Parveen Rana v. State Of Haryana And ORS
% % % % +#!%$ +#!%$ +#!%$ +#!%$ CD CD CD CD%$ %$ %$ %$D* H- * H- * H- * H- !4((%"
!4((%"
!4((%"
!4((%"
/ / / / D !#(#(%"!
!#(#(%"!
!#(#(%"!
!#(#(%"!
!'%"7!"# !'%"7!"# !'%"7!"# !'%"7!"#
!!"# $% !#+""#(,)73%4+#! #&!'!#(#(%"! EEEE )* +,- )* +,- )* +,- )* +,- ./0 1 2+1 %$ ' !!"# !3((%" '!#(#( %") 4&+,,!"5! &+ 6!!" ,+(7 #% +" % 7! 7+#!78/ //@'+!761#&!%9 #%$ $,!+ "!777(#(%"+,(# (4#97 75!) %"('+#49:;
;!49#("5 %9 #) 2&! !61 #&! !
;!49#(%" '!#(#(%" ' !$! !7 +# ("#+"4! %$ #&! '!#(#(%"! ) !!>("5 7( !4#(%" # #% #&! !'%"7!"# $% :+>("5 '+1:!"# %$ 4% %:'!"+#(%" $% #&! +4B9( !7 ,+"7 (" #&! +:! #! : + +2+ 7<=975:!"# # !"7! !7("#&!:+##! %$%#&! 4%&+ ! )2+7(:(!7 .0 %# #(4!%$:%#(%" .0 " +>("5 %$ #&! %9 #) 6& &("+3 +,(+) ) + 1+"+ + +"7 >+&&+9 97&+ 1)73%4+#!+(#("54%9"
"!,%$ +57(&+"4&+"7+) 73%4+#!+44!'# #"%#(4!%"6!&+,$%$ !'%"7!"# #%/H+"7 !'!4#(3!,1 .?0 & &+3! &!+ 7 ,!+ "!7 4%9"!, $% #&! '+ #(! +"7 5%"! #& %95& '+'! 6%%> .@0 '
'! 9+,%$#&!% 7! &%2#&+# #&!!;!49#(%"'!#(#(%"' !$! !7 7+# #&!("#+"4!%$ '!#(#(%"! ,+"7%2"! 2+7(:( (!7:! !,1%"#&!5 %9"7#&+# #&! 7(7 "%# 4&%%! #% ' !$! +"1 %6=!4#(%" 9"7! !4#(%" /A % A %$ #&! + +"7 4B9((#(%" 4# #) /A8? *$% &% # F#&! 4#G- *$% &% # F#&! 4#G- *$% &% # F#&! 4#G- *$% &% # F#&! 4#G-) 1!# $(,!7 +" !;!49#(%" +'',(4+# #(%"
6+!7%"+"+2+ + 7<7!#! :("+#(%":+7!("$+3%9 9 %$#&!( 4%&+ ! ("#&!+4B9( ( !7 ,+"7 .D0 &!
!+$% !+(7,!5+,(9!+, !+71# #+"77!4(7!761#&!%"I6,!'
'!; %9 #3(7!7!4( (%"7+#!7//D //D //D //D'+!7("
"(3(,''!+,%*-8/ (3(,''!+,%*-8/ (3(,''!+,%*-8/ (3(,''!+,%*-8/8A 8A 8A 8A A%$ A%$ A%$ A%$ D *J,' * D *J,' * D *J,' * D *J,' * - %*-?@ - %*-?@ - %*-?@ - %*-?@?@8 %$ - ?@8 %$ - ?@8 %$ - ?@8 %$ -) #(#,!7 F +:'&+, +:'&+, +:'&+, +:'&+, H H H H !
!
!
!
9 9 9 9 + 1+"+#+#! + 1+"+#+#! + 1+"+#+#! + 1+"+#+#! "79# (+,"7"$ +# 94#9 !!
"79# (+,"7"$ +# 94#9 !!
"79# (+,"7"$ +# 94#9 !!
"79# (+,"7"$ +# 94#9 !!
!3!,%':!"#% '% +#(%" (:(#!7 !3!,%':!"#% '% +#(%" (:(#!7 !3!,%':!"#% '% +#(%" (:(#!7 !3!,%':!"#% '% +#(%" (:(#!7 7H 7H 7H 7H G G G G)2&! !("#& &!%"I6,!'!;%9 #&+6!!"
"',!+!7#%9'&%,7#&!4,+(::
+7! 61#&!4%&+ !
2(#& !5+ 7#%!"#(#,!:!"#%$ (:(,+ +:%9"#%$4%:'!"+#(%"
"+ 5 +"#!7("$+3%9 9 %$#&!( 4%%2"! ("#&!+4B B9( !7,+"7)&%2!3! ) !# (4#!7 +2+ 7 %$ ("#! !
!# !,!3+"# '+ + // #% /? $ $ %: #&! +$% !+(7 7!4((%" 7+ +#!7 //D+ !!
!;# +4#!7&! !9"7!
F// " $+4#) 2! &+3! 6!!" ("$% :!7 +# #&! + 61 #&! ,!+ "!
"!7 4%9"!, +''!+ ("5 $% #&! +'
+''!,,+"#) 2&(4& ( "%# ! (%9 ,1 7('9#!7 61 #&! ,!+ "!7 !
