High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/15099/2019disposed of

Alok Mishra And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2021-11-09Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl14 pages

!" #$#$ %%&$ '$ ( ) &(*+#$ %% ,

- ),)./ %%&$ '$ ( ) &(*+#$ %% , 0000 &$ $ +#1)2$13(, $)#!3$42 1 $#,$ $ 55(!2 32&(*+ $3(./ # .,!$ ,6 ,$ 7#$(4#' $ 4 0000

!"#$%%!&$&'() !!'*$++!&$'+, !"#"%&!&$&'() !!'*'-&!&$'+ 7# $#8,,! ($) -9 $&

-2- *!/ ! +#!

:);< <. $ !*/ "4 , ! #., $.

# !.4$.

=($ 2$$1+8#,$ >$#$ #$!

#$?( # !$ ( ! $#,$ 2#,,! $!!8#.

$"(,@$/ !

$ , ! ().

/0/ # + !+/#,$ #$

#!!44# (..4$$

=($& ,

.,! =($& 9 ,$( ! # .,! 8!! # (..4$$8(! #8##$8$ =

( !!2( 8# # ($

( #1 !#,$

( ),)./28# ##,$ 8## +.

( # ! - #!!44 # (..4 $$

# . .,! # #$ , 9 =($ & 9 7# #

( 2 :( )$/8$;( $ <.:);<8 (..1# .,(4 (..4$$ - 2 $@ # # ($8 ,! ,

# !!84$$

! "#$%

( )

* &

-3-

"%&#%&"#$% )+ ,(-! .

/ &

. & '

, )+ ,(0! .

& )

"1&#0&"#$1 )+ ,($%!

* / 2 3

/ !

&' ) &

#0&#"&"#$- )+ ,($!

(

& ) ""&#-&"#$4 )+ ,(5!

-4-

! &

$4&#4&"#$-& ,

& ) &7 ($4 # , / # 2 # .$ # +

.,$. $.

# !. 4$.

=($ $$1 +8 # ,$ <$ ( ! $ # ,$# (+.##,$ 2#$ ,( # ,$ !

#.,/2 :);<<.8## .,! !* / # + ! ! !. # + ,$,$ 7# $!1 ,$ # !. 4$.

=($ $,$( #$+!8

' ) 8 0 3 "#"$9

)$-40 6 "#$:!.

"/ ,;

< 1####$ & = > ;

"4&#0&"#"$ ?

&= >;

#4&#%&"#"$& ' @ /

-5- "4&#0&"#"$ ? #4&#%&"#"$ . + A >

C +

+ * . &D& ,

/ .

6 / 3A B

C +

+ . &D& A . B

$& '2 , (

/& "4##### ( / '(2 . ! , ,& "& '

/& $"4#### ( / '.2 '

E! +

F 6 & B##05":C

/& $"4#### ( / '. 2 '

E! *2 @ ;8

6* #4&#1&"#"$

-6- ,&) F

+ ) " :& '

/& $"4#### ( / '. 2 '

E! . )& %& ' , ,

:# ! +

) >

9 CASES FILED BY SECOND PARTY S.

Case Title Case No.

Details of Forum No.

Case 1.

Daljit Roy v.

CC/2500/2015 Criminal JMIC, Sandeep Somany Complaint Jalandhar and Ors.

Daljit Roy v. HSIL CS/528/2017 Civil Suit Civil Judge, Ltd.

Jalandhar 3.

Daljit Roy v. Alok CRM/1422/2019 Application JMIC, Mishra (Vice under Section Jalandhar President of Kitchen 340 Cr.P.C.

Appliances Department of the First Party) 4.

Daljit Roy v.

CRM/1421/2019 Application JMIC, Sandeep Somany under Section Jalandhar 340 Cr.P.C.

Akhil Bharat Grahak CS/940/2019 Civil Suit Civil Judge, Panchayat V/s HSIL Jalandhar

-7Limited (instituted at the behest of Second Party) 4& ' , .

) @ 8 , .& &

-%# "#$- A

6 &4 .D

* .

<"3, >

)& 0& '2 , )

= *> / /

$4:4 "#$- ,

:# ! +

)& 1& ' , .>

G .

/ ( ($4#--("#$-

/ ( ($4$%"("#$-

, > ?

:# ! +

)

H ( E#0&#"&"#$-&3

3 &/& 6 & "4## "#$4 &/& & &"4## "#$4& 5& ' , (

, > ? 3 *

-8- .

&/& &6 &"4## "#$4F & -& ' , +

) . . 2 , 8

! .

