Bajrang Lal And Others v. The State Of Haryana And Others



   




 !


   
""
 

%'( &(+#,#)$ 

- -  %./%$0 1%2 )'3(/,

------ ('#'#)$(/, 4(/,5, %/7%$% )'3(/,

------ (,8)$&($',
    91 -

6
  6  /(,($'

/- #$%'

63%/:%;

&<)+%'( %882#+%$'8('#'#)$(/,-

/- %<# 5''

63%/:%;

 %/7%$%- - -  6 ;

-

 1

""
  - 3#, %$ %882#+%'#)$ 6(+'#)$ 

82%+#$0 /(+)/& (,)25'#)$ )-  - - ;

"- -

)/ /(%,)$, :($'#)$(& %882#+%'#)$;

,%:( %22)@(& (,)25'#)$ )-  - - ;

" '%A($ /(+)/&;

,5=.(+'

%22 .5,'

(?+(8'#)$,-

-

882#+%'#)$ %++)/&#$027;

)*-

- /%7(/

/'#+2(,  
)$,'#'5'#)$ $&#% #,;

#$'(/ %2#%;

#,,5%$+( $%'5/( :%$&%:5, &#/(+'#$0 /(,8)$&($', &(+#&( /(8/(,($'%'#)$ - - 

B @3(/(#$ 8/%7(/ +%//7#$0 )5'

:#$)/ %&.5,':($', ,#'( 82%$ 8/)8),(&



#<#2 6(+/('%/#%'

#$# 6(+/('%/#%';

,) ,8%/( 8('#'#)$(/,9 )/ 8/)<#&#$0 %2'(/$%'#<( ,#'(, $(%/ 5, 6'%$&;

5$#+#8%2
)::#''((;

>%$#$%-

-

*5/'3(/ 8/%7(/ &#/(+'#$0 /(,8)$&($'

)- A((8 8/)+((&#$0, %/7%$% 5=2#+ /(:#,(, 1%$&

<#+'#)$ ($'

(+)<(/7

+';

,3)/'

9C

+'9 %=(7%$+( '#22 &(+#,#)$ 8('#'#)$-

- /#(*27;

%/( ,:%22

>%$#$%;

#,'/#+'

%3($&(/0%/3;

)8(/%'#$0 ,:%22 =5,#$(,,(, 2#A(;

<(0('%=2( ,3)8,;

:)=#2( ,3)8,;

=%/=(/ ('+-

('#'#)$(/, %/( 8),,(,,#)$ '3(,( ,#$+( C-

- %<(//(& #$#'#%227;

%22)''(& 2%$& /($'

>%$#$%B ,5=,(D5($'27;

/(,)25'#)$ - -C;

8(/:#''(& +)$,'/5+'

'3(#/ 2%$&-

*5/'3(/ ,5=:#''(& - -C;

/(,)25'#)$ )- B @3(/(=7 #'

%22)''(& 2%$& A3)A%, =%,#, /($'-

+2%#:(& %/( 8%7#$0 /($'

'#:(-

- %88(%/, )<(/$:($'

%/7%$% &(+#&(& +)$,'/5+'

#<#2 6(+/('%/#%'

#$# 6(+/('%/#%'

<#22%0( $3%$# %'

2%$& :(%,5/#$0 C >%$%2

"

%/2%B *%+'

=)/$( )5'

*/):

- - 

-

- *5/'3(/ %<(//(& %$)'3(/ /(,)25'#)$ - -  ,%2( %$)'3(/ "

>%$%2  %/2% %/(%B %88/)<(& %/7%$% )<(/$:($';

- - C

-



-"

'/%$,8#/(, ,):( ,(/<(& $)'#+(, - - C

";

)227-;

+%22#$0 58)$ '3(:

<%+%'( '3(#/ 85/8),( +)$,'/5+'#)$ )**#+( 65= #<#,#)$%2

**#+(/

B @3(/(58)$ ,):( %88/)%+3(& '3#, #-(-
C C

;

+%:( )*;

- - "

B /(2(<%$'

(?'/%+', /(%&,



        

 

     



 

    



   

     





    

   



  

          

       

 

 

   

 

         

   

    

      

     



 



 



   

 

          

    



           

   

   

   

   

   

         





 !

  "  # - %<(//(& +):82#%$+( %*)/(,%#& - - "

;

'3#,
C C;

,5=:#''(& '3(#/ /(,8(+'#<( /(82#(, $)'#+(, - - C

";

)227-B ,5=,(D5($'27;

%0%#$ #,,5(& $)'#+(, - - 

 /(,8)$&($', %2,) /(*5,(& %++(8'

/($'

*/):

8('#'#)$(/,-

%2'3)503 ,):( ,5=:#''(& '3(#/ /(,8(+'#<( /(82#(, */(,3 $)'#+(, - - 

B ,#$+(

"

/(82#(, =(#$0 +)$,#&(/(& +)$+(/$(& %5'3)/#'7;

%++)/&#$027;

)-  %$)'3(/

CC ;

%2,) )*;

-- 

B /(2(<%$'

(?'/%+'

/(%&,
$ %                          

      &  

  '('($'$)  *+  ,(  -  "       





    .

  

       /   1+   2

  



   !

  3  /

 





 





   

 &    

 



 

   

    

   



4    %  1   5 5 "

* 678$  9678$* 9" &  

*

    

 

 



  

 

               : !   