!"(% 4%9"!, +''!+ ("5 $% #& !'%"7!"#) #&! $+4# #&+# #&! ,+"7 2&(4& 2+ +4B9( !7) &+ 6!!
!!" 9#(,(K!7$% #&!'9 '%!%$$% :
:+#(%"%$("79# (+,(#!+"7+,,%##!
#!7 #%#&!"!!71'! %"("+44% 7 7+"4!2(#&#&! 9,!#&!"' !3+,!"
"# " %#&! 2% 7) #&! +4B9( ("5 5 6%71 ( +,% 6!"!$(#!7 #% 4! #+ +(" !;#!"#) 2&(4& ( +" ("# 9:!"# "#+,(#1 %$ #&! #+#! &9) #&! 4+, ,! &+3!#%6!6+,+"4!7("#&(4!"
"+ (% / L! + ! %$ #&! 4%"( (7! !7 3(!2 #&+# +'+ # $ %: #& 4%:'!"+#(%")#&!+''!,,+"#2 2%9,76!!"#(#,!7#%#&!("#! !#$% + '! (%7%$$(3!1!+ #%6! !4> >%"!7$ %:#%7+16+4>2+ 7+"72 2! :+>!(#!;',(4(#,14,!+ #&+##&!
&!+''!,,+"#+ !"%#!"#(#,!7$% +"
+"1 ("#! !#$% +"1%#&! D'! (%7L L!2%9,7+,%&+#!"#%+77#&+##& +''!,,+"# 2%9,7 6! !"#(#,!7 #% +,, %#&! 4%"!B9!"#(+, 6!"!$( $(# 2&(4& $,%2 $ %: +2+ 7 %$ 4% 4%:'!"+#(%" +"7 #&! !'%"7!"#* #*- +9#&% (#(!&+,,4%:'9#!#&!4% 4%:'!"+#(%"+&+6!!"7!#! :("!
"!7 61#&!+2+ 7'+!79"7! !4 !4#(%"/A%$#&!4#+"7<% :%7($(!
(!7 61#&!(5&%9 #% #&(%9 # #("!;! 4(!%$+''!,,+#!=9 (7(4#(% %"
/ &! +(7 7!#! :("+#(%"
" &+,, 6! :+7! 61 #&! +9#&% (#( (! !;'!7(#(%9,1+"7+#+"1 +#!2 2(#&("+"%9#! ,(:(#%$#& !!:%"# #& $ %:#&!7+#!%$#&(% 7! +"7 7#&!+:%9"#%7!#! :("!7&+,,6 6! 7(69 !7 2(#&(" +" %9#! ,(:(# %$ #& !! :%"#& $% 94 94& 7!#! :("+#(%"2(#&("#! !#+'
'!4($(!7#&! !(" /? "#&!!3!"#%$#(:!,("!
!2&(4&&+6!!"$(;!761#&(%9 9 # ( "%# +7&! !7 #% 61 #&! !'
'%"7!"#*- +9#&% (#(!) #&!1 &+,, 6 6! ,(+6,! #% '+1 ("#! !# J "("! ! '! 4!"# *8M- %" #&! +:%9"# % 7!#! :("!7$ %:#&!7+#!%$94 4&7!#! :("+#(%"G .C0 "3 3(!2%$#&!+$% !+(77!4((%" !
!"7! !761#&!%"I6,!'!;% 9 #) #&!' !!"#'!#(# #(%"(+,,%2!7 +,,%2!7 +,,%2!7 +,,%2!7+"7#&!(:'95"!
!7% 7! (!#+(7!&!:+##!
! ( !:(##!76+4>#% %#&!,!+ "!7;!49#("5%9 #4% %"4! "!7$% $ !&+7=97(4+#(%"+ +"7 (" 4+! #&! '!# #(#(%"! ( $%9"7 #% 6! 4%&+ + ! (" #&! +4B9( !7 ,+"7 '+ 4 4!, +,%"52(#&#&%!
!2&%' !$! !7 !$! !"4!9"7! !4#(%"/A% A%$#&!4#) "!4!+ 1+:%9 9"#+7!#! :("!7$("+,,1+,%"52 2(#&#+#9#% 16!"!$(#+"7("#!
!# #&! !9'%"6! !, ,!+!7("&($+3%9 2(#&("#&!#( (:!'! (%7#('9,+#!7(" +:'&+
+:'&+
+:'&+
+:'&+ &+,I &+,I &+,I &+,I 4+!*9' +- 4+!*9' +- 4+!*9' +- 4+!*9' +- .A0 !!
!7,! #% +1 #&+# #&! 7!#! :("+ +#(%" %$ 4%:'!"+#(%" +"7 !,!
!+! #&! !%$("$+3%9 9 %$#&!'!#(#(%"! 6!:+7!(" #! :%$7!4((%" !"7! !761 %"I6,!'!; %9 #(" +:'&+,I4+!*9' +-
+:'&+,I4+!*9' +-
+:'&+,I4+!*9' +-
+:'&+,I4+!*9' +- .80
!"
"7("5:(4!,,+"!%9+'',(4+#(%"* *-)($+"1)&+,,+,%#+"77('% !7 %$$ * - * - * - * - + 4& + 4& + 4& + 4&/ / / /) ) ) )D #(> L& L& &!#&! '!+>("5< !+%"!7 ! &!#&! !'% #+6,! ! <% <%