← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9432/2021dismissed

M/S Amrik Wines v. State Of Punjab And Others

2021-05-13Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh22 pages

    

 !"#" $%

&  '(#)*"+"$#

"

" $* ,#

-

 .$/ 0 $1 2*#  

#3 $1$ '% 45' -'5-  

 

    

   

   









 

 

!!!!!

'5-6 758 "

   # $ % &' &' (&() 

# 

 + ,"

  # ) -*   . 

     / /  /



   #    

#  #   (& &1 (&)2

)& &3 (&(& 4 5 +'

+6  *7



  4 

 )( &8 (&()  5 +2

+97 .#

     5  : '99&9113/+ ( ;

* #   





 

*

 

 



< :  )992=

 



#



 

< : 4  7  )332 4

 > 9 )3327

  

# 

  



#

* )336+)332



 

)992





?

(

  4  



#    7 

   )332 

   #

* #  *  

< :  )992  

 

  

 #

 



 )992





+ ,

  "$"

" $

$ 

   #  #  5+ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @

A 



#



+  



 



# #

 *=

A  

 

 



 

=

@ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ B ?

 





#

   

 )992  

 #



 .=

0  *  #  5  +'

+6

# 

 

 #  45  +2

+97

# 

   

'

?

 



+ , 66  ,-  

 

: %



  5





 



--,  -    



  

#   *+

   

=

4 7





=

47  

*



#  = 47  

#



= 47

  

# 

=

47









#=

4#7



#=

#

 

* 

'    

: %

 

#

  B @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @

@

, 23 5'-5-+ 4)7 %   "



* "









 *#+

 



=

4 7 * *

      #   

#  * 

* 

 C 

"

26 + 4(7

47=

47  * 

*

 

    #  

* .



47

 *

 4(7 :

?





+ 4)7   "

 



 "





 *  B

& > 

*

#  *  





 

  



  





+ ,39   -'-  ,5  - -    5  ,

$



 



    

#    *+

  

# 

# 

#  



4 7





 



 

  

  

 #     1)  1( 







 

47 

  D





 -   )998

 E

.

  (&

 47

47

=

47 



*



 

   #

  . # .

 

   =

47 

  

   



#   #   #



#



 

*   .# # 

47

  



 

.

    #   

.     *

 

.  #

 

#



   .# #



47

  



   +

47 #   

  

   



##  .   )36'

47  *#

  

 

 # .  

#





 #

+ 

#

.

 

   )366=

47 # 

 



 

< : 47  4)7 )369  

   



## 

 

*





:

 *

= #

 

*

#

  

 # #

47

   



>



   #

 

*

#



   .# # =

47

   *   E

>#   

"

 #

 

#



    .# # =

4#7

  

 +

47



 * ;## ; < :

=

47

 



"



  #



; 

-

+-

=

47



:

 #

 



= #

 

*

#



  

 # # =

  # 



 

 

$ 

? # $ " G "  ? #  

5    *=

47

  ;5+ 

      

: 

:

 ;5+

    =

47 

 * *

## 



= 4.7





   *

  =B   





< :  )992



;



 39

*

 



   

#  

 *   

 



*

#  4

# 



*  7

;5  )3)1





 *      )3)1  



     #





  

#

 



 

#  

  



.    

  #    



 #

)1      

   "H > )9(1 (&)2

 &( &8 (&)2 45 +)7 4 

   "H > )&( (&)27  *  

   # 









     #

#

 ;5

?

"  &2 &3 (&)2 4 5 +17 $ 



   #

# 

   



 

 * 



 7







 #

)1 > 

     # /

 

 )&      

                

  

  

               !        ""

#$ %  6& :*  + 4)7 ?



# *  +

5

4 7



   0  

#

.

# "







83=

47

 







 

# 5 =     

 

* 4

*7 



*

 *

 

  

 

4(7 

#

.

# "







"

 



 + 4)7

* 





#

$  





#





* *   #



. 5  

 





* *  

  

 5 

   

 



*





#



 B

&   %' (   )*+   ""

#$  "$"

" $# + $ 

 



   #  #  5 +

@ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ %*+, <!"#  *=$.   >;5 : B    



* *  5    

 

 

#

0 5 #  #

 



 



B

 @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ , -   ""

  

 

. "  "

        "

  

 &  /       0 "" 1$ -  

  

                

 

            2'  334*

 



   " +,  *    # 

 

6&  )3)1



 *

  66 6269

 )992 )( "0  *

#  

 #

() 





< : 4  7  )332  *

 

  

 

  )992



  )992



    = 

 #  *   

#   

 



;5  )3)1

*

  #

   

< :  )992

# 



)8  #  

  



 *   

#

, B 4 

 )9927



 

,

B 

,

# 

# E B

  

   



  ,  

#B

, 

# E 

B ,

B 

 , 

# E B $  



 

   

 



 )992   

# 







   4



# E 

 )992



7 "0  * #

#  

 # 





 )332 #

 )1 $



 

#



  



  



*  

#  

 )992

 

   *  *  

 E  







    #

  * 

0  *

 ;5

?

