Narinder Pal Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another

 



    
        !" #"$%&%'(   )%'#") *+%',- ..

"!%!%'") /& +! !"  0'1 2 '# '!-") ..

"&3'#"'!& (  45  +
 
+ 6      !  "#$%$ % & '

%#(  ! 

12%)+"-) 7 !89 ) *:

!%*  + 
 
" %

(  ,% - ./+0   + -% *     /
      *    &   %!-     ,%! --   "!"    +1 2%34 5 !  "! !! %-

!6 7 8    !6 !! (  
%9/,- -- "  : -%  "!"/ "!  

! 
 ;% - %!-     (     6       (           "    ( "!"(6 !6   6 %7  %% %  "7,%

 %""

(#  -   - 7"         <6,%7% !!

 - 6   #%!  - !!7 -  (7 -  % "(7 -7")   !%    (66! -     "7  7% = (% " - ! !%(7 "!"  %  "- 6  - ,% 6=6  "!%  7  "76! !%"  !  ,% 

 )  "   

   ,% %!  7-)  6! ( !% " !% " 2"!% "  %-

!7  "  =6  "               !%        6! " " "! ) 

-7"!7"!    (66!:6

> %-  "!  !%,% 7 -""?5%      (66 (7!%-)   "6,%- %- 6  !!% -?- ! ! 7 /-*7"!  -?-  "!" (66  "!%* 3

2! !  -)   7!  "!%- %-  (%!" "!%-!!- =6(77% ! * 3

 ( 

3 !7:6   - "!"(6 ! :

 7:(  )  7

 ! ( % /
) "

 ! (% /
@

 2- /
6" "" ">- 2-

 (- - 6  "    !    

     (-   -?    6    -  ")  ,%  >- (7* 3

 -? ! !%5%"  7 ! %! (  " : )
% (!"(7  !! ( % ! %=   >-*  +

(7 =- 
% 5% (( 6  7!  " !%6%67(%

 " "6 ! %(

 :  % 6%  ,%  7 -) 

  ""(7!-  "  ,%-

 !66 2 -

 !6 (!"( "!"<>6

 - 76!! (%  -!7  - %-      %- !!7(7 2-  ""            :    (  !"    ( "!"@2 ! ("-

7  

  %(!"( "!"(7 
% *  !

 (  
% -6%  %  !!%  
%!" "( "!"  !6%!7 >%! 
%

  %  ,%  %(7%(- "  " #%    "  "#% 

   ?!  >-(!7%!
%%( #% 7"*6%67(  #%  :  ! -? ?  "  "    ""            7"  " #%   ,% 

6   7!"( "!" =A( *%!"
% "!7   -!  -?- "!"-   


 

  

  !" (% B0  )   !     "-  "     (   %    ( %"" % !6 =- 
%,% - " ! -./ "!2   #%   

 " !6- " %  "!%-

 %* 3 
/  !6 6!%6 %7"(% ( 2  6 -%- % !6?:14  %  #% 14!(% !  7
%  /  6     !6    ,%   "  ! -   "!./"7(2 6 

 "   !%6%!     %"     -7 (! (=6 ( 2  % !6 =- 
%"% %- % -7  "=%%

  "!7 

 >"% !  7   ( -7,%  %-  " "A "7

  !% *%

 !% % "!  7*"7 7 "!"(6   "



 %! %> 
%! 

  ""(7!%( 6  6>-  ! 7 : ! 7( ,% -

0 "! --%

  5%  " 

-  6 "-7   !"-7   %    

 - !%! ,% - ! %7

- " ""    "    ! !%

> 

  -% ""7- 67    "7!%6  6-( 7! !% !  !%/  -7   =- 
%"7,%  "! -  6 ( %

 "

 !(7   "(> % " 6%!% %-!!!#%  2"#% 6%( % "(7,% -  " ! % "!" "!"6  "/ 6 =- 
%"% 6  6% (%  7  #%  %6 "! - %  "! -6% "%    (%    !     6  !  "  "!"(6  "6-6   %  #%  !!!  " !%  6 (,%14

" =-

%     (  6  6     #%     ,%   " ! -C   !            7     2 ! -(=  6 ! 
 ;%  - %!-   "!%%    !(7 
% 
%  % %!%!6%( (7>!- ! -/6(  #%   " (6 ! !

-7 !!6 ) ./+0    + -%*  /
 *

& %!- ,%! -- 

(7,% ,% !!   "!"

  (6 ! "!% 6 !6,%!!   !!  6 ! "! ( "!" ! -(-,%  !!    !  (       
%  6%    (  ,%    7 ! -%  =     + - !! "! ,%   "!" 
+ 6     
 *!>-9  D9 !(  D9