Sujender Pal And Others v. The State Of Haryana And Others

 



  


 

  


   !

"#"$%"& '() ! ! 

$'('*(+"& '() ! ! 





    



     
  
 )  , - !

.
 ..   /

 , - !

.


/-   

    !
" 
#"$"%

&'" (# ! )!"*%

* +%""",# !
""

#!"

% +%""" ! )!"*%

&'",# !-#"* -"!"'#" "%

&'" !
#&"$+" %

&'" ! "$ "%

&'"" !


#"# "%

&'" ( .
  //// ..   /

!

0

#  '*"$  $"

    #  "  ,      (  " $" "$ $"

# '' %%$( #*' " 01234205(#"""+&$%# %# *"  *" ($"'6%#%# '$

."*&"

*(  (#6 *' 4

#  *"  '*  ""  (  #    #" ('(**  ' %    *")   $%    #  $" "  (
'020 ( # #"7$"" ""'



" '6%  #"

*"  "  *$  '%  4208 9#"(  (  #  (    "  #  : '  (  4208:; "  '"$ '" #< '(4208:%# #""" '40(4205% &,#("="' #"(%#"#*" " ."*&"

*(#*&" *' #(%# #""  #"#*" %'&(#"**"'#

"'6  '      #  " '6  '%  0531 9#"((#'"** "#:

'(0531:;# '$ (** $" %"#"."*"&"

*(  (# *&" *'%# #""&"*"

*( '$

*" ($"'6        


     



                   

  

! "

#

 $%#"

                    "   &  $%#"

'

  ""

 "'        ( )#  

 *  "

# 

"  "

  #' #

 '  ""' "

$%#"
+ 8 >#" "& #,%#"# "#'"*(#  *"  ##"&''

 "*##"'6(#*" " "

#"* ,##("$* # #"&"'6 #*"

*(& (#&" *  1 !&% "*' #"# #"&



' "

#"''(&  '$"%"$'# "%# *" #*" (#*" ,"

?"' #:*" %,#"%# '  ?' #    *"     "'6%  # #  $")  #  $ 

('"9; @ >(#"& #,%#"&,( '*"A(#*' " 01234205(#"""+&$%# "'6 *"  *" ($"'6 #*&"(# *'9";="' #"( ,
-.# $

 ""    /  0"  

  &"'            '   " 

' ( !

  "#

     !

&  ""

 

! "'  

"   
!

&"

  #'   '  ""'  

*                   "

  1' 


2&

( !3#

 "   

 "  

 *

  4   

    

'    "   "    "

 "   

     " '   %#"      & '   "  #  "'



 %#"  

 

         '    "   ''      

 
5!4  "      

 *

    "&

!  ##

"#

 6 

    #



   
B

##"&"*(* "9 = .

0@; (#"#'' ) *" (#*"  &,(#*'9"; A #%#" (#"& #,%#" #."'6 *"  #"   '"*C#*" "$" #%#*"  *" ($"'6   &"

*."* "1#'(# 2'$ $"3"+45(6 47"

#*895##5'(# '2 47"

:"1$("& +'*(#":

2'$ 47"

;"4545'("$#! 5

#  *"  '*  ""  (  #    #" *") # $%"&*(
'020 9";",**"% "'#('*"A(#*' " 01234205(#"""

+&$%      #  "   $  '$  '$** # %#("'("'(''= ""

"# B(# *%"(( "&%"(# # #  '' %',#("="' #"( 70
- 



"     " 
-

#    ' " 





 " '

  
8    
  '

#  "

'

%

9 '5"# " ': 5 

 "  

0" 
-"  " 

'
 -            

    & & ;< 9=

  
+ 3

 "

 (  #  "  '%    $")  "#'

$ '9;%#"#*" ""$") (#"  *'" # "*C %"*C"

*%" %" &"

*(("'*" #" *'76*%# '*(#'"" %#"#*" " #  ."*    &"

*  (  ("'*"  #  "   *'

#'",**"" $$ %#& (
'020 (#:

'(4208:&,(#*' "

01234205  7"*%    &"*  $"  (  "*  *"'#

"'6'  #:

'(0531:%## %("%(#*" % #%'"** ,#  #  & *   .&  #   *'  %  #    "# '$***",(* #" #"#"

&  $

"&*(
'020 (#:

'(4208:%*' "

01234205%'$**'"'" "*" " #"

 #"  #  "      #%  ""    .

