High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/3941/1998disposed of

Jalla Ram v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2026-02-24Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

( ( ( ( ,&$(' ,&$(' ,&$(' ,&$(' ? ? ? ?(' (' (' ('@ @ @ @ <

< $83 3(%!

$83 3(%!

$83 3(%!?EE E E E> 77$//,%&

77$//,%&

7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& ?

?(' (' (' ('@ @ @ @ <

< 77$//,%& 77$//,%& 77$//,%& 77$//,%&

( ( ( (

7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& ?A@ ?A@ ?A@ ?A@(' (' (' ('@ @ @ @ <

< 77$//,%& 77$//,%& 77$//,%& 77$//,%&

( ( ( (?

7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& 7(%.$%& ! ! ! !

#$ $%&! # '(# # " " " " ,+$$6$6),#5,-.6(8,&$

*%+,%$)&,-../- *% %+,0 BBBB - #,/

- #,/

- #,/ 12

.$ &)3 +*.45$%&- &)$ ,0(6$5 5$%&3(%$. &)#$$ ,77$,/ ,#$ 0$ $3%4 .3 7( $.(', &) )$ ,5$3%6(/6$8(55(%7(3%&

('/,;,%.',8& (#8(%6$%3$ %8$ ',8& ,#$&,9$%'# '#(5

(?('@ 12 #3 3$'/: &,&3%4-&)$/,%.(;%$.0:

- 3&*,&$.3% 3// ,4$ ,5;,/-$) 3/ /<3 &#38& ,&),%9(&;, (*4 4)&&(0$,8=*3#$.63.$%(&3'38,& &3(% .,&$. > 3

*$. *%.$# $8&3(% ? (' ,%. 8=*3 3&3(% 8&- @ @? )$#$3%,'&$# #$'$ $##$. &( , @? 8& '(//(;$.

. 0: %(&3'38,&3(% .,&$. E ?-

*$. *%.$# $ $8&3(% > &)$#$(' & &)$ &35$ ( (' ,8=*3 3&3(% (' /,%.- 8$#&,3% '

'#*3& 0$,#3%4 &#$$ , ;$// , %(%C0$,#3%4 &#$$

$D3 &$. (6$# &)$ ,5$ ,%.

. ,

*77/$5$%&,#:, ,;,#.(.,&$.EEA>;

;, 7,

$.0:&)$,%.8=*3 3& &3(% (//$8&(#3%$D$ #83 $('3& 7(;$#*%.$#$8&3(% ('&)$@?8&-3%&)3 #$4,# #. 12 $3 3%4 .3

,&3 '3$.- &)$ ,77$//,% %&

C/,%.(;%$#

'3/$. #$'$#$ %8$

$$93%4 $%),%8$ $5$%& ('8(57$% ,&3(% 0: 3%6( (93%4 $8&3(%@ ('&)$@? 8& )$ ,'(#$5$%&3 (%$. #$'$#$%8$ 7$&3&3(%

8,5 5$ &( 0$ .3

$. 63.$ +*.45 5$%& .,&$.E?E @*%.$#&)$(#.$# (' $'$#$%8 8$(*#&C8*5C../3 &#38&*.

.4$- *#., 7*# 1?2 : ;,:('7#$ $%&,77$,/-357*4% %3%4&)$ ,5$-/$,#%$.8(*% $/ '(#

*053& &),&&)$,

5$%&('5 5,#9$&6,/*$'(#&)$'#*3&0$,#3%4 4, ;$// , &)$ %(% %C'#*3& 0$,#3%4&#$$ ;, 5,.$ 0 0: &)$ ,%.8=*3 3&3(% (//$8 8&(# ),63%4#$/3$.*7 7(%'(#5*/,.,&$.AEA@A7# #$7,#$.0:#3++$#-3#$8 8&(# ('(#&38*/&*#$- (6$#%5$%&(' *%+,0-),%.34 4,#)$,#%$.8(*% $/,/ ( *05 53& &),&&)$,8=*3 3& &3(%7#(8$$.3%4 3%&)$7#$ $%&8 8, $;$#$3%3&3,&$.63.$%(&3'38,& &3(% .,&$. > ,%. &)* &)$ ,

5$%& ('

' 8(57$% ,&3(% )(*/. ),6$ 0 $$% 8,##3$.(*&0:4 4363%4,77#(7#3,&$3%8#$, $0$&;

