High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8658/2019dismissed

Suresh Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli14 pages

!"# $! %"! & ! '! (!) %"! &*+ % *, (-./0*12340*,'4(,#0*1(,5(40612340 (7./0*12340,*2,//451280

!"#$ %#& # '(

!"#$

) * + ( , -# !"#$

) %#&#!#. / !0 1 2 "'-- *

!"#$ ! + "

!"#$ %# 3 %#

! &$ , - $#!! #(- "

!# $#%$ - $ &#$!

- , -$#!($! "

(

#(4 *,'4(,#0*1(,5(40612340*,/ . $##") "# "! 1 !"# " #(!

) #% +$ # 50354 #%

- #

#1& & $) 6 ! $7( #

1 $ 58./##% $#%$ * !(!$ #..#% !$7( #$.9:0* #($!#558..::5 1# % " ) & ##$#11$1#%$#%58./#8.8.58.0 $#!!,)& # &# ##%

7( # ',)+ $#1& ,$ "!,) % *# #*#%

1#% ( $#%# #(!$ #0 #% .9:0 $ %# # ) -#(! , ! # * $

& - #%

#&#$!

- ,$

1! $ ##& #%+ # '&)

&# ##%

7( # 5 +#%

& -#% #&#$!

-#(-(!$ 50354 #% $ #% 58./ $#$! $##") $#&&! (& #(!

& # #% +$ # 50354 #% $ #% 58./ * &( ,) # ( #$#%#;, +(&1#(#%!

$ #%

) -!#*& $ %#!$

- #!1!#

&!(!$ #50354#%$#%58./&<#( !

$(! !

&$ $ ) ! "

%# & $ #50354#%$#%58./ #*"%#&(&##%!$ !

-1

! %$#$#$ (!

-& - &#%=(!-1*#( !, (%% $ ! 1 &#!($! , #* >? ! "

# $#$ " %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

# $#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

) -. -., ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! ! ! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %' " ) 0' "

)

'!"

)

' ) 0

,* 1 1 !"

#$ ! "

! & "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ ! !" !

"/ "

! "

! +

) "

"""% !

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

")( 52 !"

#" $

! "/ "("!2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

! & ) 6 %6

! !" ! "/ "

! +

7 " ) "

& # $ ! "

' "

"/ "

#$ 2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

( "

& # $4%% ! ""

%( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! &

) ! "

#$ ! "

# $#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :"%)

0( "

! "

! +

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 "

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

! ! )! "

! & " !"' "(! "/ ( % ""

, ! ) " ! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & (

% " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &' '

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! ! "

! " "/ . / (1 ! (, $ #% =(!-1 $ , (11 @! %#

#* - 1 %# 1# $

) # & $

! !#* ,) # ( #$

# $ * # &#$ ! ,

!,( ! #, #($!(!$ #.. #%$#%.9:0 #!

#%$#11$1#%$#% 58./ 8.8.58.0 #

& #% &#$!

- ! 1 *

$# ( #*" * ! $#1& #,!1 !(!&#"

##%$ #%58./

#$ * !(!$ #..#% $#%.9:0 , #($!& ##$#11$1#% $#%58./ &#"

##%$#%58./*#( ! "# , - # &&

! &#$!

- *

$# ( &$ #% # $ % $ #% .9:0 # , &

! 3,4 *#! >#; (! ,* ,# $# -$ #% $ #50354#%$#%58./ #, ! -.# -. $1 #'

& -#% #&#$!

- ,#$# -$ 1(,%(

! -,) % &# ! , ' ,( $#1& # * # $ "! *#( !,#

) %$#1&

, $$&!,(&# #, ' *#( ! , #

& - #!"

&&#$ ! 3( $ 3$4 % &$ #% $#1& # %#

! $#$! #;, +(&1#(#%!

$ -#

) #,"! <& # &

! 1

& #% $ 50354 #% $ #% 58./ !# # $ (! !&# #% $#1& $#(A 7( !#,&#"! $#1& 1#(* !!* $ ,<&

& ! -#% 1#(*#( !1

1#( 1 ! "

!#* ! *#( !, !

