M/S Naresh Mittal And Sons v. Jaswinder Singh

              



!"# $% #&'('$) !)*!+, -.

 /( !+#(0 '""!1 !)2 ($)( 333#"'"'$)#+ 4#+(*( !(5')2#+ 6')70 333#(8$)2#)"

  9:

63 6

   

+#(#)" +3!*+!; 77!+5!1. 2;$&!"# %$+ "0# 8#"'"'$)#+3 +3*)<##" 63 +!+. 2;$&!"# %$+ "0# +#(8$)2#)"3 ====    . 3 0!11#)7# ') "0# 8+#(#)" +#;'('$) 8#"'"'$) '( "$ "0# $+2#+ 2!"#2 33
 8!((#2 >, 1#!+)#2 $*+" >#1$5. 50#+#>,. !) !881'&!"'$) *)2#+ +2#+ ? *1#  . %'1#2 >, "0# 8#"'"'$)#+81!')"'%%. "0#+#>,. (##@')7 +#<#&"'$) $% "0# &$*)"#+ &1!'A %'1#2 >, "0# +#(8$)2#)"2#%#)2!)". ') ! &';'1 (*'". 0!2 >##) 2'(A'((#23

0# #((#)"'!1 %!&"(. !( &*11#2 $*" %+$A "0# 8!8#+>$$@ !+# !( %$11$5(

0!". ')'"'!11,. "0# 8#"'"'$)#+81!')"'%% %'1#2 ! (*'" !7!')(" +#(8$)2#)" 2#%#)2!)" %$+ (##@')7 +#&$;#+, $% (3
.?
./3 $8, $% "0# 81!')" '( ))#B*+# 3 ) 8*+(*!)&# $% "0# )$"'&# '((*#2. +#(8$)2#)"2#%#)2!)"


 A!2# !88#!+!)&# !)2 %'1#2 5+'""#) ("!"#A#)". &$8, 50#+#$% '( ))#B*+# 
3 ) "0# 5+'""#) ("!"#A#)". "0# +#(8$)2#)"2#%#)2!)". !( (*&0. 0!( )$" 2'(8*"#2 "0# !;$&!"'$) %$11$5#2 >, "0# 8#"'"'$)#+81!')"'%%3 $5#;#+. '" '( 2#)'#2 "0!" !), !A$*)" 5!( >$++$5#2 >, "0# +#(8$)2#)"2#%#)2!)" %+$A "0# 8#"'"'$)#+81!')"'%%. ;'2# &0#C*# >#!+')7 $3
??
2!"#2 33
3 ) %!&". '" 5!( !;#++#2 "0!" "0# +#(8$)2#)"2#%#)2!)" *(#2 "$ (#11 !7+'&*1"*+!1 8+$2*&# "0+$*70 !7#)&, $% "0# 8#"'"'$)#+81!')"'%% %'+A. >*" 50#) "0# 81!')"'%% 2'2 )$" 8!, "0# !A$*)" 2*# "$ "0# 2#%#)2!)". "0#) "0# 2#%#)2!)" 1#%" "0# %'+A $% "0# 81!')"'%% !)2 ("!+"#2 "$ (#11 0'( &+$8 "0+$*70 /( #5 !+,!)!

+!2')7 $A8!),. !)2' !>5!1'3 *# "$ "0'( 7+*27#. "0# 81!')"'%% 0!2 %'1#2 ! %!1(# !)2 %+';$1$*( (*'" !7!')(" "0# 2#%#)2!)"3

;#). &$*)"#+ &1!'A. &$8, 50#+#$% '( ))#B*+# . 5!( %'1#2 %$+ +#)2'"'$) $% !&&$*)". "0#+#>,. (##@')7 2'+#&"'$) "$ "0# 81!')"'%%%'+A "$ +#)2#+ "0# !&&$*)" +#7!+2')7 (!1# $% &+$8( 0!;')7 >##) ($12 >, "0# 2#%#)2!)" "0+$*70 "0# !7#)&, $% "0# 81!')"'%%%'+A3

) 8*+(*!)&# $% %'1')7 $% "0# &$*)"#+ &1!'A. "0# 8#"'"'$)#+ 81!')"'%% %'1#2 !) !881'&!"'$) *)2#+ +2#+ ? *1#  . "0#+#>,. (##@')7 +#<#&"'$) $% "0# &$*)"#+ &1!'A %'1#2 >, "0# +#(8$)2#)"2#%#)2!)"3 ) "0# (!A#. '" 5!( !((#+"#2 "0!" ! (8#&'%'& !A$*)" 0!( >##) &1!'A#2 $% (3 1!@0( ') "0# &$*)"#+ &1!'A. >*" 0$5#;#+. !2 ;!1$+#A $*+" %## 0!( )$" >##) !%%'B#23 *+"0#+A$+#. #;#) "0# &$*)"#+ &1!'A '( )$" A!')"!')!>1# !)2 "0*(. '" '( 1'!>1# "$ ># +#<#&"#23

