Shyam Sunder Sharma v. A. Sreenivas, Ias And Another

  
  
 



  

   

    

!"


  !
"! #$%$&'



#(')&*(+%,)-./01('$ #',$2$')')&$#

#!(&/$$2! (&&.!$&)#$2+'3/01('$$&$#(4. (#3(&(  #$$%&%'( )&* +, ,$2#$%$&'1&'$52'2$')')&,(%6$$& )4$/24$(/)&7',('',$#$ )%8)4 +4/)%6$/)$&1$ ',$#/$#/('$/9  2(%%$/63',)%
+#')&
: ; ,$2$#(')0$2(#' ',$#/$#)%#$2#/+1$/ 6$48

<=:)',+'$>2#$%%)&7(&32)&)&&',$5$#)'% ',$1(%$.

)&%'(&'2$')')&)%/)%2%$/ 8)',(/)#$1')&'#$%2&/$&'

 ?,$)#$1'#$&$#(4 )7,$#/+1(')&.(#3(&(.

!,)-%,(!(/(&.!$1'#9.(&1,-+4('4-)&'',$7#)$0(&1$ +& 4/$/63',$2$')')&$#)&,)%4$7(4&')1$!$2'$56$# .

@?9A(&/''(-$(1&%1)+%/$1)%)&632(%%)&7(

  %2$(-)&7#/$#(%2$##+4$%(&/)&%'#+1')&%)%%+$/63',$ 0$#&5$&' #5')5$'')5$8)',)&(2$#)/ +#5&',%

#5',$/('$ #$1$)2' (1$#') )$/123 ',)%#/$# B8$0$#.) 2$')')&$#%')44 $$4%(77#)$0$/63(&3 ',$ #/$#%2(%%$/63',$( #$%()/(+',#)'3.,$%,(446$('4)6$#'3 '(22#(1,',)%
+#'C &&')1$.)'8(%)& #5$/'',$
+#'',('',$2$')')&$# #$ +%$/'/$2%)',)%%,(#$ 
&'#)6+'#3#0)/$&'+&/@ #%,#'.


A(&/',$#$ #$',$5(''$#)%6$)&7/$4(3$/,$

$#8(%5(/$63',$ 2$')')&$#',(',)%%,(#$ 
5(36$(/D+%'$/ #5',$(5+&''6$2()/ ',)5 #5(##$(#% 2$&%)& $(#&$/  1+&%$4  #  ',$  #$%2&/$&'%  &  )&%'#+1')&%  #5 (#$%,  *+5(#.  #)&1)2(4.  0$#&5$&' 
44$7$.  D$4)  %'('$%  ',('  ',$ #$%2&/$&'%,(0$(7#$$/'/$2%)'',$%,(#$ 
 ',$2$')')&$#( '$# (/D+%')&7',$%(5$ #5(##$(#% 2$&%)& $ +#',$#%'('$%',('',$ (##$(#%( '$#(/D+%'5$&'%,(446$#$4$(%$/'',$2$')')&$#8)',)&%)>8$$-%

#5'/(3 '',)%%'(7$.4$(#&$/1+&%$4 #',$2$')')&$#%'('$%',(')& 0)$8 ',$%'('$5$&'5(/$634$(#&$/1+&%$4 #',$#$%2&/$&'%.& 1(+%$ (1')&%+#0)0$%.,8$0$#,$%$$-%4)6$#'3'#()%$,)%7#)$0(&1$)& (11#/(&1$8)',4(8) (&31(+%$ (1')&(#)%$%8)',#$7(#/'1(41+4(')&  ',$(5+&' &0)$8 ',$%'('$5$&'5(/$.',$2#$%$&'2$')')&)%/)%2%$/   (%  ,(0)&7  6$$&  #$&/$#$/  )& #+1'++%   ,$  #+4$  )%%+$/  )%  ,$#$63 /)%1,(#7$/ ,$ 2$')')&$#8+4/6$('4)6$#'3'(0()4',$#$5$/)$%)&

= (11#/(&1$  8)',  4(8  )&  1(%$  ',$#$  )%  (&3  7#)$0(&1$  8)',  #$7(#/  ' 1(41+4(')& ',$(5+&' ')%,8$0$#14(#) )$/',(')&1(%$',$%'('$5$&'5(/$&6$,(4

 ',$#$%2&/$&'%'/(3)&1+#')%&',&+#$/.',$2$')')&$#8+4/6$(' 4)6$#'3'#$0)0$',$2$')')&8,)1,%,(446$('',$1%'(&/#$%2&%)6)4)'3

',$/$ (+4')&7

)1)(4 * #$$%&%'( , &-($ = 

5- :,$',$#%2$(-)&7E#$(%&$/

$%E :,$',$##$2#'(64$

$%E