;$$%,:@A&($8$50$#- - 0:#$/:3%4*7(% &)$7#38$3%.$D7#$6,3/3%4,&&), ,&7(3%&3%&35$% *77(#&-/$,#% %$. 8(*% $/'(#&)$, ,77$//,%&

7/,8$ #$/3,%8$*7(% %.$83 3(%.,&$.EE@E7,

$. 3%

C?F@ ?F@ ?F@ ?F@C 3%8, $('H ,#&,#3%4),% ,#&,#3%4),% ,#&,#3%4),% ,#&,#3%4),% %. ,#%,3/3%4) (% (')#3 $ %. ,#%,3/3%4) (% (')#3 $ %. ,#%,3/3%4) (% (')#3 $ %. ,#%,3/3%4) (% (')#3 $ ,# ,# ,# ,# 3%4) (% (' 3%4) (% (' 3%4) (% (' 3%4) (% (' )#3 $ ,# 3%4) *88$

(# 3% )#3 $ ,# 3%4) *88$

(# 3% % 3%&$#$ & (' /,&$ )#3 $ ,#- 0 % 3%&$#$ & (' /,&$ )#3 $ ,#- 0 % 3%&$#$ & (' /,&$ )#3 $ ,#- 0 % 3%&$#$ & (' /,&$ )#3 $ ,#- 0 0(&) 0(&) 0(&) 0(&) #$ 3.$%& (' #$ 3.$%& (' #$ 3.$%& (' #$ 3.$%& ('

3//,4$ ,#.( ,#,%- $) 3/ ,&)

3//,4$ ,#.( ,#,%- $) 3/ ,&) &)&),%9(&

*%+,0 &,&$ &)#(* ,%9(&

*%+,0 &,&$ &)#(* (*4) *4) (*4) *4) (//$8&(#*#., (//$8&(#*#., (//$8&(#*#., (//$8&(#*#., 7*#,%. &)$# G 7*#,%. &)$# G 7*#,%. &)$# G 7*#,%. &)$# G 1A2 % &)$(&)$#),%.-/$,#%$.&,&$8 (*% $/ *053& &),&&)$,

5$%& (' 5,#9$& 6,/*$ $ , #$4,#.

&)$ &#$$ ;, 8,# ##3$. (*& 0: &)$ ,%. 8=*3 3& &3(% (//$8&(# ),63% %4 #$/3$. *7(% &)$ '(#5*/, .,& &$. AEA@A ,%. &)$ &35$ 4 4,7

0$&;$$% &)$ ., ,&$ (' '(#5*/, ,%. &)$ %(&3'

'38,&3(% ;, %(& 5*8)- &)*

&)$ ,77$//,%&

%(&$%&3&/$.'(#,%:,77#$83,&3(% % 1>2 ) ),6$ )$,#. /$,#%$. 8(*% $/ '(# &)$ 7,#&3$ ,%. 4(%$ &)#(*4) &)$ 7,7$#0((9'3% %. *0 &,%8$3%&)$ *053

3(% 5 5,.$(%0$),/'('&)$,77$//,%&

1F2 8= =*3 3&3(%3%&)$7#$ $%&8, $;,

8,##3$.(*&63.$%(&3'38,&3(%., ,&$. > 3

* *$. *%.$# $8&3(% ? (' &)$ @? 8& ,%. &)$ ,

5$%& (' 8(57$% ,&3(% ;

;, 5,.$ (% &)$ 0, (' '(# #5*/, .,&$. AEA@A ;)$#$ $, - *%.3 7*&$./:0$ $&;$$%@AC&)$#$),.0$$ $%,77#(7#3,&$3%8#$, $3%&)$7# #38$ 3%.$D;)38)),.

.4(%$'#(5F7$#8$%&&(F 7$#8$%&&)$#$0:5,93%43%8#$, $(' ?A 7$#8$%& (6 6$# &)$ 7#38$ ,

$. 0: # 3++$# 3% 3& '(#5*/, ., ,&$. AEA@A )$ $ ,'(#$5$%&3(%$. 3%8#$, $), $6$%0$$% ,77#(6$. 0: &)3 ( (*#& 63.$.$83 3(%., ,&$.EE@E7,

