High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/97/2022dismissed

Brij Lal And ORS v. Rattan Lal And ORS

2023-04-29Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!" #$%& ( ))''

*

& ( )

'+

',!

))''

%(& "- ,!

!

.) / #$ '1

,

!

(!

)'

#$%& ' )$2(, %( ( 3 , %"

$ 2( ( ,3'

$ 2( )$2( "3 2( ) $2(( - 2( $ $ $

& ' ) $2(,42

& ',5($'$2(

& ', ''

$ $''

2-- ) ,5($' $ $!

)

6''

$ )$2( $!! ( 2(($'2 ')

$($ 3 "

#$%& ',$ $''

2# +,'($,+$2

!'

$

'

78$$''2 ', '' $

-$$2 )$2(

$ -9!

' '1

$!' $'

:$

")!

2$

$!

, ( ,

( - $ "

'

$ 1"

) (!

/ )$2( $2;( $ 2$! '

''

$ 6!( +( $2

+ '<"

'

( ( 8+ '8"

'

,$

6$ ($

$''

2-- ) ,5($' $ $!

)

,-(

-!

2$! '

''

( -) !( -1 )'

, /

& / )$2(

2$! '

''

$''

2# +,'($= ( 2(

'6 9!

$ ( " /= / "

2 '+

('

-(

/,- /-$2 21 $( ) $!'' $6$ ( (6$ >$ -1

+$2

2

$"$ 1, ' 2 $!

) -$'$ 1 / ) $2(

' '1 !!$2

9!

$

($ 6 $ 42 5% $2(, / , )!

$'178-19!$$2 $ ' ! )

/, ( $$''2 ', '' $ -$$2 ) $2(

(1"

$6$)$ ('

$ ? $= ('

6 ! '$

6 2

9!

$) 1"

") 1= ($") 2' 6 2 9!

-1(6$2 ('

- ! ) 1$2

") 1 ("

+ ' @'$2 22$,

- 2( $ $? $

2

$2 $!, '' )) $'

%$ 6$

" ! $$2 $ '2 '-%!

$, "$ ,! $2

/6 6 ('

$

? $ $ 6 ($'

!? $)) 1,6($!((( ) !( 6$ (($6 = /( 9!

' 6$ (($ 66$($

,6$ ( (-$2 1 $ ' !9!$ )($"= !(

$2 6 )'

1 ) /-1 /= $? $$ '2 '$

$ 9!

$, ( -!"6$)$ )) 1,6($!($ '!

$ !=

!!6$ ( !('

$2

("

$$2 $, !( ) 1 $"$ ' $! / ) $2( ( $ $2 )!1 ,(6 ) -1($3 "

#$% & (& ' 1! )'

/,,7

/ / $' )

6$

" -"$

$2

' $ )!

( 2$! '

' '

$

$ $''

2 -- ) 6 9!

$

)$2( '!$

$ !$

''$2 ('

$$''

2#(2 (: (6$

" (!

- )) : (, ) 1 "

!$2

7 5()'

$')'$!

$ (6$

"

/ ! ''2

$$ (6$

"

6( $

" $ 8

( )' $2 ( ) $, ''6$2 $ 6

" >( (

' ! !'

$

!

78$$''2 ', '' $

-$$2 ($2(

A

>( ( ( )'

' ! )"

$% !

$6(-1 ( $ "

$2

'

$ 1"

A

>( (

$ "

-'A >( (

'!

$ $' () $

7 >( (

))-1 ($6 !

! !

" $'$2 () $ A 8 >( ( (? $$ !

")( -

$9A >( ( () $ $- %$ "$%$

! 1) $A < >( (

!" (! 6$ (!' (

( )) ("

$

!

" (! A '$ 5( ) $ 6

?

)) $ $ ' $!$ )) ($)!

$!'

$" <

( $2' ! ' () $, $ 'B

B$$'C 2 C$ ,)

-12$$2$ 6$ $$2$"$

6$ (! D6, !(B 2 $!

$

"

+ () 1"

") 1 $") 2 '

( !$!'

) $'$2 (

9!

' 6$ ($ 6" ( 2

(!)1

% 2" 5($6 $% 2" !

7 @'$2 22$ -1 ( $ % 2" !, )'

$' )) '$ (B $ $!

C 2,$)

,6($!( $2 $ $ '$ $!

C 2,$)

,6($% 2"

!

$" (% 2" !) -1

$ 'B $"$ )) ' $

$ $6$ ( (% 2" !) -1 B -'6,

+!+

( ($B -16 $'$2 2 '

! )) ') 1$2

"- !!) , $") 2% 2" !) -1 (B -'6- $

$'-1 ("-! ) /( ' )) -16 1 $'$2 !

) $ :( ( ' ! ' () $-$2$2

( 2( (! : $

($'" "$ $ ($ 2 '

! )) ' : ($!

, $ 'B 6'' @$ ))'

B

$ $ '$ $!

C 2,$)

!$$2 ()' $2 () $

-1 ( 2( ) '1$ ($!- 2( !-1

(!

,$'$2( (

'% $!$ ''2 ')$ $,( !"

(!!' $

/ )$2(6 -'

6 $ )) 1,6($!(6 '

!? $?

($" (( 1$2( $)$ -19!

$

($2 ,6(( )) - ($

/

& '5()' $-1

/ )$2(6 (6 ()) 1,

((6 % !

8

+ -(

! '

"

( 9!

-1($"$

/

6 $''2 ', '

,"$)

$ $ ' ! 9 -1 / ) /6!$ %!

:

- $!

- -' (6

) ! '

()) 1-!

(6 ($2 ! (6

$ 6 6 -1 !"" ! $ ( ! () $!!$$($

! $ ("

5( )'

( ) ! $' $ +( - 9!)

, +(

$ $( "

', +(

$ ) $"

$( +( ( ? 6 , ( )) 16

+ -'

!? $?

)$2( >$ (2 ) 1"

") 1 ($") 2 ' ("

+ ' , $ 'B $2( '1$ $!

$ ) 1

") 1 "

(-%!

$ 7 '

( 2(' ! ' ))''

-1 $2

" >5%$2( $ )%!

)) 1$ ((

)$2(6 ! '$

- ---1 B -'6 ! '

('

2 )$ !(

"

$ "$$ $

2 $ ( -1 5( , ()) 1$ ( " )$2(!

-

+ -( $2 ! '

?

/

8 5( % 2" -1 ' ! '

))''

$

-1DE-' )"B ) $B$$')) '/77

!"

))'$!

-' () !

$

!

!$! "

! ( !

( ! 9 $ 6($!( !( -

$( -"

>$ ( (!! $$2!-1 (B -'6 6$ (6($!(: 1 $ 2 6$ ( -

? '

6 $, () )) '$- -$"$ :

$ !!$2'1 $! ( "

$ 2 '

)) '

$"$, "$!''

))'$!

$ ,$ 1,)$2$ )) '

$) !!$2'1 #$%

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#