& $#& ', , ) + (

> . ) , ) . F +

)& $$& ', ) * & 2 ,

.& $"& ' , )

. &

& $:& ' ) . + ,

F .&

-9- $%& ' , ) + . & $4& ' , ) . )& $0& ', )

)& . . #$%&'( )*&+,+-.

. 9(

'/ 0/$ %/$

'/ 12'34 %/$& / %*50$

'&! '*1

/'6/01$'/'( '&2' 34)$/01 ( ( 69= >;

69*> / J 9 $& ;

(! "& 8 / (!7 ,$( ! #+1 !.4$.8(! #8# #,$ #1 ##$!4,4+8#. ,$4$,# 2# + , !!/# $ #,$ 8 $ $2*,,! (,,$+/

18(! + !2+$44$ $#,$ !.4$.28#,$/$

$?( #4 4 # (..4$$# !

-10- ,$4$,# 9 # # ,$/ $ , 6 .,! #!! $$ !! ,$ #!, 44 # ,$ , !!8 !

$ # ?( #4 # .,(4

.,!# (..4$$; ($#$ +/$ ,6 # !. 8# 1$ # $ , 6 ! 4 # $ ,$/# !. #1+ 41!($!/8#( / $ 2 $ 2 $( (( !( $. / ?($$ 8# 1$ $3(./# ,,$#$(4#1 $ 4 # #)#!*/# .,!$ ,6 #

#$ # 3(./ !

4$/# !. 4$. $,$( #$+1 $3(. / # # #

#$$!*/# !

1,! !48## ,$ *,,! 8# #$!*/# , !!/ # # # . #1 + $ 1$ =,! #. # , # # 4 $ .4 # . + $( 7# $!1 ,$ #

1 9 $,$( #$+!8 7 8 " 9 )22*)=' E2 & *> / ,

/ 6 / 3& .

-11- 9( $& ' )

)

. . + & "& ' )

)6*8)/ *9"4&#5&"#"$ ( *K,E6K6' / (" = . .

&6 &

)6*8)/ ( *9"4&#5&"#"$& *K,E6K6' / ("7 $ 3(. / # ($#$ (+. # # !. 4$.

=($ # +$8#( /,$

($(( !( # . 4(+ ; (+.## #$!*/ 1$/!,$ 2#( 2 (! ,,$,$ !!/#$(4#1 $ 4+(# (!/(#$A # 3(. / ,,$ # +#!

$ 3(. / #

($#$ ##

1 !*/# !

+ 4+/#. 8#( / ,$

($ (( !( 4( +

-12- $ 3(. / # ($#$ $ $$ ,4 - =($ & #4#!4## ### + #8 B2+4#$/ #

.,!7#$!1,$,$4$,# # (..4 $$ =($& $,$( #$+!8 :& .

+ .

& & J 6 J 6 '

J$ 8 / ')

*. )& 7 &# , # $14 ! #$ $ $ 3(./$"$ $ $"C D$"C@D ,# ,/ #), !&8$ $/= (+/!*/# 1($ 3(./# + 18# ,,# +"$ $ $"CD 7# ($# #$ # !$ ( ! $# ,$ # ,$( # ! $,$( 4# !.4$. =($ 2# ($ ##.$# +. +!/ !+8# ,$ # .,! ;#>(!!@ #*(4. # ($8)*:0341/03;< %34'$<1/$%$1'( )35%= !&$$# " (1() '$*&28 #! # :4# ($ # ,8$ ($ ) -9 $& !!8 #

.,(4 .,(+!

?( # # ,$ ( 8#$#:4#($ !

## . $?($,$1#+( #,$

!8$#$8 ($# *( 7# ,8$ ?( #4 .$.! ,( !

-13- :E+!# ,=($# 0%303;<$%$1 '( )35%=%34%3'$<1/ !+,-+>

/0?03%*@>A!#!

+ $1 #$$ ($# *( $,$1#+( ,$

($2 #$ ,8$ + ( +/ # ($ ?( # $.! ,$ 4 8# # .,$. # +

7#$!1,$ ,$ # *(4. $,$( #$+!8 @B '

F 2/ + >

:"#

+ .

GL ! >

! .

&MMM(((MMM7 5,4 18 # +1 $ (.

2 .$ # # # ,$ .$ # + .,$. 2 - $!!8

$4!/2#.,(4

(..4$$

=($& $.! .,! =($ & 9 !! ?( ,$ 4 $ 4 #$ $.2$ ?( #18 # !.4$.

=($ 2?(#,$ ) # . , #1 + 2 ,4 .

!!( ,,! 2 /2 #!!!

-14- ,# ,/ # $$ + ,! # ! #$

230140 $+&$&'

, B##$ ,"4$ F 6 B##$,$+! F 6