$ -#%#,

- ##1 '& )1 " ($ &#$ #,&

@!%#!% ( 1 '

- )1A

% -#$ #/.3.4 /.354 /0#%$#% .9:0 !$#1& -1* & 1

&#"

# $ #B. !98#%$#%58./ #;, &<#(

! # ) $#7($ #% #& )1 #% $#1& #1 '& )1#% &$ /0#%$#%.9:0"#;, + %($

! #$ )1 #% $#1&

, #%%!C!! (! $ # /.3.4 (# ) #,&

@!%##& )1 1#( 1

!!(#%(

# $$&,)

!#*#$

%) %( #;, + %(#,"! %

!#*

!%$%# -$#1& #$ #$

1 * #&

! 1#( 3!4

-&#"

##+$ #50#%$#%58./#, #%$ #50354#%$#%58./ #;, +(&1 #( $

! $ #%%%#& )1 , ! ,( # !&# !

) # & ) 1#(

#- *

(, %#!&# !%#1 =# )#%# !

-%# ") #1# $#1& #(!$#%58./ #,

! #

!#* # !

#% # # %#

# (! $ # 0 #% $ #% .9:0 - !

- !&# ,$

! #%=(!-1 %# -$#1& ##%#

#* 1#)#( !# " , !&# ! * 6 ! $7( # #

$# # ()# #(* &$#1 =# )#%

!# !

- 1 -,) % * !&# ! )#%1#! &$ # 1 =# ) #% # !

- - $#1&

#%#

#* ,( (!$ #/0#%$#%.9:0 *#( !,$#7($ 34 - !1#!#% '

-&# # #;, +(&1 #( !$

! ! -#% 7(&#C11# !(1 *#( ! 1 &)

&# , '

* - !#" -#%

#$ -

, !## ! #$&# , '(!$ #.D#% $#%.9:0

!" + !$ #, ) !

" -#

& -

3%4

$#1&( -- && #!#%% ") ,*!

! !$#11$1#%$#%58./ ) 1#! (, #,<$ (!!* $1 %<$ (!

1#! &7( - && #!#%E) # &#"

##%$ #50354$ #, "#'! 3-4 #;, #( %($

! % ##%

-! ! #* (& ! $ 1 &#$!

- ##! $#$ (!! (1,

&#$ ##%$ #50354#%$#%58./$ #, "#'

!##"

! 1, !$

1 34 & //B #;, #( 1 ! $ &#"

# #% $ # 50354 #% $ #% 58./ 1 # ,

"#'!,),%

!#**#*$#!! # 1#% ( $#%# #(!$ #0#% $ #% .9:0 ) (,7( &($ # ! # #* $ # "#'&#"

##%$ #50354#% $#%58./ 0 & $ &( %# ,) & # ) #* &# ##%

!$#1& F #.5CC5C5C. .5CC5C5C5 .5CC:C. ./CCEC5 ./CCDC/ ./CC./ ./CC.0C. ./CC.0C5 ./CC.EC. ./CC.DC. ./CC.B ./CC.9C. #

1 ( -.8F

.:1

( ! "( #%2

&( (&

! $((- 1&$ (&,)& #

& #%%(

)!" #&!$# #)

! * ! ,) + #% ) "

! # # !

! /88..:9: !8E8..::8 (!(!$ #0 !$ #D#%6

$7( #$ .9:0 %#

#*!,) !!

!558..::5%#&(,

$ &(&# 1 ) %##11$

$#///0 (- # $ #%& # !& "

7( # + %

!# '&# ##%

& #

&# ##%

7( # ( , $#!! & # "$ "!$#1& #"

*#%

! & ) , 1 ! # !$

# &#$!

- ,

&! (! $ # 50354 #% $ #% 58./ ! %$ ,1 !#$ "

* & #%

!,)#

!#* ), $' ) .::8 !#-#% & # " !#& !$ #%!

$ # E

$# '(

6! !!

!"#$

) && -%#+ #% ) (,1 $# ##% & ##%, &# ##%

7( !"# !#% 1 &# ##%

7( ##%& #* ' 1#% #($1#% ! %,)$#!