"*&"

*(#  *" %#(("'*" # " *'%"#"  %"&*( ?'& '$*"%"$"

 #"#'' %" '#

<

"

& ?'&#'$*"% $"("&%#"# *" "" "*'$(#*"*"*"  #'$*(#*&" *' #(%#*"

'*(##""

**") #"

&" $% #$ #&(
'020 (#:

'(4208:

" D%%*' " 01234205 02 7'*    &  (  ,#  &  # "'6  *" %    #     '' %  #  #"   "'9;(('"9;9";%# ,##
" '$ "

*,(#"'6 *" *"*#&$( '$*    "

*  ,#  &  #  "'6  *"     #  .
"%#$"),**$, ,##"$ (# & '  :

* =7#'"(  

!"#$ "%  

&'()**+
+'

&$")"*(# "'6 *" # # *'"' #%#&(  *C %#=' (#"

&, ""

*,% "#"

*%"# #"'$" '$('#

#
"("""%#,* "**# .& $ # *'9; #(%='"&"='"* ''$"'%"$'#"%'''( #"6  = "  $  (  '$"  $  $ %  # $") #*6 "%'""  #
" ='#6%#%# #"""$(."* &"

*((#"'6 *" %$" '$"



#
"(""",&%#"

&='""&"*"

* #' (#'"

=

00 7'*"*,##" " #*"

"*

&'"+"*%"""#",# ","*(#*'

9"; "'&' "(# " #"& #*#*'9";*)* .'"**  04 !&%"*(""@(#*(#  %&"* #"1#""*"

'& #

$ "$('$",&%#" '&

4%,#"%0" 8"' " ,#'  08

#(('(#"

&%#"%# # '' " $ "''#&"* (#*"'# (# "'6' %" # #""# ($ '#"** #&"* (#*"'# (#"'6'  01 !&%,#0" 8"' " *",(*,(#*" %###"&   $""#  ,#'$""$ $  '(4%*  %" ,#'" *" #$76*%#*&"$ $"

(#"#'' %# #" %#% #    '$"  "$    (#,#  *"    '.

4 0@ #%#7"*'"* " ,-$""

./0  " 1" 0 23404"56 7   

  8$",'

 +*

%#"

* #

"*,#$*""#", #*&" ""

"#(#& '9";"="' #"(

>

7,
>" # ' 

" "     

'

       "    6    #'6 

  ( 9:;$$$$ 5"

4<$"  6 $6
"  "$ 44 =& 6>4

"''" / <?6"  <   $     32/       

 "46$

"'$6$<6/42 < &  ""

& $     32/'  "  6>4  4  $  6   * @ 9:;$$$"6 $6
6 52" 6 4" 6' 24 $ 

  66'    6$

5  $ 

4

66 4  6>4"  065"'  4  $  6   * @ 9:;$$$

66$ " 2"5$  ""$ $ 6>4

$ "<6/42 < &

""

&'$54'$ $

$ " <4 =''$

64"<$"0""""'

2 046/$  @ 5,
- '$?5?@"

           

 " #"  

   #    "      <'  # 


A# #



    5?@

 # 

      

-"

"   

$

'   #$? 5?@ '9 4
55? 

"

' '  1$%#"                  

    '      

"

   # "7 #

+ 7 +
9#' &"'      #        $  ?          '    $ ""

! #'       

 $  ?           $

'                  $ %#"1 '  "#' $  0          

,         #

  " 

 "7 #

+7 +






@?
-"

$ 5?@ $0

, " 

  $?
-#'' $0

,



&    $  ?
 -          # $?   #<  '




- 



  

" #              "        $  %#"   "

6#  <'  '


@
> " #$? #   $%#"  "  *  '   "

'  7 #  +7  +   '

   6 64"04< 6 040"
9/0$ """400 :

@
  

  #  

       9B

$

"    

  '   $ ?5?@   *  " 6"

 $%#"    #

  

 #

"7 #

+7 + 

 '

#& ' 7



+

 -      '      '    

!

   '    

    $  %#"  <'    &      $  ?          5?@ #$'#" #' <""

 


""

    " '

   
8  #'   ""

       

      !


-  #" '

  ""

 

      !     &"  $   

,
C  

 #$ %#"1 '  "

 

 "

  #     

   

                   



-# #  "           "

   #             & "( 7AB(B.C89(: - '   $ ?5?@ 7  *+  " 6

 '#"                

        

      #  " #

+7 + ' 




AB(B.C89((: - 4
! '#
- $?'#   #   

' 



  '



AB(B.C89(((: -                  '#
 -

# #'      #  "  7 #

+    7  +'   # 

 *     

 #  " 
+ 5(1:

$&"$ '2 475#
'*$4!

0B >"($"#%#7( $#,% #"$ '$**(&*%#6   $

,#' #(%#"$ $ ,#'(@2%222D.

"'#(# (#,#  #$,## :/ 6$

 "$  )

$  "$ 

, ($ " # ""* "#
"''  0A
'#$"'"*(#"  ' %#%"**#





 "*'"9;%("%"*" 9;  (

..   /

  /-    ! ! 

  )"& # 7"47"$ #;"1?5(6$"1#'("& ) "#'

7"47"$ $";'$418:"

) "#'