$.3%

C?F@ ?F@ ?F@ ?F@C 3$3%8, $(' , ,# ,# ,#&,# ,#&,# ,#&,# ,#&,# 3%4) 3%4) 3%4) 3%4)*7#,

$/$6,%&7,#,&)$#$('3 #$7#(.*8 8$.)$#$*%.$#!C H) )$ ,77$,/ 3 '(# $%),%8$5$%& (' ' 8(57$% ,&3(% '(# 6,/*$ (' &)$ &# &#$$ ;)3 )38) ;$#$ /( & &( &)$ (;%$# 0: &) )$ ,8=*3 3&3(% (' /,%. )$ 4#3$6, ,%8$ $D7 7#$

$. 3 &),& &)$ $'$#$%8$ (* *#& ),. ,88$7&$. &)$ 6,/*,&3(% (' ' &)$ &#$$ 5,.$, 7$#&)$'(#5*/,8,//$. "#3++,#"

'(#5*/,"'(#,

3%4 4 &)$ &#$$ '(#&)$:$,#@A)$/$,#%$.8 8(*% $/'(#&)$,77$//,%& ;(*/.,#4 #4*$ &),& ,&3% *%+,05,//%.* &#3$ ,%.D D7(#&(#7(#,&3(%353&$. $# * K K,3/ 3%4 %4) 3%

(EF (' EE- .$ $83.$. (% @EEE- &)3 (*#& ),. ',8& 8&(#$. &)$ 3%8#$, $ '(# ,

5$%& & (' 6,/*$ (' &#$$ '(# &)$ *0 $=* *$%& :$, ,# 0:&,93%4%(&$('&)$3%8#$, $3% 3%7#38$3%.$D%&)3 8, $-&)$/$,# #%$. 8(* *% $/,#4*$ &),&, ,4,3% &&)$6,/* *,&3(%5,.$, 7$##3++,#"

'(#5 5*/, ('& &)$:$,#@A-&)$7#38$3%.$D),.4 4(%$'#(5F7(3%& &(AE7(3%& & 3% @ @F )3 - ,88(#.3%4 &( )35- ;(*/.

. 5$,% ,% 3%8#$, $ (' I (6$# &)$ 7#38 8$ ,

$. 0: &)$ ,77/38,&3(% (' ' # 3++,#"

'(#5*/, ,.(7& &)$ 6,/* /*,&3(%,%.;(*/.7#(63.$'(#I I 3%8#$, $(%&)$6,/*,&3(%5,.$,

7$# &)$ ,77/38,&3(%('#3++,#"

'(#5*/, ,JJG

1@2 )3 (*#&-$6$%3%8, $(' %3(%

%3(%

%3(% ('%.3,,%.,%(&)$#6$# * #3& ('%.3,,%.,%(&)$#6$# * #3& ('%.3,,%.,%(&)$#6$# * #3& ('%.3,,%.,%(&)$#6$# * #3& 3&,5 3&,5 3&,5 3&,5 3%4)- EE??

3%4)- EE??

A-

A- *%.$# 353/,# ',8& - ) ), *7)$/. &)$ 3%8#$, $ 0, $. (% .3''$#$%8$('&)$ $;)(/$ ,/$7#38$3%.$D 12 88 8(#.3%4/:- 3% 63$; (' &)$ .3 8*

3(% 5,.$ )$#$3%,0(6$- &)$ 357*4%$.,;,#.

..,&$.E?E@-7,

$.0:&) )$ $'$#$%8$(*#&3 $&, 3.$, ,%. &)$7#$ $%&,77$ $,/3 ,//(;$.&(&)$$D&$%&&),&

C/,%.(;%$#

) ),// 0$ $%&3&/$. '(# 3%8#$, $ (' ?AI (6$# ,%. ,0 0(6$ &)$ ,5(*%& ,

$. 0:

&)$ (//$8&(# 63.$ 3& ,;,#. .,&$. EEA> &( (;,#.

8(57$% ,&3(% '(# &)$ '

'#*3& 0$,#3%4 , ;$// / , %(%C'#*3& 0$,#3%4 &#$$ 0$ 3.$ ,// (&)$# &,&*&(#: 0$%$ $'3& 7#(63.$.,%.,.

.53

30/$*%.$#&)$@?8& 1E2

$% %.3%4,77/38,&3(%

-3',%: ),// ,/ ( &,%..3 7( $.('

$0#*,#:

$0#*,#:?

?-E -E -E -E &39 > ) ) )$&)$# 7$,93%4L#$, (%$. $

)$&)$##$7(#&,0/$ $