  





   

   

  ;      

  

                

   # -

8(/5,%2 %=)<( (?'/%+'(& --  +2(%/27 #$&#+%'( (%/2#(/

CC  ,'%'(:($'

2(%/$(& +)5$,(2 %5'3)/#'#(, 8/)+((& '%A( %+'#)$ 8/)<#,#)$,

+'

)/ %$7 )'3(/ %+'B :%7 %882#+%=2( :%''(/-



- %88(%/, $)@ %$ (<#+'#)$



+'

,3)8A((8(/,-

- $ %*)/(:($'#)$(& +#/+5:,'%$+(,;

3%<( =(*)/( '3#, ,((A#$0 /(2#(* ,;

$)'#+(& 3(/(#$%=)<(-

"- (%/&-

-
)$+(&(&27;

#$&5+'(& 2%$& )@$(& /($'

=%,#,-

8(/5,%2
2%5,(

 (<#+'#)$

 ,3)@ ,8(+#*#+ 0/)5$& '%A($ (<#+'#)$ ,8%+( /($'(& )5'

+2(%/ ,'#852%'#)$ <%+%'(& 9%, @3($ /(D5#/(& ,%:#'#9- *5/'3(/ 8%/% (<#+'#)$

 3%<( +)$,'/5+'(& ,)2#& %'

,#'(;

*%22, +%'(0)/7 ($+/)%+3:($'- $ 8%/%"

(<#+'#)$

;

*)22)@#$0 %<(/:($'

:

 



 

     +



/ 



-   

  

  

 

 

/ 





     

 

-   +    



   

    # - $#'#%227;

3%& %88/)%+3(& '3#, 8('#'#)$;

+3%22($0#$0 %+'#)$ #,,5#$0 $)'#+(, '3(:

<%+%'#$0 8/)8(/'7 D5(,'#)$;

82(% 8/)8(/ 8/)+(&5/( 8/(,+/#=(&

+'

*)22)@(&;

%++)/&#$027;

'3#,
)5/';

-- 

;



+%'(0)/#+ ,'%'(:($'

2(%/$(& +)5$,(2 8/)+((&#$0, #$#'#%'(& %++)/&%$+( 8/)<#,#)$,

+'-

- )@;

@3($ (<#+'#)$ 8('#'#)$, 3%<( )'3(/

+';

3%<( %0%#$ %88/)%+3(& '3#, 82(% ,#'( 82%$
#<#2 6(+/('%/#%'

#$# 6(+/('%/#%'

:)&#*#(& ,) ,8%/( 8('#'#)$(/,- -

/):

8(/5,%2 (<#+'#)$ 8('#'#)$;

#'

(<#&($'

@)/A #$# 6(+/('%/#%'

%2:),'

+):82('( @)/A
):82(?

0)#$0 =)'3 '3(,( =5#2&#$0,;

'3(/( $((& %88/)%+3 /)%&, ,8%+( 8%/A#$0-

-"

%88(%/, %++)5$'

)++58%'#)$ 8/)8(/'7 )'3(/ ,3)8A((8(/,;

%*)/(,%#& @)/A +)$,'/5+'#)$ #$# 6(+/('%/#%'

):82(?

=(#$0 %**(+'(& &(2%7(&- 3( +2(%/27 &(:)$,'/%'(, +)$&5+'

8/)2)$0#$0 '3(#/ 8),,(,,#)$ )<(/ ,#'(;

:7 +)$,#&(/(& <#(@;

2%/0(/ 85=2#+ #$'(/(,'-

-

'

'3#, ,'%0(;

2(%/$(& +)5$,(2 ,5=:#', %$)'3(/ /(,)25'#)$ - - 

";

@3(/(#$ #'

/(,)2<(& 6%:#'# ,3)52& +)$,'/5+'

,3)8 2%$& ,)5'3 %3($&(/0%/3(@%/# /)%& '%A( %+'#)$ 8()82( @3),( 2#<(2#3))&, 3%<( %**(+'(&-

- 3%<( +)$,#&(/(& %*)/(,%#& +)$'($'#)$ /%#,(& =(3%2* 8('#'#)$(/,B *#$& $) :(/#'

,%:(;

(,8(+#%227 +)$,#&(/#$0 *%+'

/(,)25'#)$ - - 



" :5+3 8/#)/

CC ;

)'3(/ )*;

-- 

 8/#:%/#27 ,'%'(:($'

2(%/$(& +)5$,(2 8/)+((&#$0, #$#'#%'(&

+'-

-
)$,#&(/#$0 ')'%2#'7 +#/+5:,'%$+(,;

%:

+)$,#&(/(& <#(@ %$ )=2#D5( :)'#<( &(2%7 &(+#,#)$ (<#+'#)$ 8('#'#)$,;

+'

)'3(/ +)$,(D5($+(, '3(/()* 8/)2)$0 8),,(,,#)$ )<(/ ,#'( D5(,'#)$-

- <#&($'27;

+)$,'/5+'#)$ #$# 6(+/('%/#%'

@(22
):82(?

=(#$0 %**(+'(&;

2%/0(/ 85=2#+ #$'(/(,'-

++)/&#$027;

*#$& $) :(/#'

,%:( %++)/&#$027 &#,:#,,(&B '3(/( ,3%22 &#/(+'#)$ %5'3)/#'7;

&(%2#$0 (<#+'#)$ 8('#'#)$,;

+'

+)$+25&( 8/)+((&#$0, (?8(&#'#)5,27-

- ($&#$0 %882#+%'#)$

,;

#* %$7;

,3%22 %2,) ,'%$& +2),(&-

 6 

 

- - 

,.A, 3('3(/ ,8(%A#$0 /(%,)$(&

 !(,

) 3('3(/ /(8)/'%=2(  !(,

)