← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6931/2023disposed of

M/S Haryana Mining Company v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-09-01Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari7 pages





   

   !"



        "!

#

$$%&$% 



# #         "!

#

$$%&$% 

"$%"&''' ( $%"&'(%   ! !()  *+ ,!-!) 

./ !.* !0

1*$*2#!-)   !$0 *,!

1*-)  !*' !

.*  ! 2#! 3-3 !/ , * !#!.*1- -!/  !  #!0

1*-)  !! 4-5 6

7 894:48 !

*#3 13-)  !! 9

7 894:48 ;;;;

'' ()& %

 (!

 #

3* '3  ! !* '2

1!!

  6-   -  '

  ./   ! !-  

 <  31/  '!= - !/ -

* #!/-,* *

2 ! !

 

 $*

#!- 6-*'

**!

!>!  !! 

 

    



   





   

     

  

          

    

 

 

 

      

        

  

!

   "  #         

    

 $   

      

       

         

!    

      

 

   

    



 

 % 

   

   

 &  

 

  ' (   





)

 

      

 

 

  

   *

 



!  

           

    ' +   





 ,

 & 

 

      

  &    

   *  )

   !  

       

 %-.$(/,$"0",  

    %-.$1+*+$"0", 



  

 

 

   

     



 &        

        

   002"0", +3





 %-.$ 1+*+$"0", 

 

 (4

      

    

    



%    

     

      

 

   5  67 "  8  &  9     

    



  3 1  5  %-.$1+*+$"0",6          

 % 

  

                  

 

  

  



5 6   

    

  

  '  (  $  56    #   8    8 5:

 ' 6

/+1 ,;

  

    

 

8& 9   

 



 3 1 5%-.$1+*+$"0",6

          

    

       

  

  

    

 

 

 !  



 

     

         

 #    

  

   

 % 

  

!

  

 %  *3

   

 

  5 6 

 $

 3 (       

     

     5  6

   

      







  !





    

 

      

  

         



  





 +#      

           

         

     

  % 

 

         

 %  





5 6

&



!  



   



 %     





 

  



  !    

      

   

 

 





#      

  &  

  

   

 &       (# 







    

   &    

    (02"0", 1  

  

% 



    



  !    2< 00/"0",7 

 '#!

#     *  .)  !!  =  ./  *

#!-  * !   -* '

 '2

1

*3



* '! )'!*!!'

./* ! !-

  31/- !/ -'! )'!,*!. = >! *!

!-# 3=

 #!?# * 1

* ='

!* 

# *'! * '

!=-,!.# 

#3  *!3) > #

! '  )3/ 2

1'3  99- - 6,)!- * . 

**!

!>! '! )'!-* 

  * 

#3 ! 

# *'! * ' !=-/*!

  

/-#' -* >   '! * '   /   -    *#  3 ?#   !*!  0

3/  !

)!33/*3 .

/ !=





>#! 84  



   



  

    



  8=  8%   



  002"0", 

>.   % 

  



  



     

 



      

       ,01"01   ",02"0";

   

  

 

 

 

      

  

          

?

  

 

  7  $*3!



! #

3''!

1!*' !!1# - * *# ?# !#

'#3 .

/

3/

?# #=   !! -?#=# ,*!**!3 ! #.= .!*

#!-**' !

!/- -,

13 ?# * =* !    :  *3

-  *  3!

    #

3  !1# -  *  * ' !   !=  

  .  '!=     > )  *  =

!  =

!3 -!=*3 3 -# 3

* !3 .

/- !=

 *!#1*

>#! 84

3 ?#  4 

 ''!

-**!



'#, *! ' * )3 /    

= -   -  =  ?#  *  !3)   #    .  3133/   .3-#' *'! ' ! *3

-!

#!

1** !#' * 

'#- /! #3

*' ! !=- . =! 33!= 11

1 3

=

1  ) 

?# 3/- '!!=*# !2

=.!*

#!!3 !./*3!

 #

3-!*' !-*3!3  ?# , *

9= *

!=/-3 ?# *#!*! #= 5 !! -*!  $*  3!

    #

3  

!# 

='!    * =

#.= -* *  =  =-*.!*#

 ='3 , * ./*' !-*!#' *!   -* .0   *,!

3 .

1!*, * #.0 =

1  ) *

 *' ! !=



5 &#!*!=!- 

3  ! *!

#!

1*' !=. =  .33/ #  *33 1?#* ='

33*



= !# #' -** ! !  -=/'!  

*!

1*'! ' !-   *'    * 

1@ A

= ,)!-*=2

) 3.3 *'! ' !-*.)*!

1.!* ! !  - *33

33. 

!#.3 .!/*' !- 

.*3./*3!



! #

3-!*' !*#  3 ?# - *  #

 *  =

!  =   .)  ,)!- 

    *! 

 '     *  !3)     -  *#  ./  *   ! !   - *!#' > 

=# - . ='

./*' !-=/.

!-.0# 1

*#

##!.  .3-#' - *' ! / 9 (!

 #

3''!

1!! 9   -*

1! !

* '2

1!!=./* ! !  - ,*!

 *! 

   !!   .#  *  * 1  !  3! @ A 

 * ='

*'! * ' !=  -.

1 

#3

* .)!1!-*

#!

'!*!3 !=)! -*=     '* !1#= - *!!- * =2

1  * !1#= 1

.!*

#!-*#  

. =

 /#! /)3 / 6  *3

-'!=

.3!= 3/.!*

) 3 #! -!= .3.! #!

-*

 ! 9% 3= -  /-!3

1'! - !

!=*=

  ) /@ A ./* * 1 ='

*'! * ' !=- *33 . #.0 -*

= * ) 3 #   



 B*  *  ,!

  '

 !  

    , *  .) .

!)



1=

33 # ''3  @ A-  /-  @ A-

    '* '/    *

 !!  .  '3     *   3    *!

      '' (

  & &  (%  

*+,-.+   

+-*+-/.0-123456/-1.74-8 -.67

+-*+-//-07/*19,- -.67