Swaran Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"# &#'()($*
++ ,-!.!* ,(*/0 ++++++ #"("($*#.
1#.)2) ,"!"# 2*3!4 $"0#.) ++++++ #)5$*&#*") 6 7 +
, ,
.#)#*"
.+
!.3(*&#.
,(*/08
&9$'!"#
.+ .!"##:
,$&0(8
&9$'!"# 5#"("($*#.+
.+ !9*##"
,(*/08 ,#*($.
2*3!4+
.+
+,+ 0(*&8
&9$'!"# + + + ,
8
+
7
+ #"("($*#.
,-!.!* ,(*/0 %(;#& 2*&#.
."(';#) < = $*)"("2"($* *&(!8 (*"#.
!;(!8 )##:(*/ *!"2.# '#."($.!.(
=8 5!))#& 2*3!4
)0$."
6(*!*'(!;
$AA())($*#.68 -0#.#4@ 0#
5!))#&
!;!*&0!.
(9()($*8
!;!*&0!.
)0$."
6 (9()($*!;
$AA())($*#.68 !55$(*"(*/
,-!.!* ,(*/0
#0)(;
()".('"
B!52."0!;!
%2."0#.
.#)"$.#&
5!))#&
$;;#'"$.8
!;!*&0!.8 -0#.#4@
!*3("
,(*/0 B02.&+ +
.(#%;@8 &#A()# ,0.(
0!/!"
,(*/08 5.#9($2) 5.$'##&(*/) -#.# (*("(!"#& %(;;(*/ !%$.#)!(& 9!'!*'@+
52.)2!*'# 5.$';!A!"($* A!&# %(;;(*/ !%$.#)!(& 9!'!*'@8 = !55;('!"($*) -#.# .#'#(9#&
(*';2&(*/ !55;('!"($*) )24A(""#& 0#.#(*+
0# #0)(;&!.8 B!52."0!;!
-#;;
,24
%%('#.8 B!52."0!;!8 .#'$AA#*&#& *!A# 5.#)#*"
!%$.#)!(& 9!'!*'@+
+ 2.(*/ 5#*&#*'@ !%$.#)!(& 5.$'##&(*/)8
!*3("
,(*/0 %(;#& 4#%$.# ".!*)%#.
7!A4!.&!.( %.$A '$2."
()".('"
$;;#'"$.8 B!52."0!;!
!*@ $"0#.
'$2."C -0#.#25$* ".!*)%#..#& '$2."
()".('"
$;;#'"$.8
!;!*&0!.
)0$."
6$;;#'"$.6+
+ 7#!.*#& $;;#'"$.8
!;!*&0!.8 !%"#.
'$*)(&#.(*/ .#;!"(9# A#.(") &#A#.(") '!*&(&!"#)8
!*3("
,(*/0 #0)(;
()".('"
B!52."0!;!8
+
7#!.*#&
'!A# '0!;;#*/#& 5.#)#*"
%(;(*/ !55#!;
4#%$.# '!A# !;;$-#&8
-0#.#4@
5.#)#*"
,-!.!* ,(*/0
>
#0)(;
()".('"
B!52."0!;!+ +> ##;(*/ !//.(#9#& !/!(*)"
5!))#& $AA())($*#.C 5.#%#..#& .#9()($*
= 4#%$.# !;;$-#&
=8 -0#.#4@ $AA())($*#.6)
!55$(*"(*/ B02.&
.#)"$.#&+
>+ !%$.#A#*"($*#& '(.'2A)"!*'#)8 %(;#& )##:(*/ .#;(#% )8 *$"('#& !4$9#+
+ 7#!.*#& '$2*)#;
)24A(") #..#& ;!- %!'") $AA())($*#.6)
-0#.#4@ B02.&+
"
)24A(""#& A$.# A#.("$.($2) "0!* (*!)A2'0 4$"0 .#9#*2# $%%('#.) .#'$AA#*&#& 0() '!*&(&!"2.# B02.&+
"
%2."0#.
)24A(""#& *$*)2("#& $*;@ /.$2*& !4$2"
= @#!.) !/#+
"
*#?"
)24A(""#& !;"0$2/0 $;&#.
"0!* 8 0$-#9#.8 0# (*'!5!'("!"#& 5#.%$.A &2"(#) 7!A4!.&!.+
"
)"(;;
%2."0#.
)24A(""#& (/*$.#& %!'"
#?)#.9('#A!* A$.# #&2'!"#& "0!*
8 "0#.#%$.#8 0# .(/0";@ .#D2(.#& A!(*"!(*#& $AA())($*#.+
"
*#?"