#@ 1$ # /8: !

! 5D8..::5 !1 !

) & # !

! # $

# ( $#! $#1& #%#

7( !( )!! * 1 ! "

#& # !,)1 '

%$ # !1 # 1 ! * & # 1#( #% $#1&

!) , $ "! ,) % *# * $#!!#* 1#% ( $#%# #(!$ #0#%$ #% .9:0 %# $# # # #% $# -$ 1 #! +$ #50354#%$#%58./ %(

! &# ##%

! ! !( ) ' ! #,

- # #% + # & )

$#1& # ! !

$ -! * ! *

& )1 #% $#1& # $ && #1 !

D % & #% , - #(- ,) $#!

- & ) - ! #

!#* $#$!

"1 ) #&&#!& ,)$#!

- &#"

##%$ #50354#%$#% 58./!##&#"

! &

%#1#

!#*34# - & * $ #* C #&1 !(!

*#* -#, * !

)

$ " #* % &##($1 #% !# " #&1 (# )3+(& 4 & )%# #%

#&1 ! + #"1 &$ (!! %#1 <$ - #& # #% * !

#(!$ #09#%.9:0$##" *

! # !!

$ 7( !#

,#&# # # )

$!,( !

$!&& ) - #% $#% &$ " %!

)

$ -#!#& #% & # "

$#$ ( #*#( !, & # #

) &

$! * # *# %$ " , - " # $( #%

#$ * & #*%

! ) , $' ) .::8 * $ ! & #

&&# $! #(%#% 1 ) 58.:## ) ,(

# &$* $$#1 * )#%& # #%

$ *#%$ ,- " #% * * # (# " &##($1 $#!

- #% & $ C

#@ 1$ #(-#$#( &)

&# , ' !( + !<$ !&#*"! (!$ 09 #% .9:0 $ ( % &##($1 #% !# " #&1

(# ) 3+(& 4 ! &# # #%

* "

- , $ ! ( 1, -(#( ) $ $#!

- #%

#@ 1$ (%% # 1 &)

&# , ' !( &$ (!+ #"1#<$ &#*"!(!$ #09#%.9:0$

%( (,1 ! " % & # " $# # '

& #% #%

!,) ) -(&# #%

%!& #*

-& #(!$ #50354#%$#% 58./

1 $ # , -# # & ) #% & # ) * !

)

$& #%!

#7( ! #, ' 11!

) !

)#$$(!#& #%

!#*# ' & $ )( # $$C*

"#% * $ (%% #- & B % "

-&(!& !

-#%,#$# -& $#!

- $# # * " # # # $#$ (! 7( ) $#"! ,) & $

! !#* ,) #;, +(&1 #( #% !

$ #% !# " #&1 (# ) 3(& 4 ! & ) #% & # $

& - #%

# &#$!

- !" !

#(- & # " $#!! $(

&# ##%

* 1#*"

! "1 # "

*#% & #% >

; 1 ! ,) #;, &< #( !# " #&1(# )3+(& 4* #;, #( $ -#

) ! *#!&# #(! $#%.9:0 11 #%&)

&# #(! +$ #50354#%$#%58./A + #"1

! ! * 11# !(1 #% '

&# #* $ &$ ,)$#!

#@ 1$ # .:5!

!588.5880 1#(# '

-#%&)

&# ##%

!#$&# ' ,# (" -#%

+ %" %

!#*

&# ##%

! & !($&# ##%& (%# ,% ! # ,

% #% #* + + $ &# , ',)$#!

#@ 1$ #/8:!

!5D8..::5 %# &)

&# ##%

* + & #%& # ) &)

&# ##%

( ,)=$!%

&# ,

!,)1 # ) & !# #* 9 1&# %

#(#%&$ $% !

-#%&# "

-, ' !

-"! + %($" -#%

! $

-# #&#$!

-#-#(!# #%+$ #50354#%$#%58./ #& )!

* $ ,!

" -#%

!#$ "! + # &#*(!$ #09#%$#%.9:0$ ,<$ ! % '

-#%!( &# ##% !

! ( $ #%=(!-1,) #;, +(&1#(#%!

