High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2048/2000allowed

(O&M) State Of Punjab Etc. v. Bhupinder Singh

2019-08-20Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal9 pages

! "#

$$%% &# '( ) !% *"$# +" "# ,

# # "-. % /.

# &0- "#1. 0 # " #$

)"%%+ " $# $$% " ! # + ## + # # !3 " ) # 4"#!3 # %#

"%%+ 1% ## 5 6

$ !3 7/.

% +.

% 8

!3 " # # /#%

! !+ %%+%. %#:0#. % + $#$% #% #0 #% #+% + 0#+ #0 " #$ ;$% 4 # !3 " #% ) # 0 +1 #

5 " 1 ! #1 $$% !3 " % # <+.

% 0 +1 # 8

=" #$ ;$% 4 $$ ) !%

> 4 # " % %?

4" " 4 $

% @ 4%.

!" > 4 $% #

$ # #$ # # 3

% ,.

% > " #1 ! # 1 8 9

8 5

# 85 3 > 4 #0 4" "#+" ! " 1 4 #$% !3 "1 #+ $3 ?#3. " 4 # 5

$# ?#3 $+ + "1 #+ ?#3. " $$# 4 $# + ( $# =" ?#3 %1 #$ # 4"#!3 "#+ %0% + "1 4# ! $# 0

> 4 #0 4" "

4"" 4 %3 #$%

,#.

## 5 6

1+ " #$ # 1 #0 4 $ !3 # $#

% $$% + 1% ## 4 1 !3 7/.

% +.

% 0

#0 $ % ! # " / . )"+#" %

1 " 1 0 ## 8

=" $$%%; " " %%+ " ! 4"# ## 1$+ 4# +" !

=" #% ) # #1 " %% 4+ # #1 :

A""# " 1$+ ## 5 6 .

# %%+%. %% 0 B

A""# " $% % " %# $#3 #B

A""# " $# $#%3 0% # " $#$ ) # # B

=" $# 4# $#1 0 $$ #

"# #$0 >0+ "# % # " $# " %+" 1#% # #. " #% ) # + %% "# " #$ ($ " 1$+ 1% # 1 #0 " ! $ 0 % $# # $##! )% (

% % #+%3 " 4 0%%3 # " %% 4+ :

=" " $% # " 1$+

## 5 6

$ !3 " .

" 7/.

% +.

## 8

$ !3 " # # /#%

! # %%+%. %% " $% "%% ! # ! #0 " 1$+ ## "0+ 0# ! $ > "%% ! % %% " ! %#3 1 %1

" ! "#! #. " $$% $### !3 " $$%%; 4 1 !3 " % # <+.

) % # " $$%% 4 % #+ " + ) # + 1% # 4 1$% 4" " $# 0 )% ( %

% % " #% 1#+ 0 # # 1$% #% $ 0 *" +1 " ) # !

"#$% %&'( )*+ , -./0 /01 7 0"1%3 #+ " ! # $+ 1% !3 .

%. " %? %;#$ 4 $# %%3

%% " .

% 4 #0 4" "

0%3 $# $ + 1$ $"1 1% # 1 #0 0 " #$ 4 %% 4 $$ #3 $$# $# ! # " $"+ "

#3 #$ " $# $ $"1 1% # 1 #0 7 #"# #+ " " #$ !1 #$%3 " "

! 0% $$ #3 $$# $# ! # " $"+ "

#3. "# #. ! "% "

1% " ! $ 4"

" $# # $##! )% (

7 $$ #

" . " " "0%3 #% $ "# 0 *"

+1 " ) # &% %&'( )*+ ,#$

$ *3-..44

5/ 4"# +1 " #%# 0 *" !

"6$ $&$)8

" ! # #"# % % 7 #"# #+ " 0#3 ! 04 $%# #1 " ". " %? 4 +0

$$ #3 % #$%3 " "

4" %!#3 $$# ! # " $"+ "

#3 3 4 #-+ 3 3 1"+ !

" $# $ $"1. + " ) # !3 $%+ #% $ !

"6$7 $&$)8

! %% 4 . !+ $#0#

) % #$#+ " #$ .

" ##3. " $$ # " 1$+ +1 !3 -+ +1 0 *" !

"6$7 $&$)8

7 "0 "# % # " $#. $# " $$# !

# #

=" 4"

% # 0#3 " $# $$% #0 %0 # " C4""# 1% 4 $ !3 # $#

% 4"

1 )% (

* # 0#+ " !1 1 !3 % # " $#. $$# $# (# #%0 $# )% (

% %. # ":

1% # # #- "%% ! $ !3 # 1$ 4# 1 $ %

# # # "1 #- % " # " ! +0 # !% $$ #3 "

4+ + " $# $ ! - #+# "1 (( (( 7$!%3. " #$ 4 #0 4" "

4 4"#!3 " $"+ "

#3 0%3 $# $ 1$ $"1 1% # 1 #0 04 " "#+ $# 0 + "1 $# " ?#3 #$ #. $3 4"# 4 $$% " %?