) +#81, "$ "0# !%$+#(!'2 !881'&!"'$). '" '( 2#)'#2 "0!" "0# %$+ +#&$;#+, $% (8#&'%'& !A$*)". "0# &$*)"#+ &1!'A 0!( >##) %'1#23 ) %!&". '" 5!(

 $)1, "0# "#)"!"';# $*"("!)2')7 !A$*)"3 1($. "0# &$*)"#+ &1!'A 5!( !((#+"#2 "$ ># A!')"!')!>1# ') "0# 8+#(#)" %$+A3 %"#+ 0#!+')7. 1#!+)#2 &$*)(#1 %$+ "0# 8!+"'#(. ;'2# 'A8*7)#2 $+2#+ 2!"#2 33
 . "0# !881'&!"'$) *)2#+ +2#+ ? *1#  . %$+ +#<#&"'$) $% "0# &$*)"#+ &1!'A 5!( 2'(A'((#23 ##1')7 !77+'#;#2. "0# 8#"'"'$)#+81!')"'%% 0!2 %'1#2 "0# 8+#(#)" +#;'('$) 8#"'"'$)3

) 8*+(*!)&# $% "0# )$"'&# '((*#2. "0# +#(8$)2#)"2#%#)2!)" A!2# !88#!+!)&# "0+$*70 &$*)(#13 :#!+)#2 &$*)(#1 %$+ "0# 8!+"'#( 0#!+23 #+*(!1 $% "0# 81#!2')7( $% "0# 8!+"'#( 5# 5#11 !( &$*)"#+ &1!'A. &$8'#( 50#+#$%. 0!;# >##) 81!&#2 $) +#&$+2. +#;#!1( "0!" "0# 2'(8*"# >#"5##) "0# 8!+"'#( +#1!"# "$ "0# +#&$;#+, $% (3
.?
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

, $% (8#&'%'& 8#+%$+A!)&# $% "0# !7+##A#)" "$ (#11 2!"#2
3
3
? )2 %*+"0#+ !>$*" "0# "#+A( (#""1#2 %$+ #B#&*"'$) !)2 +#7'("+!"'$) $% "0# (!1# 2##23 ) "0# >!('( "0#+#$%. ) $>(#+;!"'$) 5!( !1($ %*+"0#+ A!2# "0!" "0#+# !88#!+( ! ;!1'2 &!*(# $% !&"'$). ') %!

 #%')'"#1,. "0# $>(#+;!"'$)(. ($ A!2#. ') 8!+!7+!80 $3? $% "0# 'A8*7)#2 $+2#+ !+# $*" $% &$)"#B"3 $50#+#. %+$A "0# 81#!2')7( $% "0# 8!+"'#(. '" '( #;'2#)" "0!" "0#+# 5!( !), +#1'#% ($*70" >, #'"0#+ 8!+",. 5'"0 +#7!+2 "$ "0# (8#&'%'& 8#+%$+A!)&# $% !7+##A#)" "$ (#11 2!"#2
3
3
?3 6##A')71,. "0# !22'"'$) $% 8!+!7+!80 $3? ') "0# 'A8*7)#2 $+2#+. '( $) !&&$*)" $% &*" !)2 8!("# A#"0$2. 2$8"#2 >, "0# $*+" >#1$53 0#+# '( )$ &$)"+$;#+(, 5'"0 +#7!+2 "$ "0# $>(#+;!"'$)( !( A!2# >, "0# $*+" >#1$5 ') 8!+!7+!80 $3? $% "0# 'A8*7)#2 $+2#+3 D##8')7 ') ;'#5 "0# !%$+#(!'2 %!&" ('"*!"'$). '" (0!11 ># ') "0# ')"#+#(" $% "0# 8!+"'#( &$)&#+)#2. '% "0# !881'&!"'$) *)2#+ +2#+ ? *1#   '( 2#&'2#2 !%+#(03 ) "0# 1'70" $% "0# (!A#. "0# 'A8*7)#2 $+2#+ 2!"#2 33
 '( (#" !('2# !)2 1#!+)#2 $*+" >#1$5. '( 0#+#>, 2'+#&"#2 "$ 2#&'2#2 "0# !%$+#(!'2 !

881'&!"'$) !%+#(0. 50'1# &$)('2#+')7 "0# &$)"#)"( $% "0# !881'&!"'$) !( 5#11 !( "0# +#81,. %'1#2 "$ "0# (!A#3 0# 8!+"'#( !+# 2'+#&"#2 "$ A!@# !88#!+!)&# >#%$+# "0# $*+" &$)&#+)#2 $) 33

3 &&$+2')7. "0# 8+#(#)" +#;'('$) 8#"'"'$) ("!)2( 2'(8$(#2 $%3 !)*!+, -.

  

47*1!"'

 E0#"0#+ (8#!@')7/+#!($)#2 #( E0#"0#+ +#8$+"!>1#

$