"  &2 &3 (&)2 

# *

 

 

  * *  



< :  )992



 

  *



 )'

?

 * 







;5  )3)1 

 

*      5#

 

 *





#  

# 

  

#





*  

# 

#

# 7



* .  

#  



  



 

     

    

,H

 /+     * 

 # 7  , &



   - 

"   

"       "           ""

 ""

       

     "            $

"  "          

        &  0

  !4,!,5!4

         *  +                   6 



&       



  "

     ""

       

       

    .  "

,,



 

     !* 

 "  

 +    

       

                 ""



,,! ,!7,5!5, $ 

# 

  #   B $$   

#  #

#

  

 *

 + 



 )332 4  &' &' (&()7



*  #

 #

   # 

 



. #

 # )'/)6  &' &' (&() 

   # 

 . 

#   #  /

 +   &1 &9 (&)2/  &2 &3 (&)2/   

 )992  



# 

#   &' &' (&()

 

  



 

  ((6 " $ 



9   

   

  

#   

    

   





  



 



4 

$$$ ?



#     &6 &' (&()

# 

  &2 &' (&()



# 

+ -

+

                        

 !"

 #        $% $& '$'!    ( (      # )    *  ( 

    ((#           #  $+ $"

'$!+,-.  )/0*(##    (## 1      ) * (   $& $& '$'! *(  *   * ( (      (#                      *  ( #     2    $& $& '$'!    (    

 3    *                         *       (           2 ,-(4 5 0     67(  5 8 $ ? *

  





 *

:

#  &' &' (&()

 

EH

 E   &6 &'/&2 &' (&()     

 * ;5

"   &1 &9 (&)2 #

     #

     :

129)6&(8/+

 # 

  

  # + )& &9 (&)2

#  4

  #   

.

 #



 

 5 



  

 # 7   

  

#

#  

# .

#

 

   ;5 : 7       .#

# * #  

 





#  

     I #  * 



#

 

< : 4  7  )332

  

 &' &' (&()J   

 

  

 # 

   

#  

#

   * 

# #

 



$







 





 #

 6&

;

;5  )3)1 

  . *

 



#



      



< :  )992

 4

 *   

5

7

<    

 

 

#  #

 



 )992

#    

* #

 4

7 

 

  #  / 5

5  +'

+6

7

 #

 

# 

 

$ ;

# 

# 

  

 

 

 )992 



+ ,

  -*  ##     # ((*    *       (   

?

 

 



: 

 * 



      

%  *   *    4  #

'

 &' &' (&()7



 

: 



  5

 

 4

 ;5 K ?

" 



# 

: %

 #

))  &' &' (&()7

 

 

   0  

 7

 

 

 

#  5   





;5  



#

    

 ///

#

?

 



# 

 #   5  +'

+6

#

   )992

 5  +2

+9

#   

0  

$$ ?



# 

   # )'

)6   &' &' (&()   

 )992

#

 

   .# *

   

  

 



  <+(  



*

*

#  &1 &9 (&)2

 



 

 #   *  #

)'



    

 #   &2 &3 (&)2  ;5

 ?

" 

# * 

  



 



 

&2 &' (&() 4* :  -

L 

    # 7



* 

 



 

 

*

  

 

 *

#

 

 ((6 " $ 

 

.      



 E   9 



?

5



  

 

#  &' &' (&()  * EH

 E      *

 *     

  

  

  

  

   *

# 

    &1 &9 (&)2   #   

 #  

?





  .

 

 #   &2 &3 (&)2

 ;5

?

"

 -

  (2 &( (&)2 "H > )&( (&)2 &( &8 (&)2 "H > )9(1 (&)2  7

  &( &8 (&)2 #



+ ,

* (   1:4     4); <)  = !$'    '$!+  *   *      #      ;'+ $'

'$!+ 

 * (    '



      ((  *    (          (,0  ;                           # $"

$> '$!+    #(        

  (( (           #    #     >!

$> '$!+;#    #           #          ;                 #  8 ?

 

 

    #      &3 &8 (&)2  #  *



  

* 

 

  *



8) &8 (&)2

? *

 *  



  

 *  



 

 

   *  

 

$

 



 







 

 

 &2 &3 (&)2

   ;5

?

" 5#

* 



.



 

   



    #  # 

  &( &8 (&)2

 

?





#

#  



  



  

  )332



# 

#

*     &' &' (&()=  

 

 

$$$ ?

   #   &' &' (&()



   * $   #  

0  

'

? 6 7'5-8      .#/  M/>

 :

M/>