% =" #$ 4 +0 3E 1 #$ " "

4 +0 %!#3 $$# $# 3 4 #-+ 3 !1 " $% 7 % " #$ " "

4 '(

. " %? % !1 " #$%3 '(

> 40#.

# " # ! - 4. " %? 0% $$ #3 $$# $# ($% " $ # 3 1"+ + " $# $ $"1

=" ? " 4 %% # # 4""# 04 " # !+ " . " + ) # ! " " $"+ "

#3 1$%3 4" " #?#1 )% ( %

% %.

"# #.

1% " #+"%3 ! 4" %% ?% ! % 4+ "##

7 !

"6$ 7 $& $)8

# ?#3 #$ #. $#

%. ># %% $ # "# 1 $# #0 $ "1 " "

68 4"# 4 1 " $ # 4 +0 3F 1 1- " #$# "

4+ + 1$ $%3 1% # 1 #0 =" $ # !1 % #$# #$+ " 0# " #3 " ! # 1 " "?## =" $"+ "

#3 !%0 0# -3 # !% # !3 " $ # $ " % ## 4"" " % $# 0 !% 4:

) ?%3 " %# 1 # 1 #0 4" # 1 3 7 (+ #1 +0 $"1 %# " 1%

> 40#. 0#!% "#+ 4%% ! +0 "1 # " #% " 1 " 1

=" ) # "% " $# " $ # ! # " $#

% " 1 %0#3 "

4 + $# # # " . " #3 #?#1 $# % "#+ 0+ !3 )% ( !

0 " $# 0 #% "

+ !? " $# 0 % $ " 1$ "

#3 #%+ #0 " "

$# # % 1-+ $ 1 !3 " $"+ "

#3. "# #. $$ #3 "0 0#!% "#+ !? $+ 1% 1

#?#1 )% (

$ *36$7 $&$)8

"# 0 *"

" ) # # #+ " +1 !

"6$7 $&$)8

3&9!*: ;<'*$% , &#$% %&'( )*+ , *3'% & $-.1=4

*3!

& 9!7&$ >') *

- " "% " 4# "

" %? % # #$%3 #0 #$ "# 1 !% ! % ( %

% % " (# "0+ + "# +" " %%% " #?#1 %4 7 4 #"# "% " "# , #"$ # 1% " " 4# #$# # % 4" % $# #3 1#

!0 " $ !%3. " %? % #? $# % "#+. 1 ! +0 "1 % 4 % 0 3 + " % A" #+# !

"6$7 $&$)8

4 "% " " . " %? % 4 $# ! # " $"+ "

#3 " 1 %0#3 "

"1 " "

. 4 %#%3 " " "

#3 " %%3 1 $ 1 4# $"1 1% " .

" ) # "% " )% (

#?# " " "

4 +0 " + !? " $# 0 % $ 1$ "

#3 $# # 1-+ $ 1 " $"+ "

#3 " "

" ! +0 # " $"+ "

#3 " 1%3 1 $ 1 4# " $"1 1%. " "

4 1# #1%3 4" " #% " " #?#1 ! % (

" ! 0 %

1%3. " ". "

4 # 1$ + $# $ $"1 1% # 1 #0 =" %? 4 %3 +0 $$ #3 !1 " #$%3 " "

! 4 % +0 $$ #3 $$# $#

3 1"+ !

" $# $ $"1 7 04 $%# #1 " % "#! #. %

$ " #$ + " ) # "

1% 0 # 4 $# 0 )% (

# " %?

% 4 +0 ? $$ #3 ($% " $ #+# $# $ $"1 " ##3. " %? % 4 +0

$$ #3 !

" !1 " ($% 4#+ 4%% "0 $# % "#+ + " $# $ $"1 1% # #0 =" $#. $#% #$%3 " "

4 % #0% " $ %+ % #$%3 " "#+" # + " ?#3 $# + 4"# " #$ 4 $# + ( $#. "

# ($% " "#+ + "1 4"" % %3 ! $$# "# " + # #$%3 " "#+" # #+ " ?#3 $# + =" %3 !1 1 !3 " %? + " $# $ $"1 " " %? $ $ " %#3 -$+ 04 " % "%#. $# $ $"1 13 ! # ="# 0 4"$# 4" #+# 1!# "%# # "# + 4"

% 4 +" ! - # !3 %+ #$ " "

7 04 " !

0. 7 "0 % " % " + # # !3 " ) # 4" #+#

: " $# 0 )% (

# " 1$+ ## !+ 0 # 4 #3 " # #% # " #% 1#+ 0 1#$# #%0 $# 0 . ". # # 1 $#0#3 %!% !

7 04 4" " ! "#! #. " $$% %% 4 +1 # $ !3 " ) # # #% # %%#3. % !3 " $%;#$ "%%++ " 1$+ ## %1+ ?% #% 1 4" "# +"

# A""# #$ #!% G ;