  $        #                #$ 



%        "   

+805+0),%'  "  $

*   $  %

"  (/= "

%" " %  '%'"   $'"   $ (844 )003+0),%'  

""  /

"

 "

  " $""         '    ="

%'

/ "" 

"   7

'  6  "   

 )003+0),

"   %  "   2 '   '          "   "       5

" "     "  $ " $""

 /6  / 

/  " 

/

  / " "    9 E  $(844 )003+0),%"   

+

+805+0),%

"  $

*   $ %

(/= "  %" "  '  "   +90++0)5%

/ /" (/= "

%" " E'" /2 $ /  "  "$" %  "  ""  /

 " 7 / $$ ' ' 6   /"  '"" 

)003+0)," $"     ' / $ E

    / '  /

 " " 

" '6   

/"  )5)0+0)) 4 F"  

"   %" '$ /   

2 ""  6$  /

 "   7 

$"   

'   /"   #2  F  "       "    

+805+0),' /"  

*   $ %

"  (/= "

% /2= "

%" " %   '%'"  '    ""  

2 /

/ $$ $  ' "

 

 (844

)003+0),="     "    

"  ..... 

    



!

" ###

    $

 $%

 $  &   '

 (  '

$ 

   %( #   # 

  &'' %  #  )

"   

!

!"  $   % ((*  +#    # ) ,--

!

"$ % ((* .(#  ,/0"

  !00/-0!1  #  $  2      

3'

*)4#  $ * %% +

# &($(#   $# '#  *5&*$+#3&*(

+$$'# # &(    67          2    ''      '   8  ,  #'   #8, & 6 6!9%% /

$ 0     %#

( #

 $(  



 

#  

(  6 $    (    8  ,   '   67%  9  %%  $$    (     #   )    '&)         &  '  &(    '

 ( '$) ( &.. / =" ' 

 /"   2

 $

   '"  $"4%"     6$  /  

        7

     (844/"     " /   F " % (844 )003+0), "  /6

 ' /"  2 '   

  "   4" $

   / $    "

 

"  : '(&# '   ()# !00/-0!1      $   # (  $    # 

  ,--         %

#    (  (

#

 $   #

(   1      



   $       

2 

 *    # $ ( 2 

$     3 (  . *  '  '

 (    4( * &3 #&(    :#



 $ '( 



 /" = "

 %" "   "  /2 $ % %" " "  

,

+90++0)5/  "  "$"   (+>)445%   

             $ $6$ 

/"

  $"

()8"    

" 

!" ,!"# $ %&'# (&)&(* %% +   $        ,-      &   

# $#    #$ 

 )0 D  "  "   " %  "        "   

)+0++0)4/"     "" 

" 

' / ' '      

  % '"   %" 7

  '"  "  

'   "   2

%" "

  '" " 

6  / (+2 7   "   %" /    / "

" 

 "  / ""

" 

$'"" 7 $

' 6  / (+2 7      B"  (844  )003+0),A "  '$ 

"

2 B"" / "  /  6$

 " 7 

"    

 "

 "      )>" )948  "  $ /  "     /" @/     

-

   5'

  %( #        %   .

((       #  !

!

' ,-6

  %   

 )+0++0)4 "'

"  "   %" 

"

 /"   7  " 

 "

     " 6$ 

/ (+2 "  ' 2 () "   % '

"'" /    " "  ' 2 ()"

"'6 " $    " / " $ % /  $ 

 $ ="

%"    2

)+0++0)4%" "" $"   %$    ()2 '     / "  "     (+2  '      

"  ' / '  ))  $% '" 

 "  / % /

" 

"$/    6  / (+"  ' 2 ()

(844 )003+0),%"        ''" ' $      ()2 ' ' )003+0),+004+0)5%    ,8" )948

% $ $    "  $   ,0))+0++%"      %"

%



)+   $ %%  

 ++)++0+,  . *)&/

6  ?" "   6$    #

( ?" "  / #

(