High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/28428/2015allowed

Narinder Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2015-10-08Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

!"! #$ %& '

&!#(&)!#*+ +&"

,,,,,,,, ! #&"

-&"."

.#/ % +&"

,,,,,,"0 #(# $ $ $ $ 12),)) 12),)) 12),)) 12),)) &"#

&"#

&"# $ &,!3& 4/!

& .& '(5

! #&", &,,),)!(+.'.#/ %, &, &!"+ 5(!'(5

&&"0 #(# " , , 6666 )', )', )', )', ! #&" + (

( 7 !# ,

(

, 8,

9'.#(&) ! #" '9:'9 '9'99& (;!

< +#(!

## 7 (' :

=11 &"+ & >'

&*!"

7! )

! # /!

7 .& 5!( /.(*4# ? &(& (

( 9

&(&( + #5!

#("# ! #&".#(& ! #" '99'9& (;!

+) <,**&!5(

+ "

!( /.(*4# ? &(& +!& #5!

! # #( "# # '0 ! #&"0& &&( 7% +0077

.& , ;5&' (.&!#* + 0#(# @ 7' 0 !"

5 4!

%7@"

7( +!&(!"0.

, &#( .#"7 + 0 ! #&" + "".%4!

(

+!#A."

! #;

"7!

%7 %A.

"+( !"

%7@"

7( +!&(!"0.

,#".00 & +!" &*.4# "'

&#( .#"7 ! #&"+ "07 (&7!

# #

/.(*4# +!" .& !#).%)!#*+ # +&-",)

).%)!#*+ # +&-",)

&@ # # +&

9=>,,,=&!4!# 7>

&@ # # +&

9=>,,,=&!4!# 7>

&@ # # +&

9=>,,,=&!4!# 7>

&@ # # +&

9=>,,,=&!4!# 7>

';+&!#'

77 ;!#*A."

! #";& 4( & #"!(&

! #$ B= >C+ +& +0 ;&D& !"

%7%@ +!*+ .&

.#(&) ! #&,,,!" # & 77(%@) ! #9

&,,, &!

#%!#5 3(!# 00& 0&!

5#!

# " &# 40 .#( %7!##

.&E =>C+ +& &!4!# 70& (!#*" #%A.

"+(%@

+!*+ .& !#D& !" !

"0 ;&.#(&) ! # &,,,5#

."(;

.#(*.!7 @

#( #5!

(%@ 7 .& + .*+ +4

&!"

".%/.(! % 0077

.& EF C+!7( 7!#*;!

+A."

! # , ' +!" .& !#

+/.(*4# + "+7( ".#(&$ B+& ."

7 !#5 30 ;&.#(&) ! #9

&,,,'+ ;5&'( "# (% +!*+ .& & 4 &" & !#* !

"!#+&# 0 ;&.#(&) ! #&, ,, #(0 "" 00& 0&!

&(&" " .& #(" /."

! ,F C+!7( 7!#*;!

+A."

! # ,' +!" .& !# :' 8 #( +/.(*4# + "+7(.#(&$ : "&* &(" +( .% D0&""(%@ +7 &#( )!#*7.(*;+ +& +!#+&# 0 ;&.#(&) ! # & A.

"+ + &!4!# 70& (!#*" # % "!" 40& 4!"# &(!# % ;# !"

# % !#5 3( 5# !

+ ."( + " %# +7( *.!7 @ #( #5!

(%@ 7 .& '; !#(

!# &,&5!#( &"

.7 ,5",)

(+@ & ("+G #&,'

=>=&!4!# 7><

> )8<'

+.# .#

&!4 #!

7(!"0.

;

+ 0077 # =+."% #(> + ( %# #5!

( .#(& ! # < #( "# # ( 4 # +"H !40&!" #4# #(+!" 7;

"0#(!#*%

!&"

0077

.& , + 0D .& A.

"+( &!4!# 70& (!#*"30!#*!#5!; +0 .7!

#( !& .4"

# " " #(!# +!# &"

9 /."

! %"&5!#*

B # !#.

! # &!4!# 0& (!#*"; .7(% %." +0& "" 7 ;F

7" %@!#5 3!#*!

"0 ;&.#(&& ! 7 #"

! #,)!# +!*+ .& ( "# 0 """"

#@0 ;& 3!# + #.#(&& ! 7 #"

! #' + !

(( !"! # ## % #"

&.(

55"

+!*+ .& ;!

+". +7!3.#0 777 0 ;&,

8, + 4 *#!

.( !#+&# /.&!"(!

! # D& !"

%7%@ +!*+ .& .#(&) ! #& ;!

+ 5!; 0&5# %." 7 ; & " .&

+#(" /."

! '+ ;5&'!";!(# .*+ !# 7.( "0 ;& A.

"+ +0& (!#*"!#&7

#7@ +# # 40 .#( %7

# "# ;!

#(!#*

+% &.#(&) ! #9 &%.

". + 0 ;&'!# .& #"!(&(5!;'!"D& !"

#@"

+& !" # D0&"" % & #( !#5 3!#* ". + 0 ;&!" .77@/."

!( #

#( !& .4"

# "

", IIIIII # + 7!*+ +" 0 .7!

" #( !& .4"

# " ;+& # #7@ + 0 !" %.

+!& 7 "&7

!5"=!# 7.(!#*( .*+ #(" #!#7 ;

&"0 #(# ,> + 5 7" ".00 & ( 4!

74# ' ; & + #"!(&( 5!;

+ 40& 4!"; .7((!"+ &4 #!J &7

! #"+!0 ." 0&4 ## &!

4 #*"

4!7@ 44%&" ;+ & 7!5!#* +& " / !#

4!7@, #

+ 40& 4!"; .7( 7"

(#!

7 407 /."

! ;+! +!" +5&@ ""# .&/."

! (7!5&@"@"

4,)!# +&!"

# "

&@4% &* !#5 3!#* 0 ;&.#(& ! #&,,,

& #5!

."(%@

7 .& #((.&!#*0#(# @ 7

". + #5!

! #'!

&" % " !#5 3

+ !#+&# /.&!"(!

! # #( "

&!3 ( ;# 0& (!#*"".%/ &

!#"

&(",F

-!( &(&(

'0077

.& ;

(!& & &( +"

4# !" #("#(!

&0 & ;!

+&* &( *#.!##"" + 40& 4!"

( % ;# !", #0.&".

!( &(&' +0077

&& &(!#* +"

4# !"+ "&0 &

+ 40& 4!"

( % ;# + 0 !" ;

" *#.!#'

+ .

0&"".& #(5 7.# &, +."' +!" "!" 5&(%@ +( !"! #*!5#%@ !5!"! # # + +!" .& !# ).% )!#*+1" " =".0& >, &(!#*7@' +!"0 ! #!" 77 ;(,40.*#(/.(*4# ? &(& (

#5!

#("# # 0 ""(%@

7 .& &"

"!(, #"A.# 7@' + &!4!# 70& (!#*"

! #&" # +% "!" + ,

(

, 8,

9'.#(&) ! #"9:'9'99'&*!"

7! )

! # /!

' !"

4&!

& A.

"+(, ".7

# 7@' 70& &&(%@ ! #&"% 0077

.& ; .7(%&#(&(!# &.

. ." #("+ 77%"

( 7 &(%@ +0077

4&!

&, =)> =)> =)> =)> %& '

%& '

5!&