#$ #,$

-! % #($1#% ! !" -#%

+ %# * $#1& -1* $# #

!,)

$+(&1#( !#" #&1(# )3+(& 4 - "

(# " &##($1 # ( ! - #%

1#( # '

- #% &)

&# # #%

! #$

&# '

! - "! + G $

- #

#&#$!

- $#%& # #1

: "

*#% %#

! "& #%!

$ # -# ($& , !#,% - "#($

!#**#

&&# $! #(

&# #% 1

) - $

- #

#&#$!

* ,% - !# &# *# &&# $!#(#%

&# #% 1!##- " ( #% $ # # &# *# ! $# # $$& % #%

#* #(

- !

$ #=(!-1#%#;, +(&1#(#%!

$ #%; 0; :!!" # $ # $7++* &<#( $ -#

) ! %#

#* '...15. Therefore, the law on the issue can be summarised to state that, in the event that the person interested has not filed objections in response to a notice issued under Section 5-A, and has not challenged the acquisition proceedings, the quashing of the declaration issued under Section 6 in some other case, would not enure any benefit to such person. More so, where the possession of land has already been taken, and such land stands vested in the State, free from all encumbrances as provided under Sections 16 and 17(2) of the Act, prior to the date of decision of the Court quashing the declaration in toto, no benefit can be taken by him.

Where a party has not filed objections to the notice issued under Section 5-A, the declaration qua such persons is generally neither quashed, nor does it stand vitiated qua him, by any error of law warranting interference. There is also another view with respect to this matter, which is that, in case the said land has been acquired for a Scheme, which does not fall within the ambit of "public purpose" then, in such a case, it would not be a case of acquisition under the Act, instead, it would amount to colourable exercise of power...'

.8 %#

!&#&# ##%

* 7( ) &&

! ( & # &$ (!! %#1

) - $

- #

#&#$!

-, !#,% $$(!##&#*#

!$## &&# $#( &&#&

1 (& #% !

#!"#,=$! & # "%

!# ! ##*) !

$!* #

!#*34*#

, ! %#1 # &#$!

- ( & #% !

$ !$

-# #&#$!

- ,)=$! .. #*$#1 -##$#!

1,#%+$ #50354#%$#%58./

!1 !

)$#1& ,$ "!,)& #$ &#% $#1& 1#( #* $#1& 1#( * !!

! ,# $ ##& #%+ (# !

$ -

- - !& )1#%$#1& # $ # $#! $# -$)&$ ,! $ #50354#%$#%58./

#-# !( # #% $# -$ &$ ,! $ # 50354 #% $ #% 58./ %(

! !1 -% $ ##%

& -&#"

!!(!$ #50354#%$ #%58./$ #, "#'! .5 '(

#-#%% $& !! * 1 "1 )$#!! + !

!%# &(,

$ &(&# &(,

$ &(&# %# (

@ # #%

! %# !" #&1 #% #11$

$#///0 (- #&(,

$&(&#

"! ,) ! -C &&#"

) #( &

&& !%# 7( #

7( ")1($

# "&(,

$&(&# %%$&

-#%501 # ! & '

- & & #& + ( -#1$A "$# !! & #% -(1

! ,) &#! ! * $#1&

-1* 1 1&# % $##,'& 1

-* $ -#(#% ##%

!# "

9 &(,

$&(&# C (# )*# ,&# #!$ ! ,#((

@ ##%

! % "

-,"! + ./ 7( #% ,#"!

$( "

*#%

*(11 @! /D/#%!#" #&1(# )3(& 4 &$

) % "

$#!! $ ! &)

&# # #%

7( "

- , ' #,

- # %# & )1 #% $#1& !!

$ -!

#$# ! -

7( ")1($

# "&(,

$&(&# * "# ### ! $ %(

) !

$ -! #,

- # 7( ,# $# -$ #$$( $ #50354#%58./$ , -# && #1 !

!$ & !

1 ! .0 "

- !

1 ! 1

* & #

# % )

#1 1% * & !

1 ! + (7(# % ) !"

! 2+F 4 + 3

664 8/855855 #=( A& '

-C #! C# A&# C#