)24A(""#& &$#) 0!9# ';#!* !*"#'#&#*") 0# '.(A(*!;
.#/()"#.#& !/!(*)"
0(A+
("0 !%$.#)!(& )24A())($*)8 5.!@#.
A!&#
=8 5!))#& .#)"$.(*/
5!))#& $AA())($*#.+
+ #.
'$*".!8 '$2*)#;
!55#!.(*/ !*3("
,(*/0 $55$)#& )24A())($*) A!&# 4#0!;% )24A(""(*/ 0!& #..#& (/*$.(*/ -#;;
)#"";#& ;!- A!""#.
7!A4!.&!.8 '0$('# $;;#'"$.
;(/0";@ (*"#.%#.#& -("08 #9#* (% "-$ 9(#-) !.# 5$))(4;#+
"
)24A(""#& @$2*/#.
!/# "0!* 5#"("($*#.8 9#.@ .#;#9!*"
'$*)(&#.!"($*+
"
%2."0#.
)24A(""#& A$.# ;!*&0$;&(*/ "0!* 5#"("($*#.+
) .#/!.&) !;;#/!"($* "0#.# .#/()"#.#& !/!(*)"
8 ("
)24A(""#& A#.# .#/()".!"($* *$ /.$2*& *$*'$*)(&#.!"($* '!*&(&!"2.# 5$)"
7!A4!.&!.+
"
)"(;;
%2."0#.
)24A(""#& "0#.# *$ (;;#/!;("@ $.
5#.9#.)("@
.#)"$.#&
= 5!))#& $AA())($*#.+
''$.&(*/;@8 5.!@#.
A!&# &()A())!;
5#"("($*+
<+ 0!9# 0#!.& '$2*)#;
.#)5#'"(9# 5!."(#) 0!9# !;)$ 5#.2)#& 5!5#.4$$:
-("0 "0#(.
!4;# !))()"!*'#+
=+ #.#8 ("
-$2;& !55.$5.(!"# )"!"# .#;!"(9# A#.(") &#A#.(") 8 *$"('#& $;;#'"$.
(")
'!* )2AA#& 2*&#.
!."('2;!.) #"("($*#.
,-!.!* ,(*/0 #)5$*&#*"
!*3("
,(*/0
/# &2'!"($*!;
D2!;(%('!"($* <"0 ';!)) "0 ';!)) 7!*& 0$;&(*/) :!*!;
A!.;!
:!*!;
= A!.;!
=+ 5$* '$*)(&#.(*/ A#.(") &#A#.(") '!*&(&!"#)8 $;;#'"$.8
B02.&+
$-#9#.8
$*;@ /.$2*& #?)#.9('#A!* 0!9(*/ #D2!;
';!(A $2/0"
0!9# )#;#'"#&+
7#!.*#& $AA())($*#.6)
$4)#.9(*/ 2*&#.
!
"#$ %
& % '
<
%
& %
(%
) *% $ !
+ $, -"
./ 0"!"/!01 12
./30 $$!/!0$$! 3. 4
5
(%
$ 6#% 7 &
!
8 %
$ & 8 !
9 9 5 %& 4
!
1 : &
; 1
1 %& !
9 9 8
%& !
9
!
&
%
% "
% %
7 =+ 5$* '$*)(&#.(*/ "$"!;("@ '(.'2A)"!*'#)8 !A '$*)(&#.#& 9(#- 0!& #..#&
-("0$2"
!55.#'(!"(*/ )#"";#& ;!- A!""#.
7!A4!.&!.8 '0$('# $;;#'"$.
;(/0";@ (*"#.%#.#& -("08 #9#* (% "-$ 9(#-) !.# 5$))(4;#+
"0() .#/!.&8 .#;(!*'# '!* 5;!'#& 25$* (9()($*
#*'0 "0() $2."
<
(9(; =>+
=
=+> 2."0#.8 @$2*/#.
!/# "0!* (*!)A2'0 5.#)#*";@8 !4$2"
=> @#!.) !/# -0#.#!) !4$2"
@#!.) !/#+
$*64;# ,25.#A# $2."
!
(9(; ==8 0#;& !/# '!*&(&!"# .#;#9!*"
%!'"$.+ + 9(#- !4$9# &()'2))($*8 &$ %(*& !*@ (;;#/!;("@ $.
5#.9#.)("@
!55$(*"(*/ .(/0";@ .#)"$.#&
=+
+ #)2;"!*";@8 %!(;) )!A# !''$.&(*/;@ &()A())#&+
+ #*&(*/ !55;('!"($*
)8 (% !*@8 )0!;;
!;)$ )"!*& ';$)#&+
,
++
)3:) 0#"0#.
)5#!:(*/ .#!)$*#&
#)
$ 0#"0#.
.#5$."!4;# #)
$